Premium product, acceptable service, and great take-away. Jersey Mike's tends to be more expensive, and worth it. Corporate has NOT invested in Software to Track take-away orders, and in a few cases chaos reigns. Seems like an easy patch. Experience has indicated that service is better in Centerville than at Hilton Head; although Centerville has management problems. We favor the hot chicken and steak hoagies. Will pay more for this premium product. read more

Every Jersey Mike's location I've ever been to has been solid, and the Centerville location was no exception. I went on their Day of Giving a few weeks ago in March, and the parking lot was overflowing into the next lot, and the line was to the door. I placed my order to go via the app and it quoted me 30 mins. I walked in at about 25 mins and my food was ready to go on their pick-up shelf. If you're not familiar with their Day of Giving, look it up! All JM locations pick one day every year to donate 100% of their proceeds to a specific charity. This year was the Special Olympics and they raised about $20M. Also be sure to download their app. You build points for free items, and get a free sub on your birthday. Definitely one of my favorite sandwich shops! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - To go bag - Sandwiches Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

See all

We ordered a big kahuna cheesesteak on rosemary bread. But for some reason only half the sandwich was on rosemary bread. The other half was plain white. I would appreciate it if they were out that they would at least inform me. Poor read more

Great service, pleasant employees and healthy sandwiches at a good price. I will be going there again.

Tonight's supper contained a little more onion than usual and two LONG dark hairs in my veggie sub! #gross. Ticket number 01-000427-99-103664. Won't be ordering for a while after this. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Notice long dark hair on wheat bread and veggie sub... - Sandwiches Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

See all

I have been to this location twice now. In general, the folks behind the counter are nice, and the sandwiches are fresh. You can get either cold or hot subs, chips, and a fountain drink. Your standard fare for a sandwich shop, with their selling point that everything is made fresh, not even cutting the meat until you order. And they have the TV tuned to ESPN so that you can watch some sports while you eat. This is a convenient location for me as I use the library next door frequently. I really only have two concerns. First, for the number of people behind the counter, things don't seem to be extremely efficient. Maybe it is just my timing but I now have been here once before and once after lunch rush. Second, I strongly object to being asked if I want to tip for counter service. I really don't understand this trend in these sorts of restaurants. I order at the counter, pick up my own food, and clean up after myself. Why isn't all the other functions that the employees perform covered in the salary that the restaurant owner pays? The owner is asking me to pay 10% more on my bill for service? Why don't they just pay these folks upfront and increase the prices accordingly? read more

Always had a good meal here. One of the better sub type places. I can't wait until the one in Englewood is done. It is closer than the one I usually go to. I hope the staff is good I see a lot of comments about HH STORE. I like this place, read more

Always good, I've been going here for ages and I won't stop coming back. The staff is incredible and the food is even more incredible. The juices fill my mouth like the taste of a goddess spitting down my throat. The fresh baked bread makes it taste like I have been stranded and it's the first thing I've ever eaten. And the meats are delicately sliced creating the faux atmosphere of a family owned deli. I will NEVER stop coming here. read more

I love jersey mikes with my whole being. This is a good location. Always pretty quick and nice.

Great subs. Original Italian Mike's way is my favorite.

I love Jersey Mike's, by far my favorite cheesesteak around. This location however is the absolute worst in every imaginable way. They just cut the corner of my bread and piled everything on top and just wrapped it up. I had to go up and ask for a knife and fork to eat it and explained why I needed it. No apology or offer to remake it, just gave me a knife and fork. The soda machine had no carbonation. I told them, they acknowledged it and told someone to go fix it, which never happened but they continued to sell drinks, flat syrup water I mean. This is where I chose to go to lunch for my birthday lunch. I wish I were in any other area, so I could have went to literally any other location. I can think of 3 more locations do yourself a favor and go to one of them rather than this one Customer service * Food preparation * read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Half-a$$ cut bread - Sandwiches Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

I normally Love Jersey Mikes, but we stopped by there Saturday afternoon to pickup a cheesesteak to take home. Imagine my surprise after I ordered a whole cheesesteak with sauce and fried onions that they do not have any sauce anymore for cheesesteaks. WTH? He said look at the menu board that is all we have. LOL Got a large Italian hoagie to go. You guys need to step it up. What Philly girls doesn't get sauce with her cheesesteak with just fried onions...NOT read more

Always a great sub. Friendly staff. Eat in or pick up- you can't miss. Each site is run efficiently.

Normally this is a great place, but today (July 4th) they seemed to care more about the online and DoorDash type orders than the actual customers that took the time to come into the store. Unfortunate. read more

I love Jersey Mike's Subs and I am so happy there is one in Centerville. I have been eating there since the grand opening and they treat me like family. It's worth the wait to get fresh-cut meats and vegetables. There is a Subway across the street and they could give the sub's away for free and I would still go to Jersey Mikes. The staff is so friendly and it feels like your neighborhood deli. They remember my order and my name everytime I come in. read more

I went into order and people who came in we're getting their food Who came in after I checked out. They were like 12 to 15 people in line and I have no idea what took so long to make my order but I didn't have time to wait for it due to a commitment. Then it took another five minutes to do a refund when it should've taken like 10 seconds. I've never had this trouble with Jersey Mike's before; however, all the good luck I had was in Northern Virginia this is the first time I've been to Jersey Mike's in Ohio. I would not recommend this place on far Hills they are disorganized. read more

Visited the location on Rte. 725 this evening. Came in at 8:50 pm. I know they close at 9pm The counter person took my order and then informed me that it was too close to 9pm for them to make anything so we were refused service. If they have no intention of serving food until they close they should put a sign on the door saying when food service stops. I've always had great service at both locations in the area until tonight. Time to take my business to establishments that want customers ¹ read more

So kind & so accommodating of my dairy allergy! Always get amazing service at this location.

In my opinion, best customer service ever! They're always so friendly and very quick. I come to this jersey mikes at least 3x a week! My order is always perfect and the staff makes you feel good. I have yet to meet someone who is rude. Thats rare now a days. Also, I like how they don't skim you with the food. Thats the best part! You get what you order, and what you pay for. read more

Just had my first experience at a Jersey Mike's, and what a good choice it was! I got #2 (I think it's called the Jersey Shore something) which consisted of fresh sliced ham and cheese. Yes, you read that right. Sliced deli fresh for my sandwich. You could taste the freshness in all the ingredients. I tried it "Mike's Way" with lettuce, tomatoes, I swapped onions for pickles, and a dash of seasonings and red wine vinaigrette. Very tasty! The restaurant was clean and staff was friendly. If you need a change from Subway and Penn Station, give Jersey Mike's a try. I will definitely be back! read more

My wife has a gluten allergy so it's hard to find places that she can go to est without consequences. Jersey Mike's not only has a gluten free sub roll, they also clean all of their equipment and used sterile equipment to prepare her sandwich. We REALLY appreciate the option and the care. read more

Hands down my favorite sub place. Everything is fresh sliced in front of you, roast beef is cooked daily in the store, so is the bread, and it shows! It's more expensive than somewhere like Subway but undoubtedly better. You get what you pay for. Highly recommended. Get Shore Points to earn free subs! read more

when you order sandwiches and you are very specific about what you want on your sandwiches . I say Mikes way on both ,that what I get , no I get the oil and vinegar , I don't know how to be more specific about it. very unhappy about how they do not care what you order read more

If I have a choice between Jersey Mike's and other sub restaurants I always choose Jersey Mike's because the main difference is the quality of the product. They slice both the meat and the cheese in front of you here so it always fresh and they do not skimp on toppings. I have never had a bad sub from here before. read more

Jersey Mike's is the absolute best sub in town hands down! The meat is fresh with good portion size. The bread is fresh and doesn't get soggy. I travel across town past several sub shops just for Jersey Mike's. read more

Great food and great people! You wouldn't think a place like this (national or regional) would remember your name but they do here! I work up the street and go in at least every other week, if not more, and the service is always exceptional. I've noticed they hold fundraisers and benefits for charities quite often as well which goes a long way I feel. In fact, today they had a benefit where 100% of the proceeds went towards the local charity. By the way, the food is amazing too! I highly recommend the chicken philly, club sub, or Italian but everything is good. read more

This is about as good as it gets if you know about NJ and south Philly hoagies. The Italian Mikes way is the best. A little less lettuce please, and some hot peppers top it off just right. It's the fresh baked rolls that really make it a Jersey Hoagie, which they call a sub. It really doesn't matter the hoagies/subs are great! read more

Been here numerous times, always have had great service and the #10 Club Sub is excellent

Awesome! Generous portions of meats and cheeses. Always get it made "mikes way". Always fast and fresh. We've done their catering and it was also an excellent experience. read more

The customer service is great and everyone is always friendly! I always get the #13 Italian sub (so I can't provide a review about the other sandwiches) but it's consistently delicious!!! Get it Mike's way if you like dressings/olive oils! read more

Nothing wrong with these subs! They have their own unique style and they are not as bland as subway. I personally think Debellas up the street is worth looking at first, but JMs has a pretty mean sub too. Check it out if you're a sub person! 4/5 read more

Just had the best sub ever and it's not because my boyfriend Mike is from Jersey. The bread is perfect. You get lots of quality meat and the cherry peppers give it an amazing kick. I will be back, again and again! read more

You will never get a better sub in all of Dayton. The other joints have nothing on these guys . The staff is amazing and you can tell they are proud of what they are dishing out. So forget Jimmy Johns and just say no to that yellow sub and go to a place where the food is great and they appreciate you business. You will never feel you just another face in the crowd here. read more

Hard to believe a sub place runs out of bread. Poor management of this store makes it no competition for Subway.

Great Food, Fast and Fresh, always a great choice for a quick meal. I have been going there for years and this place continues to deliver on taste and value. B Hucke read more