Our first time here. The store is clean and bright, and there is a lovely selection of bagels! Lots of varieties of cream cheese available. The counter help was smiling, helpful, and efficient. We ordered breakfast sandwiches on bagels of course, and they were great. I'm looking forward to stopping in for a half dozen next time we're in town! read more

Pale, underbaked, raw inside non bagels. Flat, oversalted. Not chewy or crispy. So bad I don't know how they can call a low gluten, underbaked, under developed, non boiled bagel a bagel. Bagels must be boiled. They are made with a high protein flour. They are risen. They are baked until golden brown. Someone here needs to learn what a bagel is and how to make one. read more

BEST BAGELS EVER! Not even kidding I recommend this place to everyone traveling in the area. They are unique to any other bagels in the area and I could eat them for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. They are also reasonably priced and workers are very efficient. read more

Super slow. Took twenty minutes from door to counter. 5 teens appear to be running the place and were arguing about people being on break. One employee making food without gloves on. Coffee was cold. Prices were good. Bagels were mid. No one cleaning the tables. Not dirty, but not clean. Not impressed. Wouldn't come back. read more

Outstanding product, but the service on Saturdays is less than desirable. What seems like a bunch of teenagers waiting on people that seem to have no care about getting people taken care of. Multiple times in the last few months I have witnessed several people walked out, or opened the entry door and turned around to leave. Including myself, I waited 15 min and moved 1 position forward, after 25 min I didn't want to wait anymore. read more

Jersey is a favorite in my house, they have such amazing bagels and so many choices! The staff is always friendly and efficient.

Nice little place for a bagel and cream cheese. 1 star docked because they don't have low fat cream cheese, hot tea, or any type of vegetables to put on your bagel. Despite all of that, I really enjoyed my breakfast here, steady stream of customers and they go quickly through the line. There's a good variety of bagel flavors and the bagels are soft and fluffy with a generous amount of cream cheese on them. read more

Great little bagel shop. Service staff is very friendly and helpful. Great bagels and coffee. Good prices. A few tables for dine-in but more of a take out place. read more

Maybe people come here for bagels but they absolutely don't come here for breakfast sandwiches on a bagel. We ordered two this morning and there was a line but it moved quickly. The egg on the sandwich is definitely microwaved, reminiscent of the fast food chains. The bacon totally soggy. Even Dunkin' Donuts bacon had more to it than this bacon. And fast food chains have improved their microwaveable eggs so Jersey bagels eggs are actually worse than fast food. I would come back and get some bagels for home but I wouldn't get any hot lunch sandwiches or breakfast sandwiches from them. It takes a minute to cook an egg the NON lazy way! read more

Jersey Bagel & Deli - a close up of a sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Atmosphere: Very classy inside, light and airy. Great display of their product. So funny note: we got some bagels early on a Sunday morning, just a few, and we loved the so much we went back for more to bring in to work the following day, but they close at 1 p.m. on Sundays just an FYI. We were 10 minutes too late for more carb filled goodness. Service: Friendly, the staff had plenty of suggestions and information about pricing. Food: Shut uppppppppppppppp. These bagels beat the pants off of Einstein Bros. and their cream cheese is a whole different level of goodness. We are hooked, we actually didn't renew our Costco membership since we now have a local bagel place vs. buying Costco's bagels ( Kirkland-Einstein bros. recipe). We have had the blueberry bagels and cheddar herb. I can't wait to try more items off of their menu. read more

Yes, go here! The bagels are fresh with just the right crust and soft inside. The garden cream cheese is flavorful. The honey butter, yum! Cute, very clean place with quick friendly staff. And you can't beat the prices. read more

Bagels so good, they're almost worth moving to Appleton for! My wife used to live there and brings lots of them back to Chicago whenever she goes back to visit. I'm always sad when they run out! read more

The bagels here are the best in town! They have so much variety and it comes out quick and yummy! The staff is also awesome! They are so nice, they even wrote us a note on a napkin to have a great day! I 100/10 recommend! read more

Jersey Bagel & Deli - My bf with his pizza bagel and the note. - Bagels Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Always great breakfast or brunch, very friendly staff! Remember your lunch card because you'll be back for more. Only bad thing I have to say is I have been going here for years and the bagels have been getting smaller and smaller. read more

Some of the best bagels in the area! My family and I love Jersey Bagels! All of the bagels are so amazing and soft! We also love how much cream cheese they put on your orders and the variety of cream cheeses! If you are looking for a good breakfast place get there bright and early because the bagels go fast! read more

Jersey Bagel & Deli - hours of operation - Bagels Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

See all

Excellent bagels! Nice variety of sweet and savory! The staff was super nice and service was freaky fast, two thumbs up must try again.

I regularly order catering from Jersey Bagel. In the last six months I've had issues with staff hanging up on me or taking my order and then when I go to pick it up, there is no record of it. I won't be back. read more

Best bagels in Appleton! Love their selection of bagels and cream cheese. Their Jersey bagel is my go-to!

Jersey Bagel is the best Bagel place around. The breakfast bagels are to die for. I've been coming here for about 16 yrs on and off so the staff don't know me. I always get a salted bagel IF there is one left, apple crunch bagel and maybe the breakfast bagel if I'm really hungry. My mother in now addicted to this place so every time she is in town this is the spot for us to come. Unfortunately there is one employee that makes it always unpleasant to even want to walk through the door because she is rude, no smile, no customer service skills whatsoever. Today just happened to be the worst day for her I guess as I had only one hand to use with 3 baskets to carry along with a coffee cup and I asked her for a tray and she said no. Then continued to watch me have trouble trying to grab everything with a toddler by my side. It took a customer to help me bring my items to a table. As I watched other employees help other customers bring their items to the tables (mind you it was busy as always)! Maybe she is just have a bad day every day for the past year now but someone should talk to her. I'd give it a 5Star but can't due to her. read more

Excellent service and homemade bagels. Even when they are busy in the morning, you get in and out. The bagels are always fresh and their cream cheese is amazing. Definitely a great option for office treats or visiting relatives. read more

Delicious bagels, staff is always friendly too!! Definitely worth a drive from GB to get!!

Great bagels at a decent price. Jersey Bagels has a good selection. I usually end up buying more than I intend to because there are quite a few that I really like (Blueberry & SugarMon are my favorites). All the employees are super friendly and really helpful. I haven't had any of the sandwiches yet, but I definitely will be trying one soon. read more

Mother's Day! Great service staff is literally running to refill all the bagels! I have not seen that in years!

We bought a dozen bagels and three containers of cream cheese for a family brunch Christmas morning, a mix of everything, plain, and a few others. First of all we found that one of the containers of cream cheese was underfilled (I'd estimate it had 1/3 less than the others), which wasn't evident when we purchased it because of the label over the lid. Overlooking that, we dug in to the bag and discovered that all of the plain and everything bagels we got (8 in total) were incredibly doughy and very undercooked. I do prefer a softer bagel, but these were far too soft and did not have any of the chewiness a good bagel should have. When we tried to cut them they all ended up mangled. My wife is from a large Jewish family and grew up on the east coast, so she knows her way around a quality bagel. This being her first Christmas ever with my family, she wanted to prepare a brunch that included some bagels and lox, and was very disappointed by the quality of these bagels. Needless to say, if we ever decide to get bagels during a visit to the fox valley again we will go some place other than Jersey bagels. For what it's worth the staff was very friendly. read more

Amazing, Absolutely Amazing! The Bagels are delicious, I practically come in for breakfast every day!

Phenomenal bagels! We ordered a lot of bagels and spreads for our company meeting this morning and everything was very tasty, fresh, and phenomenal! Lots of different options for both bagels and speads. I tried the Honey Butter spread on an everything bagel and then the original cream cheese on a onion/chive bagel...both were very good and there were many other flavors of spreads like Strawberry, Chocolate Chocolate Chip, Vegetable, Vanilla Creme, and others. read more

Bagels and cream cheese are sooooooo good! Best in fox valley in my opinion. Only down fault for me are the hours, could be better. Overall great bagels! read more

Poor customer service! Ordered for pick up, not only were the sandwiches not ready for pick up, they weren't even started! So instead of saving time, I lost time. Only been here 3 times total, they've gotten it wrong 2 of the three, not getting my money any more, great product, poor execution. read more

My wife stumbled upon this place, and it is great! I feel the location might be hurting the success of this business though. It's a very relaxing atmosphere, quick ordering, and they offer more than just bagels and cream cheese. The wraps and breakfast sandwiches rock! Plus they use Boar's Head Deli Meats. Great place for Sunday breakfast! Seriously the best offering of bagels. Cheese Lovers with vegetable cream cheese is my personal favorite. read more

I love their bagels, they are the best I've ever had! I'm pregnant and have no self control and get more than one a week speedy service and always friendly staff read more

Their bagels are absolutely the best bagels in the Valley! The service is pretty good. They are generally fast and welcoming, just not stellar in my opinion. If it was just a matter of food, they would definitely be 5 stars! read more

Jersey Bagels recently reopened in one of the old locations of former 7-chain SueAnne's Bagels. With the same recipies, all that has changed is the name. This place has the best bagels ever...check out the spinich quiche and hot tomazzo. Mmmmm. Now if only they had a store in California! read more

What attracted me to this place was the name, being from Philly. The prices are great and the bagels and cream cheese are very tasty and fresh. It may have helped that I went at 630 in the morning. The lox and cream cheese is very yummy and Its hard to order anything else but I also enjoyed a cherry bagel with vanilla cream cheese. read more

Delicious food and phenomenal service! Try a Jersey Club on the Hot Tomazzo YUMMY! Plus the staff is always helpful and friendly. We'll definitely be back again and again :) read more

Amazing food!!! I loved everything so much and can't wait to have it again. Great for sitting down and having a nice meal with family. The staff is so amazing and nice, couldn't of asked for a better way to start my Wednesday! read more

Great, fresh bagels at a reasonable price! Love that they have the SueAnn's recipes and monthly flavors (bagels and cream cheese!)

Great bagels and variety but go early for best selection. My husband and I are frequent customers and love this little neighborhood shop. Also, there are usually buy on get on free coupons on Copps and Festival grocery receipts. read more

Great bagels, great breakfast and lunch sandwiches, and fair prices. Highly recommend.

Sadly, Jersey Bagel & Deli must have new management. I was appalled at the terrible quality of their sandwiches - chewy corned beef on my Reuben and rancid tuna salad. My family and I used to frequent Jersey Bagel & Deli almost weekly for a long time. We will never go back again. All four of us threw our sandwiches in the trash after taking one bite. I wrote a message via their website and have received no reply. You will regret spending money here. We spent more than $30 and it was a total waste. Sorry to say, Jersey Bagel & Deli is no longer a quaint, good-quality bagel shop. read more

Best bagels in Appleton. It's always busy on weekends, but the wait isn't too long. The coupons in the mailers are nice too.