Has that Old School vibe. A little small, but what it lacks in size it sure makes up for it in generous portions. They are definitely not stingy with their food. And Wow....the Mexican food I ordered was sooo delicious! The green chili and sauce were the star of the ensemble. Come there with a big appetite, you will leave stuffed. The waitress was very friendly with a big smile. She kept coming by to see if we were doing ok. Great service. One of the best Mexican restaurants, I've been to. Food is Delish! read more

On a Route 66 road trip we stopped in to Jerry's. It's a small cafe filled with friendly locals and travelers and wonderful staff. Had to try some of their basics. I had a cheese enchilada, refried beans & rice. Had a side of chips & salsa. Husband had Jerry's open-faced burger with red and green chili. Both meals came with sopapillas. Everything was fabulous! Such a great way to get what felt like a true picture of Gallup, NM. read more

See all

Of course I found it through my fellow yelpers I was looking for fry bread and this place popped up Decided to come because it has good reviews. Saw a guy eating a sopapilla outside said it was good and there were several people outside waiting so we were like ok it's gonna be good. Ordered the Sopapilia covered in red sauce because it was a popular choice. Sadly, I was disappointed. I think it would have been good by itself no sauce. Just a sopapilla by itself. In sauce was too much. The red sauce did not taste homemade. If it is I'm sorry but it just wasn't my cup of tea. The kids drummettes were fried and tasty. Other than that it was just another diner. We did meet others who said they frequent but knowing true Mexican food, it's a no go for me. Service was ok. Ambiance Diner feel. We met a guy who said there was a cafe town the road that he preferred I don't remember the name but at least I know I'm not the only one who did not enjoy it. He was also from Cali so there you go. Sorry to disappoint. Good luck finding good eats. SYOY read more

See all

So much food! Every local we spoke to, even hotel staff said to go to Jerry's for breakfast. The service was outstanding and the restaurant was eclectic and old but very clean. I asked the waitress which was smaller the sopaipilla or the breakfast burrito? She said the sopaipilla. Holy moly. It was stuffed with thick bacon, hash browns, eggs and smothered in red and green salsa (they call it Christmas salsa). I ended up opening it and eating the inside because it was seriously enough for 2 people. Hubs had the Eye Opener. Two eggs, Christmas salsa, hash browns and bean, served with sopaipilla. He barely finished. The coffee was so good! Best place for breakfast in Gallup. read more

Jerry's Cafe - Front - New Mexican Cuisine Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

The food was excellent. My husband and I both had the Miguel's Special. Our server Janelle was really nice and attentive to our needs. Checked on us several times. The ambiance was busy but nice. Everything was so CLEAN. When you look over to the carousel tray holding condiments and see the salt and pepper shakers not with a sticky buildup of with food particles is a plus in my opinion. Watched Janelle wash the jelly holders in back as we were finishing our meal says everything about their cleanliness. read more

Jerry's Cafe - New Mexican Cuisine Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

Local family owned Classic. Usually a wait but not too long. It is crowded because it is really tasty. The Tamales with spicy red and green NM sauce were delicious! Vibe is 1972. Nothing fancy just good food, good service, and happy people. read more

See all

This very local joint has an old time ambiance: long and narrow with two aisles running down the sides with booth seating, and clientele where I believe I was the only passer-through in the joint. I opted for a chili relleno with a side salad. The salad was larger than usual for a side and all the ingredients were fresh and crispy. Very satisfying. The chili relleno had a proper fluffy egg coating and a cheese filling. Red and green sauces are offered and you can choose "Christmas," their charming term for both. (See picture). Service was friendly and prompt. A great local spot and on a freezing cold night there was no wait but every table was full for most of the time I was there. Parking is available on the street nearby and around the corner. read more

Jerry's Cafe - House salad - New Mexican Cuisine Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

See all

First time here. 30 min wait at 2:45pm on a Saturday. Ambiance...It's a hole in the wall with okay service and tasty food. It's downtown, and easy walk to nearby shops to offer Native American art, clothes, and jewelry. read more

If you're looking for a place to eat in downtown Gallup, check out the old-school café with a neon sign Jerry's Cafe. As soon as you step into the bustling restaurant, you're greeted with a smile and fantastic service. After browsing the menu, I decided on the Don Carlos. When my meal arrived, it looked incredible. My only gripe was that the steak itself didn't impress me, but the rice, beans, and egg were perfect, and the chili had some of the best flavor I've ever tasted. Served with fresh sopapillas and honey, it was a total winner. I'll definitely be back to explore more of the menu. Don Carlos - B Sopapillas and honey - A++++ Red Chile - A+++++ read more

See all

Today was the second time we have gone to this cafe for breakfast. The service absolutely amazing, with the hostess seating you right away and getting your drinks, the wait staff getting your order and explaining any options on the menu to the cook staff putting out the best food. This is the best restaurant I've been to in Gallop hands down. It's a bit out of our route to and from Colorado but well worth the drive. read more

Jerry's Cafe - Something for every palette. - New Mexican Cuisine Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

See all

If you're looking to satisfy your appetite at a reasonable price, definitely stop here. The food is sooo good and the service as well. Refried Bowl: it may look small but it fills you up! It comes with tortillas (recommend corn) and a sopapilla. Flat enchiladas: amazing read more

See all

Passing through Gallup and checked Yelp for a recommendation and Jerry's popped up. As other reviewers have stated, this is a very small local's restaurant with limited seating. When we arrived there were groups of people waiting outside, however, we were lucky to be seated right away since there were only two of us. We noticed for such a small place, they had several staff members and they were all very busy serving or bussing. Yes. It is sort of a hole in the wall and could use some upgrading aesthetic wise but that is the charm of Jerry's Cafe. But, you are a little cramped. We were sat right next to the kitchen, restroom and dish carts, etc. We were immediately greeted by a nice young lady who brought us water and our server Janelle quickly arrived and brought menus. Janelle was super friendly with a huge smile on her face. She never left us waiting for service. We were both super hungry so she recommended Miguel's Delight which came with a chili relleno, chicken enchilada smothered with red chile and a crisp beef taco. It also comes with a sopaipilla for desert. My husband and I both commented how we haven't had good, sloppy yummy Mexican food in years and it was absolutely delicious. We both ate every single bite! Do yourself a favor and stop in at Jerry's Cafe if you are passing through Gallup. read more

See all

Ohhhh, are you in for a treat. But you have to find Jerry's first. Don't do what I did and wing it. Plug it into your phone! I found myself cruising off the beaten path and on to well beaten roads. If you get off 66, you're on your own. But hey, Alex J. , don't you have to get off 66 to get to the restaurant? Well, yeah, but just one block. Not the safari I went on LoL! When you find this hole in the wall, you've hit the jackpot. The food is authentic, satisfying, and filling. Most of all, it's really good. My choice was the Jerry's Special. Chopped steak topped with green chilis, (hatch green chilis) and you get rice, beans, and soppaipllas. Like I said, filling. The soppaipllas came in handy. They and the honey cut the slight heat from the chilis. Now don't let me scare you off of the chilis. They weren't that hot. Oh man those things are good. Very good!! The rice and beans are OK, but the chilis are the star of the show in this selection. Immerse yourself in the culture which is Gallup. Enjoy what you're about to experience. Quick Tip: You'll be rubbing elbows with the proud population of Native American, and Hispanic origins. I felt honored to be welcomed into their restaurant and into their community. read more

Jerry's Cafe - New Mexican Cuisine Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

Great staff, good ambiance a real gem of a hole in the wall. Food was very good price was reasonable and I left stuffed. Definitely would go again if I ever come through Gallup again. read more

Jerry's Cafe - Had the Cherelle's Choice on staff recommendation and it was delicious. - New Mexican Cuisine Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

See all

Small and out of the way restaurant. Food was delicious and portions reasonable. Service was quick and the waitress friendly. read more

Jerry's Cafe - Miguel's Delight A chile relleno and a chicken enchilada smothered with green chile and cheese, served with a crispy beef taco. - New Mexican Cuisine Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

See all

First time in Gallup, looked on Yelp for a breakfast diner and found this one. Got there early enough that we had no trouble getting seated right away with coffee within seconds. We both had an amazing meal. My husband had their huevos rancheros and has been comparing it to our hometown diner who he thought was the best. Said this one went up a higher scale! I had the breakfast smothered with chilies, hash browns (crispy) with sausage. Oh, so much food! But, absolutely delish! Our waitress was Anissa and she was fabulous. Friendly, smiling, fun to talk with and very attentive. 5 stars aren't enough for this local diner. read more

We waited for 20 minutes- then another 10 minutes- they sat everyone else - all the people that came before us of course but also all the people who came after us. Then they said we it would be another hour. Just then someone left the restaurant complaining about the cleanliness and we decided to leave. Awful - will never be back. If you see a line just walk away read more

When in Gallup , gallop over to Jerry's ! This is everything I want, need and expect from a diner . From the decor To the staff To the sounds of the kitchen To the food. Even the sign out front ! I look forward to coming back in the future . read more

Of the old-skool New Mexican joints in Gallup, this has always been one of the best, and these days - it seems - one of the last good ones standing. If I were a tourist and looking for breakfast or lunch with an authentic RED/GREEN experience, I'd come here. I've recommended this place to more than a few folks. Yes, you have to order chips and salsa when you sit down (and no, they are not free). Get over it. read more

Jerry's Cafe - Cherelle's Choice sopapilla. Amazing. - New Mexican Cuisine Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

If you are in or passing Gallup, Jerry's Cafe is a great restaurant for super yummy food and friendly service! Brianna was super accommodating to our particular requests and the food came out perfect and so so so yummy. The green chile sauce on my stuffed sopapilla was good enough to drink. Definitely will find my way back to this authentic New Mexican spot. If there is a line, it is worth the wait. read more

See all

I love this place! Anytime I pass through or stay for a few days in Gallup, I must have a meal at Jerry's Cafe. Place is not large and filled with locals and guests. To describe this place as a "hole in the wall" may be an under statement. The food and service is excellent. I have been here many times and haver never been disappointed. Put this on on your list for great Mexican Food! read more

See all

My husband and I stopped by here on our roadtrip and we are glad we did. It's a very small restaurant so be expected to wait a bit depending on the time and day you are going but worth the wait! It definitely is a hole in the wall but staff are friendly and food was delicious! The food came out quick so we were in and out in a good amount of time. Definitely recommend if you're in Gallup or stopping through. read more

Jerry's Cafe - New Mexican Cuisine Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

We've been here several times as we drive through town. If we hit it right (they're closed on Sundays and the line can get very long at prime time), we try to stop here whenever we can. The place is not that large and there are not many tables -- most of them are 2-4 person booths. I've had several items off the menu over the years, but the staple for me now is the bowl of chile (green) with a sopapilla. That said, you can't go wrong with the Jerry's Special, which has been served the same way since 1976 (hamburger steak smothered in green chile and cheese with sopapilla, beans and rice). Get it with the soup. The soup is a chicken, vegetable, rice soup that is wonderful. read more

I expected the best because Jerry's has a 4-star rating. This goes to show you that 4 stars for some is 2 stars for others. My hubby had Jerry's special, hamburger steak covered in green chili. I had chili rellenos, topped with green chili. Hubby LOVED his dinner, 5 stars for him. Mine was "blah"; needed salt and a hot sauce, 1 star for me. We agreed on one thing: the sopapillas! 5 stars of light, puffy dough with honey! read more

Jerry's Cafe - Chili rellenos - New Mexican Cuisine Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

See all

Came here as a party of four around 3ish, and waited about ten minutes. It's a small space but not too noisy, and looks clean and nice inside. It's fun to see the different pictures and stuff hanging from the walls while you wait. We ordered the Jerry's special, and 3 Combination #1 plates, with a beef enchilada and cheese enchilada on different plates, and the red and green sauces on the side. We also got chips and salsa to start off with. The salsa was delicious and refreshing, but just a little bit of spice. As someone who loves spicy food, it was pretty tolerable, the more you ate the spicier it got! The waitress said that the spice of the salsas differ everyday, and the red sauce was delicious and a little spicy (2/5). The tamale was super yummy, meat was tender and masa was the perfect ratio of not too much or too little, the sopapillas were amazing (especially since it came with every meal), the salsa from the chips was refreshing and spicy. The toastado just came with beans and toppings (lettuce and tomato), but with some salsa it was good. The enchiladas were good, some of the tortillas were still a little crunchy, but the meat inside was great. Got the sauces on the side to try them, and ended up flooding it with the red salsa which was pretty good. Definitely worth a stop, it's a cute little family owned restaurant that's almost a hole in the wall if you're not a local. However it seems to be always busy, ofcourse they had only a maximum of about 20 booths/tables, so that doesn't help the waiting. read more

See all

Very small place! Really good staff. Very polite and helpful. Come on the not busy times or expect to wait. Typical small town cafe do not expect a fine dining experience. I ordered the Jerry's special because I like green chile. read more

Jerry's Cafe - Jerry's Special. Green chile. - New Mexican Cuisine Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

I was in town for work and had been recommended this place by a local. The inside has an awesome vibe and the food was good! read more

Jerry's Cafe - Don Carlos - New Mexican Cuisine Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

See all

Local gem. Service was outstanding, the food was amazing and the atmosphere was decidedly New Mexico. Would Inreturn? Yes 100 percent read more

Jerry's Cafe - Jerry's Gallup - New Mexican Cuisine Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

Worth the stop off of I40 for some Mexican Americana on the historic Route 66. Great diner vibe. Sopaipillas are 5 stars! Perfect stop while passing through. read more

See all

If you are crossing over from Arizona into New Mexico, this is New Mexico on a plate. The rellenos are dipped in fluffy egg batter, not the crispy kind. The sopapillas could be a little warmer but they are thick and fluffy. If you like classic hole in the walls, Jerry's is for you. read more

Jerry's Cafe - New Mexican Cuisine Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

Food was great a local recommended it and I'm glad I trusted him. Looks like a coffee shop but it was packed Large portions cooked to perfection service was excellent read more

10 out of 10! Great Service and amazing food. Tamales were fantastic. Some of the best I have had. Chili perfect. Service was very good. There was a short line when we arrived, but we were seated quickly. This is clearly a local place and will be the standard stop for us when on I40 from now on. read more

Jerry's Mexican American Food Café This place was a great find. A small locals spot. Pretty sure we were the only travelers there that night, and the place was packed, but we were seated fairly quickly. Jerry's starts you out with the traditional chips and 3 salsas. All were addicting. My wife ordered the enchilada, topped with an egg over easy. It came with rice, beans and salad plus she ordered a taquito as a side. That turned out to be enough for at least two people. Everything on her plate looked to be made from scratch and authentic Mexican food, far removed from anything one might end up with from Taco Bell. She said everything on her plate was delicious. I ordered a combination plate that included a chili relleno, a chicken enchilada, a taco carne, that came with rice and beans (I think that might be standard with every plate of Mexican food). Again the portions were generous nearly enough to feed a family and everything was most tasty. But we didn't stop there. Since we were in New Mexico we had to once again have an order of sopapillas with honey. Hot and fresh out of the oven, and each about the side of a small loaf of bread. We only managed to eat two of the three on the plate. They were outstanding but we had maxed out on consumption for the day. Do yourself a favor and make Jerry's Café a prime destination whenever you find yourself in Gallop. read more

See all

I'm so glad we were able to stop in for a meal at Jerry's during our route 66 trip. I saw a lotttttt of shit online about how good the food is here and I now feel qualified to assert that it is not misinformation. We came in for breakfast at around 9 or 9:30 and I'm glad that there was a table available. The service was great. I couldn't pass up the stuffed sopaipilla and their menu includes a VEGETARIAN OPTION with a garden burger!!! I was so excited to see this! Vegetarians want to try stuffed sopaipillas too! It was INCREDIBLE. It was absolutely slathered with chili and cheese and stuffed with egg, cheese, and garden burger. It was so good. Reflecting on it now is killing me. The portion was massive and there was no way I could even come close to putting that whole thing down. They replaced the coffee about every second. The prices were extremely reasonable. The wait was minimal. I don't have enough good things to say about this place. read more

See all

Visited 4/11/2024 Dinner Loretta and I, Jerry's New Mexican Cafe in Gallup NM. A small hole in the wall Family Run Cafe. Passed down Authentic New Mexican Dishes to die for. Loretta ordered Cherelle's Choice. A Sopaipilla Stuffed with Carnitas, Grilled Tomatoes, Onions, and Jalapeños with Red and Green Hone Made Chili Sauce. Very Tasty. I ordered The House Made Chili Rellenos Sauced as they say, Christmas Style with Beens & Rice and a Sopaipilla with Honey. That's Red And Green sauce Both. Excellent For Sure. I also had to try A Ground Beef Hard Shell Taco. Also Tasty. All in all Excellent Food and Service. Prices are fair and portions are Filling. I'll be back for more next time I'm in Gallup. read more

See all

Even at 1:30 it had a line (we were seated in less than 4 mins). It was full of locals, regulars and folks like us passing through. A bit spicy but fresh and good. Sopaipillas with every dish was much better than the usual chips and salsa. Lots of vegetarian options too! read more

The food is absolutely the bomb!! Red Chile is delicious. However, the hostess is so unkind. Rude and never smiles. Archie. Got to get rid of her!! Other then that. Very delicious read more

The staff was very sweet and welcoming. Apparently it's always busy here which is a good sign. But we got a table within a few minutes. Hubby says that hamburger was just meh. But oh my goodness, Cherell's Choice was sooooo delicious! I can't handle spice so I asked them to put the sauces on the side. They were tasty but too much kick for me. Even without the sauce, yummm! read more

What a pleasant surprise! We stayed in Gallup on a long road trip so breakfast was just a stop on the way. But if we come back through we will make an effort to come here. I'm pretty sure we were the only non-locals in there which is a great sign that the food is good! Which it was! The red chili sauce chefs kiss I want more l!! I also want to hang out with every one of the super amazing staff. The Helped us order and took good care of us. Made sure we had everything we needed and suggested the best items to try. It had a cozy diner vibe, really retro and comfortable. Booths lining the walls and a few two person booths in the middle. read more

See all

Great food and friendly atmosphere. Very attentive staff. Nice to have a nice family restaurant in the thriving Metropolis of Hesperia