I'm not a sweets kinda guy, but we got to try these cookies at an event and was quite impressed, so we swung by on our way outta town. This time I wasn't up for it, but my son decided to try their ice cream and man, they've got that nailed too! Quality sweets at a reasonable price for what you're getting! If you're in the Fort Collins area, swing by and get your fix! read more

Stopped in a little after midnight for some late night dessert and I was not disappointed. The staff was really friendly and let us a sample a few items before we decided. Great place for a late night snack and hangout. read more

See all

Pretend you're me: It's cold, rainy and miserable. You park near Insomnia Cookies and walk in wet--only to find no employee at the counter. A lone couple waits for service, ignored. In time, a girl appears from behind a wall. Lethargic, dreary-eyed, non-committal. "I'll be with you," she says to the couple then disappears behind the wall again. In a bit, she putters to the cookie oven, opens it, turns a tray twice then slogs back to the counter. Still ignoring you (me), she approaches, takes the couple's order--then returns to the oven. She waits for the couple's order, going out of her way to avoid eye contact with you (me) and presumably, the burden of customer service. She wraps the couple's package, hands it to them and then eases back to the oven. You call to her. "Can you help me, I think that's my order on top of the oven." She gazes at the order from a mile off, lifts her helium balloon hands, takes hold of the cookie box and reads the name. Take note: I've been standing there for over ten minutes. I confirm it's mine and ask why it's been sitting there when I could have been out and happy nine minutes sooner. Flat-eyed, she says, "I was busy with other customers." You (I) think, "Wow," and wonder if she's okay, in an altered state (it is Colorado) or sick. You want to feel bad for her, but she looks at you as if you're hateful for questioning her, her schedule and lack of service aptitude. I've worked all over the world, including the pits of Miami and South America where customer service is at best optional and normally terrible. My experience at Insomnia Cookies that night, starting at 7:09 PM and ending at 7:23 PM, was worse. By far the worst service I've received in Colorado, particularly Fort Collins. Will you receive better service? Perhaps. Was this an aberration? Maybe. But the anecdote is fact--terrible enough service for me to write a review. I don't blame the girl She's a kid. Who knows what was on her mind or in it, if anything. I blame management. Two employees present, no supervision and terrible customer service. That starts and ends with lack of training and control. read more

The cookies are good but they are sooo wasteful. Once cookies are 4 hours old, they throw them away. The employees are not aloud donate or give any of them away. They throw away hundreds of cookies every night. The food bank or anyone could use a free cookie! Ridiculous read more

These cookies were pretty good. I ordered a dozen. Paid around $24. They had all sorts of flavors, snickerdoodle, mint chocolate, peanut butter , candy cookie, chocolate chip. Double chocolate. Parking here is a little difficult at times. No problem getting in or out of the shop. The guy who helped me was totally cool. He put the warm cookies in a pizza looking box , I paid on their iPad and that was that. The cookies lasted and still tasted "fresh" a few days later too. However the mint one , it's pretty strong in mint, and the same day I ordered them the mint essence had gotten to some of the cookies. I would maybe order a few again if I happened or be near. read more

Insomnia Cookies - My cookies - Desserts Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

Bad bad idea... I try to not order from anywhere cause I love food. But one night I needed some comfort food and found these awesome cookies. Bam in in hour had hot cookies at the door for a mid nite movie marathon read more

Ugh I wanted this place to be awesome. My poor kids. All they wanted was a deLuxe cookie. After asking for two different kinds and getting shot down because they didn't have anything ready. The service was horrible. They both looked like they'd rather be anywhere but there. The cookies were really great. They just need to get their act together. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Snickerdoodle and chocolate mint - Desserts Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

Jason at the front has great customer service skills and is very friendly and welcoming. He adds great value to this business and will have me returning frequently. read more

We ordered 4 cookie wiches through their website and they came on time, the vegan and gluten free cookies were separated from the others which was great. The icecream to cookie ratio was perfect, and the cookies were warm and delicious! Definitely recommend. read more

Insomnia Cookies - red velvet cookies and cream cookie, double chocolate mint cookie, rocky road icecream - Desserts Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Buyer beware there is some shady business going on here!! Last night my fiance and I decided to buy some cookies for a friend's birthday. Rather than ordering online we decided to go there instead, being that we live so close. My fiance's car was in the process of being towed within minutes of us arriving. We went outside to find out what was going on and the tow truck driver was demanding $70 to release the vehicle. THE DEAL WAS $70 NOW OR $400 TOW. He made it very clear that he works for Insomnia Cookies and was told to tow any car illegally parked in the back parking lot. He pointed out a sign that wasn't very visible (in the dark) and located fairly high up the wall. So if someone were looking at the other signs posted much lower, it would be easily missed. I understand businesses are hurting right now but this is not the way to go about it. The employee's could and should have told us about the parking situation. They clearly saw that we walked from the back parking lot. And nothing was said. Even after we explained to them we just recently moved here and were looking forward to trying their cookies. How can anyone support a business being shady like this??? ***Message to business "spend the money on proper large signage so, consumers can see them in a dark parking lot!!! We definitely feel the business owes us $70!! And we can tell you this much...we will NEVER be going back nor will we EVER recommend this place. PERIOD!!! read more

Damn good cookies. Really glad I found this place. I loved the smores cookie and could eat about 50 of them. They have a lot of good options and gluten free which my wife really enjoyed. I will need to come back if I'm nearby again. Good work Insomnia Cookies. read more

Insomnia Cookies - So many good choices!! - Desserts Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

First off whoever the guy is with long hair behind the front counter is awesome. He was very funny while we waited for fresh cookies. He does little tricks which are exciting. Those cookies were hot as heck and o so good. He let's you know all the warnings beforehand. He is very nice and the cookies taste great. Cookies are great. They are military friendly which is awesome. I had no issues and would recommend them again. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Vegan chocolate and chunk - Desserts Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Buyer beware!! Bad business behavior here! This business has lost my business. Just moved here wanted to buy my neighbor cookies for her birthday and Parked in the back lot at 6:30 at night and my car got towed. By 6:33 I was told 3 minutes later my car was being towed employees acted like oh your car is being towed? I'm like what???? Why would my car be towed? This business is a total SCAM WE WERE IN HERE less than 3 minutes and boom your car is being towed! What a nightmare! Our CAR WAS TOWED!!!!! $370 later I didn't have a credit card to pay so he offered for me to Venmo $70 or $370 to tow my car so what choice did I have they towed my car. The tow truck driver was a complete a * and said that the parking is only for delivery drivers only and employees. It's dark out signs are not visible they are placed very low they must be scamming customers and this is disgusting to me and I wanted to just surprise my neighbor since I found out that she had a birthday so we wanted to support a small business. DO NOT SUPPORT A BUSINESS THAT HAS A TOWE TRUCK PARKED RIGHT OUT SIDE LOT ! How dare they? This is disgusting to me!!! I was told by the tow truck driver that this business hired him to tow cars for parking in his spots. They will only allow you to park in the street because there is a smoke shop next door and they don't want any extra people parking here. This business lost my business and the sad part i wanted to support a small business that has been blowing my emails up with coupons ....unfortunately didn't have my phone to use coupon nor did I have my credit card to pay I paid cash. Highway robbery $400 cookies?? Really??? What type of scam is this ? I will never support a business like this ever again and hope you all don't either. read more

You can't beat the flavor of these cookies. Particularly if you like Snickerdoodles; they're the best in Colorado as far as I know from 20 years of tasting and testing the 'doodle here. (It's a hard job, but someone's got to do it.) I've dropped by in person to the storefront twice and have had orders delivered three times. The cookies are great for late night snacking not just because of the sugar rush but for their warm, soft goodness, the kind of cookie you'd use a spatula to take them off the tray because they're so warm and floppy. Delish. Tonight, alas, my cookies arrived cold. Still great flavors and nice texture, but not a hint of warmth anywhere in the container they came in (like a small pizza box). Delivery was prompt, the young woman doing the delivery was delightful (and good at finding a place like mine, tucked up against the park). But I didn't realize until she left that we were the proud new owners of 12 cold cookies plus three cold but free chocolate chip cookies, a special for the night. I am (dutifully) sampling the cookies as I write; the chunk chocolate cookies are fully cold to the hand and a little crunchy on the outside where their original goodness has grown sadly rigid. I wish Insomnia Cookies would pack a little flyer saying how best to warm up their cookies when they're being delivered in cold and wind. That might even be useful for the next day if your eyes were bigger than your stomach. I like the place, I like the people who work there, and I usually love their cookies, so I'll be giving them another chance. If anyone from Insomnia is reading this please know it'd be a huge service to your customers to advise how best to heat up the cold ones.Maybe even a URL printed on the box saying HOW TO HEAT UP YOUR COOKIES? read more

I ordered cookies in November and was sent the wrong type of cookie. I called and spoke with the manager, Alicia, who said that they would hold a credit that I could redeem the next time I ordered cookies. I tried to call the store today to add cookies to my order and was connected to a customer support rep, Tahira. She was patient when I got frustrated and she went above and beyond when she didn't see notes on my previous order. She called the store and spoke with Alicia. They made things right! The cookies are wonderful and the service was outstanding!! Much appreciation to both of them as we look forward to those warm cookies on this cold night. read more

Jesse or whatever the fuck it was did a great job selling me on that sixth cookie. So he's technically the best employee to ever work at Insomnia. read more

Cute place! Stopped in here after dinner with a friend n our kiddos. They have a good selection of cookies to choose from and ice cream as well. My kiddo decided to try their chocolate chunk cookie with vanilla ice cream n sprinkles.. and I had the double chocolate chunk cookie. They serve it nice and warm, who doesn't love that?! And I read that they're open late until 3am and would deliver! Perfect for those who get the munchies and really want some cookies in the middle of the night haha. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Excellent service and warm cookies! My goodness this place is so Yummy! Warm cookies with ice-cream! I don't like you can't leave a tip when you pay with a card though. read more

I'm a huge fan of Insomnia cookies, I have come here multiple time at various hours of the day and have never been disappointed. To start when we walked in the employees were smoking, the floor was super dirty (leaves and foot prints) and the counter girl wasn't very nice. Then when we went to order we felt rushed, they were out of buttercream frosting, s'mores cookies, and birthday cake cookies. Those were my first three choices. Then when I asked more jokingly why they ran out she said don't look at me I can't control it. Any way, after I got my cookies that I paid almost $12 for three of them, they were super salty and barely edible. It would be understandable if just the peanut butter ones were salty, but the chocolate chip one was inedible because of how salty it was. They were also visually unappealing, and super oily. Also I didn't get my receipt, because "it didn't print" read more

Insomnia Cookies - The super oily unattractive cookies we couldn't eat because of how salty they were - Desserts Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Honestly it just wasn't very good. Too sweet. I threw half of my cookie away. The atmosphere of the place is also not inviting.

Was in & out quickly with half a dozen very warm/fresh cookies! They were delicious. The peanut butter cookie was my favorite, but they were all good! If you want some freshly baked cookies, this is the place to go. read more

Ordered two pints. Driver got lost, by the time they got here they were half melted. And the pints themselves were packed only 70% full. Won't be ordering from them again. read more

If you like cookies, this is the place to be. They are outstanding and very affordable. 10/10

Great experience here, you can tell the cookies are to die for. My personal favorite was just the standard chocolate chunk cookie. And the fact that they close so late means that when you get a hankering for a cookie, no matter the time, it's possible to quench that! read more

Another chain cookie place. The cookies are thin and slightly greasy but pretty yummy. About the same level as Crumbl. Not as good as Tiffany's Treats if you're from the south. They're open late which is nice if you have a late night craving. We've tried a bunch of flavors but the chocolate chip is still my favorite. Not sure if this location has vegan cookies, but I know some do. read more

EXCELLENT customer service. So friendly and helpful. And the cookies are warm and delicious. Thanks for the great experience.

Probably a 3.5... decent, but a little disappointing. I love cookies! Not like in a "cookie snob" kind of way (if that's even a real thing lol), but in a "I love pretty much every kind of cookie" way lol! So, this place didn't need to be that great for me to be happy, but, still, I was kind surprised that I didn't really enjoy their cookies as much as I thought I would. Pro's: friendly staff, open very late, a shop solely dedicated to cookies and cookie/ice cream sandwiches, they deliver! Con's: limited flavor selection, kinda small cookies, kinda expensive, taste good not great It is kinda awesome that they deliver though... read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Why promote 3 am delivery on the window and everywhere when they're only open until 12???? I know covid has changed a lot of hours but everywhere it says open until 3 am, on the website it says "open now", google maps "open now", apple maps "open now" even on yelp it says they're open until 3 am everyday. I walked up to the door at 2:30 am and there was two workers inside the door was locked, I was confused and they just gave me a dirty look as if i was an idiot for trying to go in. I'm sorry but the window has a huge sticker that says 3 am so i really don't get why you wouldn't expect costumers to show up past that time. I'm not saying they should be open that late, but at least have accurate information and don't waste people's times. I've always loved getting cookies here but they have completely lost my business after the blonde girl working tonight gave me such a rude look. Literally false advertisement. fix your hours if you're going to close 3 hours before stated. not that hard. read more

After our great dinner at The Colorado Room, my son and husband had a sweet tooth! So, Insomnia Cookies is right next door, and so so good! The service was great, friendly, ice cream very good! I must say that I did not eat the cookies, but the guys did. The woofed it down so fast! So, if you are in Fort Collins, this place is not fancy but excellent food. read more

Addictive cookies, baked just the way I like them, soft and kinda mushy. Their sugar cookie is the best. 6 cookies for $9 they also sell ice cream and milk. Open late! And they deliver read more

Yeah, just like the pictures... Choco peanut butter cup had 2 halfs of a peanut butter cup, thats it. read more

I would more realistically rate a 2.5. Regardless, I was not impressed. I heard a lot of hype surrounding this place and unfortunately it did not live up to my expectations. The biggest factor was the pricing. Almost $2 for a normal size cookie, that's a bit absurd. Other places in town have larger cookies for the same price or cheaper. I would be more accepting of the price if the cookies were of higher quality, although I found them to be slightly above average. As well, service is huge for me, and I understand it's a cookie shop in a college town, but customer service should still be of upmost priority. The cashier seemed bored and unenthusiastic, and had to ask my friend to repeat their order, then me to also repeat my order. Overall it seemed unprofessional. read more

First delivery was wrong. We called back and they said they would send the correct order. It's been over an hour and still waiting. Horrible, horrible company and service. $40 spent on cookies and it looks like I'll have to contest the charges with my bank. Complete scam. read more

Really good cookies and quick delivery! Lots of different options and gluten free options as well.

Delicious cookies and great hours when you want something sweet but it's late. Friendly staff. Everybody loved the cookies, they were warm and had great choices available. read more

$15 seemed a little steep for a couple scoops of ice cream and a cookie. It wouldn't have been so bad if we got the right cookie and if the moose tracks ice cream I ordered was made with vanilla and not white mint. Yuck. read more

Okay this place is dope tbh, it's addictive just a warning to everyone, a little expensive but totally worth it I would even pay more for their product...... if you are thinking about going here then do it you won't regret it at all read more

They charged me full price for my order but failed to deliver the whole thing. I called them and they said they were "too busy with the delivery orders" to bring the rest of the order back to me So I paid for cookies that I never got because they were too busy to deliver them so that's cool read more

Service is great the girl behind the counter is extremely friendly and dropped everything she was doing as soon as we walked in the door! On the other hand the cookies turn cold and hard within just a few minutes. Very overpriced. read more

Friendly staff and good cookies! I got a dark chocolate chip and M&M cookie. If it were warmer I would be tempted to get an ice cream cookie sandwich. Cookies are a pretty good deal, too. read more