We ordered a cookie cake for our CSU student's birthday, and Eileen's did an amazing job! I put some general details in the order and we were very pleased with the result. Delivery was great as well. read more

Eileen's Colossal Cookies - Birthday cookie cake - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

This is a small non descriptive store that smells heavenly when you enter. There are a dozen differentypes of cookies you can buy by the sleeve or individually and there's always a special of the week. They even have gluten-free cookies my favorites are the chocolate chocolate chip with walnuts. Or maybe the peanut butter with chocolate chips or the sugar cookies. They are very attentive and provide great service. read more

They have the best cookies! I love the cherry chip cookies the most but all of there cookies are fabulous!! read more

Delicious. These are better than homemade I would recommend. Great for special occasions. read more

I order a giant cookie with an edible photo on it and had the shop write Happy Bday! They delivered it to my college student and it was a big hit! Yummy and decorated exactly the way I asked. read more

Eileen's Colossal Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

I just so happened to stumble upon Eileen's as we made a quick stop to the plaza before camping. It was exactly what I knew I needed, some fresh cookies for camping. The staff was incredibly nice and was patient with me explaining al their cookies and giving me time to make a decision. So I never felt pressured to hurry up and make a selection. I picked 4 cookies, mind you I'm a tough critic when it comes to cookies so it took a while for me to make a selection. The final selection: chocolate chip, white chocolate chip macadamia but, snickerdoodle, m&m. They are big and thick cookies, I'd say roughly 3 inches across and maybe 1/2 inch thick, oh and let's not forget soft. My two faves were snickerdoodle and macadamia but ... which is rare for me because chocolate chip is my go to. The reason for me review ... I picked these bad boys up on Friday and finished them on Sunday. THEY WERE STILL SOFT even after leaving them in the bag in our car while camping. I was so tempted to stop by and get more for the ride home but alas we all know the struggle of I-25 so I'll have to come back another time! read more

Eileen's Colossal Cookies - a hand holding a cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Cookies are wonderful. Wish they were closer to me. Would order their frisking online if available.

I'll start by saying Eileen's cookies are tasty. I have ordered from them on a few different occasions for various events. They do great custom orders and get the job done in a timely manner. Most recently, I ordered a custom cookie cake to use in my proposal to my now-fiancé. All I can say is, make sure you spellcheck the cake before you leave the store. I was rushing around all day getting things ready, and did not look closely at the cake until it was too late. The glaring spelling error is highlighted in the professional photos we got back from the engagement. "Weirdness" doesn't follow the "i before e except after c" rule so it's tricky, but this cake was for a really special occasion and a quick spell-check by the staff would've been appreciated. read more

Eileen's Colossal Cookies - Custom Decorated Chocolate Chip Cookie Cakes -12" small -14" Medium -16" Large - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Highly recommend! They were helpful and quick for a last minute birthday cake!! And went above and beyond on the decorations! Even was able to use UberEats on this speciality cake! read more

Eileen's Colossal Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

I have been buying these cookies for a long time and have never been disapointed until I stopped last Wed. Sugar cookies were on sale and I always buy them and only them. I buy a dozen of each, plain and frosted sugar cookies. She sold me Halloween frosted cookies that were left over from Halloween. They had colored sprinkles on them for Halloween and were not fresh at all. One bite and the frosting crumbled all over. The cookie wasn't even soft, it crumbled. I should of spoken up and asked for fresh cookies instead of accepting the 3 day old ones. They should of been on sale for $5 and not the unfrosted ones! Lesson learned. read more

The cookies are usually pretty good, although sometimes quite dry. The last time I was there, the guy had on gloves, took my cash, gave me my change, and then went right back to frosting cookies with the same gloves on. That grossed me out as we all know how dirty money is. Don't know if I'll go back after that experience. read more

Discovered these cookies through Morning Fresh Dairy so I haven't been to their store front. We ordered a 3 pound dough batch of the Oatmeal Scotchie. The dough baked well and the cookies are definitely tasty... Especially warm and fresh out of the oven. Unfortunately I noticed they use margarine and not butter. For what I paid I would like the real deal. read more

Eileen's Colossal Cookies - Margarine... Not butter... - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

OMG!!! BEST COOKIES ON EARTH! No joke! I was bummed when they moved from Sheilds/Drake to Timberline...but I will gladly trek across town to get me some Monster cookies (peanut butter, oatmeal, m&m) They sell day old cookies for like $4ish, or you can get them separately. I'm not a big fan of frosting, but the frosting on the cookies is soo tasty. I've gotten the Giant Cookie for friend's bday and its always a huge hit! Great, now I'm going to have to drive across town tomorrow just to get some cookies for my fix. SOOO GOOD! read more

Great cookies. Great prices. Friendliest guy in glasses helped us. Very joyful personnel and they made my family's day.

On days when I have to go run and do errands near King Soopers on Timberline I every once in a while get the urge to have some cookies from Eileen's Colossal Cookies. They have never let me down with being friendly and always have the most yummy cookies. Certainly one of the best places you can go in Fort Collins to get fresh cookies for sure! Chocolate Chip cookies are my usual choice but I have bought some other ones there as well and always enjoyed them. Never had a bad experience here! read more

cookies are easily one of my favorite desserts. this place has made somewhat of a name for itself but i really don't think it stood up to its name. they were OK. there was by no means anything special about these cookies, presentation, flavor, or packaging. read more

MY WEAKNESS!! I have never been a sugar fiend but this place is amazing. I can't have my favorite grocery store sugar cookies anymore due to a gluten allergy but Eileen's cookies go above and beyond any cookie expectation I've ever had. Would definitely recommend - and they make amazing "cake" cookies and decorations!! read more

My fiance and I were on our way to the subway right up the plaza and smelled the fantastic aroma of dough and we couldn't help ourselves but to see where it was coming from. Once we walked down the plaza we found this gem of a bakery. We went in and found a fantastic assortment of cookies and found we couldn't help ourselves but to pick 6 different cookies to try. All of them were as good as, if not better than, the last. We will definitely be back to purchase some dough as well as more fresh cookies. I recommend you all do the same. read more

BEST COOKIES EVER!! Plus they will decorate any cookie like in a matter of minutes if they have time. They are so talented in whatever you ask for. read more

I was expecting some great cookies. I asked what was popular and the lady behind the counter mentioned the sugar cookies so I had one of those with frosting. I also had some cranberry and macademia nut cookies too. The texture and taste were dull and way too sweet at the same time. Perhaps I just had a bad cookie day. I may try it again but this is the rare occassion where the cookies won't be calling my name. read more

Never heard of this place not that long ago, but working in the hospital and all my coworkers on their mission to fatten me up, I have been exposed over and over now. I like what they have to offer. They are fair in prices and their quality doesn't wavier. I try not to come here too often, gotta watch my girlish figure, but since it is in the hood, it is hard not to stop in here for a pit stop sugar fix. If you haven't had one, stop by, find one you fancy and I'm guessing you will be satisfied, if not hooked. Maybe I'll see you there. read more

This place is great! Their cookies are so soft and yummy. They artists are creative and can frost anything you want. I would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a good cookie! read more

Small but tasty. I think I will just buy the dough from now on to make huge cookies! I have had most of the flavors and loved all of them.

if i was rating this store based on the customer service it would get 1 star. every time i have been in there (lots) and the owners are there...it's sure to be a doom and gloom environment. it's such a shame that they are SO unfriendly and curt. it has me on the edge to not go back....BUT... THE COOKIES ARE DELICIOUS! the cookies get 5 stars! as do the cookie "cakes". YUM :) their frosting is delicious and has a heavy almond flavor and the cookies are soft=perfect. you will get a great cookie, but it would be a real surprise if the husband or wife give you a smile. shame... read more

We've been getting "cookie cakes" from Eileen's for birthday parties for many years now. They are amazing and the staff always does a beautiful job with the cake artwork. Another Northern Colorado gem! read more

These cookies are really good. Tons of flavor packed into each chewy bite. The prices are decent and you can buy them in bags of a dozen if you want. The cherry chocolate chip cookies... yum! read more

Love this place. I particularly love the white chocolate cranberry oatmeal. My husband is crazy about the molasses cookies. They also sell day old cookies by the dozen for a couple of bucks. read more

I absolutely love this place! They have the best cookies on earth! The cookies are always made fresh and just melt in your mouth!

Sadly disappointed that they are not open on Sunday. The monster cookie is a favorite treat for my family, but apparently not on Sunday's.