I stopped by to try a cupcake or two and was delighted by the cheesecake and cupcake flavors available. I couldn't decide on a cupcake flavor, so ended up buying a mini dozen cupcake box: hot cocoa, red velvet, and candy cane ..... Also, a mini raspberry cheesecake to-go! The cupcakes were light and flavorful! The cloud-like frosting was just perfect- well balanced and not too sweet. We kept them in the refrigerator, and after a day the other ones took on some of the candy cane peppermint... yet all still tasty and cake texture was just as divine. The cheesecake looked small, so we ate it straight from the box. The cake is a bit denser - not a complaint! more like homemade than big box store! - so the frosting and fruit topping was a great combo to add to the mouthfeel and contrast of the cake and the graham cracker crust. Next time, ill enjoy this lovely mini cake by the slice instead of spontaneous fork'fuls to get a better balance of cake:fruit top:crust ratio per bite. The cake round was maybe 5 inches and would've been lovely in slices of fourths or sixths. It was a great spontaneous dessert buy and we'll be back again. I saw the other community reviews of the specialty cakes ordered, and look forward to ordering a special cake for our next special occasion. Friendly service and clean storefront and cake display. No long lines, so no wait! Thank you, Cakery. read more

My friends ordered this for a baby shower party and they were delicious. Very much a gourmet style cupcake. I had the smores one and the graham cracker crust and torched marshmallow on top were nice additions. read more

The Cakery - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Food: Let me just say that I'm a vanilla guy all the way, but found myself a little disappointed by the texture of the cupcake, it was quite dense and not light. Flavor was ok, frosting was delicious, not too sweet. The almond joy cupcake I enjoyed a lot! I thought the cake was better, it was lighter and airier. The frosting had a great punch coming from the coconut. Quite a fun concept! Red velvet was my favorite, because I loved the cream cheese frosting so much. The cupcake itself had a good flavor and ok texture it was still a little dense for me sadly. Service: The lady who checked us out was great, she was helpful and kind. She told us about the rotating flavors and how many they had. She told us about the rewards program. Atmosphere: Cute little bakery with a nice display of their cupcakes! Overall: The cupcakes were overall good, but for $4 a pop, I'm still debating if it was worth it. read more

The Cakery - The cupcakes were very pretty! - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

The Cakery has to be the PREMIER cupcake & specialty dessert store in the entire Front Range! Tucked away amidst dozens of other storefronts in a busy Ft. Collins outdoor mall, the Cakery isn't large, but once you step inside and see their fantastic offerings, you'll be hooked on the sight of their desserts, alone. Absolutely beautiful! But, once you actually taste how delicious everything is, you'll definitely be hooked! The staff is super helpful, answering any questions and describing their goodies in great detail to make sure you're happy. We especially love the fantastic Tiramisu Cupcakes and the totally decadent Chocolate Fudge Brownie! The Cakery is THE best dessert shop you'll find from Cheyenne to Denver! read more

I ordered a very, very, very Blueberry cake that my wife requested for her Birthday. When I went in to place the order the lady was delightful, helpful and made ordering a special cake fun. I just want to say " the cake was without a doubt the single most delicious cake I've ever had in my life! Everyone at the dinner thought the same thing.... Thank you " The Cakery" for making such a special cake! I will always be back for all my cake and cupcake needs. read more

The Cakery - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

I was very disappointed. The cake of the cupcake was airy and light like a cake mix. The frosting was supposed to be buttercream. First it didn't even frost the whole cupcake. It was barely sweet, thin & oily. Not a true buttercream frosting at all. Also seemed store bought. read more

These cookie sandwiches are absolutely delicious. The lemon cheesecake also looks fantastic. Can't wait to try that next.

I am blown away by the absolutely delicious cupcakes being created here! I ordered two dozen cupcakes for an office baby shower and Jackie went above and beyond to match theme and color. She also suggested flavors that were AMAZING! When I picked up the order, the level of decor made them almost too pretty to eat...almost! And this is just a little thing, but it shows me the attention to detail given: they spelled my name correctly on the order, lol! Definitely check out The Cakery if you want that extra touch! read more

The Cakery - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Made the drive up from Loveland and it did not disappoint! One bite of the double chocolate and I was in heaven. Super friendly staff that was so accommodating to my 3 boys. My only regret is not getting more! We will be back! read more

The Cakery - Vanilla, tiramisu and double chocolate - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Expertly made, and delicious cupcakes! We have been coming here once a week, every week to pick up a little sweet treat! The service is always fast and friendly! And cupcakes, needless to say, are amazing! read more

I am so happy with the cake I got this weekend, they did an amazing job. I will be coming back for more birthday cakes read more

The Cakery - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Perfect and delicious cake for my daughter's "Midnights era" themed birthday party, and on a quick turnaround too. Thanks for being so easy to work with! read more

The Cakery - Midnights era (Taylor Swift) birthday cake! - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Beautiful and delicious. Cakes and more cakes. What more could you want from a cake store?

The woman working at the front counter went above and beyond to address my concerns about their gluten free option. I hate to be a pain but having celiac I do have to take a few extra precautions. I got a chocolate cupcake with buttercream frosting and it was delicious! Significantly better than all of the other gluten free options I've tried in the area. I'd say even a better balanced desert than the GF option at Nothing Bundt Cakes. No hate to them but having a smaller and more affordable quick desert is more enjoyable for me. It was light, delicious and I will definitely go again read more

Love this cupcake shop as always!!! They update their flavors daily and switch up their options with seasonal choices! Be sure to drop in for Santa's favorite sweets! read more

See all

I loved the red velvet cupcakes, the cupcakes are very airy and crumble in your mouth, I'm very specific about my cupcakes, and these absolutely blew me away! I did end up getting a vanilla bean cupcake but the icing was cold and hard to bite, and the cake was dense. Other than that, I'll give the benefit of the doubt and say it wasn't supposed to taste like that and maybe it was a mistake in the batch! Service was quick, a little awkward, yet friendly. Ambiance is normal, not much going on. read more

I stop in here for cupcakes often and have gotten birthday cakes from here in the past but what is making write this review is my sons birthday cake this year. we did a pokémon theme so the cake was a pokeball and it look awesome! we are vegan so of course we got the cake to be vegan and a lot of our nonvegan guest couldn't tell the difference. we will always recommend the cakery! read more

The Cakery - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

The Cakery did a really cute custom design for our event. The cupcakes were delicious and cute.

The cupcakes I purchased for my wife's birthday were so delicious, a little steep in price but what isn't nowadays. If you want quality baked goods for your next occasion, the cakery is your place. read more

The Cakery is a great addition to Wellington's retail community. They do great cupcakes in fab flavors. The bakery is in a quaint old building right on Cleveland Avenue (our Main Street). It's decorated in pastel colors and is very sweet. I picked up a tiny 2-layer cake for Mother's Day and everyone said it was the best cake ever. The owner of the bakery is a great marketeer and does fun things with other local businesses-like beer/cupcake pairing with Old Colorado Bewery. Love the Cakery read more

Great selection of yummy tasting cupcakes and friendly staff. Always something new to try!

I ordered two cakes and 24 mini cupcakes for a graduation party. The large cake was supposed to be vanilla bean and the small cake red velvet. I also ordered three flavors of mini cupcakes, 8 of each. When I picked up my cakes the large cake was actually red velvet and the small cake was vanilla and the mini cupcakes only came in 2 flavors even though I distinctly remember the worker reading back to me the three flavors I ordered. I also asked for the cupcakes to the decorated the same as the cakes which they were not. Not to mention it was all VERY over priced. Not the end of the word, but very disappointing to pay over 300$ for incorrect order and just very mediocre products. read more

Want great cupcakes?? This is the place. Made from scratch cupcakes that are delicious, not too sweet and lots of fun flavors. People who work there are very sweet and will work with you on creating what you want. They also have miniature cupcakes for a one bite, less calorie treat. Thanks for being a great addition to Wellington! read more

Yum!! Can't go wrong with these cupcakes. Absolutely moist and delicious. The icing really sold me to complete the cupcake, you can tell the passion in this hand make cupcakes! We tried a four pack of Lemon Raspberry, Chocolate, Cookies n Cream, and Chocolate strawberry. Our favorites were the lemon raspberry and the Cookies n cream ! They are even decorated elegantly - ours had a football chocolate on it for super bowl day!! :) read more

The Cakery - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

The Cakery is a great small bakery. They have baked goods in vegan and gluten free that are delicious. If you need a cake made for an occasion, this the. Place to go in Wellington. read more

We Googled for custom cakes for 50th Anniversary Celebration, and all Google came up with was grocery stores or out of business shop. A friend said there was a cake shop in Wellington, so we finally found this shop. They really need to get a better street sign, though. We passed it twice before we realized where it was. We went in and the clerk was so friendly and knowledgeable about the products they produce. We told told the clerk how many people and she told us the size we needed. She also explained what was in each cake. We choose the Black Forest Chocolate cake, Cherry filling, topped with Whipped Cream frosting! We picked it up the day of the gathering without any problems. This cake was simply divine. The dinner was BBQ, and the cake was so perfect a contrast to the meal. My daughter in law is a trained professional chef and baker, and she raved about the design and flavor. That cherry filling was so good, not too sweet. The gold sprinkles on top was a great addition. I highly recommend The Cakery. read more

The Cakery - Black Forest Chocolate cake, Cherry filling, topped with Whipped Cream frosting! - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Oh Boy! These are my Favorite Cupcakes! I could and do eat them on any day, at any time and for any reason! You don't need a Special Occasion to enjoy these wonderful Sweet Treats but they are always a nice addition to any Special Occasion or Holiday get together! What I appreciate is that they use fresh, quality ingredients to make their Tasty Goods...this is one of the reasons that makes them better than other choices...for Me they are priceless because once eaten I am Over the Top Satisfied! Keep Up the Awesome Work Guys! read more

Thank you to The Cakery for an absolutely perfect cupcake. You can tell they use the finest ingredients in their "from scratch" cupcakes and frosting. We tried Key Lime, Carrot Cake and Vanilla Bean. All three flavors were scrumptious!! Even if you don't live in Wellington, it's worth the drive. The Cakery's cupcakes are sure to delight your taste buds! read more

Jackie & Lydia will make all of your cupcake (& cake) dreams come true! Their big, decadent, fresh, & delicious cupcakes are DELICIOUS & their customer service deserves an A+ rating. They rotate daily picking around 7-8 flavors of the day from their extensive menu of flavors, too, so it's always fun to try something new! Highly recommend! read more

Good for the soul! Cute little shop. Great tasting cakes. Always a variety of flavors. Owned and operated by a friendly local family. Gluten free and dairy free cupcakes available as well. read more

The Cakery - Fall flavors! Pumpkin, french toast, chocolate peanut butter, apple spice, vanilla bean with buttercream, double chocolate. - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

I absolutely adore cupcakes and am always on the lookout for yummy bakeries. I was passing through town and stopped in this cute place - great selection of flavors, super friendly staff, classy packaging and my peanut butter cup cupcake was so delicious! One of the freshest I've ever had with just the right balance of flavors in a cute polka dot liner! Highly recommend you check this shop out! read more

The Cakery - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Excellent service and amazing cupcakes! I'm out of state but found The Cakery on yelp. I was looking for a local place to deliver some goodies for my friend who lives near there. They were able to help me right away, reasonable delivery prices, excellent service! They called to make sure my friend was going to be home and get fresh products, and then followed up with me after they delivered within 24 hours of ordering. Seriously, cannot say enough good things about doing business with them! They were incredible! Way better than flowers, door dash, or Amazon! If you're looking for something special, this is it! read more

Best cupcakes in Norther Colorado! Different flavors everyday. The cupcakes are so moist and the buttercream icing is to die for.

Outstanding cupcakes from this sweet bakery. We have stopped in for treats from time to time and always loved them. We just had a birthday party for my daughter and we ordered 3 different flavors of cupcakes for the occasion! Everyone raved over them! We love supporting a local small business. read more

Thanks for coming up with a delicious vegan option! Not too sweet. Just perfect. Best I've ever had. Always worth the drive from Windsor. read more

The Cakery - Cookies'n cream vegan cupcake. You all are geniuses! - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

I ordered last September for my daughters first birthday, and was extremely pleased with the way my cake turned out, along with the customer service received. If I am ever back in that area, I will be stopping in for cupcakes. Amazing bakery. Highly recommend. read more

Treat yourself to the amazing cupcakes. They leave the FOCo cupcakes in the dust. Love supporting our local shops.

Amazing family cupcake shop. Only complaint is they taste so good you want to eat more then you should

Sinfully delicious! Wide rotation of flavors, gluten free options, heavenly frostings and all this raving from someone who barely has a sweet tooth. Make the drive north folks, you won't be disappointed. Only open Tuesday-Saturday, 10-6 read more

This lady's cupcakes are always delicious. My best friend got some for my baby shower and we are all of them.