My family and I had dinner here tonight. We were so looking forward to authentic Italian food from "family recipes". We were so disappointed. There is no doubt that the meatballs were frozen and store-bought. The linguini with clams lacked flavor, especially garlic. The chicken mixed in the pasta alla vodka was boiled and tasteless. And the veal parmigiana was disappointing. The menu and website is misleading. And the lack of professionalism and etiquette by the staff just added to a less than satisfying experience. Shame on them for serving food that was not authentic as advertised. So disappointing. read more

3 of us dined. All 3 meals and appetizer was not enjoyable. It was like frozen food they defrosted, heated up and served. Sorry Montebello, but I hope you use this review to improve your food. There is a great opportunity to provide good food arbor hands. It's up to you to do the job. read more

This was a terrible experience. There were six of us. Every meal was either over cooked or tasteless. Chicken on the carbonara was overcooked. Veal was like leather. The coppino was tasteless. The service did not fit the price. No water service, had to Ask, food delivery was haphazard, actually leaned over the table to had the dishes. Not milk or sugar with the coffee. Had to wait and coffee cooled. Ambiance was old and tired. This is awful as Kings Way is forcing the residents to pay for this restaurant. read more

If you like amazing Italian cuisine, this is the place! It starts with a warm sliced loaf that comes with EVOO that has been jazzed up with Zucchini marinated in balsamic vinegar. To start I recommend the baked artichoke hearts & Shrimp if available as a special appetizer. If not then maybe an order of momma's small meatballs. Don't forget to order a glass of house Chianti or Prosecco. Main courses that I might suggest would be their classically done chicken parmigiana with homemade pasta or the savory veal saltimbocca ;). For dessert I went with the traditional tiramisu that is homemade. They cap things off with a complimentary lemoncello read more

Il Montebello - Chicken Parmesan - Italian Near Me - Yarmouth, Massachusetts

See all

Great food and Great Service I as the table enter with sausage and it was excellent Everyone else enjoyed their dinners as well. read more

Food was great. I had the fettuccine salmone, salmon, asparagrus and mushrooms With a cream sauce, delicious. Husband had Clams with white sauce, very good, others enjoyed eggplant parm , server was fantastic. complimentary limoncello enjoyed by all. Nice night read more

Awful service and food total waste of money. Calamari was chewy and chicken was rubbery. Bolognese was

Don't waste your money . Our waiter was not friendly and so apparent did not want to be there. The food was disgusting. Calamari was chewy . we had the chicken cacciatore which was pure rubber and the linguine Bolognese which tasted like dog meat. read more

Once again I was pleased with food and wonderful bread. Had pasta bolognese. It was excellent and very filling. Couldn't finish and was just in mood for pasta. read more

Il Montebello - Sea Bass-Excellent - Italian Near Me - Yarmouth, Massachusetts

Really flavorful bolognese- and the house made linguine option is a must. Dave had the swordfish- said it was fresh and super delicious. Wonderful ambience as well. Server very nice, might have been new. But overall a great night out! read more

Got out of work early on Thursday night, ordered a large margherita pizza to go, was told twenty minutes, I get their early and paid up, pizza delivered on time, took it home and it was delicious!!! I will definitely return. Bartender friendly and easy to deal with, of course, it was a very quiet time of day. read more

Awful service, awful food, and it is expensive for what you get. My wife and I have been there twice, first one was bad, we have it a second chance, but they failed. On our first visit, I ordered pasta and meatballs, the menu said the sauce was homemade and the meatballs were also homemade. The sauce was spiced up jarred sauce, which can be good, but certainly not homemade. The "homemade" meatballs, small frozen meatballs you can get at the grocery store. And this meal was not cheap. Truly the worst pasta I've ever had at an Italian restaurant. Our second visit was worse. My wife ordered the Affettati, "seafood salad," with Italian cold cuts, my wife asked what kind of seafood, the waiter said "shrimp, mussels, calamari, clams and scallops, she ordered it. The food came, which was meat some cheeses and peppers, etc, NO SEAFOOD. The waiter came by and she asked where the seafood was, he said it didn't come with any, we showed him the menu, he said that it was wrong and walked away, never asked if he could fix it, never apologized for the mistake, and never brought it up again. My wife decided to eat it, it was old and stale, nothing fresh for $26.00. I ordered the baked clams, which said fresh clams, but they were clearly frozen, and tasted horrible. Eventually the waiter came back, we got our check and left. The sad part for us is that we live at kings way, we thought it would be great having a restaurant on the property to frequent, but it is not this place. The atmosphere is an upscale hall. Tables haphazardly placed, the bar area is ok, the tv had a test pattern. The place sits on a golf course, but does not offer easy foods like, burgers, sandwiches, stuff to grab after playing golf. Instead, when they open during the day, you still only have the dinner menu. The staff is not rude, but not attentive in anyway. No visits to see how things were, they had to be flagged down. When they did come they were nasty, not friendly, one guy acted like he was mad because we asked a question, and the rest just have attitudes. Don't waste you time or money. The place is a microwave mill, nothing is fresh, and the seafood they have is not only not fresh, but old. We will not be returning to our neighborhood restaurant, which sucks. But I will gladly make the trip out of the complex after golf, there are some pretty awesome places to eat in Yarmouth Port, and the staff in those, is always pleasant. SAVE YOUR MONEY AND TASTE BUDS, DO NOT GO HERE. read more

Il Montebello - This is what is says... - Italian Near Me - Yarmouth, Massachusetts

See all

The food is out of this world. Homemade sauces are dinamite and there drinks are on point! read more

Il Montebello - The drink menu is to die for! - Italian Near Me - Yarmouth, Massachusetts

See all

This restaurant is the sister/brother of the 4 Seasons Trattoria on Rte 28 in Yarmouth across from the RMV. Consider this a dual review. BOTH serve quality entrés and offer homemade pasta. Il Montebello is located on Rte 6A in Yarmouthport in the Kings Way Condo/Golf course complex and of equal quality. The wait staff shares the responsibility of serving you and can't do enough to please you. Check out BOTH menus which you will find varied offering some unique entrés. read more

This is one of my husband and myself favorite Italian Restaurant on the Cape. The food, service, and ambiance are fabulous. Whether you eat inside the bar, at the bar, in the dinning room or on the beautiful back patio overlooking Kingsbury Golf Course your experience will be the best. We loved the first Restaurant, Four Seasons Trattoria on Route 28 in Yarmouth 11 years ago. It's like eating in your Nonni s kitchen. read more

Ordered lunch to go from the golf course; Italian hot dog and a panini. Upon opening the bag on the 10th tee, we find a sausage sandwich with mushrooms, and an Italian cold cut sandwich. Called the restaurant back to tell them we were given the wrong order, and the reply was, well that's how we make Italian hot dogs, and we don't have a panini maker! So either the ordering sign/menu on the 8th tee was wrong, or the management simply does t care about truth in advertising. The food was inedible; we were given a refund by the manager, which was the only saving Grace. Haven't had dinner here, so this review only covers the golf course lunch. read more

Food good but overpriced. Manager/host extremely rude while seating us after golf. Seemed to not want golfers to dine even though it's connected to the golf course? You can tell the culture is bad here with none of the staff being friendly. It made our group feel uncomfortable. Will take my business elsewhere on the cape! read more

The "Host" was wearing a much too tight golf shirt which drew attention to his large belly. We waited while he spent more time on the phone taking orders, I guess, rather than being at the podium to greet guests. We were finally seated in an area with a non english speaking server which made ordering and asking questions very difficult. The food took a long time and there were little things neglected like fresh pepper and parmesan cheese, the server was also assigned outdoor tables and disappeared for most of our meal. The drink I ordered, the Italian Spritz, tasted medicinal and was sent back. The dinner portion of mussels were half of what we've gotten at every other Cape restaurant. It was a very disappointing dinner in every respect. read more

Had the special chicken, Montebello, Apple tart and pistachio cheesecake for dessert were superb

The food and service were both amazing. I enjoyed the Chicken Parmigiana and Caesar Salad. The tiramisu was delicious. I will recommend the restaurant to everyone. read more

Absolutely amazing meal in Yarmouthport this evening; one of the best gastronomic experiences we've have on the Cape in years. As context for those of you who may be familiar with the Italian restaurant scene in Manhattan, the proprietor Patrick, brings two decades of experience at the pinnacle and blends the intimacy and culinary glamour of Il Mulino and the range and quality of Il Postino! I started off with a simple insalata tricolore, napped in a fruity olive oil and a spritz of lemon; it was followed by a 2" thick roasted veal chop, tomahawk-style on a classic demi-glace, smothered with a medley of wild mushrooms, and accompanied by oven-roasted potatoes, carrots, and beans. For dessert I opted for the house-made lemon sorbetto -- a perfect, palette-cleansing balance between sour and sweet. The glamours Mrs. enjoyed a Caesar, "the best chicken parmigiana on the Cape," and a profiterole. Guests are offered a Limoncello courtesy of the maître d'h at the end of the meal. We were thrilled with our meals and expect to be regulars. #ladolcevita #boneappetit read more

See all

As usual , rude people that think a lot of themselves but don't usually serve good food . Maybe you'll get lucky . I'd like to give it no stars but not an option . read more

Took my mom for her birthday. We sat outside on the patio overlooking the greens. Alek was our attentive server. Great service and in edible Italian food. We felt as if we were there only patrons despite having a number others dining. Highly recommend for a delicious meal and attentive service. Thank you for our memorable meal! read more

Il Montebello - Our attentive server Alek - Italian Near Me - Yarmouth, Massachusetts

Manager is a complete jerk and treats customers terribly! we have spent good money at this place and the manager was rude and couldn't care less! The owner should get rid of him. read more

We've eaten here since they opened. The service is always exceptional. We usually go here with my in-laws and make a reservation but tonight we went just ourselves and ate at the bar. Our bartender was awesome(I didn't get his name) my husband got the swordfish picatta and he said it was excellent. I got the dish I always get, the chicken and sausage with fettuccine (polo scarapiello). Tonight's meal was a little disappointing as the chicken was boneless thigh meat instead of breast. The thigh meat has a different taste and was tough. This dish has always been with chicken breast and I wish it would've been noted on the menu as I would not have gotten it. I'll know for the next time and there are other delicious options on their menu. Otherwise, this restaurant has a vast menu and great service. In the summer it has a very nice outside deck. I also love that they give you limoncello at the end of your meal. read more

Ordered sea bass for 29.95. It was wet, poached and gross. My husband had seafood risotto. The shrimp was decent but the risotto had a weird sugary taste. The food is high priced and not good. If they want to survive during Covid they better step up their game. read more

Very good food, although service was a bit slow on a recent visit. Nice atmosphere and large menu selection. Overall would recommend.

I SPENT 47.00 ON A PIZZA AND A SIDE OF MUSHROOMS!! The pizza arrived cold ( perhaps the fault of Grubhub). The pizza was supposed to have extra cheese and mushrooms. No mushrooms, and they didn't even bother to CUT the pizza. No cutlery, no salt or pepper. Mushrooms were bland button mushrooms.. not even seasoned. SO BADD. I will NEVER go back to this place. read more

Food was good. Drinks as well. Service a little slow but generally a pleasant experience. Nice outdoor seating. Staff friendly.

Great food, service and friendliness by all staff.... I had sole francaise, clams casino and spaghetti Bolognese and my husband had the salmon special-can't wait to go back-great menu-lots of choices-thoroughly enjoyed the evening.... read more

This restaurant has gone downhill since we were there three years ago and we would not recommend. The food was not very good....two pizzas ordered...one was burned and one was undercooked. Pasta dish was watery; swordfish was not edible. Atmosphere is loud and unattractive; big Pepsi machine in the dining room; service was poor with personnel having difficulty with understanding English.....not their fault but it made menu choices and questions difficult. We will never return or recommend. The manager was rude and not customer friendly. It didn't even look clean. read more

This place took my order before they closed, then canceled it while I was waiting for my food. Hope they enjoy their evening off.

The service was awful. The place was practically empty at 3pm and we were largely ignored. We had to grab someone other than our waiter to ask for the check. Food was average, service was awful. Sorry, won't be back. read more

Have been here a few times and have had pleasant experiences. Good food and service. My last visit was completely spoiled by horrible service. The waitress was rude, inattentive and down right annoying. When I spoke to the owner/manager about this experience he was just as rude. He defended her and was angry at me for bringing it up to him. Told us not to come back if we didn't like the service and added that they are busy enough. Won't ever go back! read more

Well, I have to say, even though I will most likely be back again, I still have truly mixed feelings about this place. Let me start by saying that the food was truly AMAZING! Seasoning was on point. I had a yummy Ceasar salad, and great Alfredo for my main course. Then, I had the Profiteroles for dessert and oh my, they were delicious!!! Overall A+ for the cuisine. The service? Not so great. We waited 20 minutes at the door for a seven o'clock reservation. Everyone in line with us also had reservations. Several people just gave up and left. When we finally were seated, our server was very pleasant. He was clearing working overtime, since they were very understaffed. He worked as a busser, waiter, and bartender. Some of the staff were challenging to understand because of their thick Italian accent, but it did add to the experience! The atmosphere? Decent. We sat outside. It was nice on a golf course, great view, however, we got the bad table. We were seated right next to the dirty plates and dishes, which were an awful eyesore. No music, which was sad. The seats were uncomfortable, I saw some bringing a cushion. Overall, nice spot, if you got a good table. Social distancing wise? Bad. When we were waiting in line to be seated, there was no order and everyone was heaped inside a small hallway, no restrictions. I felt slightly unsafe. They cleaned down the tables, quickly between uses. But the owner himself had his nose out of his mask!!!! That was very uncomfortable for me. Overall, the food was awesome, service slow, not the best place for COVID safe dining. Will definitely be returning, but maybe just for takeout until this whole thing is over. read more

Montebello Restaurant ruined Mother's Day for our family. We ordered lobster rolls. They were the worst lobster rolls we never ate because they served old, just boiled lobster, so the lobster salad was hot. They were not edible. When I asked for a Gift Certificate, not even a refund, the manager refused. Montebello obviously thinks it's ok to serve inedible food for take out. AVOID IT LIKE THE PLAGUE. Never going there again and it is in King's Way where we live. read more

We were very dissatisfied with our meals. My wife has the veal saltimbocca. It was tough . I had the swordfish in wilted linguine.the Parmesan was overpowering. This is surprising because the restaurant is affiliated with the Four seasons restaurant in South Yarmouth that has great food. We knew something was amiss when the wait staff never asked how our meal tastes!!! read more

We have been going to this restaurant for many years. My night out with my mother turned into a nightmare. We were midway into our dessert when we were asked to move and change tables so that they could accommodate a larger party. We were rushed and treated like we were not important. Then when we asked to talk to the manager, the waitress said you should feel lucky the owner isn't here. He would have not been as nice to you. Really? It was so disturbing. Customer Serive? read more

I'm a little afraid to post this review because it might make other people show up at Il Montebello and crowd me out. But in all seriousness we were really impressed. The restaurant at Kings Way seems to turn over more frequently than it should. They just haven't been able to get a good outfit in there. Until now. The restaurant is run by the same folks who run the renowned Four Seasons Trattoria on the other side of town. Worth a visit if you're cruising the south side of Yarmouth. The only reason I took a star off for this particular evening was because they were a bit understaffed and it made some of the service slow (to be fair it was July 3). But that is where the criticism ends. I can tell you about the excellent service, the house Chardonnay that knocked my socks off, the beautiful view over the golf course, or the rich but actually light homemade pasta, but the one thing that made the biggest impression on us was that they CARED. From the person who answered the phone for our reservation, to the servers (all of them), to the bartender, they all hustled and were as attentive as they could possibly be on what seemed like a surprisingly busy night for them. We will most definitely come back, and next time we will bring friends (oh, and a little bug spray if we're going to eat on the patio, just in case). read more

Had a wonderful dinner. Great, patient service. Very personable. Beautiful, spacious setting. Split a Caprese salad to start. Very nice and Mozzarella was perfect. I had Chicken Romano that was delicious and tender with sweet artichokes. My wife had the Chicken Marsala that she really enjoyed. My son had a Swordfish special that didn't last long. Very fresh. As great as the meal was the dessert special, made table side by the owner, was incredible. Fresh fruit covered in a custard with Prosecco. Unbelievable! Been back a number of times. Each as perfect as the first. The issue now is deciding between all the great entree choices. read more