Arrived Saturday night following a matinee performance of the CC Symphony--there were 7 of us seated and taken care of by Jack, who was amazing and gave suggestions when asked. Entrees were delicious (I had the butternut squash ravs in cream sauce and an espresso martini. We all shared the crème brûlée and the cherry-almond bread pudding (my personal favorite). Loved the food, service & the read more

See all

This is our first night on the Cape for Labor Day Weekend and we picked Siena to get an order to go. It was a major mistake. We picked up our order on time and it was all cold. The Greek Salad pizza was obviously done first, it was cold. The Cod filet was under-done and the potatoes were hard like they had been sitting in a warming tray and last but certainly not least the Chicken Parm. The Chicken was so bad that we actually were wondering if was pre-made and warmed up in a microwave. There was nothing redeeming about this meal. Oh, its price tag of 142.00 including tips the scale. If we could have give half a star, we would read more

I love Siena I have written many reviews before tonight about this restaurant. I have used the upstairs for a family function Our waitress Coleen L was a gem She had been on an extra shift and she was hustling and yet she was attentive as if there were no one else that she had to serve Thank you Coleen L Great place to dine read more

See all

We decided to order through DoorDash after the restaurant we had Valentine's Day reservations at couldn't accommodate us. So, I can't comment on the customer service or atmosphere, but I can definitely speak to the food--and let me tell you, it's rare that I finish a meal and wish I could still be eating it. This was my first time trying chicken Milanese, and I'd gladly return just for that dish. The nutty flavor of the arugula combined with the rich creaminess of Parmesan and the zesty lemony notes on the chicken cutlets was absolutely incredible. The potatoes were perfectly seasoned with a nice crispy texture--overall, I was thoroughly impressed. My fiancé went for the grilled ribeye, and you could really taste that it was grilled to perfection. The portion was huge, and it's a great value for what you get. And let's not forget the meatballs--seriously, they were AMAZEBALLS. If you're visiting the area, even if Italian food isn't your first choice (though they do offer other options), this place is a must-try! read more

Siena Restaurant - Chicken Milanese , Grilled Ribeye Steak, and Meatball App. Complimentary bread and Parmesan dipping oil. - Italian Near Me - Mashpee, Massachusetts

Went tonight for the first time. Yes, I'm boring, so I ordered the veal parm. It was okay. Just okay. The marinara sauce had way too much of whatever herb mix they use. Way too much. I took a lot of pasta home, and plan on adding some jarred marinara sauce to tone down the overuse of herbs. Will likely try it again. read more

Walk into the restaurant with 4 employees at the hostess stand chatting. No greeting, no acknowledgement of existence. Ask if my take out order is ready and one of them begrudgingly head to the kitchen without a word... Food was cold but okay, quality and customer service do not match the price and quality of other restaurants in the area is so much better read more

Great outdoor patio. They have a rotating summer sangria special and i started with that very refreshing drink. I had a generous and tasty halibut with risotto and veg. My husband ordered his own delicious pizza and an IPA. We were too stuffed for dessert. Would return. read more

We had dinner for four people at Siena. The overall experience was OK, but the prices were quite high and the quality of the food was mediocre. The bread was not fresh; the meatballs tasted as if they came out of a can or TV dinner. Although our waiter was very nice and helpful, there were many young people on the staff hastily walking back-and-forth and not giving way to customers. At one point, I was actually tripped by someone who walked too close behind me. Additionally, we had a gluten-sensitive diner on primary and ordered some gluten-free items, but one of the items came out with bread crumbs , which I caught and asked about, thankfully. Considering the prices, we did not feel that the food and service were up to par. read more

Long wait for food,but we had wine and bread. Fried calamari undercooked! Ordered Bolognese,absolutely tasteless! We kept putting salt on it,still no taste,very weird. Server brought use free dessert because of slow service,nice girl,but we didn't complain! Just won't go back even though we have gone there since it opened! We try it every year and it is never as good as it was,going downhill annually,too bad,last time. read more

Went in for a dinner with friends. The food was nothing special. The full meal portion was large but so was the price. The pasta was not fresh, and the sauce was Ragu style. Veal parm was 2 round circles almost resembling veal patties. The facility was well appointed. The service was efficient but unfriendly! First visit and it's -One And Done!! read more

This lovely little restaurant was a perfect spot to enjoy dinner on a work trip. The ambiance was very calm, dark, yet inviting. The staff was very attentive and friendly. I wanted to love this place, but sadly my entree lacked flavor and I had to add salt and pepper, which is not common for me to do. I had the Padre e Figlio which was Pappardelle pasta with mushrooms and garlic. The pasta appeared homemade and the ingredients were fresh- so I was thrown off by how bland it was. I will definitely give it another go and try something different next time- maybe a pizza. read more

Siena Restaurant - Padre e Figlio - Italian Near Me - Mashpee, Massachusetts

We had a work party here and I started with the Raspberry Lemon Drop for a drink and then just had them keep coming as it was delish. I then got the calamari for an app. It was fresh fried to perfections and not rubbery at all. My main course was the veal parm, this also was excellent. So much food that I was able to take half home and have later in the week. If your ever in Mashpee and are craving Italian this is the place to go. The staff is attentive and very friendly and professional. AND the food THE FOOD !!! read more

See all

6 of us had dinner last night. Both my wives' dinner & mine were mediocre at best. Service was adequate, nice table. Other meals were better than ours --- none really outstanding. I will be reluctant to return soon -- too many other better choices. read more

Food was pretty awful. Ambiance is nice and staff were nice as well. Got the Bruschetta as an appetizer which tasted fine, however was messy and none of the ingredients were especially high quality. Got the Tuscan Sausage pizza for dinner which makes this a low star review for me. The roasted garlic cloves were just too much and ruined any chance of flavor for me. Some slices were just missing half the ingredients all together, like just plain bread almost. It was also soggy and drooping. I understand it was a busy, but it honestly was a disappointing meal and I could keep listing more specific complaints about the pizza. However thank you to the staff for being nice, especially the server who could tell I wasn't very happy and still was nice to us. read more

We went here recently for our anniversary. The atmosphere was very nice and our waitress was amazing. So personable and very attentive. The food was just ok to me. I had halibut with farro and it was dry and boring. My husband had a bolognese and it was dry and boring. My daughters both had pasta with vodka sauce. They both liked theirs. The bread was good and the drinks were good. I'd give them a second chance. read more

See all

Service was ok. Food was terrible the Calamari was over fried and brittle. The chicken parm was also over fried and uneatable so I sent it back and the second one was just as bad. So I had a small salad with three shrimp was ok. The ambience was fine but I would not recommend the food here. The staff is ok but the kitchen is really bad. read more

The only reason for 2 is because of the young man in the bar who was SO helpful. In the past we normally just come in. He needs a raise. I called to see if you would honor a Mashpee commons gift card and he checked with the manager and said yes as long as it wasn't outdated. The card was from less than a year ago so we assumed it was a go! My husband went in to order and the man at the door took the to go order and said "No, it's not working. Go try the gift card at a store near by or something." I asked my husband to try the order with someone else because the man at the door didn't seem to know how to work the system. This ended up being well over an hour ordeal. The bartender did get the gift card to go through. But don't ask for any special requests! We asked for tomatoes on a pasta and the kitchen said they can't add tomatoes to a dish because they don't carry tomatoes (it's an Italian restaurant). The poor employee seemed embarrassed and when we got home we saw why. The mussels ordered for an appetizer had tomatoes sprinkled all over it. The BBQ chicken pizzas toppings were only on one side. Furthermore, it was implied that because it was a gift card the order wasn't very important... but some of the order was paid by us with tip as it was our anniversary. We normally spend our anniversary with you but probably not anymore. We go out like 2 times a year. A take out order took at least 1.5 hours because we had a gift card. Thank goodness for the kind young man in the bar. read more

Food was not hot and pasta was not freshly cooked! Chicken parm was horrible. It was served in a bowl of mush. Don't sit in the back room! It's so noisy you can't hear your parties conversation. read more

This used to be a great place for pizza and entrees but over the past two years the prices have increased the quality of the pizza and entrees have been unacceptable. There are other restaurants in the area that are offering a diverse menu at favorable prices. Of course during the summer months the place is full of tourists due to outdoor dining. If it's ambience you want then dine here. read more

It is Friday night, and that mean take-away from Sienna! We have become obsessed with Sienna's Bolognese and a Mediterranean Salad. We have repeated many times; each time amazing. We need to come in for their 4/c dinner soon! read more

We were staying in nearby Cotuit and picked a random restaurant for dinner. We couldn't have made a better choice. Everything from the service, food, drinks, and atmosphere were fantastic. Jess and Ben were both very gracious and welcoming. The cocktail list was interesting and creative, and all of our food was delicious. We will certainly be making Siena a regular routine whenever we are in the area. read more

Siena Restaurant - Crispy brussels sprouts and breaded artichokes - Italian Near Me - Mashpee, Massachusetts

My roommate group had dinner at Siena tonight. It was great! We had two appetizers, grilled artichokes and roasted Brussel sprouts. For main courses we had penne putsnesco, pasta Bolognese, and eggplant parmigiana. The eggplant was delicious! Service was great. read more

Siena Restaurant - Eggplant parmigiana - Italian Near Me - Mashpee, Massachusetts

It was a cold evening over Christmas. My husband and I went with two friends. Indoors, the restaurant was nearly as cold as outside. I had to wear my parka. I almost asked for an outdoor heater. It wasn't just the temperature that was cold. The ambience was frigid. Not much effort went into making the place warm and cheery.....Then the food arrived and things got worse. I had a Ceasar's salad with shrimp added. It's a good thing I work out a lot because it took all my strength to slice the shrimp to eat. The romaine lettuce didn't seem fresh. My husband had mussels. Small, dry mussels. Have you ever had small, dried mussels? I didn't think so?... It must have been a few days old harvest. One of our guests ordered a side order of Brussel sprouts that arrived black. Brussel sprouts are most often green. I've never seen black Brussel sprouts. They tasted dry and crunchy. I wouldn't feed these things to my Golden. If you know Goldens, they love to eat.....The other guest enjoyed her hamburger in an Italian restaurant. We should have gone to a burger joint,... The good thing is that we now know never to go there again. read more

My husband and I were recently in Cape Cod for a quick getaway but unfortunately a lot of things were closed now that summer is over. We found ourselves in a small shop area with some restaurants still open, one of which was Siena. The manager/front person who was an Indian man was pretty rude and terse but our waitress was nice and attentive. The food was also much better than we expected. We weren't super hungry so we just got a Cesar salad, meatballs and calamari, all of which were well made. The meatballs were especially good and surprising. I'd recommend whoever it was who led us to our table get a better attitude though. read more

Siena Restaurant - Meatballs, calamari and Cesar salad - Italian Near Me - Mashpee, Massachusetts

I stopped in for an early supper after shopping at Mashpee Commons. Today is my last day here and I've been having mostly seafood all week. I was extremely surprised at how good my meal was, it was fantastic! My waiter Brian was absolutely the best server I have had all week, bar none! Because it wasn't peak supper time there were not a lot of folks here at the time which I liked because it was nice and quiet. I have to give this restaurant 5 stars without question as they checked all my boxes and ended up being the best I had all week! read more

Just had dinner there for the second time . In addition to the good food & service, I especially liked that you can order small or large portions on some dinners, priced accordingly. read more

I have been here a handful of times over the year and have never been disappointed, but it is never a restaurant that I think to visit. We went for lunch because we had a gift card. It was surprisingly busy, but there was no wait. We were seated at a comfy, large booth. Our server came over quickly with waters and told us he would be with us in a few minutes. He was efficient and polite, but not necessarily friendly. We ordered the calamari appetizer, which was a very large portion! The two of us didn't come close to finishing it. I suggest ordering it for 3 or more people to share. My favorite part was the crispy banana peppers mixed in. The dipping sauce that it was served with was interesting and good. For entrees we ordered the siena burger and the "famous" caesar salad with salmon. The burger was delicious. Cooked perfectly medium rare and topped with crispy bacon, cheese, and caramelized onions. The burger seemed to be made with high quality beef. It was served on a really nice bun. It was one of the better burgers that I have had in a while. The truffle fries were also good ($4 upcharge which was a bit steep). We also loved the Caesar. Siena is definitely able to live up to the "famous" reputation. Other than the sad fact that they don't serve their delicious bread during lunch, we were pleased with our meal! read more

Siena Restaurant - Calamari appetizer was HUGE and delicious! - Italian Near Me - Mashpee, Massachusetts

See all

Siena has gone severely down hill. I have been going to this restaurant for the past 10+ years and every time it gets worse. The bread is stale as can be. Might as well not even offer it at that point. Pasta is just plain and boring. Sauce tastes like it is straight from the can. I really have tried to like Siena since it used to be so good, but unfortunately I can no longer make excuses for this place. It's just a meh restaurant with overpriced food. read more

We came here for lunch on a Saturday and we're seated right away. My fiancé and I both got Italian sodas and split the Tuscan sausage pizza. Everything was so good and fresh. Definitely coming back to try the pasta dishes! read more

Siena Restaurant - Tuscan Sausage Pizza - Italian Near Me - Mashpee, Massachusetts

Food was mediocre at best. I ordered their seasonal ravioli dish- pumpkin (I had two bites and that was it - so sweet and doughy). My husband ordered the chicken parmigiana which is pretty basic but he requested rigatoni instead of spaghetti and of course that never happened ! We never send anything back because we know what happens when you do that !!!! Tiramisu was very basic. Waitress was bored and tried to rush us out while we were still eating our mediocre tiramisu by plonking the check on the table. DON'T waste your money ! read more

Worst Italian restaurant I've had. My husband ordered spaghetti and meatballs. Needless to say meatballs were hard as a rock terrible. We complained to the waiter. They gave him short rib ravioli instead. But he had to wait for it till we all finish eating it finally came to the table. I ordered the chicken Parm. It wasn't good either but I didn't complain. We couldn't believe that we had to wait for this food an hour and a half. And that's probably how they get you. Food is mediocre very expensive. Extremely disappointing. My brother got Pasta Bolognese. It was terrible. We end up paying an absorbent amount of money for something that was mediocre. Very disappointing. read more

Great chicken piccata and parm dishes. Their pizza leaves a lot to be desired. Not worth the $20 or more that it costs. Got a pizza to-go the other day and was disappointed. The rest of the menu and cocktails there are delicious. Service is always friendly and they have a great patio for outdoor dining when the weather is nice. Prices are higher than the quality bc of Mashpee commons setting so that goes into play. But on pizza line there are better options near by. But a wonderful date night or celebration spot. read more

Siena Restaurant - Cheese pizza - Italian Near Me - Mashpee, Massachusetts

See all

Good service. Went at lunchtime. I think their dinner menu and prep is much better. Pleasant atmosphere. read more

Food/service very average for the high prices charged Outside seating is great when weather good enough to sit outside read more

Decent place didn't go in but ordered takeout. All my good was really good and decent portions for grabbing lunch stuff. I'd come back to sit inside or outside. read more

Excellent atmosphere great wait staff Mixed drinks wine over pours for very reasonable prices food great Go about once a month a go to for sure read more

Siena's website states "We love parties" and "It is the place you can proudly bring guests for an evening of great food, great wine and great people." We found this to be absolutely true. We recently had a surprise birthday party at Siena with 15 guests. It is one of the few restaurants in the area that accepts reservations. The staff was so accommodating. We were welcomed in the main dining room and made to feel at home. The service was outstanding and the food was delicious. Some of the favorite dishes were the truffle fries, calamari, beef short rib ravioli, mediterranean salad and shrimp scampi. read more

I would not recommend I've been here 3 times now each of the last 3 summers however it seemed like the quality had dipped each year... I will give it another chance because my family loves it read more

We ordered 2 cheese pizza's tonight. Both were overcooked. The one pictured was very overdone. It wasn't even sliced. Needless to say we will not be ordering pizza From there anymore. Little sauce, dry cheese, no flavor. Very disappointing. read more

Siena Restaurant - Cheese pizza from Siena, Mashpee - Italian Near Me - Mashpee, Massachusetts

Absolutely wonderful Food is great No complaints about the service Easy to find parking in the lot behind the restaurant read more