More like The Pizza Disguise. They serve crappy spongy dough with ketchup and melted cheese disguised as a pizza. No wonder the place was empty at 6:15. Horrible pizza unless you find the worst kind of cheap ingredient Greek pizza worth eating. Wouldn't eat it again at any price. Friendly people but this isn't food, it's garbage. read more

Ordered a Gyro sandwich and small Pub (premade) pizza at 6:00 on a Monday night off season for the Cape. Got an email acknowledgement then another saying expect delivery around 7:13. They arrived a half hour after the expected time...the sandwich meat cold (even though wrapped in foil) and the pizza completely congealed, looking like a leftover. My home is not even a 5 minute drive from the restaurant. Not good. read more

Great takeout spot after a long drive to the Cape! Delicious eggplant parm with penne, and meatballs with penne... and the bread!! Toasted and garlicky. Huge portion for a "half" order. So good! Friendly staff. Double thumbs up. read more

Pizza Guyz - Eggplant parm with penne - Pizza Near Me - Mashpee, Massachusetts

See all

Walked in, stood around not acknowledged by any of the 10 staff members. Decided to move on and get pizza elsewhere. A simple "hello, be right with you" would have sufficed. read more

I ordered the gyro dinner and a small cheese pizza for delivery. Came 30 minutes before they said it would get to me and was fresh and hot! The gyro tasted great, warm pita bread and gyro with veggies, it came with a salad and a huge portion of fries which were great. The cheese pizza might not look the best visibly but the taste was amazing. One of the best pizza sauces i've ever tasted. I totally recommend trying it, this place needs better ratings because the food is wonderful. read more

Came in and got a couple of slices. Very mediocre pizza. Dominoes is better imo. Pricey as well. Service was decent - but still, wouldn't bother returning. read more

Pizza Guyz - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Mashpee, Massachusetts

See all

Took over 2 hours for delivery! Pizza was lukewarm at best! Never again. Other than that pizza was good. read more

There was a mix up with our order and the manager/owner made it up to us. I have a lot of respect for this business and the pizza was delicious! Thank you! read more

The best bbq chicken pizza EVER. Service was great and despite being extremely hot, everyone was very friendly. Will definitely be back

Pizza looked a little smaller than we were used to. Got the large- 8 small pieces. But it tasted good! Delivery was quicker than expected.

Awesome subs very friendly and fast no errors on orders either great steak bomb and fries

Good pizza. Fast. Nice staff. Good deal for the price in todays market. Was delicious as leftovers next day too

I'm new to the area so I had to take a chance on a Pizza place and start weeding them out. The Pizza Guyz is just want you want for a pizza/wings/beer night at home. Fresh and well made with good ingredients. I will be going back for sure read more

Pizza Guyz - Custom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mashpee, Massachusetts

This is my go to place. Very friendly staff excellent service, fair portions and pricing. Hard working folks that care about their community. read more

Had friends over last night for their chicken Parmesan calzone and steak and cheese calzone. Both were a huge success and delicious. Both were huge in size and included plenty of marinara sauce. Five stars and Thank you to the Pizza guyz. read more

Ordered a small pizza, fried ravioli and clam chowder for delivery. Hands down best pizza we've had in the Mashpee area since we moved here in May. Fried ravioli were also delicious. Can't beat Captain Parker's chowder and the price was super reasonable. Highly recommend this place!! read more

Everytime I order something that comes with sauce, I never get the sauce. Today I called and explained that to them when I put my order in for delivery . And low and behold they once again delivered my food without sauce when I called back to speak to a manager and Tania is who she said her name was acted like it was somehow my fault. After waiting 1 hour and 40 minutes for my food she then told me I had to wait again for my sauce to be delivered. She offered to refund me only the money for the bluecheese they never gave me. Horrible service, Horrible management, Horrible idea for anyone to eat here. .... read more

I ordered the Calzone and my wife ordered the Eggplant Parmesan pasta. We were both impressed how good the food was. Not only it was good but also plentiful. I ordered the large expecting to eat half and take home leftovers but could eat about a third. The atmosphere was very nice. It felt like the home town pizza shop. Customers in and out were greeting by their first names. Really nice. read more

Great family owned and operated business. Delicious pizzas, subs, and daily specials.

I ordered delivery to the Mashpee High School for our teams bus ride home after the games. We needed a gluten-free pizza for a celiac student and 12 other pizza's. They were super helpful, on time and made sure there was no cross-contamination. The kids and coaches all raved about the taste of the pizzas. Would highly recommend! read more

My favorite pizza place in the whole world. I just wish it was closer. Everything here is delicious but I especially recommend the macaroni and cheese bites! read more

It's like a $5.00 pizza. You're better off getting a frozen pizza from a grocery store

Pizzas are average. Dough/crust is nothing great and sauce is mediocre. but the PRICE is where its at. Way way way overpriced. $18.49 for one topping. If they had real competition they would be out of business or lowering prices to make it affordable. A large 3-4 topping pizza should cost $15. Cheap owner never gives any decent discounts. Mashpee needs affordable food and its not this place. read more

Try the new pub style pizza.fast delivery. Good size menu to choose from prices are ok

LOVE THE FOOD! Always ready fast, I don't live in the cape but everytime i'm there i stop here!

I come here at least once a week for lunch and i've never been disappointed! They are fast and have such a great variety of food. My favorites are the chicken pita, and chicken caesar wrap, the alfredo wrap and the burgers!! They also have the best sweet potato fries ive ever had!! I love this place 10/10 everything is so good!!! read more

We ordered delivery during the week. They were very courteous on the phone and the delivery arrived quickly. That aside, I have to agree with the negative reviews - why is this pizza barely cooked?! The pizza has a strange doughy characteristic to it and you can tell the pizza dough hasn't been cooked enough - I found that to be quite disgusting. The eggplant Parmesan grinder wasn't much better - soggy bread, flavorless and soggy eggplant. I wasn't impressed and I would say this is far from the, "best pizza" on the Cape. Go elsewhere. read more

Very tasty pizza and subs, severs plenty of fries! Very polite employees, make you feel welcomed!!! Chile is to die for!!

Just awful pizza...greek style, which is undercooked, doughy bread ..not a good crust and sauce is bland with too much cheap cheese. If your main offering is pizza, then master it. This is far from anything I would recommend. read more

They've gained a new favorite customer. The pizza was deelish. They initially sent a burger that wasn't prepared correctly but when i called back they said they'd fix it immediately and it was devine. They even gave me more curly fries (I ate the ones with the wrong burger, they were good lol). And they send the bun, condiments, and wet toppings in a separate container which is what really sold me. I hate wet bread!! read more

This place has great subs. The meat is always fresh, great vegetables and an excellent quality northeast style sub roll. I've tried a bunch - from roast beef (perfectly rare!), Italians, cheesesteaks and blt's - they've all been great. This is my local go-to place for a great sub! read more

For anyone craving traditional American food for little price, this is your place!! my boyfriend and I got regular french fries, sweet potato fries and a clam chowder cup. The order took a while to come out but the wait was well worth it! I want to mention the size of the portion they give you- we got a small on both fries and got a HUGE BOWL of fries that we could barely finish. Same goes for the clam chowder- a cup in this place was like a bowl sized clam chowder at the average restaurant, not to mention it was delicious. The sweet potato fries were incredible and I don't want to get carried away and say that they were made on the spot but they definitely looked and tasted like they did. Overall, if you're looking for something cheap, American, and filling, this is your spot! read more

Pizza Guyz - a plate of french fries and dipping sauce - Pizza Near Me - Mashpee, Massachusetts

See all

Pizza Guyz is by far my family's favorite place to get pizza. The pizza has an amazing flavor and I'm not sure how they could ever get a one star review. This is a family owned business and they care about the food and service that they offer. I live off cape and anytime we are in the area, my kids beg to eat here. Don't listen to the bad reviews, try it for yourself and you will not be disappointed. I wish that they were a franchise so that everyone could enjoy their food on and off cape. Thank you Pizza Guyz keep up the great work! -Melanie read more

Ok, so this place came highly recommended, but I'm not too sure why. Pizza wasn't fully cooked and tasted ok. The wings were the typical deep fried wing, and same as the pizza, tasted ok. There were ceiling tiles failing down over the seating area and over the kitchen. Not sure of the pricing for this area, but they seemed expensive for what they offer. On the plus side, the staff was super friendly. read more

pizza dry, lukewarm and hard as if it had been sitting out too long. Over done or reheated? I don't know. I have had better from them in the past. Sorry can not recommend them, read more

Their box boasts this is the "BEST PIZZA". I'm not sure I'd go that far .. but something about their pepperoni pizza is truly addictive. I think because they might throw some cheddar on there.. maybe (??).. anyway, yum. What IS best is their specials! Grab a menu or download one online and there's a different bonus offering every weekday. No coupon, no problem - when you call just tell them you'd like "the special". Pizza Guyz' garlic and parm fries rival Red Robin's - those are a "must try" - especially since they will upgrade the regular fries for $2. Worth it. We were underwhelmed by the fried raviolis. These seemed as if they were fried from froze, rather than hand breaded, which was a shame. If they did these by hand they might be able to add some spice (or flavor) which would help. The greek plates were very generously portioned but both the pita and the grilled chicken lacked that "we just made all this fresh" vibe that the Royal Family Restaurant in Dennisport's chicken souvlaki gyro has. That knocks off a star, plus their phones are seriously under-manned at lunchtimes: Busy, busy, busy, then "can you please hold?" every time. Still - popular is a good sign - and we liked some things here, and Pizza Guy's pepp pizza, garlic fires & specials are dope, so we'll keep coming back. read more

Very good pizza! Not to even bring up the delicious curly fries, which were heavenly.

I drove by this place for a while now, never thinking much of it. I usually order stuff closer to home on the rt. 28/Falmouth area. Glad I did. Great friendly service from the guys working there, and never a long wait. Tried the steak n cheese and it really is one of the best in town. Fresh chopped steak and a fresh sub roll w melted cheese. Hit the spot. Also tried the honey bbq melt w bacon blended cheeses and ranch dressing. Just as good as the one friendly's serves if not better as a wrap. They also do have the best fries in town. Legit Look forward to trying the pizza this weekend read more

Love this place excellent food and fast delivery! I would of given it 5 stars except there has been a couple of delivery mistakes that they brought me wrong thing and I didn't want to wait and was told next time my sandwich would be on them and when I brought it up next time they didn't know about it but delivery girl remembered next time she brought me a delivery ! I had ordered a grilled chicken sub and was brought a grilled chicken pizza and two other times I asked for the military discount and was not given it ..otherwise we order from this place about once a week! The food is exceptional ! read more

The NASTIEST food, I've EVER had in my LIFE! We all have/had DIARRHEA!! The pasta dishes are some quart jar out of a warehouse of no-name brand bulk made for prisoners ;every other spaghetti has the "MARINARA". The pizza is basically "Salted Dough", the sandwiches are equally "SALTY"; Luckily the "Gyro",has thick pita, so the salt doesn't hit you as much, but the "DIARRHEA" still coming. HORRIBLE! HORRIBLE! HORRIBLE! read more