First time trying out "I Love NY Pizza" - I called in my order and spoke to a gentlemen who was friendly & answered all my questions as I was not prepared and did not look at the menu ahead of time. He told me that I could expect to pick up the order in 20-25 minutes. I arrived 30 minutes later and my order was hot and ready to go! I ordered a 12 cut sausage pizza and 12 medium wings. Both items were delicious - pizza was thin and chicken was moist and flavorful. Upon pickup, I noticed many different options in the display case which all looked great - can't wait to come back and try more. read more

I Love NY Pizza - Sausage Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Schenectady, New York

I don't normally do this as I don't want to affect their business in the area. They make great pizza. But they outsource to a delivery service that is absolutely horrible and there isn't much recourse for their customers so I feel it should be known. We ordered a pizza last night. It was a cold rainy night. We did not request contactless delivery. We specifically said please ring the bell or text us upon arrival. The delivery service did neither of those things. We were sitting in our living room (next to the front door) awaiting its arrival. I decided to run out and grab soda and upon opening the outside porch door (We have a covered front porch) I almost stepped on our pizza. It was left on the outside concrete steps in the cold and rain for I don't know how long. I know it was long enough for it to be a cold, soggy pizza. We called the pizza shop who said they couldn't help us because it's an outside delivery service. We were provided the outside (slice.com) delivery services phone number. They wouldn't offer anything more than a 15% off refund and had the audacity to say "the pizza was delivered a half hour early." Be aware when/how you order. We will not be using I love NY again, again, not because their pizza is bad but because I will not deal with their delivery service. read more

This is NY. One of the best slices around. There are few places who do pizza right, I Love NY Pizza is one that nails it. I Love is a typical pizza joint where you can come in and order by the slice, or get a whole pie if you're feeding the family. They also have a number of other options on their menu, but why bother with such a selection of pies? Grab your slice to go or eat at their indoor tables. The staff is beyond friendly and go above and beyond to make the pizza right the first time. Don't expect fine dining, expect aw some food! read more

I Love NY Pizza - Tomatoe Bacon Tomato Ranch Slice - Pizza Near Me - Schenectady, New York

Very good NY style pizza. We get a large pie with mushrooms and very happy with it. One of our go to places in the area

First time in NY, stopped by I Love NY Pizza for lunch. Staff were very genuine and generous enough to give us some sample slices. Definitely recommend. read more

My families go to spot for pizza nights. Love the pizza and wings!! Plus they have specials! They are always willing to accommodate food modifications! Super customer service! I have tried other pizza places and can't find anywhere else that has both great wings and pizza!! read more

I ordered a grilled chicken salad online actually 2 of them. it was $50 for two salads.. I decided to pick it up. I specified that I wanted extra cucumber. Upon picking up the salads i was told that they refused to do extra cucumber.as rude as that is I pay the $29 and leave. When I got home, 5mins away, and my salad is all lettuce, no cucumbers at all! My food experience is ruined and I should have gotten a refund when they refused to make my food they way I asked. NEVER EVER WILL I SUPPORT THIS BUSINESS AGAIN! read more

I Love NY Pizza - a salad in a plastic container - Pizza Near Me - Schenectady, New York

Where is the best slice of pizza? Well, that depends. Which shops are closest to you when you need a slice the most? There is a great joy to having a local slice shop. A place where you feel at home. It's your shop. You enjoy the highs. You weather the lows. And you get to know the pizza deeply. For a long time, The Pizza King was our local shop in Schenectady. When the king himself passed away, the place was just no longer the same. I Love may not have the same magic, but this shop makes a solid slice. The crisp bottom is unmarred by the telltale cross hatches of a pizza screen. Crust bubbles exist and they are glorious. The crust itself has decent flavor, and the end crust has a reasonable lift. My whole family appreciates the judicious application of sauce. It's hard to walk the line of just enough, but not too much. I can't tell you how many times I'm called into service to scrape extra sauce off my daughter's slice at other shops. Is it brilliant? Not quite. But it's good enough to keep bringing us back week after week. That's no small feat. And now, it feels like home. read more

I Love NY Pizza - Look at that bottom. - Pizza Near Me - Schenectady, New York

One of our go to delivery spots. Good prices and fast delivery. We like the jalapeño and pepperoni pizzas best. At times, pizzas can be a little inconsistent, but nevertheless good. read more

I arrived here at the very end of a recent pizza tour, and was pretty stuffed already. But, upon walking in I was hit with the sights of about a dozen different types of pizza waiting to be eaten by the slice. My wife had the pepperoni, and I could only stare at the sausage which looked fantastic but I was too full to enjoy. The pizza was cooked perfectly, with a nice dark brown crust and enough chew to give a great mouth feel. The sauce was flavorful and the cheese nice and stretchy. The pepperoni caused a grease pool so deep that a lifeguard could have gotten a summer job here. I tried bites from my wife's and liked it a lot. It is similar to other good pizza places in town, and I wish I had a much emptier stomach when I came here. But, I got a pizza of Hawaiian pizza to go (yum) so I will get to enjoy this place again later tonight! read more

Boring flavorless sauce, rock hard crust and a $28 price for a large pizza. With so many other good choices in town, just pick someone else.

I recently ordered from this restaurant located on Union Street, Schenectady, N.Y. They used to be great. They stopped delivering service for many, many months after the pandemic so I was happy they were back to delivery. Unfortunately, I ordered the chicken wings and when they were delivered, there were five wings that were loaded with "fried" chicken feathers still attached to the wings!! Not sure how they didn't notice all of the feathers since some of the feathers were at least three inches long. Totally threw them all out. Fortunately, I will never be ordering from them again. Unfortunately, they lost a loyal customer! (The post has me from California, but I'm not in California - I'm in the Capital District, NY). read more

Excellent pizza. The owner was great to us, and we'll definitely go back next time we are in the area!

I order from this location several times a year, never had a problem, food is great, the guys are awesome. They're closed on Sunday's which sucks but it is what it is ‍ read more

Sorry, but the Ft. Edward location is my choice. But, it's too far to drive so this location will have to do. The pizza here is good, but.... read more

Like someone else said, pizza is subjective, but this is unbeatable. No longer in the area, but had been going here since 2008 and any time I go back to Schenectady, it is at the top of the list. I recently moved to NYC and was expecting all pizza to be great, but was actually let down. *None* of it really came close to "I Love." I'm still searching for a duplicate of this place in NYC. Pizza slices themselves are quite large as you would expect from a "NY" slice, but they are not paper-thin like some other places. So you will actually fill up on 2 slices. Thin enough slices that they are not spongey, though. Crust is browned on the bottom and crunchy enough. I haven't ordered a whole pie before so I can't rate that. read more

The "I Love" experience. Usually when I go there it's chaotic but the business is prompt. Parking can be tough and there is limited available seating in the Dining room....if you can call it that. Hehe. Anyway...I don't think I have ever stayed there to eat. I always pickup and run. Generally I feel their pizza pie comes out great. I love NYC style pizza and usually they get it pretty close. Lately, though, I don't know what is going on. The last three to four times ordering from there, I have experienced burnt pizza both on the crust and bottom. That just seems to ruin my experience. Anyone who knows me knows my natural aversion to anything remotely be-speckled by the black ash. I think it goes back to the days when my dad would make toast, and he always had a knack for burning it and then serving it- saying it still tastes good. Eat it. (Did I mention he likes pretty much all types of bread, seasoned with black dust??) But I digress. I just prefer not to have charcoal flavored pizza, maybe that's just me. Hopefully they can figure that problem out soon. Maybe their oven temp is hotter than their thermometer is reading...Maybe they get too busy and forget to take it out in time and they don't care...Maybe they are thinking "Hey we mostly serve high-school and college kids, they have indiscriminate taste...so they won't care." Well some of us do care and not all of us are college kids anymore. As an aside, I had a slice of BBQ chicken pizza with my wife and that wasn't burnt. Usually it's not the specialty pizza's that are effected, seems to happen to me more with the cheese and pepperoni variety. Too bad, because that's my favorite. I love, I LOVE NY Pizza. It's just time they get their act together once again. Please OH PLEASE check your pizza before it's too late. I will update this review at a later date and see if they have resolved the pizza burning issue. I haven't given up on them. read more

I Love NY Pizza - I Love NY Pizza of Schenectady. - Pizza Near Me - Schenectady, New York

See all

pretty horrific. Fries tasted old and were cold and completely lacked flavor or crisp. Wings were soooo gross. I mean, just so mediocre and completely flavorless. Not to mention completely overpriced!!! .. we are disappointed- we were really hoping for a better experience. The food really definitely tasted old and had a shoe like quality. read more

I Love NY Pizza - "Cheddar fries" - Pizza Near Me - Schenectady, New York

Great place to eat pizza is great salads are superb. Order they way you like it, they always accommodate. Sandwiches are full size and delicious. The staff are the nicest guys and funny. read more

The Not-to-be-legally-confused-with-similarly-named-enterprises I Love NY Pizza of Schenectady offers fairly standard NY style floppy pizza, and a fairly large menu of side items including fairly decent hot wings and fairly disgusting (white parts of the iceberg/romaine, fake paremsan cheese, industrial dressing, etc.) salads. Our pizzas have had burnt crusts on both visits, but surprisingly fresh vegetables and decent-tasting meat, with somewhat indifferent cheese and sauce. The service is prompt (the counter can be a bit chaotic on busy nights, but the staff multi-process, so hang in there) and the prices, while not on the bargain side, are not expensive either. Pizza sizes are by cuts (the 12-cut being the biggest, and being much smaller than the epic large floppy styles of NYC, but that's more to our liking anyway). The seating is quite limited and parking can be difficult, so it seems more suited to take-out or delivery than dining in. Maybe the burned crust bothered me too much, but that jarring little taste bomb of charred flour tends to sully what would have been an otherwise OK pizza experience. For now we'll leave them with a somewhat marginal three stars, on the low side, and probably put them at the bottom of our Upper Union Business Improvement District Pizza list, but not so far down we won't try them again down the road to see if they can do better. read more

I ordered a couple times from this place. I thought I found my new goto place for pizza, but the last time I ordered dropped them off my list. The order was placed via grub hub, which gave me an estimated time frame of an hour. Ok, cool Then it changed to an hour and 20 minutes, then an hour 45 minutes. Finally showed up just under2 hours later. Cold, and like it has been sitting out all day. Nasty. Grub hub did refund me $7 for late delivery, but the order for pizza and cheese sticks was $47! For a medium extra cheese? Sorry. No more. read more

Absolutely nasty! Never have I ever had a calzone this greasy!! The blue cheese was spoiled! Pictures attached. Make your own choice. Mine ended up going in the trash. read more

See all

This place had the best selection of slices. The crust had good bite and chew. Also, had the best crisp on the underside. The slices didn't have much sauce and the pepperoni was super greasy but it tasted pretty good. I was a little appauled at the puddle grease that covered my plate at the end. I was comparing pepperoni slices today, but I really love their white slices with ricotta. read more

See all

Word of advice: Never call to order food for delivery directly through them. When you call to order, the people who answer the phone are rude and condensending, just because you want delivery. The redirect you to a website -which I thought was poor customer service. The food is medicore at best. The crispy chicken on my wifes salad was fried garbage that was dry and tasted old. The quality and flavor of the chicken wings is poor, and they are NOT jumbo, despite what they advertise. The sicilian pizza; the sauce was flavorless, not overly thick and was burnt. I think they just called it a sicilian pizza because it was square, and should probably research was siclian pizza actually us. And because I was pretty much forced into picking up because I didn't want to order online, when me and my two young daughters walked in, the patrons were less than desirable and made the whole atmosphere strange. For upper union street it was unsettling to see such an unpleasant crowd that not only made myself uncomfortable, but my daughters as well. I do not recommend this place and can only hope that they listen to feedback from their customers. And from what I am reading, I am not the only person who feels this way. read more

Enjoyed a piece of cheese pizza as part of Yelp's Tour de Slice. Out of the five different pizza slices I tasted, I love NY was in a close run for second place. The crust was thin and had some crispness. It was a bit greasy, but it was not dripping off the pizza. The end crust was crisp on the outside with a perfect thickness. I would have preferred a little more sauce. The cheese and sauce had a nice flavor. read more

Review time kids! I have to admit that I'm a regular here. There's a reason, it's freeking good. Every time, it's the same good,ny style,thin crust pizza. Quality and consistency is the key here. I personally love the bbq chicken pizza, the bride likes the supreme, and the boy likes the buffalo chicken. The wings bone in or boneless are always good. See? Something for everyone! Go with your buddies after a union hockey game,Or grab the family for slices, order a pie and wings before you leave work and pick up on the way home. The key here is authentic pizza in a pizza shop! read more

I ordered pizza slices for delivery from I love New York on Union Street, Schenectady. One slice came with 2 pieces of pepperoni and the other with 3 pieces. I called to make them aware and the guy on the other end responded by saying 'What do you expect for $3, 15 pieces of pepperoni? I kid you not! Taken aback now, I texted him a photo and he had the audacity to suggest that I tampered with it! A simple apology would have been sufficient as it could have been an oversight or mistake, but to be so rude and unprofessional is really unacceptable . My family loves pizza from I Love New York but their customer service today was atrocious and leaves a lot to be desired. My kids dinner was ruined, thank you I Love New York of 1705 Union Street, Schenectady, NY 12309. read more

I Love NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Schenectady, New York

See all

I've been getting boneless wings from them for ever and have loved the strips of chicken that made up their wings. It was a great deal for $12. But now though, they've changed from chicken strips to Teeny Tiny nuggets which are totally not worth it anymore. Basically they are charging $12 for 12 chicken nugget-sized pieces. Which is a rip off. Go to McDonald's next door and order a 20 piece for $6 and toss them in Buffalo sauce for a better deal, unfortunately. read more

Been going here for over 15 years. Consensus best pizza in the immediate area, and all our neighbors agree. Ignore the negative reviews. Great slice selection too and we drop in with the kids regularly. For a pie and wings, you can't beat this place... read more

The worst pizza I've ever had in my life. Never threw a pizza away before. 1 star for delivery guy being g personable

Let's start off with the fact that I'm from NYC and have some knowledge as to good pizza. Having said that, there are other variables to the equation for which the basis of a review are based on, including customer service. The other night, as I proceeded to pick up a called in order, my first interaction was with the Hispanic man in shorts behind the counter whose crappy attitude and rude manner set the tone for the remainder of the experience. Apparently the owner was not around and he felt the need to assert his displeasure with his job at paying customers. At a different point in my life, that little interaction would have been very memorable for him. But I digress. After establishing the order, and the fact that I was 10 minutes early, he more or less told me in his crappy manner that it will not be ready until the time promised. Did I mention that my uncle owned a pizza place in Queens and I worked making and selling pizza in my youth? Standing by the counter I observed carefully that the pizza was in fact ready, as were the extra special order slices and garlic knots. For some vengeful reason, he wanted to taunt me and teach me a lesson for being there 10 minutes early, so they sat on top of the oven. On the hour, a man that may have been the owner walked in and started to move things around in a somewhat expedited fashion, and noticing the boxes handed them to me. As to the food, the garlic knots resemble large marbles. It's flour and water for crying out loud. How pathetically cheap can you get? And the glistering liquid in which they swim in is undoubtedly NOT olive oil so why skimp? Not everyone is a stoned college student that has the munchies. The specialty slices were burnt, as it is usually indicative of black corners, not well done by any means, BURNT. The large pie was entertaining in that if you slice a circle into multiple thin slices, you could claim it provides multiple servings. Perhaps if it were finger food or appetizers. Once again, flour, water, yeast, canned tomato sauce, sub par oil and economy bulk cheese. I know the profit margin. In a location with so many pizza establishments, why not stand out in quality. The taste is good, which gives you a heads up above Pizza Hut, but why stop there? You call it NYC pizza and have all those nice photos of NYC sport moments, carry the tradition sincerely rather than just in name. read more

This place is a bit pricey but it's absolute gas. You must get the ziti pizza. It changed my life. Basically the beyoncé of pizza. Hits ridiculously hard. Don't sleep on it. read more

Coming from Brooklyn, I'd like to say that I know how to judge my pizza. Surprisingly this place isn't bad. The crust is crisp yet soft on the inside. The cheese is just right and the sauce is well seasoned. Not the greatest pizza I've had in the world. But eons better than some of the pizza in the area. The staff is very friendly--all smiles there. So that's another thumbs up. Overall a well rounded restaurant that will continue to get my business as long as I'm in the area. The reason why I'm not giving this place that one extra star is because of the flies in the place. There are dozens of them buzzing around. Wouldn't want to eat in there while this continues. read more

Pizza was terrible the delivery guy was sketchy and the pizza box was open I will never order pizza from this place.

At first glance, the place appears a bit run down, but aside from the look of the place, the pizza was good! Sauce isn't overwhelming as some pizza places in the area have an overly sweet sauce which I find unpleasant. Toppings were generously topped and the price was reasonable. Would recommend to try it out. read more

The real deal! Great crust! Good cheese and toppings and very reasonable prices. I had two slices that were every bit as good as any pizza I have eaten in NYC, Brooklyn, or anywhere else. Bravissimo! read more

At this point I cant leave a review regarding the food because Im still waiting for it to arrive. When I called at 6:11 I was casually told my delivery would arrive in 45 minutes which I can acknowledge on a Sunday evening. However, its now been 1.5 hours and Im doubting if it will arrive at all. I called and some jerk with no customer service skill told me the driver was just leaving. Even if this pizza is the best ever I WILL NEVER ORDER FROM THIS PLACE AGAIN! Update: COLD AND SOGGY read more

My family has ordered pizza from I Love NY Pizza at least 3x and have been disappointed with it in some way each time. The first time was delivery and the pizza was quite cold and very difficult to chew. Its as though they had a bunch of pizzas made and just reheated them. The second time the pizza crust was burnt and cheese falling off the pizza. The last time was the trifecta of wrong. Burnt, Cold and a soggy mess. 3 strikes and I'm out, maybe another time but only if someone else buys it for me. read more

Solid pizza, great Variety and atmosphere. Been coming here for years. If they have hamburger pizza, yes you read that correctly, try a slice. But make sure you ask for ketchup read more

I am a downstater. We are used to thin crusted pizza, which is not the custom of these parts. And although many pizza's are good here up here, they are not thin crusted. After trying most of the pizza places in Schenectady, this is the closest to home pizza, crust is thin, sauce is good. I have only had great experiences with the staff, I applaud you all, thank you. read more