How anyone doesn't give this place 5 starts is beyond me! The food was incredible and we are food snobs from NYC. We've been to the best places in the city and this most certainly is right up there if not better in some instances. Stand outs were basically everything but the Burrata, Horse Fries and Cheeseburger were to die for. Everything was cooked to perfection. We marveled at how they made this decadent cheeseburger so darn light and airy. We didn't have a reservation so rather than wait 20 minutes for a table in the main dining room (with wonderful live jazz band) we chose to eat at a table by the bar. Weston, the bartender and our server, was attentive and helpful throughout. We may have to come back to Lancaster just to experience this place once again! It's truly a meal we won't forget. read more

This place was BUSY on a Saturday night (a good thing for a restaurant and a good sign for those coming in for the first time)... we didn't have a reservation, having planned to late, but they do keep tables open for walk-ins and despite being told it was an hour wait (whatever, we knew we ran that risk), we were seated in 15 minutes - Luck, maybe? But awesome all the same! For how busy they were, the server was very attentive and very accommodating as we were yapping away and constantly not ready with our orders so kuddos for the team and putting up with us! I love the mystery beer concept, its not great beer, but being from DC at like $2 a can, I am not passing that up, ever. And a cheap beer with a burger is the perfect combo! On to the burger... I have heard that this is a great burger... and I have to conclude that I agree though it is reminiscent of a Big Mac - just way better ingredients - it has to be the sauce they put on it... Anyway, nice size patty, good amount of toppings and a quality bun (not too soft, not too thick, bread soaks up some of the juices but doesn't fall apart). The mussels were quite excellent as well. It was a Thai curry broth the night we were there and it was drinkable, like soup... we did ask for extra bread... enough said. I am going to take a minute too and praise their spirit free cocktails. THIS IS HOW THEY SHOULD BE MADE. They used bitters, tonics, etc to craft something that tasted like a cocktail but without alcohol which means they were not sickly sugary concoctions, but expertly crafted beverages. Just really great options. All that said though, their espresso martini was one of the worst I have had. Just skip that. read more

I can't believe I've never been here before. Ultimate comfort food with max flavor! Great service! So much history in the building and restaurant. We had the Fried Green tomato BLT and shrimp and grits, chefs kiss So delicious read more

Horse Inn - Gastropubs Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Another delicious and entertaining night at the Horse Inn! Always consistent and welcoming! read more

See all

Went to the Horse Inn last week and had a really good time. Cool place. You kinda feel like you are in an old horse barn which is actually pretty sweet. They do this mystery beer thing which is just a cheap beer but it's fun and feels on brand for the place. Food wise the beef tips are the move. I would honestly go back just for that. Good spot overall. read more

Horse Inn - Gastropubs Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Cocktails Extraordinaire, "Tips and Toast" and Jazz Tuesdays! My recent first time visit to this eclectic upstairs Speak Easy bar and restaurant on a Tuesday night was a strikingly great and memorable experience! The room exudes a warm and comfortable vibe, super friendly staff, patrons and jazz- trio musicians. The bartender cranks out "best-in-your-life" versions of your favorite cocktail as only a seasoned pro can do (I went with a Knob Creek Rye Old Fashioned, later a Paper Plane that both knocked my socks off!) This kitchen is Lancaster's best kept insider secret! Fresh Lancaster County meats are featured on my buddy Alan's favorite two dishes there: the (Sirloin) Tips and Toast, and the Horse Inn Burger- we split and shared- and devoured both in "STUNNED SILENCE' Be sure to save room for their made-in-house Ice Cream for dessert- EPIC rotating along with standing flavors! The smooth "Tom Ponce Project" trio that plays there every Tuesday night attracts a group of local clientele that savor the entire experience, and I found myself wishing I had anyplace like this back home in the Philadelphia Mainline! Yes, the Horse In now tops my list of the very best things to do in Lancaster, PA! read more

See all

Tonight the manager decided to solve and internal miscommunication within his staff by asking my girlfriend and I, mid-dinner, to pick up our food and drink and carry it back to the bar from which we came and that the table was needed for another patron who didn't already pay in full for his/her dinner. I was never so insulted that his tone and when my girlfriend rolled her eyes at his request he said "I don't appreciate the way you're rolling ur eyes at me". This was after he told us to pick up our dinner and carry it back to the bar as if we were somehow doing something wrong. Keep in mind we explained that we already paid in full to both the hostess and waitress and that moving to a table was necessary due to my girlfriend's back issues. They both very pleasantly said "no problem". We are big tippers and are quite mature so this is not the ranting of a millennial or anything like that. We were very good large tipping patrons who will never ever go back to the Horse Inn. Shame on your manager- get him training stat. read more

I managed to snag a 5 o'clock Friday reservation two weeks in advance--the only time left. When we arrived, there was already a line out the door! We parked around the block without any trouble, but take note: the street in front is residential only, so use the lot behind the building or find street parking nearby. The Horse Inn is the oldest consecutively running restaurant in Lancaster City, and its setting alone is worth the visit. Located on a quiet residential street with little façade, you climb two flights of stairs to the third floor and step straight into a 1920s-era speakeasy vibe: low ceilings with exposed beams, original hardware and brick walls, iron gates and chandeliers, and dim lighting. There's even a small area big enough for a three-piece band, which I'm guessing plays jazz on live-music nights. The whole space easily exudes the coolest casual atmosphere in the city. The menu is simple but solid. We both ordered custom cocktails, which is not something we usually do, but this felt like a place we could trust, and we were right. He ordered the burger; I had the fried grains. Both dishes were solid choices. Dessert was the real showstopper: a scoop of sweetcorn ice cream that easily ranks among the best ice creams I've ever had. Service matched the vibe: our waitress was straightforward, checked in just the right amount, and seemed to anticipate our needs while keeping the table turnover smooth. All in all, a great experience. Next time, I'll try to visit on a Tuesday for the live music. Just note: it's definitely not handicapped accessible, and I did see older patrons struggle with the stairs, which tells me it's been worth the climb for a long, long time. read more

See all

This place is a total gem. We had the steak tips and the burger. I would say one of the most enjoyable dishes of this kind we had in a while - and we live in NYC and are used to a high standard. The burger was really up there in my opinion and the steak tips were really enjoyable too (gravy!). The service was naturally kind, not over the top, just pleasant. The interior is folksy and fun, we got to listen to the resident jazz combo and had a nice chat with the band. A thoroughly enjoyable visit and highly recommended read more

some of the absolute best food I have had in a long while. typically, we discuss what could have made this experience better? well the short answer tonight was NOTHING. food was seasoned perfectly and looked just as good as it tasted. we found this spot in Yelp, of course, and it was certainly worthy of the rating and then some. we didn't make reservations so we enjoyed beverages at the bar until our table was ready. we began our dinner with the pea salad . it was cool and refreshing with a hearty mix of flavors, he ordered the tips over toast and i had the burger. we splurged with dessert enjoying the chocolate mousse and another fresh fruit dessert. we enjoyed all of this delicious food in my favorite type of environment, dim lights and dark wood! i will certainly revisit this location ! it is one of the few true five stars for me! ZERO. complaints! read more

See all

If you want a quaint bar, with a live jazz music, built out of what used to be a horse barn, with lots of old-fashioned stuff hanging around, then you might like the Horse Inn. The food was good, but not great, a total bill for an hors d'oeuvre, two entrées, and a dessert was almost $100. I liked my chicken thigh on a bed of rice. The chicken was juicy and tender. The chicken gnocchi was not quite as enjoyable. My wife described it as undercooked noodles. So I let my wife have some of my chicken and I ate some of her gnocchi. Food is a four out of five, but value for money is only 3. Probably you're better off getting the hamburger or one of the other sandwiches, since what you want at a bar is really bar food. I can't speak to the mixed beverages since I generally don't drink alcohol. My wife mistakenly ordered an Irish coffee, which is strong but OK. read more

After having the debate of whether our GPS had betrayed us and dropped us into the middle of nowhere, we finally followed some Yelp pictures to find this spot. It's not that the signs aren't visible or the address not accurate, it's just that it feels very out of place in an urban downtown without a ton of other businesses close by. Moving past that initial hiccup, you climb up a flight of stairs to reach a trendy, fun inn with great food and a deep beer list. My group was seated immediately by a friendly hostess, though we were met by a waitress who seemed to be having an off day. Happens to the best of us! What wasn't having an off day was the food, which was stellar. We got cheesy fries with sausage incorporated as an appetizer, and they were phenomenal. I grabbed a burger after that, which was a combination of short rib, brisket, Chuck, and dry aged beef. The flavor oozed out with every bite, with crisp, fresh toppings punctuating every delicious morsel. To top it all off, the salad was awesome too, both in look and taste. This is why you can't always trust your instincts, even when they scream "your wife is right, you did put the wrong address in the GPS." read more

Horse Inn - Salad wedge - Gastropubs Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

I got the burger with onion and tomato and an order of wings. I really like the atmosphere of the restaurant. It was something very unique. Food was excellent. read more

Horse Inn - Wings in their house sauce. It was slightly spicy and tangy. 18.00 for dozen aug 2025 - Gastropubs Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Excellent food. Great burgers - although I did not want it, I don't think anyone should ever tell a diner paying for their food that they cannot have ketchup for their burger. Can't stand when a chef feels it's ok to tell someone how they should enjoy their food. As bad or worse than wine snobs. read more

Cute restaurant. The food was delectable as were the desserts. Honestly, you cannot go wrong. And the staff were just lovely--taking care of our every need before we had time to voice them. read more

Great food! Great service. My wife and I had the burger and the chicken sandwich and we shared both- very happy with the food. Service was very personable and fun. Dessert was excellent. Definitely worth a visit. read more

Our last dinner on vacation in the area we came here and it was delicious! We were staying right up the street so we actually walked to dinner too which was nice. Service was great. read more

See all

We walked in just past 5:00pm and were able to snag the last available table. Pro tip: make a reservation! We aren't from the area so we had no clue how busy it would be. Every seat was filled. There was live music (pianist) who was incredibly nice. We took our baby daughter near him to get a closer look as she was really enjoying it and he played a short, fun rendition of "If you're happy and you know it..." for her, which she loved! Service was very friendly and the cocktail was stellar. Food was great. Burger was perfectly cooked. Fries were fantastic - had a light breading on them, providing a crisp exterior. The burrata appetizer stole the show. Don't think twice; just order it. The shrimp and grits were just OK - probably wouldn't order again but I'm not a huge shrimp and grits fan anyway. The pot du crème dessert was the perfect end to a great meal. Great experience. If we are ever in Lancaster, this is where we'll go (and we'll make a reservation!). read more

See all

Absolutely love Horse Inn. The cozy, casual vibe is amazing and the regular live music provides a great atmosphere. The cocktails are the best in Lancaster. The menu doesn't change much, but it's consistently good. read more

Horse Inn - Gastropubs Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Came in with a party of 9 to celebrate me and my fiancés engagement. The food was amazing, the service was impeccable, and they really made us feel celebrated. We will definitely be back!! Thank you for making our dinner special! read more

The food is very good... somewhat limited menu but the Horse Inn burger lives up to the hype. Grab a 'mystery' beer and have a time.

Such a beautiful restaurant and the staff is super friendly. I got the burger! Delicious.

This place is awesome! It dates back to the 1800s I believe when it was originally horse stables. They've done a great job converting it into one of the most unique restaurants I've had the pleasure of eating at. It's not very big & was packed when we arrived. We called ahead to get on the wait list, which wasn't too bad. We didn't think it would be so busy that early, but we had drinks while waiting for our table & took in the history that surrounded us. The host & wait staff were excellent. The wait staff is not in any type of uniform which helps make it that much more personal. The food was delicious & I am definitely looking forward to our next trip back. They had an awesome piano player as well who did a fantastic version of a Pink Floyd song which I had never heard played on the piano alone before. If you're in the area I highly recommend stopping by here for a bite. read more

Got here at 7PM on a Tuesday and it was packed. There was some parking on the other side of Marshall that was full, so I parked a few blocks South and walked over. I would consider Horse Inn a speakeasy. The entrance is nondescript and I would not have known it was a restaurant had it not been for Yelp. Once you go upstairs, there's a bar area with tables in the back. I was seated at the bar almost immediately since I was by myself. Tried two dishes the bartender recommended: Tips N Toast - chunks of steak, cooked medium and sitting on french bread in a pool of sauce. Pretty flavorful - black pepper, Worcestershire?, red wine. Wish the bread was separate because it was soaked through and didn't have much life to give. Farmers Salad with Ranch - lightly dressed (which is my preference) and a ton of different fresh veggies. Maybe the marketing of local greens and house-made dressing got me. Thought this was solid, but nothing special. My recommendation? Bring a friend or two and share. I would have liked a half portion of what I ordered and then gotten to try a few more things. Grab a cocktail. I felt kind of lame coming to place like this and not trying one of their unique drinks. Unfortunately, work beckons for me tomorrow. Make a reservation. This place is popular! read more

See all

One of the best places to eat in Lancaster...at least always one of our favorites. Fun and interesting atmosphere, great service, and always delicious food. Drinks are creative and tasty. It's always a great time if the Tom Pontz project is playing too, but sit far enough away from them if you want to have a conversation and listen at the same time. Come here for a nice date evening, or time with friends. You won't be disappointed. Clayton was our very friendly and helpful server this evening. * Added note - follow their IG page, and their garden page for more insight into the business . They pride themselves on good, service and support local food suppliers/businesses. read more

See all

Service was fine. Overpriced for the food quality. Not a 4.4 star which is what convinced me to go. Small portions

Wow! Completely unassuming when you walk up, looks like nothings going on... then you walk upstairs and are welcomed by the warm and chatty atmosphere. We were sat quickly despite being told 30-45 min wait. Piano player was wonderful and added to the vibe. We ordered the Kalettes, cross between kale and Brussels Sprouts (a winter crop apparently) flash fried with sesame seeds and a sweet and tangy fish sauce, so delicious!!! The burger was a 10/10, and the fries were perfect. My date had the fried cauliflower and rice with kimchi, very spicy and flavorful. Shoofly pie for dessert was delicious. Excellent service, Would definitely be back!! read more

Horse Inn - Kalettes - Gastropubs Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

The ambiance of this place is off the charts very romantic charming place. The food was very good and the horse fries were amazing. They had a band playing and it was a real nice evening. read more

This place never disappoints. Great food, great service, great atmosphere. I highly recommend the burger and Horse Fries. The wings and Tips and Toast are also amazing. They make a great Old Fashion. Horse Inn is a staple of Lancaster City. read more

What a great place! Full of history and a wonderful atmosphere. Food was a treat and service was top notch. We had the burrata with beets and candied walnuts, the shrimp and grits and a cheeseburger with "horse fries" (a must if you like french fries). One of the best burgers I've ever had. Everything was excellent. We only wish we lived closer so we could return. read more

See all

Good was amazing. Best chicken and dumplings I have ever had. The service is always top notch and the drinks are some of the best in Lancaster. Their consistency is amazing as well. They love entertaining and it shows!!!!! read more

The ambiance was great. The food was good. The band was fantastic. The service was great too. Loved it

Wonderful place. Drinks were great, food was delicious, service was fast and super friendly. Will definitely go back! The tips and toast were wonderful. The pot de creme was perfectly chocolatey and salty. read more

Horse Inn - Low Sun cocktail on right and Mellow Goat on left - Gastropubs Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Everything about this place was great, including my bartender I can't wait to go back and hopefully I'll be able to get downstairs into the speakeasy. read more

This is the best restaurant in Lancaster! The bartenders are truly chemists with the best mix of ingredients to make the perfect concoction. You will not find a better burger anywhere!! It is a small spot so you need to reserve your place. read more

I looked at the menu ahead of time so I already knew it offered more than basic pub fare, but I still have to say that I was extremely impressed by the food, especially in the context of the somewhat dive-y atmosphere (in a fun way!). We loved the chicken liver mousse, beets, and catch of the day (halibut), and my mezcal cocktail was really fun. The service was great. And then halfway through our delicious meal a band started playing some live jazz! If we lived in the area we'd be regulars, but the next time we visit we'll be sure to come back. read more

Horse Inn - Beets with plums, crispy chickpeas, and goat cheese. Excellent! - Gastropubs Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

This place was really hyped up to me by the locals I was with (it's a fav of theirs). As a former local, it was nice to find a place I'd not been too (although with Lancaster's constant evolution, this isn't hard to do anymore). They had live music - that usually guarantees brownie points from me. Two older guys on bass and keys jamming like nobody's business. The food was good, overpriced for quantity (but it was locally sourced, so that's probably why $$+). Small menu, fun drink options. I give it 4 for the vibe, dessert, and creative drinks - just know your bill is gonna be higher. It's loud, between the music, conversation, and nothing to soak up the sound...so prepare yourself to shout when talking or get reallllly close to your dining companions. I did order a salad (which I feel like let down the waiter/bartender) compared to my two other dining companions orders (handhelds and the special fries that this place is known for). My steak was rare, which means it was perfect and cooked to order. Fresh greens. I sampled some of the fries, and they did live up to the hype. Dessert (not pictured!) was FABULOUS. We got the chocolate mousse dish. It was so creamy, rich, and hints of sea salt on top P.s. it's an old converted stable, pretty cool! read more

See all

Good food but the ambiance and service is exceptional. Came on a Tuesday when they had live Jazz music and it just added to the charm of the place. Must visit if you are in Lancaster and are looking for something more lively. read more

Great wait staff, quality of the food was outstanding and we enjoyed the ambiance. It is a quant setting in town, which is always nice compared to a chain restaurant read more

I will have to credit AI in suggesting Horse Inn as I was on a road trip and looking for suggestions. Awesome decor and venue. Live music was a surprising treat. Food was excellent and service was very friendly. Only downsides were the surprising surcharge to pay for the kitchen salary, tip, or whatever they want to call it, which I did not see disclosed(i think it was 5%), and also most of the parking near it seemed to require a permit so beware(I took my chances and did not get a ticket). Mystery beer was a fun menu item, where you order a nicely discounted beer and you get whatever they give you, but no repeats. read more