Honestly I was a little scared because the manhattan and a soda came out to $22. However IT WAS WORTH THAT AND MORE !!! It was DELICIOUS!!! And the sandwich itself was huge !!!! Customer service was amazing !! Both young ladies were so polite and helpful. read more

Got maybe half a chicken cutlet on a hero that comes out to almost $20 after tax. Quality has been on the decline for a while read more

Hometown Heroes - Half of a nor'easter - Sandwiches Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

Update your website. Went in at 7pm to order a hero. I was told they were closed, the website which I checked before going said they were open until 830pm. Business 101 in 2026 is having an updated website. read more

Hometown Heroes - Sandwiches Near Me - Islip, New York

Large heroes! Best cutlet heroes around. They added seating which is nice as they were take out only for years. The staff are very friendly.

Wow! I was so impressed with the heroes we got! Each one was piled high and also was hot when I got them home. Yum!

Heard about this place but I'm never in West Islip. Went by and got the Italian combo and it was delicious. Fast service and nice store location. read more

Restaurant is bright and clean! Service is great! The sandwiches are awesome! Packed with everything you asked for. Everything is fresh and delicious! read more

If I had to pick a last meal, I honestly think I would pick the Maneater from Hometown! It is by far the best sandwich/hero I've ever eaten. All of their heroes look and sound delicious, but I always find myself getting a Maneater because it's just that good. It's definitely not the healthiest option they have, but I cannot recommend it enough! I will have to branch out soon and try some other heroes! The staff has always been friendly and polite. I usually call my order in and go pick it up, but you can order online too! Always hot and ready in a timely manner. Can't wait for my next visit! read more

Hometown Heroes - Maneater Hot Hero - Sandwiches Near Me - Islip, New York

Had the rodeo hero and I highly recommend fries were decent had to put them in air fryer when I got home and I live less than 10 minutes from the place. I'd def recommend most of the heros on menu good food. There are better options but it's so close to my house I usually go hometown read more

The food (ALL) is great! The service is as great as the food! You can't go wrong getting a hero from HOMETOWN!

First off - I LOVE sandwiches, so naturally I needed to try this place! Everything I've tried here is soooo delicious!!! Very hefty portions and fresh ingredients. I usually order the Mama Georgio which is perfection on a sandwich! Also love the hot pastrami and the curveball. Service is fast and efficient. Great spot to stop in quick, grab some heros and hit the beach. read more

Great sandwich spot on your way to the beach on the south shore of Long Island. Wonderful service and a wide variety of sandwiches and heros. Great pricing and the sandwiches were all flavorful. I recommend the Italian as its great portions wonderful bread and hits the spot. The chicken cutlet heros are also good especially the cheddar and bacon. Make sure to have the sauce as it equals everything out. Will be back. read more

Their food without exception is wonderful Their heroes are so packed with goodness that it takes me 2 days to finish it highly recommend this eatery read more

Food is always good, portions huge, and customer service on point. We usually order every weekend (especially in summer). Never had a bad sandwich. Love the JJ wrap, and tuna. I've tried almost every sandwich and never left a crumb. read more

My son and I had the wonderful opportunity of trying the heros and fried mac and cheese. The heros were absolutely delicious! We first started our lunch off with the fried mac and cheese. The mac and cheese was nice and crispy on the outside - and creamy on the inside! They were very impressive but very filling! The heros were HUGE!!! for 13.99 we really got our moneys worth! I had the Toast of Broadway and my son had the Maneater!!! Both were delicious - Far exceeded anything I could have imagined! I want to come back and basically EAT thru the entire Lunch/Dinner Menu!!!!! If you want to see my experience - Please check our video of us eating all of this delicious food!!!!! https://youtu.be/fClwI9gYMo4 read more

See all

I've been ordering the chicken ceaser wrap for the past year or so and it never disappoints. I've also had the Mac and cheese bites and they're amazing. I would recommend hometown heroes! read more

Absolutely delicious heroes. Definitely worth trying the house special hero or make your own combo hero.

I ordered a tuna hero which was good. The bread makes the sandwich. I don't know what secret ingredient that is. But this place is a go. Service is relatively fast, but it looks like it can get busy quickly! Hometown hero is definitely a hometown fav! read more

I just can't find anything wrong to say- other than I eat the whole hero and feel soo incredibly full. Takeout every time has been nothing but amazing. Honestly, you will not regret it. The only thing is they do close early so you'll have to order before dinner time. We ordered the Italian Hero and Noreastern and Buffalo chicken sandwich. Honestly? Everything has been nothing but delicious. read more

See all

Disappointed that I swayed from what I originally planned on getting which was the Instagram Mac attack sandwich. I ended up getting the goomba special which was mozzarella sticks, chicken cutlets and marinara on garlic bread...it was mediocre at best. The roll wasn't toasted so it was too messy to eat and the sauce wasn't that good. I also had the foodie card but a few of the workers didn't even know what it was but they still gave me the 10% off. I'll give it another shot because it's semi local to me and I still wanna try the Mac and cheese! read more

Hometown Heroes - New Item The Goomba - Sandwiches Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

Every single time we've gone to this place since they've changed owners, there has been a problem every time. They prices are astronomical. My husband just went to pick up our online order and they tried to convince him it wasn't paid for and tried to charge him again, you can't even order online without paying so of course it was paid for.... We got chicken Caesar salad wraps and they were mediocre at best for $10 a wrap read more

Was planning a birthday party for a one year old so of course it's mostly about food for the adults. I took a chance and ordered from here. Had an entire conversation about a gluten allergy and what my options were. Ordered the chicken hero with roasted red pepper and mozzarella. Discussed it being grilled chicken so I could use the hero filling to put on the salad I also ordered. Arrived to pick up the food and it was fried and breaded chicken cutlet on the hero. I was so upset that it was wrong and they were not helpful and their only solution was to just give me some pre-cooked chicken that they heated up and put in a to-go container. I was so mad I didn't know what to do or say and the solution was crappy. I paid $250 for food and the food and leftovers went to other people because I couldn't touch it. Don't order catering from here. read more

My go to before a day at the beach!! Best sandwiches!! Great service. Worker are very polite.

This place is A++....They use local fresh ingredients and there are so many choices for heros and wraps, you can't go wrong! I love the Chik N Berry Wrap, and the Fried Mac. Also tried a bite or two of the Mac Attack, just as great...who doesn't love ooey gooey mac n cheese?!? read more

Hometown Heroes - Sandwiches Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

Great food! Love the place very clean and reasonless priced! Good service fast and fresh!

Mac Attack FTW! So honestly I can't tell you what this sandwich is like when you buy it. My husband's work buddies pick up sandwiches every once in a while. My husband eats half for lunch and brings half home... which I eat the next day. Even reheating it (I take off the chicken and Mac and microwave it, and retoast the bread) makes for a great sandwich so I can only imagine how good it is fresh. read more

My friends are crazy and got many sandwiches to share. I simply got the BLT hero to share with a kid and we loved it. Can't really mess that up but their bread was amazing!! I need to know where they get it from. I will divinely come but for more in the future... unfortunately this time around i had some diet restrictions!!! Stay open cause ill be come back! read more

Hometown Heroes - Pretty good crinkle cheese fries. I would definitely get again - Sandwiches Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

Horrible service , have been going to them since they were in Lindenhurst. Never again, worse every time i go, heroes are all bread no cold cuts, keep raising their prices,nothing to them anymore . Asked for x tra oil/vinegar wanted to charge .75 cents seriously??? There are no cold cuts,nasty horrible service Dont waste ur time or money . Done with them !!!!!! They turned off comments on other social media just shows they stack their reviews read more

Got the spicy chicken and there was not bbq sauce. Sandwich was so dry. Also it wasn't busy so idk how they messed that up

Sure, the sandwiches may be a few bucks higher than your local deli but this isn't just your local deli. Hometown heroes knows how to put fresh ingredients together while adding their own pizzazz. We recently tried the mama Giorgio's, the lighthouse and the patty melt. Each was even better than the descriptions that enticed us in. The homemade Russian dressing on the patty melt is out of this world. I'll be asking for a side of that from now on, no matter what we get. Super friendly staff made our experience flawless. read more

Hometown Heroes in West Islip sometimes gets forgotten with the plethora of great sandwich joints we have here on Long Island. I personally think their hot chicken cutlet sandwiches rival the best. The cold heroes def leave some to be desired but once I figured that out every trip has been a success. They fry up their chicken cutlets per order so you are always getting hot and crispy chicken. This is the supreme with no coleslaw with the works. We've got chicken cutlets, ham, mozz, lettuce, tomato, oil, extra vinegar on a toasted foot long. The range of the vinegar brings the entire show together. This thing is absolutely MASSIVE almost to the point of unmanageable. Def worth the 9.99 on a beautiful Saturday afternoon. read more

Hometown Heroes - As girthy as my hand is long - Sandwiches Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

Very good service. They are very nice people who make mouth watering food. Honestly better than subway.

Food is always accurate. Very good blend of spices on cold hero's. Great rare Roast Beef!

One of my go to places on door dash. Hero's are very good. Bread always fresh. The Devito hero is one of our favorites.

While searching for the best sandwich places on LI I found Hometown Heroes. There hasn't been anything I've ordered from there that wasn't good. While visiting with friends in West Islip today, I quickly learned not only do they have the best sandwiches in town, but they also deliver! Sandwiches came quickly and they were just as good if I were to eat them in the shop! read more

See all

I've been meaning to come here for some time and I finally did tonight. This place does not disappoint! The girls at the front were super friendly and I also got to meet the owner Dan, great guy! Tried out: the waffle fries (the sour cream, cheese, bacon, and onion dip it comes with is crack) fried Mac and cheese bites which were perfectly crispy, the "maneater" hero, the special "veg head" the "patty Mac" and "fursh" All the sandwiches were loaded and super fresh. The veg head was all vegetables and they were cooked perfectly and the pesto mayo made the sandwich! If you like big macs/burgers the patty Mac is a must try. The homemade Russian dressing gives it that iconic "Mac" taste. I came with friends so we shared our hero's so we could try as much as possible. :) All hero's were priced under $10 and were huge. I dropped off a hero to my dad the "manhattan" and he loved it and won't stop talking about the roast beef in it. (Roast beef made in house!) I'll be back for sure. read more

See all

Got the Papa Georgio. Great tasting but the chicken was pathetic. So thin, dry and hard around the edges. Need some quality control. No respectable business would serve chicken in this shape. I wanted to get your opinion. read more

The contents of their heroes are amazing, but sadly the bread is not. If they used better bread that wasn't "rubbery," this place would be a 5 star spot. read more

I had 3 burgers this week and my girlfriend just one tonight and her review was it was awesome great service, cool staff and cold beers read more

So fresh...so tasty...so polite,and accuracy is the key.They were on the money with our order.It is lunch time at the shop and nobody was waiting for me to take pics..plus the food is really good.Wherever this bread comes from,I sure need to know!The shop is very clean and the staff is friendly. We got a cappy&american extra mayo fo rrd Sweetheart,Chicken fingers w fries and ranch..and rare roast beef onions o&v lettuce tomatoe for me.Everything was as ordered and sizeable.Those fingers were large very large and well fried.As I type I am stuffing the last bite in...it is too good to put down.PS,they deliver locally.We will deff be having lunch from here again read more

See all