Back here while my friend was in town from Alabama. We went for breakfast as was a special request by my best friend's dad. He lives in the area and is a regular here and just loves it and this was where he wanted to start his birthday. And I understand why. The staff is lovely, and the food is simply delicious. Classic diner vibes, if that's what you're looking for, and it's all just been so consistent over the years. It was a really nice morning seeing my BFF before flying back home and getting to celebrate her dad at a place he loves so much. Felt like old times and I'm grateful I still get that. read more

Holbrook Diner - Turkey triple decker club sandwich and fries. - Diners Near Me - Holbrook, New York

See all

I got a Oreo milkshake and pancake meal to eat for dinner. The person who makes milkshakes clearly never seen one before because they used more milk then icecream Wich makes it liquid-y and what you sould do is more icecream then milk so it's thicker. Also not enough Oreo. Add 4 Oreos next time. ‍ Waitress was rude,impatient and distracted as hell. Food cane late..it was ok not hungry Anymore so atleast they did SOMETHING right..tv is playing SpongeBob Andi hate SpongeBob. Not to many ppl here today read more

Great food great service chill atmosphere. You're not rushed and the help is amazing. Y'all do whatever they need to do to make you happy. And I love their waffles. This is the midnight cookies and cream shake that they offer here as well. read more

Holbrook Diner - Zach loving his midnight cookies and cream milkshake - Diners Near Me - Holbrook, New York

It's ok. They had a decent burger menu so I thought I was in for a treat. The patties looked like it was probably frozen from restaurant depot. Staff is very nice. Omelets and hash browns were great. Pretty clean. read more

Good to be back at an old haunt. Nothing to jump out of of chair over but quality folks and food is decent. I'm always a fan of Long Island Diners and this ranks high on the list. read more

I haven't been here in a while and always like to stop in when i travel to Long Island. I like the renovated look. I got eggs, bacon and hashbrowns. I always ask for the hashbrowns well done because they tend to be undercooked. I ate the potatoes off the top. The staff was really nice and kept refilling my coffee. I miss diners. We don't have anything like this near me. read more

Holbrook Diner - Diners Near Me - Holbrook, New York

The food is amazing. Everything they make with chicken is out of this world. Waiters/waitresses are always friendly. I read criticisms about the price. I'm not going to lie, it isn't cheap, but they give you soooo much great quality food. My boyfriend and I share a meal and they don't give us a hard time about bringing an extra plate (some places charge you extra to share) and we STILL have leftovers for lunch the next day! read more

Ambiance was kind of nice with the subtle Christmas decorations. Our server was quick and a bit hard to understand because he spoke so quickly. However, he was very polite and accommodating to our questions about the menu. The diner was surprisingly packed on a Thursday night, but we were seated 'pon arrival. I note "surprisingly" and you'll see the reason why below with respect to the food I ordered.   I ordered The Greek Chicken Wrap and it was not very appetizing. My side of potato salad tasted like it came from a big bucket that sits in the kitchen for days on end - not very fresh. When I got home, it only took 20 minutes before I had to rush to the bathroom and expel everything I ate. It went right through me - horrible feeling.   This meal was not worth its $17 price tag. Also, the menu did not list that tomatoes were included in the wrap. If I saw there were tomatoes, I would have excluded them when ordering - because sometimes tomatoes are hit or miss and these ones missed for me. My father's meal came with a slice of chocolate cake and it tasted stale and not very moist, too boot. Overall, just not enough tender loving care when it comes to the quality of their food.   I recommend going across the street to The Irish Times Pub - much better option and convenient if you are in the area. read more

See all

I love reputable Long Island diners. They serve menu pages worth of delicious from breakfast to late dinner. Unfortunately, I now live in Las Vegas which leaves me across the continent from the Long Island diners that I grew up with. When I returned to Long Island for a week to see my dad, I got to revisit the Long Island diner. The Holbrook Diner has been a local institution in the heart of the business district for decades. Although I lived nearby in the 1990s, July 21, 2023 would be my very first visit here. The Holbrook Diner has an ambiance that is both retro and modern. For example, a neon purple linear ceiling light and chanderliars compliments a faux wooden floor with plate glass windows overlooking Main Street, Holbrook. From the moment we sat down til we left, the service was commendable. The waiter was proficient in his job and never rushed us. In my opinion, it helps that the server hub and counter is in the middle of the diner. Regardless that the menu offered pages of choices, I was decided on eggplant parmigiana with spaghetti. Eggplant parmigiana with pasta has been my goto meal on my summer vacation on Long Island, as my reviews reflect. At a $21.95 price tag, it included a soup or salad. I ordered Manhattan Clam Chowder soup. I do not know what it is with diners and Manhattan Clam Chowder soup. Every Diner that I have been to has served me outstanding Manhattan Clam Chowder soup. This includes the Holbrook Diner. Before my entree arrived, I also savored house salad with honey mustard dressing that my brother presented me with. As far as my eggplant parmigiana with spaghetti, I was very satisfied. Many people will argue that the same dish is superior in an Italian restaurant such as Mama Lombardi's across the street. However, I would argue that that is comparing apples to oranges. My brother was not up for Italian food, my dad wanted something else, and I wanted Italian food, which led to the diverse diner menu bringing us into the Holbrook Diner. Both the portion and flavor were grand. This could easily make a two-parter meal. With the food, I enjoyed a couple of Cokes, which our waiter was on the eight ball in refilling. I am a fan of reputable Long Island Diners. The Holbrook Diner is one of them. read more

This has always been a reliable choice. Too many diners have some cranky old man at the cash register. Not here. The front people are so bubbly and welcoming. Same with the waitpeople. No request is turned down. I hadn't been here in years and was pleasantly surprised to see the new decor. I keep coming back. read more

See all

Best Diner around . I've been going there for years with my family and have yet to have bad service. Very friendly staff and all around great atmosphere Waiters/waitresses very attentive. If you are looking for a good diner I highly recommend Holbrook Diner. read more

I would give 10 stars if I could! We had reservations at an another place near by for brunch, only to show up and be told they don't serve brunch anymore. We ended up leaving and found this diner on Google!! What a find!!! Even with 7 people and an infant, they sat us in under 10 min and Gus, our server, was absolutely awesome!! We all totally enjoyed our meals and will absolutely be returning!! read more

Stopped by this place before meeting a friend and had an amazing experience! The staff was so kind and easy to talk to! The diner itself was amazing, it looked very cool on the inside and outside. It was lovely to see how the workers knew some of the regular customers already. The food that I ordered was very good. I wished to try some of the desserts but I was way too full sadly. I would come back to eat some lunch here again and to try the desserts! My friend really liked the panini and would recommend it. The salmon was full of flavor and I enjoyed the caesar wrap too! read more

See all

One of the best diner experiences I've had. The decoration is gorgeous and classy, with the vintage diner feel. The service was fast and waitress was super friendly. Menu is huge and varied, but prices are good and it's not overwhelming. I got the brisket melt, the bun was crispy, brisket was tender, and it was charred perfectly. It was a little bland, but I asked for some barbecue sauce. They make all sauces in house, and the barbecue sauce was FABULOUS. The coleslaw was one of the only coleslaws I've ever liked. They have a good variety of desserts I'd like to try, and even the bathrooms are gorgeous. My friend going gluten free pancake, and he said they were the best he's had. read more

Holbrook Diner - Brisket Melt - Diners Near Me - Holbrook, New York

Went in for a quick meal and was very let down by the food. I had a burger expecting a nice diner burger, but received a tiny burnt patty that tasted off. I have high doubts that was actually 7oz. The sauted peppers and onions that came on it were cut huge and barely cooked. They were basically inedible and made the bun a soggy mess before the first bite. Soggy fries. My wifes sandwich tasted good but she swears she was sick all the next day from it. Flat soda. The sweet potato fries were good and so was the coleslaw. The place looked clean but I'm not sure on the kitchen status after my first experience. Ran $74 with tip so pretty expensive for two people. I'll stick to island lake. read more

Called last minute to see if they could accommodate a table for 14. They immediately had our table and were extremely courteous. The service was fast. The food was great. Everyone ordered different things and everyone was happy. Thank you Holbrook Diner! read more

Ordered egg, cheese and bacon, on a roll. Received an open faced (2 eggs, over easy with an egg placed on each side of the roll , 2 pcs of bacon on each side. It was impossible to eat. It was Monday and the roll was stale. Worse yet, food was cold, and I couldn't get a warm up for my coffee. When I told the cashier, she thought it was funny and said ..."you should have eaten the sandwich with a fork". Been here many times before. What happened? Very disappointing. Won't go back. . read more

Seriously don't come here. I got food poisoning about a year ago from here. The strawberry pancakes. Had to go to the hospital because I was deathly ill. My fiancé always loved this diner but I decided to give it another shot last night and eat there with him. I said to myself I wouldn't eat there again. This time he then gets sick. He had the Delancey Street sandwich. Is now really ill and throwing up & I'm taking care of him. I don't understand how this place is still in business getting people sick like this. The food is bad or there's bacteria growing. There's something going on and it's not right. read more

Dead bugs on the half and half containers and the home fries taste like puke. When told management he said don't come back.

My mother in laws very favorite place to eat out - but she isn't physically able to make it there so I have been getting her takeout. They have not forgotten anything at all, actually read the notes you add to the order, and package it up so nicely. The pot roast dinner on Sunday is the best! read more

Came here for dinner with my boyfriend. I was craving a cheeseburger and fries, but didn't want fast food so I suggested Holbrook Diner. The older gentleman who sat us was very nice and personable. However, our server was not (David). We hadn't even sat down yet and he was already asking us what we wanted to drink- we just ordered waters. Then when we finally sat done and got the waters from the server's helper, David came back and asked again if we wanted drinks which we replied we just wanted water which he didn't seem pleased to hear. My boyfriend decided on having a burger as well and was just about to ask if maybe I wanted an appetizer as well when the server came again and rudely asked if we were finally ready to order. That turned my boyfriend off completely and we just ordered our cheeseburgers and fries. The food came relatively quick and wasn't bad. However, our server never came by to check on us to see how we were doing or if we needed anything, but checked on the other tables he had around us. Then, when we got the check our bill said that we both ordered a burger deluxe which is an extra $5 more than just a regular cheeseburger and fries. Neither one of us said deluxe, he just took it upon himself to ring both our orders in like that. At that point, we just were done and wanted to leave, so we left our server $4 on the table and went to the cashier and paid our check. The ladies at the cash register were very nice just like the older gentleman who sat us. I wish the whole experience had been as pleasant as they were, but it wasn't. Unfortunately, we won't be going back. If we want to go to a diner, we'll go to Island Lake Diner, Lake Grove or even Candlelight in Commack. read more

Amazing Amazing Amazing. I love this restaurant and always have. Noticeably better tasting food as opposed to other diners, fast and kind service, neat and clean yet old fashioned ambiance makes for an excellent and enjoyable experience. The menu is huge! The staff are extremely friendly as well as the owner. 10/10 definitely would recommend if you are looking for a diner experience. read more

Holbrook Diner - Diners Near Me - Holbrook, New York

Ordered my sons meal and it came out within 5 minutes and we asked for it to come out with our meals, the adult meals didn't come until 15 minutes later so my kids food was cold by the time ours came out. Food was not seasoned, soggy, and extremely sub par. Could've made better eggs at home and not put $65 for 2 egg sandwich and kids pancake meal. In and out within 30 minutes and felt extremely rushed, check dropped within 5 minutes of our food coming to the table. Planned on getting a cookie to go but decided just to get out of there. Definitely will not be coming back nor recommending anyone to go here. So many better diners in the area. read more

If the rating was based just on service and the accoutrements, I would give it a 5. However, I went in for a bagel and lox, and was disappointed by the quality of the bagel itself. It was dry, stale, day-old supermarket quality, and I expected more. Sourcing from Costco or a good local baker would be a big upgrade from wherever they're getting their bagels. read more

Food? Fabulous. Service? Wonderful, cheery, helpful waitstaff. Quiet 60s music? Check. This is a great restaurant disguised as a diner. Eggs done just right. Fluffy pancakes. Terrific spinach Greek salad with grilled chicken or salmon. Yum. Highly recommended. read more

Great food. Great service and large portions and endless selections. Very lively atmosphere. read more

I ordered a Brisket sandwich and asked for a "little gravy ". Well the waitress brought me a " little gravy ". When I got the check, I couldn't believe my eyes. There was a $ 3.25 charge for the gravy. OUTRAGEOUS. I should have questioned the charge, but I didn't. That's Okay, the food was at best, mediocre , and I will NOT go back. Could've been a lot better. read more

Husband and I decided to try a different diner and was not disappointed. Arrived on Sunday approx. 11:30am to a packed place but we were immediately seated. We both basically ordered the same breakfast and it was served in 10 minutes. We commented that it was the best diner bacon we ever had, quality cut. Perfectly well done. Everything on plate was fresh and tasty. The price was reasonable but coffee was extra. Our server was pleasant and hard working. Constantly refreshing our coffee. We found the diner to be clean. We sat on the booth side which was comfortable but did notice nice tables on the opposite side. Planning on returning for lunch, was told Greek style dishes are very good. read more

Holbrook Diner - 2 eggs , bacon, hash browns, rye toast. $8.70. Excellent! - Diners Near Me - Holbrook, New York

Terrific in every way that counts. Large portions of beautifully cooked eggs, silver dollar pancakes and hash browns. Neat looking interior. We were back on Long Island for a quick visit with family. Breakfast at a dinner added to our fun! read more

Ordered through Door Dash, order came to $115. Three entrees and a dessert. Only a part of one entree and dessert came; driver went back for the rest. Order arrived incorrect and cold. None of the second delivery was useable. Contacted DoorDash, small compensation offered. Contacted the diner, got excuses and blown off. read more

Went today for an early lunch. Water was brought over right away by a wonderful bus boy named Will. Our waitress Kristen was excellent . Split pea soup with fresh out of the oven croutons was off the hook. Pot Roast lunch special was delicious and large portion. Everyone was friendly and greeted us when we arrived. Really nice local diner with great lunch specials and a great value in this economy. read more

I ordered French toast to go and it looked like they just toasted bread and packaged it. read more

Holbrook Diner - Toasted bread.... I mean "French toast" - Diners Near Me - Holbrook, New York

Amazing!! The food, the customer service, the atmosphere!!!! Huge Huge difference from our horrible experience at the airport dinner!!!!! The dinner was clean, food came out quickly and perfect! This is the Best dinner on the island! read more

I have no idea why this place doesn't have 5 stars. I haven't dined in yet, but I've ordered via DoorDash several times and the food is ALWAYS delicious - at least for breakfast. I've tried the omelettes, hash browns and French toast, and all are fingerlicking good. read more

Overpriced, as most diners are. But the male service here sucks. Waiter was clueless. No pickle, no coleslaw. No straw w/ soda. No mustard on table with Pastrami. Potato pancakes ( off menu ) were hockey pucks. Had to ask for apple sauce & Sour cream. Even though half full felt rushed. The only thing they were quick & accurate with was the check. Go to busier diners (by the Airport) that SEEM higher priced. Service is better @ busier diner where you are not as rushed. read more

Great food great coffee Great quick service Very friendly folks. Highly recommended !!

Finally found a great diner out east here in Long Island! The service is great and the food good. I've been here quite a few times and always forgot to write a review. Their Vegetarian wrap was delicious and the broiled shrimp was delicious. I especially love that it was deveined and clean. Not all places do! They have a lot of options on their menu too! Definitely recommend! read more

See all

Our absolute favorite diner!!!! The food is always amazing!!! Never had a meal we didn't like!!! The service is always on point. The pricing is reasonable! Love the way they redid the inside. Looks great. Our go to!!! read more

Great food and exceptional service. Food is always excellent quality and the staff is friendly, which is a huge plus. My favorite diner and breakfast spot, right now. It's a real diner. It's clean and the ambiance is perfect. read more

My family and I have lived in Holbrook for 27 years and been coming to this diner for 23 years. Compared to many diners across the island as our family lives all over. Hands down the best diner. The place still seems to get better with age. That's my opinion and it's unanimous agreement for any friend, family, coworker who has never been there that I introduce. Coffee is delicious, ownership is hardworking. This Diner what you want after a long day of work with family instead of the pizza or for a early pre game day for any sport with their delicious coffee and eggs!! Huge shout out to David our waiter. You are the man!! Service Made the food better. read more