Slice of New York? How about slice of heaven! I remember my first trip to New York City and my slice of authentic New York pizza. Honestly it wasn't that good. The famous "slice" was underwhelming. So imagine my surprise when I heard rave reviews of Slice of New York on Stevens Creek in San Jose. I had to try it for myself. The service is attentive. The staff make sure you understand what you can order and very carefully take down your order and name. This is reassuring if you've ever had a wrong pizza order. No chance of that here. I ordered a large half pepperoni half mushroom olive to go and a slice of pepperoni while I waited. The slice was impeccable. Large enough to fold over like I was taught in New York City, unlike the slice I had in NYC, this one's tip didn't flop. Perfect! Next came the first bite. Hot, crispy, the perfect amount of sweet tangy pizza sauce, and the great chewy mozzarella. Hot all the way through. All fresh. All perfect. If you want better than the authentic thin crust New York City style pizza, whether a slice or a whole pizza, Slice of New York on Stevens Creek in San Jose is the place to go. When you walk in expect a line. This is ok because it gives you time to see ehat pies are zcsikbsly for slices. Don't worry if you don't see pepperoni, or cheese. Those are always available in the cabinet below the glass display. Get a black t-shirt. The design is retro-perfect. read more

High Five Pizza - Everyone's an owner! - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

See all

I can't believe I haven't been here sooner! So close to home. I was craving some pizza after work so I quickly browsed the menu to place a phone order. I went with a large garlic parmesan chicken pizza. Service was prompt and it was super busy there so good thing I called ahead. I didn't realize how popular this spot was. It was a full house with lots of TVs and seating. The estimated wait time was perfectly timed. Honestly looked so good I couldn't wait to eat the pizza when I got home. It smelled really good and tasted so freaking amazing. Love how the toppings were loaded and to the brim of the crust. Just how I like it. Nice crispy pizza and not oily unlike some other places. Kinda tasted like a chicken bake. For the price, I think it's worth. I would definitely be back! read more

High Five Pizza - Garlic parmesan chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

We were recommended by a friend to try High Five Pizza. We ended up ordering takeout. They have a special, "Every 3rd Wednesday of the Month Prime Rib Dinner Special". Dinner includes a baked potato with bacon, sour cream, chives, and butter, garlic bread and a small salad (4/5). A nice cut of prime rib with a seasoned crust. We asked for rare but by the time it arrived, it was medium. Still a good tasting prime rib. 3-Item Topping Pizza with salami, pepperoni, & mushroom. The crust was medium thickness and had a good bready texture. The pizza toppings were fresh and covered the whole pizza. Some felt it was a "bit salty". The customer service is very friendly, courteous, and polite. The manager is awesome and takes care of his customers. Support your local business. read more

See all

A time honored tradition. Have been coming here for years. Since my kids were in second grade. Now they are off to college so we don't go as often, but love the pizza, the atmosphere and the staff. Highly recommend this place, go early on game nights though bc they get super busy. But definitely worth the wait time. read more

Rating: 4.5/5 Dined here today with the fam and enjoyed every bite. We ordered XL Half All American and half Garlic Parmesan along with the combo appetizer which included bread, wings, potato skins, mozzarella sticks, and onion rings. Everything on the appetizer plate was nice and crisp and the baked wings were moist and not dry. I enjoyed the light batter on the onion rings. As for the pizza, they definitely don't skimp out on the toppings and I enjoyed the nice crispy crust and liked how the pizza held its form and didn't flop. Service was pretty fast and staff were friendly. Only thing is that I wish we were able to refill our drinks on our own instead of having to go up to the bar each time. But, other than that--I'd def come back to try other menu items whether it be dining it or ordering out! read more

High Five Pizza - Half all American and half garlic Parmesan - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

See all

Ordering was easy! It's a sit yourself and order at the counter type of thing. Menus on the wall or at the table. Got a simple pizza and the crust was kind of thin. Tasty in the moment but doesn't hold up to heat up the next day. Also got the garlic bread with cheese and forgot that fact and was expecting cheesy garlic bread so that's my own bad lol. If you prefer breadier pizza, you might wanna go somewhere else, but if you like an equal ratio of crust to sauce to toppings, then this is your place! read more

High Five Pizza - Half pepperoni and sausage and half ham and pineapple - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

See all

Had a Small 2 topping tonight and a soda. 1/2 Sausage and Mushroom & 1/2 Jalapeno & Pineapple Friendly service and very fast though they are constantly busy on a Tuesday night. Generous with refills. At first I thought I would be taking home 1/2 the pizza, then 1/4, then no need to get a box... Lively place with stand up comedians this evening as well. read more

Have been coming here since I was younger , staple location for fun events like comedy and sports game watching as well as delivering superior quality pizza with my favorites being bbq chicken , garlic sauce pepperoni or the Philly steak pizza . Busy in the evenings but also quick pick up read more

High Five Pizza - Bbq chicken / pepperoni pizza medium - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

Called in an order for pick up after work and wow I was so amazed that it was ready. Literally the phone call to place my order to picking up my order was seamless. Pizzas were hot and fresh from the oven , and delicious. Nothing to talk down on them about. Customer service here is always great, staff is friendly. High five is a great spot to go to after work for a cold one and a good slice, or out for dinner with friends and family . They also offer other items on their menu besides pizza which i look forward to trying. read more

See all

Yum! What a popular pizza spot in the area. The pizza is the right amount of thickness and fluffiness. They are LOADED with toppings. Would recommend! read more

High Five Pizza - All American & Garlic Parmesan Chicken + garlic bread with cheese - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

Best Pizza in San Jose! Family owned business love supporting them, everyone you talk to us always so happy to take your irder and assist you. We have never had a bad experience, they are very welcoming. They have multiple tvs around tge restaurant with different sports playing so you choose what you want to watch, from hockey to soccer and can't wait to visit during football season! read more

Big shoutout to the amazing staff and management at High Five for taking such great care of our Little League team the other night! We arrived a little later than planned, but they welcomed us with big smiles, incredible hospitality, and made sure everyone had a fantastic time. Their team went above and beyond to accommodate our group, and we couldn't have asked for a better experience. Highly recommend High Five for team celebrations, group outings, or any gathering where you want great service and lots of fun! read more

The good: 5 stars for High Five! My aunt lives 20 minutes from here and recommended that we try this spot. She has pizza spots closer to her but she told me it was worth driving over here. I got the meat pizza and the combination. The quality of the meat was great. It tasted better than the average meat from other pizza chains.We also got buffalo wings and garlic bread. Two medium pizzas, the bread and the wings were around $77. It fed 5 adults and 2 kids and we had leftovers. I preferred the combo because of the balance of vegetables. The bad: The buffalo wings were standard. The parking lot was tight. The interesting: The interior was festive with a Christmas tree, read more

Don't let the name fool you, High Five Pizza is way more than a pizza shop. Yes, the pizza is consistently delicious, but what keeps locals coming back is their incredible weekly rotation. Every Wednesday they serve barbecue, and it's honestly some of the best, most affordable BBQ in the area. And every third Wednesday is the famous Prime Rib Night. It's extremely popular, if you don't make a reservation early that morning, you probably won't get a table because the place books up fast. Standing room only. The vibe there is super casual, welcoming, and very family-oriented. You'll see everyone from kids in sports jerseys grabbing a post-game meal to older couples enjoying a low-key date night. Normally they don't take reservations, but they do for the Wednesday barbecue/prime rib nights, and the service is always friendly and efficient. It's a true neighborhood spot: great food, affordable prices, beer and wine only (no hard liquor), a classic salad bar, TVs everywhere including one outside for sports, and plenty of free parking in the plaza. The owners have really built a community gathering place. For me, the best part is that it's less than half a mile from home. I don't get to go as often as I'd like because I'm usually traveling or my friends are busy on Wednesdays. Highly recommend. Whether you come for pizza, BBQ Wednesdays, or Prime Rib Night, you'll leave happy and stuffed. read more

I just love high five. I moved away 15 yrs ago. And when I come back to see my mom I can always count on High Five to be the same fantastic pizza every single time.. makes me so happy to order Thank you Susan read more

Ordered over the phone for pick up! To my surprise, this place was crazy busy on a Friday night. Lots of sports fanatics and beer being poured. I was happy to have my pizza ready when I arrived. Piping hot! The crust was decent, very crispy. They didn't skimp out on the toppings! Two topping medium pizza was about $25. read more

High Five Pizza - Sausage + Mushroom - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

Came in for Galentine and pizza was great! We had the All American which is a combo! It was cooked perfect had nice balance of meat and veggies! Crust was nice and crispy. They made pizza the way I like it! Not saucy at all and no soggy crust. We also had a basket of fries and buffalo wings. Will have to come back! read more

They have great BBQ on Wednesday nights BUT, this past week they must have been so busy they DOUBLE charged me and didn't even reverse the charge after speaking to a manager on the phone. The young lady at the register (with lashes, all I can remember) charged me for items that I didn't even order. I pointed out the wrong amount on the screen, she said it was for the last transaction, and charged me for the correct item, a Rib dinner "to go". I paid, signed the receipt, and lo and behold I get home to look at my bank statement and she charged me! Called the next day and a manager said she noticed the issue and would reverse the charge. Took my number down to call me back and nothing! When I go back to speak to management AGAIN, it'll be my last time going there. Give me my money back! read more

High Five Pizza - I purchased a rib dinner to go! I understand mistakes happen but check your cameras! I didn't not leave with over $100 worth of food! - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

High-five has been a staple in the neighborhood for years. Good food, and a cool place to just hang out watch a game and eat a variety of good food. read more

Great afternoon to visit High Five to watch baseball and NCAA ball! The restaurant was packed with a lunch crowd which made it exciting for all to enjoy. A few of the tables needed to be cleaned but it was a tad busy. The bar was popping and the ambiance was cheerful. We ordered a hot link sandwich which was good but lacked flavor. Maybe the addition of grilled onions would have given it more zip. The pizza was good with a lot of sauce, meat and veggies. We tried a new adult beverage that quenched our thirst with a tad of tangerine. A good place to go for yummy grub and beverages. Highly recommend. read more

High Five Pizza - Pizza and hot link - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

I usually have nothing but good feedback for the food at this pizza place, but my most recent order of a large barbecue chicken pizza had too much of their barbecue sauce. It was slathered on so thick it dominated the taste of everything else. Think of a salad that is drowning in salad dressing. Next time, if there is a next time, I'll have to ask them to go light on the sauce. read more

Stopped in after passing by this place for years. Pamela took my order over the phone and when I walked in it just came out hot and fresh. The taste was crunchy and delicious with thick crust. A clean nice looking sports bar included. The only problem is it not the same later when you reheat it at home . But, still good. read more

See all

2 more years and time for another update. My friend loves their French Dip sandwich, although I still haven't tried it. I did, however, try their Potato Skins recently. These crunchy skins had plenty of potato so they were hearty, and they were loaded with plenty of bacon and cheddar cheese. The potato skins came with a couple of containers of Ranch dressing. The skins were a great addition to my go-to pizza order. read more

Overall, good pizza and fun atmosphere. The pizza does take awhile to come, but it was informed to be about 20 mins or so depending on crowd. The basket of fries was also pretty good...crispy on the outside and fluffy inside. read more

High Five Pizza - 2 toppings : mushroom and sausage - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

We always come for the Thai chicken pizza. It's bomb!! So many toppings make the crust a skinny legend (the way I like it). We usually order online and pick up there. They have a separate line for pickups so it's quick and convenient. read more

High Five Pizza - Thai Chicken - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

Came here on a Wednesday night for their BBQ special. The BBQ back ribs were very moist, flavorful, and tender. It's a great value for the portion and quality. The place gets busy, so it can be hard to find a seat, but the lively atmosphere adds to the experience. Customer service was friendly and attentive. Overall, a solid spot with good food and great vibes. I enjoyed this place a lot read more

High Five Pizza - Meat lover. I should have ordered half and half - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

Nice lively place. Good beer selection. Got the supreme veggie pizza and it was chock full of toppings. Tasty and nice crust. Very reasonably priced too! Order at the counter and they will call out your name when it's ready. read more

High Five Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

I called and spoke with a young woman who clearly has an attitude problem, and when I basically said I don't want someone spitting in my food--and that I'd rather not eat there--she acted like I was bothering her. I gave the place one more shot, thinking maybe it was a fluke. But nope, same clueless girl dumps a ton of jalapeños on my sandwich to the point it's completely inedible. Honestly, I wouldn't bother recommending their service. I'm not sure if she's just some nepotistic family member or what, but she just lost a customer. Big deal? in these times, every customer should. read more

Lovely neighborhood pizza joint to catch a game with a great slice and pint. Staff is super friendly. Have been going here with my family for over a decade. Love that they have daily specials and outdoor seating for summer/spring sports! read more

High Five Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

Pizza here is solid! Its exactly what you would expect when you think of good, classic pizza. Came here for lunch with my dad. I was excited to try this place because I keep hearing how good it is. I wasn't disappointed, even going in with high expectations. Location is in a strip mall with decent parking. I had no issues as it was lunchtime on a weekday. Inside is what you expect for a pizza place. Spacious, clean, and they have TV's playing sports stuff. Service was pleasant and efficient. Food was ready quickly. They have outside seating, which I appreciate, but they have the sports stuff turned up really loud outside. Presumably to drown out car noises. But had to shout at times to have a conversation in order to be heard over the radio. I'm sure it's much louder outside when it's busy (radio + parking lot & street traffic + other patrons). I had a personal size cheese pizza (I like to keep it basic), cooked crispy. They did a perfect job of cooking it just well enough to have a crispness to it without burning it. Cheese to sauce to crust ratio was ideal. Ingredients tasted like they were good quality. It was a deal at $6.50 as the size seemed slightly larger than I expected for a personal pizza. I could only eat half so I got two delicious meals out of it. Dad had a pepperoni pizza, size small, which was also a tremendous value for the size. His was cooked crisp as well, and the pepperoni had that nice cup shape. He said his was very good and put it on par with The Garrett Station on Winchester (his favorite pizza place, which I have not tried so I can't confirm his claim). But he had zero complaints and seemed eager to return to try some other items. Which is saying a lot because he's super picky and critical. Menu: They have many different specialty and popular pizzas with the option to build your own. Long list of sandwiches and appetizers (jalapeño poppers, I'm coming for you next time!). Salads and churro donuts. They have ribs/some kind of red meat item on certain days/nights of the week (Wednesdays? Call restaurant for details). I'm a fan. Looking Forward to going back to try something else! read more

4/5 is pretty fitting. I ordered a large 4 topping regular pizza (sausage pepperoni olives mushrooms), came out to be like $33 which is a fair price. Pizza was good and we enjoyed it. It wasn't mind blowing but it was still good. It's hard to find a decent pizza place in the blossom hill area so this place definitely gets points for that. The restaurant was clean and employees were nice. I did a pick-up order though. There were quite a few people eating inside so that was a good sign. I'd order from them again but I'd add more toppings to make it closer to a combo pizza . read more

High Five Pizza - Sausage pepperoni olives mushroom large pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

The food was satisfactory; however, the service could be improved. It is a great establishment with numerous televisions, making it an ideal choice for those interested in watching sports while enjoying pizza. The place also seemed to be clean read more

I did an online order for pick up. It was ready on the dot which was perfect! The staff members were very nice and helpful. Since I did a big order, they helped me bring all the food to the car. They gave me a lot of ranch which is a huge plus! The pizza is delicious! I'm always satisfied with the food. Get the potato skins! They're the best! I ate here once and it's a great place to drink and hang out with friends. read more

High Five Pizza - Front - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

From the ordering (sweet young lady on the phone.. wish I knew her name) to picking up the pizza everything was great! High Five Pizza has been our pizza place ever since they opened! We ate it at home so ambiance is what a pizza place is... beer, TV and kids and parents having a great time with their family! read more

Panko halibut special during Wednesday BBQ night is pretty good. I love flaky white fish, and it's not too common to see halibut offered, so I appreciate High Five Pizza offering it as a special. The tartar sauce was a necessary addition to the halibut. The risotto was just okay, and I was a bit disappointed that the fish special does not come with a baked potato like the other BBQ Wednesday dishes. read more

See all

This place has been in this location since I can remember, but I had never tried it before! Finally it was time to try high five pizza... honestly it's a great, tasty, amazing product but it just tastes too similar to Round Table. They even do the same salad bar set up as Round Table as well..Service was satisfactory, people come here to have drinks, watch sports, be loud and eat pizza. Nonetheless , High Five is quality, but to reach 5 stars it has to stand out on its own read more

High Five Pizza - Small Pepperoni & Sausage - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

See all

This place is absolutely amazing every time we go, and the pizza always tastes great. I wish that they would switch their garlic bread to breadsticks. I feel like they would do well doing that the mozzarella sticks are very basic, but they work. The decor is nice and very Bay Area based the restaurant is always clean. Their staff are constantly turning over tables and picking up when people are done with their dishes immediately even while they're still sitting at the table, which I really like, unfortunately the bathroom leaves something to be desired. It smells pretty bad. I get that that's a problem in a lot of restaurants, but I definitely wish that they would do something about it. This is definitely a place that you can go and watch sporting events. I believe that's a huge plus since that's a big part of everyday life for many people I do enjoy the fact that you can play the lottery there as well I have always found that being able to play the lottery at restaurants through the plus, but not many people offer it conveniently located in a shopping center biggest downfall is the parking there's just not enough of it other than that, the food comes out rather quickly, and the customer service is always spot on. read more

See all

Food especially the pizza here is amazingly good. Pizza is better here than most pizza joints. Service can be a bit slow since they are very busy during the evenings and weekends. The ambiance is a bar with sports on the TV. They also have beer on tap, fountain drinks, and plenty of seating. However on busy days, seatings can be tough to find. I would come here again but not during peak times. read more

High Five Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

We created our own pizza, half with sausage, mushroom, and onion on pesto sauce, the other half with sausage, mushroom, pepperoni, and jalapeno with regular pizza sauce. Service was standard and sufficient, and it took about 15-20 minutes for our takeout order to be ready, near closing time this past Thursday. The pizza was sooooo yummy, made with quality ingredients. Savory meats, the jalapenos adding a nice spice, and a really delicious pesto sauce, better than what most other pizzerias offer. The crust here is also quite tasty, especially cuz the sauce and generous toppings go all the way to the edges with a nice crunch. Note, if you get ranch on the side, it will be hidden valley brand, but at least they don't charge extra for this. read more

See all

I was super excited to try this place on a recent visit to San Jose as I had seen so many positive reviews....bit unfortunately this place fell far short of expectation. I ordered a small taco pizza via Door Dash...total price SAN delivery was just over $20. It looked good upon opening...but the crust was super hard (almost like several day old bread) and slightly burnt. The burned flavor really came through while eating. I could only manage two slices before discarding. For the premium cost of a 10 inch pizza this should have been much much better. read more

High Five Pizza - Small 10 inch taco pie - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California