BLUF: good for what it is: basic, mostly fried pub-style food. Friendly service…read more Went with a large group on a weekday night. Place was about half full. We were seated pretty quickly, and first round of drink orders taken. First sign this isn't a top of the line place: drinks came in disposable plastic cups. Our server was friendly, despite being a bit overwhelmed by all the orders. Got fried pickle appetizer. Not bad at all, hot and with a nice crunch. Came with a very tasty dipping sauce. My side salad was very simple but fresh, and I got a balsamic vinagrette dressing which was good. Several of us ordered chicken wings, and they came out hot and nicely crispy. We tried a variety of the sauces and toppings - all were good EXCEPT garlic parmesan: nasty stuff. Tasted like feet. Chicken pot pie was more like a thick chicken soup with a pastry on top. That said, it was very good and the pastry was wonderful. Just not a classic pot pie at all. Several got the cheesesteak, which was average. Bread was kind of dry, but it was okay. Burgers were a hit, as was the Salmon. They have some very tasty desserts, although I suspect they are sourced at Costco or something like that. I base this on similarity to those stores' offerings and the too-perfect uniformity of slices. Not to say they weren't good though. Everyone thought they were. I'd go back if I was in the area and hungry, but it's nothing special. Not great, not bad. Kinda what you'd expect along the road in Greencastle

My first time eating here…read more First, the establishment had two eateries... one is a casual sport bar atmosphere the other is a more formal dining room. Entrance isn't immediately obvious the dining room is on the left side of the building from the street. The sportbar is in the right side. Whatever... I ate in the dining room. It was a nice quiet space where your can enjoy a quiet conversation. I liked that. Service was friendly and at least initially was attentive. We got drinks and menus than she disappeared! For 20 minutes! Ugh. The good news was that the food came out quickly once the offset went in. I ordered the tavern burger without bread. It was tasty with nice crisp edges without ending up dry and well done inside. I really liked the fries which came out hot and stayed crisp without all that nasty coating you find in other places. In all I was satisfied with my visit. Good, not outstanding. I will visit again. I guess that's an endorsement, right?

Go for the ice cream! Super creamy soft serve and your typical hard dipped ice cream. Been going…read morehere for years and always love it.

Mikie's Ice Cream & Green Cow Gift Shop is a quaint family ice cream/sandwich shop in Greencastle,…read morePA. It's been around for a long time and the parking lot is always packed. They serve a myriad of food items and the staff is friendly. I've enjoyed the items I've ordered, which range from subs to ice cream. My only complaint would be that the service is pretty slow each time I visit. If they're super busy, I completely understand, but that's not always the case.

Beautiful and cozy restaurant. Has live bands on Saturdays The service was amazing. Ask for…read moreNicole. Fresh homemade bread. The muscles and the crab dip are the best I've ever had. The desserts are to die for. This is a great little place to spend some time with friends and have good food.

Just left with friends and not happy with the experience. Per our waitress the menu recently…read morechanged. I understand the need to change things up, but the menu offerings were not what we were looking forward to. Limited about of hand held offerings as well menu didn't lists sides clearly. Food was not as good as what we look forward to.

The food here was generally underwhelming…read more On the positive side, the wings were very good. They were meaty & flavorful. I wasn't excited about our other appetizer, though, as the fried asparagus was dull. My hamburger was OK but nothing special. I would have been happier if I could have ordered it medium rare, but they serve everything medium. My husband was unimpressed with the pulled pork sandwich. Also, the onion straws were awful.

We had our wedding celebration at Fireside Pub and everything was perfect. The food and cocktails…read morewere great, the staff were friendly and accommodating. Abbey and Ben took care of every detail for us. Could not have asked for more.

I had one of the worst customer service experiences I've encountered recently, and I feel it's…read moreimportant to share so others -- and hopefully corporate leadership -- are aware. While using the restroom, I brought in a fountain soda cup to refill afterward. Upon returning to the counter, I was approached by a staff member (who I later learned was the manager) who made a disparaging remark about my cup not being from their store. When I went to check out, he directed the cashier to void my transaction and charge me a higher price for the refill, apparently because he disapproved of the cup's brand. Setting aside the fact that this cost me less than a dollar, what stood out was the way it was handled. Rather than addressing the situation professionally or discreetly, the manager chose to make a snide comment and then use his position to override a routine transaction. This kind of behavior is unprofessional and unwelcoming, and it reflects poorly on the store's management. I won't be returning to this location. It's disappointing that a matter of fifty to seventy-five cents was treated as an opportunity to embarrass a customer rather than simply process a routine refill. I'd encourage corporate to look into how this manager interacts with customers, as this is not the kind of experience that should represent the brand.

Always clean, tends to be understaffed but their workers are kind and get the job done, def deserve…read morea raise

I've driven past this place a dozen times, thought I would stop in. my waitress "Bonnie" could not…read morehave been sweeter and the food was great. next I need to bring a better appetite, because it was a lot of food. It definitely has a old-school vibe, I was waiting to see Flo come from the back (google it, for the young people). I would recommend,.

Awesome breakfast here in green castle pa. Got my self a free coffee and an extra side of bacon…read more Need energy for the long haul ahead.

6 tacos, Sheetz, Greencastle PA. NASTY Grease soaked shells…read moreso thin a pack of gum wouldn't fit betw them. Sickening brown paste for 'beef'. One pepper slice per taco and a few shreds of cheese. Even Taco Bell has you beat. Order Number 157533800 Date Placed 06/01/2026 05:59 PM.

I came upon this location in the middle of the night on a trek back home. It was a welcomed sight…read moreon an unfamiliar road and a much needed stop. I needed so many things at that point, that this was truly a blessing. I was sorely in need the facilities. Once I parked I made my way into the interior. Even though I was in need of the facility, I stopped at the touchscreen to place my order. I feel like this makes the time pass a little quicker if I use the facilities after ordering. Once done there I made my way over to grab a sweet tea and head over to pay. The introvert that I am, I like to use the self checkouts, but I needed to grab an item from behind the counter. Line moved quickly, and I was on my way over to wait for my food. Food was a bit off. I really am upset that they removed tots from their menu. First it was the onion rings, then my fallback was the tots. With that gone, it really has made me (and I am sure many other people out there) cut back on my dependency on Sheetz. Take away my tots, I lost interest.

This BK has the best staff at lunch. Can't speak for other times as I always go then. Mariam,…read moreMichele and Courtney always greet me by name and deliver outstanding customer service. BK should definitely talk to these ladies because they definitely get it right!

Typical Burger King food but better than average customer service! Thank you to tonight's team!read more