What a fun place! And such YUMMY food! I was in the area, and I love cider, so I had to stop in. There's peach cider! Cherry cider! Pies! Baked goods! But nothing gluten-free, alas. If I remember correctly. I bought some German sauerkraut, which seemed excessively expensive, but it was very good. There are LOTS of pickled things. I also bought an exceedingly large jug of cherry cider. It was very good, although a bit sweet for me. I'll get the peach next time. These are non-alcoholic ciders. read more

See all

Fresh local produce, fantastic pies and cider and a huge selection of jarred specialties from homemade jams to picked everything. They bake breads too. We cannot got out east without stopping there and always try something new. The heirloom tomatoes were perfect here! read more

Hallock's Cider Mill - Bakeries Near Me - Laurel, New York

Kind of a strange vibe from the outside, but once you walk through the front door the place is very big. Sells a ton of different jared preserves and a bunch of baked goods. Very nice people and a great little place. Would say you should check it out at least once. read more

Best pies ever, always fresh,a wide variety of fruits veggies, cookies are amazing as well, a must stop when out west on the north fork

Great People with a Great Product, my go to for holiday pies and desserts! For years and years

The best cookies I ever had especially the oatmeal raisin. Chocolate Chip excellent. Cakes wonderful. Bread very goid. read more

Place is a super fun and classic spot to stop by when going east. Plenty of stuff to see around it but also the local produce is nice. I'd recommend really looking at the product before purchase as well since they do sell things they don't make in house (got duped into but honeycomb made in Hungary and packed in NJ? Lol - still was good). Recommend their cookies and home made juices and drinks. Their peach cider is an absolute delicious drink. I've tried their homemade mozzarella which was fine - probably could've used a little more salt but it's still good. Was unfortunately disappointed with a homemade banana bread - not enough banana flavor in it. And with the high prices here it's hard to walk away spending 100$+ on like 7 small things and one of them sucks. But in any case I'd still recommend making the stop and trying a few of their homemade items yourself. read more

I drive over fifty miles to visit Hallock's Cider Mill and it's absolutely worth the trip every time. Everything is really tasty - we always pick up a big jug of apple cider and try the other unique flavors of cider they have to offer (peach and cherry are particularly excellent). The folks working here are really friendly - overall the ambiance is warm and the store smells like the sweet like the pies and other products baked there. I highly recommend Hallock's for anyone looking for farm fresh goodness on the east end. read more

Hallock's Cider Mill - Apple Fritter - Bakeries Near Me - Laurel, New York

We were looking for a hard cider spot and stumbled onto this place instead. It was such a great find! Cute farmstead with a ton of housemade goodies like pickled veggies, eggs, jams and preserves as well as fresh produce and of course unspiked sweet apple cider. We also usually go to another very well known farmstead spot for pies, but after trying a variety of their press this weekend, I'll be coming here for them! Took home 7 small pies to taste test and usually you'll have a mix bag of hits and misses, however, each were phenomenal, like nobody had anything bad to say about ANY of them. Cheesecake was creamy, the fruit crumbles were made with fresh fruit and were sweet tart just enough, the peanut butter pie packed a heap of peanut flavor but was so so light, the sinful pie was aptly named :a light cheesecake mousse topped with coconut flakes, crunchy sweet pecans and chocolate... It really was sinfully delicious. Their Key lime pie was definitely some of the best I've tasted outside of FL and I'm a straight rhubarb only pie fan but their strawberry rhubarb pie won me and my fellow taste testers over. Planning to go back every weekend here on out just for these pies read more

Hallock's Cider Mill - Clockwise from top left :cheesecake, blueberry crumb, peach crumb, sinful, key lime, peanut butter and strawberry rhubarb pies - Bakeries Near Me - Laurel, New York

I fell in love with this place! It is a super cute farm stand. And they have so much stuff to choose from. And reasonably priced. First off the blueberry crumb cake is delicious! The small ones are only $8. They are so so good! They have local honey, home pickles, pickled garlic! They have key lime pies to banana bread. They have jam! Everything is homemade! They do sell flowers and fruit/vegetables. It is a cute little place to stop for some treats! read more

See all

Best Keylime pie! Everyone loves it and recommend it highly! Great for dessert for company!

Love this place. I just wish I could order and have it delivered. Hot sauce, jelly and bbq are all amazing.

Excellent products. Would recommend. Especially she'll nightlights. Nice gift shop. read more

One of our new favorite places to stop out in the area! They have such a good fresh-baked bread and desserts! They have nice produce as well, and reasonably priced. I definitely recommend the apple cider donuts and apple turnovers! Definitely pop by here to support a quaint, local business! read more

Hallock's Cider Mill - Croissants, raspberry jelly donut, apple cider donuts - Bakeries Near Me - Laurel, New York

Omg on a road full of farm stands. Hallock's Cider Mill is not to be missed on the basis of 2 items, of which are extremely high on my general list of favorite foods. You must try: 1- the clam chowder!!!!! 2- the key lime pie!!!!!! Omg I cannot express my love and gratitude for this place enough :) do not skip Hallock's cider mill! read more

Seriously the best place to get pie out East! Others who haven't discovered this amazing place might disagree for a more welcome known pie place where you need to wait online. This place has so many different pies to choose from, from every different kind of fruit to frozen pies and crumb topped pie. They also have delicious jarred veggies, fruit and jams. And of course when we stop we MUST buy the largest apple cider they have. We can't go into this gem without a large cider in hand. They have a great variety of fresh fruit and veggies, from strawberries to peaches and corn to zucchini. In the back area they have even more delicious items, including really good cookies! And some cute decorative household items! If you come across this amazing business, stop by... you won't be disappointed! read more

Their raspberry crumb cake is "the best crumb cake I've ever had". I get 3-6 every time I go because I have to get them for every family member. I clean house at this place... I also empty my bank account here lol. The sugarfree jams are... am I gonna say it? Yes I am, theyre my JAM. The Cheddar cheese is top notch. The sinful pie is just that, sinful. It's one of those things that if left in the freezer miraculously disappears. Who ate it? Nobody claims to have eaten it, but it sure is gone lol. The Keylime pie has a chocolate layer that perfectly balances its tartness. The Kellie bar is equally delicious. The blueberry cream pie is also a hit with us. All the bakes goods are perfection. We haven't had a single bad thing here. They also sell an array of seasonal fruits and veggies. They're closed for a few months after Xmas so do call before visiting in the winter months. Its a staple on the north fork and one of my family's faves. read more

Wow, I passed this place so many times and never stopped in. What a mistake! I think it was the sign award winning clam chowder, always reminds me of the movie ELF, World's Greatest Coffee, and his date responds it's just another crappy cup of coffee. Well that's not the case here. The clam chowder is one of the best I've ever had. Creamy with generous chunks of clams and potatoes. I was determined to get an apple pie and the pies are outstanding. I ended up getting the apple crumb. Big chunks of crumbs. I could just eat the pie crust and crumbs, it was that good. It was difficult leaving the store, it smelled so good and everything look good, I just wanted to try everything. I did pick up banana bread and a couple of cider donuts. The cider donuts were the best I ever had. Make sure you park in the back parking lot. There is a tree trunk decorated with wood elf's and houses, sort of like the keebler cookie guys. This is a must stop for me from now on. read more

See all

A friend of mine purchased a peach pie yesterday which she brought to my home, I cannot express how much we all LOVED this pie! By far the best peach pie we have ever had and I don't even like pie Beautifully done! Thank you read more

This place is cute like other local bakery and farm stands in the area. It was quaint with nice bakery items. The main reason we stopped was because of the signs for clam chowder! We did end up buying several other things. Buy: homemade apple sauce & clam chowder. However hard pass: portobello soup and homemade pickles!! The pickles were borderline inedible. read more

Hallock's Cider Mill - a jar of apple sauce - Bakeries Near Me - Laurel, New York

See all

So during the pandemic people have turned to comfort foods and I am no different. But a recent find at Hallock has put a new spin on an old favorite. When you think back to you childhood which sandwich reminded you of the simplest purest joy. It's gotta' be PB&J right? if there were a childhood hall of fame this plebian sandwich surely would be among the first inductees. Simple ingredients, low relative cost, simple to prepare with enough sugar to power you through your afternoon and some proteins as well. What's more, even our five and six year old latchkey selves could prepare it and mom didn't have to worry about burning the house down. Without besmirching the classic PB&J a bit, I'm am a little past those days of limited self-reliance. My budget also affords me the ability to reach beyond the bottom shelf where pathmark "No-Frills" jelly resided. If you are similarly situated, I recommend you reach for a jar of Hallocks Strawberry Preserve. This preserve takes the old standard PB&J up at least two notches to make it PB&Jammin! The preserves are so thick and rich and filled with fruit flavor that Jelly just can't match. If PB&J are the old comfy slippers then the preserves make this the old comfy slippers with cashmere lining and non-slip soles. It allows you to be loyal to the classic while still elevating your game. While I'll never dis' the old Pathmark brand that raised me through my teens, I know PB&J brinkmanship when I see it. I'm committed to keeping my game up here. You are welcome to join me. read more

The best pie I've ever eaten. We stopped here on a whim coming back from the vineyards and immediately loved the variety of freshly made sweets, breads and prepared goods. I loved that I didn't have to drop $20 on a large pie and instead opted for the smaller size that was just as packed with flavor. The berries were extremely fresh and not overly sweetened complimented by the buttery crust. I usually leave the crust for my hubby to devour but I ate this one all on my own, it was too addicting! I also purchased Hallock's honey mustard and have used it with fries, chicken and in many salads. It is very versatile, with notes of sweetness combined with the perfect amount of tang. Hallock's pies beat Briermiere any day of week. read more

I love this place. Never seems too crowded, and it's easy to walk in even with my rollator walker. I go mainly for the soups. They have excellent New England and Manhattan clam chowders that just happen to be gluten free. The people who run it are friendly and helpful. The apple cider is excellent. Their apple pie with walnuts and icing was my favorite until I had to go gluten free. A small gem with an historical vibe. read more

Love Hallock's!!! The grape juice is amazing (MUST try!!!) We got the blueberry crumb pie this time, and it's amazing. read more

Fabulous in every way. Unique produce and amazing baked goods. They really believe in using the best ingredients made with TLC

Hallock's used to be awesome. The quiche was great and the fruit pies delicious. Unfortunately, today was probably my last trip here.The quiche was refrigerated and completely watery and runny when I got home. The small apple pie was ok, tasted like canned apples instead of fresh ones. I was shocked when the young man at the counter told me it was $40. I asked him how much the small pie was and he replied $15! Hallock's has gotten way too greedy for me. Also, the 3% surcharge for using a credit card or even a DEBIT card is just ridiculous. I'm so tired of being ripped off ,so bye-bye Hallock's. read more

Best apple crumb pie ever! Picture: a tender, flaky crust filled with juicy, sweet, cinnamon-spiced filling and apples topped with light crumbles. It had just the right amount of sweetness and the apple chunks were not too chunky. I hate when theres more pie crust and crumbs than the actual apple and apple sauce filling, but Hallock nailed the ratio of this pie. I also got the strawberry rhubarb crumb pie which was delicious as well and a quick favorite of mine. Definitely one of the best pies around the area. Also, the employees are very kind. read more

Hallock's Cider Mill - Apple (cinnamon) crumb pie, light crumbs! - Bakeries Near Me - Laurel, New York

See all

Such a disappointment. I came to pick up my thanksgiving pies that I ordered a few weeks ago. Unfortunately my order was put in the wrong day for pickup. Emma, the counter woman, was lovely and trying to fix the issue. The problem came from the owner who was incredibly RUDE. I couldn't remember the woman's name who took my order so when I asked what her name was she would not even answer me. I hope the pies are good but I'll never be back here. read more

I came for the pie and left with so many other delicious things. They have a great selection of baked goods. I enjoyed everything I purchased which included an amazing key lime pie, pumpkin loaf and an apple danish. It looked like they had a nice selection of veggies, soups and ciders too. Worth a stop! read more

How can you resist just brought out strawberry rhubarb crumb topped pie? Also, many others including key lime, pecan, fresh cider to go, local farm fruit & vegs, and above all a variety of just made homemade bread. I haven't tried their chowder because its not their main thing. What I've tried is good. read more

Hallock's Cider Mill - Bakeries Near Me - Laurel, New York

See all

I am impressed. Very impressed. My whole family bought something for themselves and shared it among ourselves over Christmas weekend. Cheesecake, blueberry pie, apple crumb pie, and a couple more that I forgot, but we absolutely loved it. But that's not all they sell, mind you, but it definitely looked like their best offering. I must go back one of these days. read more

The smell instantly lures you once you enter the store. The pies are fresh and DELICIOUS. Loved their apple pie crumb cake which is perfect in every aspect from the crumb topping, flaky crust and rich apple filling. Excited to try other flavors next time! read more

The. Best. Black. Cherry. Pie. Ever. I'd heard about this place, rave reviews for the pie and most enthusiastically for the cherry pie. I didn't think a pie could live up to the hype. But WOW. Big whole cherries coated in rich filling with the best butter crust I've ever had-sugar coated crunchy, flakey, perfect. If you like cherry pie this one's to die for! read more

Hallock's Cider Mill - Outrageously delicious black cherry pie! - Bakeries Near Me - Laurel, New York

Unfriendly counter service. There are so many great places to stop around this place it's amazing that they are so rude to their customers. read more

I bought the peach pie today. And it's was so bad. It's made from can peaches and lots of corn syrup. Horrible.

Our family has been getting their pies and cider here for over 30 years !! Worth the stop . The butter scotch cookies are a real treat . Check out the unique selection of delicious everything!! read more

Great little pie shop out east on the island. I usually get the sinfull pie which is really good. It is like a heavy whipped cream filling topped with coconut and pecans that are cooked until there is a dark brown crust ontop. They also have other pies like apple, blueberry, peach, cheesecakes, pound cakes, honey, all different flavors of spreads like apple butter and other ones, cookies, maple syrup, they make there own doughnuts and apple fritters(not the best), they also have some local produce and flowers. This place is my go to place unlike the other place north of them that is all hype and no flavor. read more

I've been to Hallock's Cider Mill many times &, as a life-long Long Islander, look forward to returning every summer. But I am never returning! When I alerted the staff that a bag of potato chips I was on line to purchase was spoiled and I would no longer be buying them, the owner refused and proceeded to get into a shouting match with me. Even though he insisted that I buy them because they were opened, I still purchased the other $60 worth of products I was online to buy! So, otherwise great products, but utterly appalling, insulting service! read more

Have gone there numerous times to pick up apple cider, fruits in season, donuts, pies, etc. Every time I went I was greeted by pleasant, knowledgeable people. A great place to go. read more

We have been coming here for about 7 years. I love their baked goods. We are addicted to their blueberry pie. Before they close for the winter, we buy a couple pies and freeze it to hold over till they open again. Their different banana breads are always so moist and delicious. Their cookies are yummy as well. Wayne--the Keebler elf who does all the baking in the back--is as sweet as his pies. Their staff is very accommodating. If I want a specific pie when it's sold out--they will take my number and call when a fresh batch is ready. The personal, friendly service coupled with delicious baked goodies make this place our favorite in the NOFO. read more