I've been to Grimaldi's a few times ,but most recently went for a family dinner. They have accommodations for larger parties- we made a reservation in advance. Our server was very kind and attentive, which I appreciate! I started with spritz (so delicious and not too sweet, which I loved) and split a small Caesar salad with my bf. I feel like the small salad size serves 2 to 3 people and the large maybe 4-6. I also got a personal-sized brick-oven margarita pizza, which was good. I liked that it has a crispy crust and good amount of sauce. You can also customize pizzas to your personal preference. Overall, a solid spot to try out for brick-oven style pizzas! read more

See all

Stopped in for an impromptu lunch while shopping at the corners of Brookfield. We were seated right away, and our server was very friendly. We started with the bruschetta trio which included three different types of bruschetta all were pretty good, but I will say that the classic was my favorite. We ordered the arugula prosciutto pizza at the recommendation of our server. This is typically one of my favorite pizzas and it was good, but the flavor was missing something and there was too much arugula not enough prosciutto. We ended with dessert a tiramisu, which was absolutely amazing overall, our experience was good but next time I think I would try a different pizza read more

See all

We stopped here to celebrate a birthday and I'll admit I was extremely reticent due to past reviews. However, we were pleasantly surprised at our very normal evening here. The restaurant is a large open space with traditional pizzeria garb - red and white checkered tables, wine bottle chandeliers (very cute) and garage doors that open for patio dining. We ordered drinks and received them pretty quickly. They were out of an IPA on tap but they thankfully had a few choices with taps and bottles. Also, plenty of wine and cocktails. Our server was very nice and patient with us as we were contemplating our food choices. The small mediterranean salad was pretty big and we were able to share amongst our table. We ended up splitting 2 18 in pizzas amongst 6 adults and it worked out pretty well. My only gripe is the price - expensive for a thin crust pizza. However, the group agreed it was pretty good and many said they'd come back. Also wish they had drink pricing online but you just have to wait to be surprised by their selection. We got our drinks and food timely and dinner actually went much faster than we were planning. We also saw a large salad on our way out and it was a huge platter - well worth it to get a large salad for a group for just a few bucks more. The birthday boy received a small cannoli for his birthday, too. read more

See all

Our server was great!! The Caesar and Mediterranean salad were great! Red Pepper bruschetta was great! The worst pizza...Crust has zero flavor. White pizza was so dry I had to add a drizzle of olive oil to the top. About 10 mushrooms on the entire 18" pizza. Almost no spinach. Go for the salad! Skip on the pizza. read more

Stopped in for a late lunch today. We were greeted snd seated right away. Pizza/ food smelled amazing! Told our server it was our 1st visit and she explained the style of pizza they served! We looked over the menu and ordered a small house salad! Which was actually huge portion enough for two people. Then we had a cheese, green pepper , onion & mushroom pizza! It was very good! Place is cute and very east coast nostalgia ! read more

See all

The pizza was good but the service was not so good . We arrived with children and weren't even offered any dough to play with for the kids . The server never came to check to see how our food was. read more

Pizza was delicious and our server Julia was so kind and so fun with us! 10/10 experience!

Kind of "chainy" and pretty good food. There are so many places, this is not my first stop for service and taste, but it is convenient.

The space is beautiful and very intimate but that's the highlight. Food was okay but the service was my big issue here. Service was not the worst I've ever had but I always felt like an after thought. Took almost 90 minutes to get our food but we had a group of 12 but that still felt really long. Had to constantly remind our server about drinks etc. The bar was similar because you had to flag down the bartender Food was good but not amazing. Shared the margherita pizza with a friend and the toppings were good but really didn't pop. I thought the crust was the highlight. Maybe I chose the wrong pizza. It just was not my place but I know other people love it. read more

Grimaldi's Pizzeria - Brookfield We visited Grimaldi's recently and left feeling underwhelmed. The wait for a table was every minute as long as they said, and a little more. There is not a lot of space to wait, so your best bet is to put your name in and maybe shop nearby. We ordered a gluten-friendly pizza (note: there's literally flour everywhere, so it's not safe for those with celiac or severe gluten sensitivities), a regular pizza, and the lemon arugula salad. The pizzas were fine--nothing spectacular--but the salad was overly bitter and not enjoyable. We still ate it, because we were hungry. The service was okay, but nothing stood out. The restaurant didn't feel clean, and we noticed some questionable practices as we waited (cell phone in the prep area, for example). Overall, Grimaldi's was just average. The wait, lack of cleanliness, and bitter salad left us less than impressed for the cost. Too many great pizza places in Milwaukee to return. read more

Overall experience- Ridiculous wait and horrible customer service! My family of 3 went for dinner last night 8/21/24 it was Thursday and the area had a food truck event going on, so the restaurant wasn't very busy. Sat down at 6:20pm 6:35pm, waiter came. Ordered drinks and food. 6:55- been there 35 minutes. Still no drinks. Not even water was brought. 40 minutes- still no water drinks or food. 7:02pm-Drinks arrived 7:26- Finally got food Staff was constantly seen in the back eating and coming out chewing with their cheeks full. Where are the adults?? ABSOLUTELY RIDICULOUS!!! Food was mediocre DO NOT RECOMMEND/AND/OR DO NOT GO HUNGRY! read more

We had amazing service here! We have two young children and don't usually go out to eat but my friend told me this place was good for kids and it really was. Our server was so sweet. They had coloring AND pizza dough (like play dough) for the kids. It kept them so locked in so we could enjoy a dinner out. The food was also delicious! We had a salad which came out first and a two pizzas (a regular cheese and a hot honey pepperoni which was devine). There isn't a kids menu but I don't think there is a need for one because... it's pizza! The wait for the pizza wasn't too long but it wasn't the quickest either. The pizzas are made to order and you can actually watch them make them at the entrance area which is also cool! read more

Delicious food and great servers! The strawberry Italian soda was refreshing. I also got the sausage and white garlic pizza. It was flavorful, and I enjoyed the crispy crust. I understand that some people may not be a fan of this place due to its slow service. However, I know that they make their dough from scratch, and you can even see the workers rolling and shaping the dough. That takes time, and it makes the quality of the pizza better than other pizzerias. What separates this restaurant from other places is their amazing servers. There are many restaurants I have dined at with extremely slow service yet the server will not acknowledge it, which makes me reconsider coming back. Grimaldi's is not like this at all. Our server acknowledged that we were waiting for a long time and even gave us some complimentary bread for the long wait. When it was time for our bill, she even thanked us for being patient and apologized that she was not able to check on us a lot due to them being understaffed. That professionalism and politeness is the reason why I am going to continue to come here, even if I have to wait a bit. The food and kind service are worth the wait! read more

The pizza flavors taste great, and I really like the Ivy. I usually enjoy thin crust, but this crust is far too thin. New York slice isn't accurate, a true NY slice has substance, it's thin, but not paper-thin. These slices are cut wide, but the crust lacks the structure. I would recommend not rolling the crust so paper thin. At this thickness, it's not worth $30. It could justify the price if the crust had more body. It doesn't need to be super thick, just more balanced and sturdy enough to support the slice and toppings. This 16 inch should not have costed me more than $20-$22. If corrections are made then yes the pizza would be worth $30. i've tried the pizza both in Texas and in Wisconsin. It's pretty consistent in both places. The great flavor is consistent as well. read more

Best brick oven pizza in Brookfield. The don is the best, drinks are always good! Service is always good, in a clean environment.

Easily accessible in the shopping center with plenty of parking. We ate around 8 and were able to get right in on the patio. The patio is dog friendly and they kindly provided water for the dogs. The atmosphere was quite and server was very friendly and accommodating. We started with the Bruschetta. Tomato and Basil and a Marinated artichoke. They allowed us to swap one which seemed east enough. The tomato basil was good. I think we preferred the artichoke more. Pizza we ordered the Don half without pepperoni. It was a thinner crust than we expected but it was quite tasty. Toppings were good as well. If you're expecting thick crust or heaps of toppings this isn't for you. We left very comfortable with our choice and portions. Would definitely recommend! read more

Grimaldi's Pizzeria - The Don pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brookfield, Wisconsin

See all

Got a Brooklyn bridge pizza to go. Pizza was okay except there was very little sausage on it. My biggest complaint was a staff member who appeared to be a food expediter was wearing jeans that exposed the upper part of his buttocks. The style is called "sagging", I don't want my food touched by a person with their underwear showing. I witnessed him touch his shirt and underwear more than once with his hands while putting pizzas into boxes. This is gross and completely unacceptabLe, I'll get pizza somewhere else. read more

I really loved the pizza! I'm fiancée and I had a lovely dinner after shopping for our wedding registry. The service was great and I have nothing but good things to say about the GM, Nate. He really made us feel like the night was about us. All in all, I can't recommend this place enough! 10/10 read more

Pizza very thin, hardly any cheese, un-cooked tomato sauce with no spices. Where there was cheese it had no sauce under it. Poor quality pizza. We are NOT going back. read more

Server young. Not great variety of tap beer. I ordered a Berry Sangria which was delicious and just right for a summer night. We shared a small garden ranch salad (it was huge!!) Ranch dressing was so good-they must make their own. My husband had a 12" pepperoni which he devoured! I had a gluten free prosciutto and arugula "white" pizza. Toppings were great, crust was better than a lot of other gluten free pizza crusts I've bad. Server was knowledgeable about gluten and cross contamination. Pizza was slow to come out and my hubby's came out about 5 minutes before mine. Basic pizzeria decor and vibe. read more

Service was fantastic despite being very busy on a Saturday night. The overall atmosphere is charming yet relaxing making for a great dining experience. Food is always cooked to perfection and satisfying to the pizza craving we all get :). read more

Whenever we are near Brookfield, we stop here for really good NY style pizza. Being from New Jersey, this is our kind of pizza! The decor is vintage NYC....love it. Our server was super friendly and helpful. The pizzas just taste so good. They are coal fired, so you can see and taste the char on the crust. Be careful what you order; the crust may be soggy in the middle (case in point, their margarita pizza is very wet in the middle, but the tomato topping is oh so good!) The outer crust is crunchy, chewy. The sauce has just the right seasoning. The cheese is good quality as well. The sausage topping is a crumble and not too hot. When ordering pizzas, get the 18". With the thin crust, it is not hard at all for 2 people to finish off one pizza. One of our pizzas had a small black rock of coal on it. (Being baked in a coal oven, sometimes they will 'pop' onto the pizzas.) They usually get removed before sending it out. Kudos of the management; they understood and offered to adjust the bill. Even with this incident, it's hard to stop eating their pizza. It's just that good!! read more

Grimaldi's Pizzeria - 18" pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brookfield, Wisconsin

See all

Don't expect to dine and dash, we have been waiting an hour for our pizza now. We have tried multiple times to get in here only to be told it would be and hour or longer for a table. While I always thought the problem was Millennials sitting to long after eating, it turned out that the put online and to-go orders ahead of the dinning room. While our salads we good, the pizza came out burnt and over cooked, suggestion take the pizza out sooner and customers wouldn't wait as long. I will stick with Glass Nickel for carry-out, and my own brick oven when I want a really good pizza. read more

I am telling you that if your in the Brookfield area and you want a delicious pizza eat here! Your not going to get a Chicago deep dish here but I will argue all day long that a coal fired pizza has the best flavor. The place was busy on a Saturday and we sat at one of the only outside tables available. Beer and Margarita delivered and then ordered the tomato bruschetta which was good. They don't put the balsamic on it as many places do as that would probably make it soggy by the time you eat it so they bring the bottle and you put it on yourself. I was ok with the lightly toasted bread but if you want it crustier you should probably tell them when you order it. With that course completed the pizza came and it was soooo good. I don't put a lot on my pizza but a few pepperoni and some onions added an explosion of flavors in every bite. The sauce and the crust were perfectly cooked and you were able to taste that coal fired taste through each slice. Now hold on, because they have an app and if you sign up you get a free pizza on your birthday!! Not only that but they credited us the cost of the appetizer just for signing up. Great atmosphere, great service, and a great pizza, will bring me back here. Thanks! read more

See all

This one is hard for me to rate. I've been here a few times but this reflects my most recent experience. I arrived on a Saturday afternoon (inbetween 1 & 2) which the hours listed are Saturday 11:00 am - 10:00 pm. We were told we couldn't be seated due to online/to-go orders and an oven was being cleaned (?). While it was busy, there were a few spots I could see available to see seated at. I am not sure how that is acceptable. Perhaps signage? But another couple got seated after us. I didn't see that anyone else was turned away. Not sure if this is solely a management problem but it honestly needs to be looked at and considered. I don't need a boilerplate response from some PR person here on yelp. I just need you to figure out if you are serving patrons or not. Or am I not the right type of patron? That's what it felt like. read more

Food was amazing reminds me of being in New York. Love the cleanliness and hot food. Pizza 100% NY style.

Such an amazing atmosphere. The pizza was absolutely delicious, very much a New York style pizza. Also another spot where I will be going back to when I come back to town. read more

Grimaldi's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brookfield, Wisconsin

See all

We have a gluten allergy (non-celiac) in our family, so we had to get the gluten friendy option. Since we didn't get the normal pizza, you can disregard this review as a part of the general concensus. As far as GF pizzas go, it wasn't bad. The crust was thin and crisp on the edge crust, but a little on the soft and gooey side for the base. MOD pizza has a better GF crust overall. The ingredients felt a little skimpy (I'm sorry, we were hungry so I didn't snap a photo), especially for the prices we paid ($3 pepperoni, $3 spinach, $2 mushrooms). Overall, we felt we overpaid for the amount of pizza and ingredients we got. I did order for pickup and it was ready at the designated time, so they were good in thier estimation. I would come here again, but not to try the GF option. I'd go straight to the standard pizza. read more

This Grimaldi's location has been on my radar for so long! My mom and Nana brought me here for lunch after some much needed retail therapy and it was so good! We started with the ceaser salad which was amazing! I hate thick, creamy ceaser dressing ( I don't know why? Personal preference), but this one was so light, lemony and garlicky- to die for! The croutons we're homemade and had the perfect crunch. Would definitely get this again! On to the pizza- WOW! The thin crust was so buttery but had the perfect char on the crust that complimented the meaty mozzarella and crispy sausage. So yummy! I would recommend this pizza to anyone indecisive on pizza toppings! The basil added the perfect flavor too. Just wow. Our service was great and the inside was so cute! I love the wine bottle lights scatted around and the classic red and white checkered table clothes just makes me smile:) I would definitely recommend checking it out and will be back again! read more

See all

it has been an hour since I ordered my food and it has still not arrived. Unacceptable. It is frigid in this building.

We love Grimaldi's and often come here for a birthday dinner. The pizza is our favorite, but the salads are so good too!

The two of us have been here many times and visit typically every couple months. We come here for the brick oven pizza. Simple right?? Apparently not for the crew that worked this night. On a very slow Monday night June 17, 2024, we ordered a small 12" pizza at 6:35. At 7:35, 1 hour later they brought out a pizza we didn't order..! We are still waiting..... UPDATE: they brought our pizza out an hour and 15 later! Yay..! Again wrong pizza. Manager came out to apologize and didn't charge us for the pizza. Thank you, because of that I will give them a 3 star now. read more

It took over 2 hours for our pizza and it was less than acceptable. Manager no where to be found to explain what the delay was.

Stopped in for a couple of large pizzas with friends last night after a movie at Silver Spot. Ordered 2 large pizzas and wanted to order garlic/cheese bread but they don't offer any. Pretty hard to believe that a restaurant like this doesn't offer garlic bread!! Pizzas came out in a timely fashion and tasted good, but, both seemed very sparse on the toppings! For what they cost it really was disappointing. There are too many good pizza places in the area that give you a pizza full of your topping choices to come back to Grimaldi's. It really is a shame because it's a nice atmosphere and good location. read more

Service is always top notch. Pleasant staff to greet you at the door. Pleasant staff serving you. Food is never a disappointment. Always served hot. No complaints! read more

Seems like the oven is down at all hours. 3rd try and still no pizza. We arrived and was told would be an hour wait so we left our names. We got the text and got seated. Our waitress promptly told us would be an hour and a half to get pizza as the (shocker) oven was down. 7 pm ? Prime dinner time? Should have Told us before we wasted an hour waiting. We will never go back. 3 strikes. 1pm on a Saturday 630 pm on a Wednesday 700 pm on a Sunday Fool me once. Shame on you. Fool me again and again shame on me. read more

Very very good pizza! Love most brick oven pizzas and this place did not disappoint. Salad was excellent as was the serve staff. Located in very busy outside mall so parking can be a problem at peak dining hours Recommend read more

Garden pesto pizza and white pizza were delicious. Thin and cheesy ! Also the bruschetta was amazing. I can't comment on ambiance or service dice it was a pickup order. But definitely worth the higher price. read more

Fire! Best NY pizza in the Midwest. Paper think crust but still crispy enough to hold the toppings. Sauce is just sweat enough to balance the sausage, mushrooms and onions. This is a must have if you enjoy NY style pizza. Be ready to wait an hour for your order, grab a glass one wine or two. read more

We stopped by at Grimaldis prior to a comedy show. The place wasn't too busy on a Thursday night and the service was terrific. It did take some time for the pizzas so I would recommend ordering asap. As for the food, it was great. We got the bruschetta trio and Quattro formaggi pizza. Both were terrific. Highly recommend the spinach artichoke bruschetta. read more

Grimaldi's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brookfield, Wisconsin

See all