Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Grill Shack

    4.5 (55 reviews)
    Closed • 11:00 am - 12:00 AM (Next day)

    Order Grill Shack Takeout or Delivery

    Grill Shack Photos

    Business Info

    GRILL SHACK ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Grill Shack

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Laura P.

    This is the best hummus chicken schwarma I have ever eaten in my life. Omg omg. There's a big menu. Please choose the middle eastern. Thought I was getting a sandwich but this warm and comforting bowl of explosive flavor arrived. There was the experience of smooth creamy garbanzo beans, accompanied by bright lemon, pungent garlic, a bit of hotness from chilis perhaps? The chicken was chopped and bundled on top. Olive oil unctuous dressed the surface. Now - the pita bread - wait for it - 2 pieces - sliced in half- warm, fresh, fluffy and you just tear it open and dig into all that amazing hummus and chicken. There is nothing like this in Milwaukee you simply must try this. GOAT. Clean, spare dining area. Love the rosemary plants on the tables and middle eastern music playing softly. Do not try to eat and drive!!!!!!! Thank you Grill Shack for delighting me today!!!!!

    Menu
    Michael B.

    I was looking for something quicker during lunch on a work day and saw this place on Yelp. The Grill Shack is a smaller place in a strip mall. I believe it replaced Factory Ice Cream. I actually walked past Grill Shack at first. The menu is a unique combination of middle eastern and American and includes fries and pizza. The combos are $2 more for fries and a 12oz soda can. The sandwiches are around $8-$10. I can only speak for the one item I had, the Cajun chicken, but it was better than maybe grilled chickens for $16 I've had at a restaurant. The decor and set up is somewhat odd. There's a thin row of tables that led to the back. This is great for work lunch. Not great for groups or a date or impressing the in laws.

    Steven T.

    This has been a book mark for a while and since it has so little reviews or pictures I thought that a Steve stop by was in order so I went over for lunch. The place is in a strip mall with plenty of parking. The menu is interesting because it has pizzas, sandwiches and Middle Eastern food so I went with the Philly cheesesteak sandwich. My sandwich came fast because I was the only person in the place. My first thought was that it didn't look right with the reddish hue to it for a Philly cheesesteak. My second thought after my first bite was that the bread was all wrong because it had a very chewy crust and soft inside that required extra bite effort which squeezed most of the meat right out of the sandwich, the melted cheese on the bottom only helped everything sliding out. The sandwich had a weird flavor like giardinera and it was very oily like maybe it's cooked in giardinera oil and it had melted American cheese in it, give us a cheese choice because it didn't work very well in the sandwich. This was the weirdest Philly cheesesteak sandwich that I have had and it didn't satisfy my crave for a Philly cheesesteak at all and I would never order it again and get something different.

    Tom T.

    Awesome food! Placed an order to go! Hummus is the best around, simply great! polish sausage was excellent along with a small Greek salad! Customer service by the owner was superb-down to earth and nicest person in the industry!

    Entry and menu
    Greer J.

    Food was hot. Best tabouleh I have had in a while. Chicken shawarma was moist and well seasoned. We drove all the way over from Brookfield. Worth the drive for good Mediterranean.

    Baba Ganoush

    See all

    Photo of Nik K.
    0
    31
    10

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Shaemia N.
    205
    41
    16

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Saba M.
    196
    5
    2

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    It was really good food. I recommend this place highly. The burger was delicious and the pizza was awesome.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Good food, nice service, a little slow, could use a couple more people working but overall AMAZING place

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Great shawarma and fries! Hard to find shawarma sandwiches that aren't dry but these were so good!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of M M.
    188
    3
    0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Grill Shack

    You might also consider

    Oak Creek Diner - BREAKFAST

    Oak Creek Diner

    4.1(238 reviews)
    1.1 mi
    •$

    After my last breakfast experience of $22+ for a chili cheese omelette for one person from a dive…read morerestaurant I came here for breakfast for two people which was $30 with one coffee at a nicer diner. This is a solid breakfast spot and every table was in service towards the end of our meals. We had a chili cheese omelette and the country fried steak breakfast. I had the country fried steak this time but I did have the chili cheese omelette on my last visit and I didn't snap any pictures because a customer had a medical emergency and an ambulance and fire truck came to the restaurant but I remember liking it. The decor is nothing fancy but it's not a dive with over priced omelets like my breakfast experience, look at my last review. The country fried steak was noticeably bigger than most places around town except for NA cafe which is a real country steak and I just expected a frozen restaurant supply quality. It was golden brown with that commercial sausage gravy which is the norm for 99% of breakfast restaurants around town so I'm not going to knock them on that because I'm a country fried steak guy all my life. The sunny side up eggs were cooked perfectly. The extra crispy hash browns were cooked perfectly and the sourdough toast was better than the average restaurant where you couldn't tell if it was white or sourdough with that chew. Overall it's a solid breakfast spot with all my visits and at $13 it's $9 cheaper than my last breakfast experience at a dive restaurant and hits the spot.

    What a great find!…read more We're in town from Illinois for a baseball tournament and stopped by Oak Creek Diner for breakfast. From the moment we walked in, we knew we'd found a local favorite. The counter service was a great bonus and gave the place that classic diner feel. Everything we ordered was fantastic. The corned beef hash was some of the best we've had, the Western omelette was loaded with fresh ingredients, and the meat lovers skillet was hearty, packed with bacon, sausage, ham, and plenty of flavor. Every plate came out hot, the portions were generous, and everything was cooked just right. Friendly service, great food, and a classic diner atmosphere. If you're in the Oak Creek area, whether you're a local or just passing through like we were, this place is absolutely worth the stop. We'll definitely be back the next time we're in town!

    Photos
    Oak Creek Diner - Regulars at the bar

    Regulars at the bar

    Oak Creek Diner - 1/2 BISCUITS AND GRAVY & EGGS

    1/2 BISCUITS AND GRAVY & EGGS

    Oak Creek Diner - HAM, BISCUITS & GRAVY & EGGS

    See all

    HAM, BISCUITS & GRAVY & EGGS

    Odd Duck - Chili Crisp Devilled Eggs

    Odd Duck

    4.5(1.1k reviews)
    7.3 mi•Walker's Point
    •$$

    Fucking love this place…read more If there is a highly rated small plates place in a location we are visiting, you can count on us to find it. We walked literally thirty minutes to this place from our hotel. It was a lovely walk in early August. We had a 5:45pm reservation on a Thursday (we are old now) and we were seated immediately. Service was excellent. Ok so they have a fantastic cocktail menu. I appreciate any cocktail menu that is more complex than vodka and cranberry juice but this takes it to another level of creativity. I also like how they name them with numbers. It's so much easier to say "I'll have a 42" rather than "I will have a duperbeamerscicle". I started with an "88" with pisco, rose-poached strawberry, amontillado sherry, verjus, rose port, and pink peppercorn. Served in a highball glass and garnished with berries. Very refreshing. GF started with the "91" mezcal, passion fruit, poblano, pineapple, amaro, lime. Gorgeous and chic. Very strong, smoky flavor. When in Rome, so the cheese plate did not feel like an option. Four fantastic cheeses were served with very tasty candied nuts, some jam business, grapes, and some of the best bread I have had on a cheese plate. Thick, soft, and fluffy. Paired absolutely perfectly with cheese. Only complaint is that I wish there was more of it. I haven't had deviled eggs in a minute so I went wild and also had the chili crisp deviled eggs which were SPECTACULAR. I also got the Egyptian fried cauliflower which is served on a smear of harissa and lemon tahini. Very flavorful. Star of the show tbh was the tagliatelle with squash, tomato, these fried cheese crisps. The noodles were al dente and SO GOOD in such a wonderful sauce. GF also got the steak, she says "very good seasoning". I helped her out with the kimchi pancake. Wonderful. Such a great sauce. For our second round of dranks we both went with the "77" makrut lime vodka, tamarind, bird's eye chili, cilantro, lime, lemongrass. Very tamarind forward. Very unique. I can see why it's our server's favorite drink on the menu. The desserts looked really good (something with sticky rice I think it was a cocktail and a bread budding that looked fantastic) but we just weren't feeling it.

    We had such a fantastic dinner at Odd Duck-Thank you Yelp for being our guide and never letting us…read moredown. We grabbed seats at the bar, and the service was spectacular. Our bartender was incredibly friendly, charismatic, and genuinely passionate about the menu. He took the time to explain dishes, offered thoughtful recommendations, and made the entire experience even more enjoyable. Every dish we ordered was outstanding. The deviled eggs were easily our favorite and are an absolute must-order. We also loved the flatbread with fiddleheads, which featured a delicious curry-inspired flavor that reminded us of an Indian dish. My husband couldn't stop talking about the bread pudding and said it was one of the best desserts he's had. Everything we tried was beautifully prepared and full of flavor. If we lived in Milwaukee, Odd Duck would absolutely become one of our regular spots. We can't wait to come back the next time we're in town.

    Photos
    Odd Duck
    Odd Duck - Charred Broccolini $17

    Charred Broccolini $17

    Odd Duck - Chili crisp deviled eggs $6

    See all

    Chili crisp deviled eggs $6

    Story Hill BKC - Odekirk Venison Steak

    Story Hill BKC

    4.6(838 reviews)
    8.3 mi•Story Hill
    •$$

    Came by for dinner the other night and it was an excellent world class experience. Story Hill BKC…read moreis located in the suburbs in the greater Milwaukee area. Parking was plentiful on the street. Venue seems to be a wine bar with an open kitchen. Opted for a table with a view of the open kitchen. Staff throughout the evening was excellent. Started off with the seared Maitake Mushroom and it was tasty. It was served over a bed of aioli and topped with some cilantro. The venison was a special and requested medium rare. It came out towards a medium. Venison tends to be extremely lean. This dish was served perfectly with beets and squash. Ended the meal with a dark chocolate pie which was also excellent. Presentation was fantastic and the pie was super fresh. Portions were generous and perfect for sharing! $79/head after tax, gratuity and 3% credit card surcharge

    I really love Story Hill, the only reason I knock it down a star is that despite being good food -…read moreI still feel like it's a bit over priced. It's a great environment with a lot of good drink options. I always opt for the Parker rolls which are tasty but again expensive for the amount you get, I typically order the trout (which until coming here I didn't realize was essentially the same as salmon). It's very good and the potato pancake is a nice touch. Over my visits I've also enjoyed trying the short rib gnocchi, butter chicken, and brussels. They also have a small party room which I have attended an event in before which is always a nice touch. It's secluded and of course much quieter than their main dining area which can get pretty loud!

    Photos
    Story Hill BKC - Liquor store area with seating

    Liquor store area with seating

    Story Hill BKC - Good Morning Viet Nam!! Great special today

    Good Morning Viet Nam!! Great special today

    Story Hill BKC - Indoor space

    See all

    Indoor space

    Mother’s - Fried Tofu (gluten friendly!)

    Mother’s

    4.1(27 reviews)
    6.0 mi•Bay View

    First time here. It's a historic building on the south end of Bay View. A big old white building…read more(previously called the White House) with a small parking lot on the south side. We had reservations at 6:00 on a Saturday night. (It was cold, a little drizzly, and windy out.) The front entrance has several steep steps, and when you walk through, you are literally at the host station. They were going to seat us right behind the host station, but we knew it was going to be a problem as people went in and out. We asked to be seated a little farther from the door, and after a bit of discussion (it sounded like this was going to be a little issue), they were able to find a table for two in the parlor. So glad! Got settled in right away with menus and waters. Our server did a good job of getting us up to speed on the menu, the service, and the cocktails. They did a very good job throughout the evening (thanks, Roberto). We settled on the Window Seat (Beef Tallow and Rosemary Washed Vodka, crazy but true) and the Night Clubbing (with espresso-infused Campari). Both were very good choices. We decided that we wanted to start with three dishes and then regroup if we needed more. These included the Bok Choy Salad, Cumin and Cinnamon Braised Pork Shoulder, and Venison Tartare (Dijon Ice Cream?). The Bok Choy Salad was a real surprise, with the entire collection being so bright and flavorful. The dates had a meaty quality. The dressing with Nuoc Cham was savory with just a bit of heat. We both decided that we could have made an entire meal of that. The Pork Shoulder came next and was a good portion, with the meat tender and flavorful. The Quinoa Polenta was interesting, but I can't say that it was something I would seek out. I have had Beef Tartare before, but this was a first for Venison Tartare, so of course I just had to order it. What struck me first was that the entire thing (not just the Dijon Ice Cream) was very cold, almost frozen. I tried a couple of bites, and it was so cold that unless you let it sit in your mouth to thaw out, it was somewhat tasteless. I spread it around the plate to thaw out, and it was a big improvement. It's a good-sized portion, and even after loading up on the three pieces of bread, there was still plenty left (maybe a couple more pieces of bread?). There were a couple of desserts that we would have loved to try, but we were full and had a performance to attend. So we will have to wait until next time. Really enjoyed our first dinner. Loved the inventiveness of the menu. The staff all seem to really care about the business and the diners. With the placement of the front door and the draftiness of the dining room, we will likely book our next dinner when the weather turns warmer.

    What a gem of a place located in a street corner in a historic house in Bayviee. This place had a…read morecozy but spacious feel. They were festive with Halloween decorations and had a gothic feel. I tried the lamb jerk dumplings and tofu. Highly recommend. They both had unique flavors especially the lamb. The tofu had a nice crispy texture to it with the soy based sauce glazed over it with scallions. I also tried a mocktail version of La Pucelle, it wasn't explicitly listed in the mocktails section so you can order a mocktail version of some the alcoholic cocktails. For dessert I tried the Panna Cotta, it was my first time ever trying it and tho go get it was really good. It had a pomegranate sorbet scoop on top sprinkled with frankincense laid on a bed of shaved ice with the creamy base at the bottom of the bowl. It was refreshing! The waiter was very helpful, he explained how they served food and drinks and when I asked about I n residents for the dessert he was able to describe them in detail.

    Photos
    Mother’s - Beetroot Chocolate Cake (gluten friendly!)

    Beetroot Chocolate Cake (gluten friendly!)

    Mother’s - Shishito Peppers (gluten-friendly!)

    Shishito Peppers (gluten-friendly!)

    Mother’s - Pork Shoulder (gluten friendly!)

    See all

    Pork Shoulder (gluten friendly!)

    Grill Shack - newamerican - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...