Cancel

Open app

Search

Great American Cookies

4.0 (1 review)
Closed • 11:00 am - 8:00 pm

GREAT AMERICAN COOKIES · YELP ASSISTANT

Ask Yelp Assistant

Great American Cookies Photos

You might also consider

More like Great American Cookies

Recommended Reviews - Great American Cookies

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Great American Cookies

Verify this business for free

People searched for Bakeries 1,111 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop - Breakfast sandwich with sausage.

Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop

4.5(519 reviews)
5.0 mi
•$

I heard wonderful things about Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop and was not disappointed! I did takeout…read moreas I was tired of the conference food and picked up lunch and snacks for the plane ride back home. Service was friendly and swift. Almost too swift as I didn't have time to fully peruse the plentiful options and decide what i wanted to order to go. They also offered generous samples of their daily soups, so I got to taste both delicious soups! - Ham, brie, apricot, apple sandwich on french baguette - 5/5, I was expecting the baguette to be hard to bite down on but it was the perfect mix of crunchy outside, soft inside and not difficult at all to eat! What was difficult was the portion size as I could have easily shared it with someone else - pumpkin/carrot/ginger soup - 5/5, truly scrumptious! - italian sausage white bean kale soup - 4/5, delicious and just a tad too salty - ham cheddar chive scone - 3/5, I was expecting to really like this but it was a bit too hard and had large chunks of ham in it which was generous but not what I was expecting - chocolate croissant - 4/5, solid offering but not the best I've ever had - pecan maple shortbread cookies - 4/5 I wish I had more days in Anchorage and more time (they're open 7am - 4pm and October on only open Wednesday through Sunday) and look forward to returning when I hopefully return to Anchorage! I'd come every day to try everything!

I just love, friendly and welcoming service and interaction right off the bat. The staff was…read morehelpful and friendly and courteous. Absolutely love the vibe in here, and the smattering of awesome pastries, and desserts all over-the-counter. I may only be in town for a week, but I'll probably stop by this place at least a couple more times. They seem to have a really great staff too, I could see everyone just busy and the utmost care and attention to detail going on with every pastry. Clean and comfortable atmosphere, with an amazing staff and downright awesome pastries, and such. Another homerun on my visit to Anchorage, has my highest recommendation.

Photos
Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop - Indoor seating

Indoor seating

Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop - Croissant

Croissant

Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop - Baked goods

See all

Baked goods

The Midnight Sun Cakery - An intimate wedding at Jitter's in Eagle River

The Midnight Sun Cakery

4.4(25 reviews)
4.3 mi
•$$$

My husband and I flew into Anchorage for his birthday. I had a "last minute layer cake" prepared…read moreso I could pick it up when we made to town. The "last minute" cake is one of the cakes that can be ordered much closer to the date in question than a full custom cake. I'm so glad I did this! The cake looked amazing and tasted great. It was a chocolate-on-chocolate concoction called "The Dark Side" and I would highly recommend it. We loved the cake so much we took most of it as a carry-on when we flew home (there was only two of us, and its a good sized cake - FYI, TSA will let you carry almost an entire chocolate cake onto an airplane). The customer service was great - everything was arranged via email (which worked out well for me) and the cake was exactly what I was looking for and was ready when I asked. The owner followed up with me a few days before to make sure our pick-up arrangements were still okay. If I'm ever in the need for a cake in Anchorage again I would absolutely contact this bakery.

I'm giving her a one because I can't give her a zero. I have a wedding in March in which I sent an…read moreinquiry about services mid September. Getting ahold of her was very hard and I had to send multiple reminder emails. She was nice in the replies sent but communication was definitely off. Anyways we set up a tasting she took my money and today.... 90 days after this whole debacle she decided that my cake would not be a big enough order for her and cancelled the tasting. Very unprofessional as in earlier emails she said she specialized in what I wanted and she could do it. Very unprofessional and would have loved for the awful interaction to take way less than 90 days to get there. Save yourself some trouble and look elsewhere.

Photos
The Midnight Sun Cakery
The Midnight Sun Cakery
The Midnight Sun Cakery

See all

Alaska Cake Studio

Alaska Cake Studio

3.5(138 reviews)
5.0 mi
•$$

Delicious desserts!! We were in the 5th Ave Mall and stopped by for some sweet treats. The…read morechocolate pecan bar was DELICIOUS! I can't wait to go back for another one. The chocolate chip cookie sandwich was also very yummy. It had chocolate buttercream in between 2 big cookies. Very tasty! We will be back!

Ordered a wedding cake for a casual elopement…read more Cake execution: pretty awful. To be honest, the cake wasn't all that pretty to begin with but it got worse as the day went on and it thawed out more. Picked up my cake around 4pm and by 7pm it was a tilted Mad Hatter cake. I assure you, it was not damaged during transport. When we cut into the cake to serve slices, an entire chunk of cake was missing from the bottom tier and "spackled in" with frosting. This caused the cake to collapse and the top tier slid off to one side. There was also no dowel support between to the top and bottom tiers. Just a cardboard round which slid on top of the buttercream. That probably would have been ok if it weren't for the missing chunk of cake. People asked me if I made the cake myself. Hahaha. It was pretty embarrassing. But luckily this was for a very casual elopement, not a big wedding, otherwise I would have been pretty pissed. My parents did pay a decent amount of money for this, roughly $275. I've seen far better from Walmart's bakery. The shop got stars for the following... Cake flavor: very good! I ordered the champagne cake with strawberry filling for the bottom tier and chocolate cake with chocolate fudge filling for the top tier. All covered in white chocolate buttercream frosting. The cake and fillings were delicious. The frosting was a little gritty, I assume from using granulated sugar, but still tasty. A little too sweet for my liking but it was still good. The cake layers were nice and thick. Customer service: Great! Response time from the shop was excellent. They promptly responded to my emails on the quote and design request. I called the shop when it was about time to pick up my cake and didn't reach anyone at first, but they called me right back. I guess I could have called the shop to let them know the issues with the cake but I have a feeling once the cake leaves their shop in good condition, they would put the blame on the customer. I just won't use them again, for cakes anyways. Anyways, thanks for reading and check out my Mad Hatter cake.

Photos
Alaska Cake Studio - Bar style seating from inside looking out

Bar style seating from inside looking out

Alaska Cake Studio
Alaska Cake Studio

See all

Wild Scoops - Sunshine Club and Rhubarb Crumble Baked Alaska Cone

Wild Scoops

4.8(226 reviews)
3.3 mi
•$$

Absolutely amazing. As someone from Los Angeles, I have…read moreaccess to many great food spots and creameries. Despite that, this place makes absolutely FANTASTIC ice cream. You can tell everything they do is to perfect their craft. -the flavors are rich, deep, and uniquely Alaskan -the waffle cones are baked with spices giving it a great flavor -the store supports local Alskan products If you're ever visiting Anchorage, this place is a MUST. I am fore sure 1000% coming back!

Oh my goshhhh this was probably some of the best ice cream I've ever had and I've had a LOT of ice…read morecream Was looking up ice cream recs and Wild Scoops was unanimously suggested by everyone online. Went on a Monday in June around 9:00pm and there was line going out the door. We ended up waiting about 20 minutes. I sampled a few of the flavors and decided to order a double scoop of the Rhubarb Crumble and Sunshine Club in a Baked Alaska cone (asked for the whole thing to be put in a bowl) Both flavors were creamy and delicious! I usually don't get fruity flavors, but these were my favorites out of everything I sampled. The ice cream had great amount of mix ins and the Baked Alaska cone was tasty. I really liked the marshmallow fluff on top - glad I tried it! The portions were very generous and I was super full afterwards. Our Alaska trip was over a month ago and I am still thinking about Wild Scoops. I would 100% return - highly recommend!!

Photos
Wild Scoops - Sunshine Club and Rhubarb Crumble in a Baked Alaska cone

Sunshine Club and Rhubarb Crumble in a Baked Alaska cone

Wild Scoops - Matchaberry swirl, one scoop

Matchaberry swirl, one scoop

Wild Scoops - Roasted Garlic Ice Cream and Chocolate!

See all

Roasted Garlic Ice Cream and Chocolate!

Flying Dutchman European Pastry Shop

Flying Dutchman European Pastry Shop

4.2(96 reviews)
0.9 mi
•$$

Our favorite bakery in Anchorage hands down. The service is great. It's a quant little store that…read more3-4 people can wait to be served, or wait at the door. The cookies are some of our favorites as well as the bran muffins. We try to go at least once a month.

Stopped by because my mother now has me completely addicted--and I can see why…read more I picked up a variety of their tarts along with a chocolate cake filled with raspberry, and everything was absolutely delicious. Each tart had its own unique flavor, perfectly balanced and not too sweet, which made it way too easy to keep reaching for another. The chocolate raspberry cake was a standout--rich, moist, and layered with just the right amount of tartness from the raspberry filling. What really surprised me was how satisfying everything tasted without feeling heavy or overly sweetened--and even better, it didn't spike my blood sugar the way most desserts do. You can tell there's intention behind the ingredients and how everything is made. They also have plenty of other baked goods like cookies, brownies, and more, so there's definitely something for everyone. The staff are friendly, and the bakery itself is so cute--such a welcoming little spot that makes the experience even better. If you're looking for treats that feel a little more thoughtful but still indulgent, this spot is definitely worth checking out.

Photos
Flying Dutchman European Pastry Shop - Black and white coconut cookie. Rhubarb/apple pastry.

Black and white coconut cookie. Rhubarb/apple pastry.

Flying Dutchman European Pastry Shop
Flying Dutchman European Pastry Shop

See all

Aurora Chocolate - Aurora Chocolate hand-painted Salted Butter Caramel

Aurora Chocolate

4.9(30 reviews)
5.1 mi
•$$

My husband and I came to Alaska for our honeymoon, and this was one of our favorite spots. To be…read morehonest, we didn't expect much at first because I'm not a fan of snobby chocolates (I like basic flavors). But wow, we were in for a surprise! We walked in the shop, and there was a gentleman at the counter who greeted us and explained the chocolates to us. It turns out he is the husband of the master chocolatier who makes the chocolates! Ingrid, his wife, runs the original shop at another location where she makes the chocolates, while the husband manages the hotel location. It was a pleasant surprise to find out the gentleman is a Korean, just like me and my husband. He shared with extensive detail how each of the chocolates are made and the painstaking (and almost impractical) process that his wife goes through to craft each piece of chocolate. And yes, they are gorgeous! But even more than just the appearance of the chocolates, I was blown away by the taste. Some flavor combinations sounded a little crazy, but they actually tasted good and suited even my basic chocolate palate. If you're in Alaska, this place is worth a visit because there truly is no other place like it. It is a bit pricey, but it is well worth the money in my opinion.

After looking for a dessert spot, I ran into this one in the hotel and I was greeted by the Most…read morehelpful and genuinely nice man. Come to find out he is the husband, and the wife is the one who makes all the chocolate. I got one from every case, they did not disappoint. It was delicious.

Photos
Aurora Chocolate - Dark chocolate cherry cordial!!! It was Marvelous!!! Fantastically Delicious!

Dark chocolate cherry cordial!!! It was Marvelous!!! Fantastically Delicious!

Aurora Chocolate - Hand painted white chocolate

Hand painted white chocolate

Aurora Chocolate - Beautiful Tasty Hand painted dark chocolate

See all

Beautiful Tasty Hand painted dark chocolate

Great American Cookies - bakeries - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...