I guess somehow we've never been to this one. Odd location, little lot alongside and big one in back, so be alert at busy periods. Inside, not as big as I expected. Some tables, plus a little wall to sit on outside. Friendly patient service. The kids tried several things. I tasted the Skyline, which is really not chili flavored. Pretty much cinnamon ice cream with what seems like pie crust chunks (actually crackers.) Not bad, not weird, not spicy. A bit of a letdown for me; I expected a challenge. Ended up with seasonal lemon meringue pie, which was excellent. Prices aren't bad. I'm sure we will be back. read more

I cannot believe I have never reviewed this Graeter's location which is like an Ohio staple. My old dentist used to be conveniently located across the street from here so great treat to get after teeth cleaning appointment. Just saying! Although tonight we came back to celebrate my brother's birthday and he loves a good treat. Can't go wrong with Graeters! You have so many flavors here from the classics to the seasonal favorite flavors. I always go with the classic blackberry raspberry chip as you can't go wrong with this flavor. You can almost pair this flavor with anything off the menu. Always a great time at Graeter's as it's not only an Ohio staple but family favorite. You can instantly bring a smile to someone's face just with a scoop of Graeter's ice cream. Just ask my daughter! read more

Greater's new collab with Skyline is amazing. It was so unique we had to ry it. Stopped in the Gahanna location and was happy to find they had Skyline ice cream in stock. The staff was very friendly and helpful. This is one of the most unique ice cream flavors I've ever had. It starts out with a delicious cinnamon flavor but then you get a hint of chili powder and other spices that are unmistakably Skyline chili. The oyster crackers are surprisingly still crunchy and add some salt to cut through the sweet. It is wonderfully sweet and spicy. We may need to get another pint before it's gone. Kudos to Skyline and Graeter's for being so boldly creative. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Graeter's Skyline Chili Spice ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

Out for a cruise today and decided to drop in at Graeter's in Gahanna. Ordered the 1870 Tower: It has Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip ice cream, chocolate bundt cake, hot fudge, fresh whipped cream, pecans and a cherry. Love that Black Raspberry ice cream with huge chunks of chocolate. The Bundt cake was nice and fresh with a great chocolate taste that blended well with the ice cream. Everything at Graeter's is of high quality especially the service of their employees, very welcoming and helpful. Don't hesitate to check them out. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - The 1870 Tower!! Yummmy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

Greatest ice cream of all their new flavor minty brownie is so good. The mint is refreshing and the brownie is rich and sweet. The service was good. The staff is very nice. The ambience is OK but most of all it was so fun and delicious. read more

First time here. Nice quaint shop with seating inside, and some people eating outside. When I walked in, I noticed that they sell chocolate candy also. No matter where I go, I always order butter pecan --my favorite. I wanted to try a second scoop of something different, so the young lady let me sample the brown butter bourbon pecan. It had a delicious flavor, and at first, that was going to be my second flavor, but I decided to change because the pecans were not as crisp as I like; so I decided to try the midnight snack which was totally delicious! Customer service was excellent, but make sure you watch what is rung up at the cash register...the young lady was charging me for waffle cone instead of sugar cone. I will definitely be back for a treat. read more

Graeter's is pretty well known. I've gone a few times. I like that their ice cream isn't too sweet or rich. At least not the flavors that I've had. I normally get a cone. But I've heard that their milkshakes are amazing. I decided to go with a recommendation today and got the cinnamon ice cream which is seasonal. It was pretty tasty. You can also sample any flavor that you want to make sure that you like it. The customer service isn't the greatest. No one is smiling or seems like they want to be at work. The person who served me was just waiting for me to indecisively choose my flavors so that they could go talk to their friends. If you go after any holiday, you can find their candy and none ice cream holiday items on clearance. read more

See all

This Graeter's location is my not-so-guilty pleasure after I stop at the Target up the street (everyone deserves a treat once in a while, right?). The service is always friendly and the drive-through is quick for how long the line usually is. Almost every visit, I get their Vienna coffee ice cream in either a bowl, cup, or milkshake. If you like coffee ice cream, it is the absolute best. I have yet to find any other brand to top it. Just typing about it makes me want to take a late-night trip to Graeter's even though it's 24 degrees outside! read more

I've slowly become more and more of a fan of Graeters. While I don't find their flavors to be all that unique, they are definitely well executed!! read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - 1870 tower - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

See all

I always receive good customer service from this location. There is plenty of seating and lots of ice cream flavors to choose from. Table or bar type seating. Small milkshake was just the right size. Prices are a little more than other ice cream shops/stores. read more

See all

Lives up to the hype!! Ice cream and the service were top-notch! Had the raspberry chip and coconut chip. Waffle cone was delicious too. Gahanna location has a great, family ambiance but I felt right at home by myself, too. read more

This is probably one of my favorite ice cream shop in town. I absolutely love the fact that they bring in some many new and unique flavors so often. I'm enjoying the summer specials so far and cannot wait to see more flavors. read more

I think this location is fine they are very friendly and there is lots of seating. It does feel a bit outdated inside. Bonus is they sell dry ice for parties. I'd give the location 4 stars but the Ice Cream only 3 because Ice in general Ice Cream is amazing. Graeter's was really hyped up to me by my Ohio friends prior to moving here a few years ago but I can't say it has met the hype for me. The variety of chocolate chip options seems to be there thing and if you're into blackberries that version of chocolate chip seems super unique. It's never really grown on me after a few attempts. I guess I'll stick to my grocery store moose tracks. Again nothing against the location as their service is solid. read more

When you've spent a lot of time in Cincinnati, you begin to rave about certain "local" foods. Like Skyline Chili, or Grippos Potato Chips. And of course Graeter's. I remember how excited I was when I found Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip at Fresh Market in Evansville. So it's great to be back living in Ohio and be able to go anytime. But this location has a little problem (hence the lack of 5 stars) - parking. Only three spaces in front of the store? Others reserved for the medical office next door which is open until 8pm. Am I missing something? It was 7:55 so I was a scoundrel and parked in the otherwise reserved space anyhow. Service here is great, it's Peach season and the peach ice cream is to die for (what's wrong with a two scoop cone with peach and black raspberry chocolate chip?). Too bad I can't just walk there... read more

Now THIS is Ice Cream! I scream for ice cream every time I hear the name - Graeter's! Wow-ee! I know, too much of a good thing isn't necessarily good for you. Well, in this case it is! I have tried so many flavors here that I can't keep track of them all. I prefer anything with chocolate in it, so if it has chocolate, I can guarantee you that it is good - very good. They make everything from scratch, including the huge chunks of chocolate included in so many of their wonderful flavors. When I'm feeling guilty, I turn to the Sorbet. It has a fraction of the calories that ice cream has, but has all the Graeter's flavor you need. I usually order the seasonal special like Pumpkin in the Fall or Mango in the Summer. Most of the Sorbets come in fruit flavors like Rasberry and Strawberry. Graeter's is truly a Columbus legend in every sense of the word. It is so legendary that even Oprah Winfrey has publicly confessed that it's her favorite ice cream in the whole world. Now if Oprah loves it - it has to be good, right? Hurry - don't wait any longer - no matter if it's raining, sleeting, snowing, day or night - get over to Graeter's before it closes! You will absolutely love it - unless you're one of the only people in the world who hates ice cream or if your taste buds don't work. Man - this is ice cream! Yum-Yum!!! read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

Haven't been since middle school but it's the same great taste. Was excited to bring my son for the first time. Gahanna location is easy access off Beecher road and not very busy after school during the week. Friendly and helpful staff. Very clean location read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Single scoop of buckeye blitz in sugar cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

My absolute favorite ice cream! Coconut chip is the best! It has a nice serving of coconut, where you can taste the coconut pieces and you'll get nice chunks of dark chocolate hidden in the ice cream. So yummy! This location is always friendly and never much of a wait. Occasionally they get a little busy, but they try and get to the customers quickly! My place to go in the summer or whenever!! Also, they sell dry ice if you ever need! read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

We came back to OH to visit family, and stopping at Graeter's is always toward the top of outlet list of places we have to go. Although we can now buy the ice cream at Kroger in TN, it's just not the same. read more

I am not giving this Graeter's location a 3-star review because of their ice cream. Everyone knows Graeter's ice cream is delcious(and if you don't, get your taste-buds checked). I am giving this particular location 3 stars for one reason alone. THE PARKING IS AWFUL!! This inside of the place is huge and so is the awesome patio, but you have to fight for a parking space. if you're within walking distance, then that's the way to go. Otherwise, be patient in the awkward lot. P.S-I feel a little over critical giving a place 3 stars for the parking lot, but if you can't get into the place, you can't enjoy the awesome ice cream! read more

What happened to the large delicious chocolate chips you use to be known for?! Super friendly staff! Could use some outdoor seating with umbrellas. read more

Some of the best ice cream around, and local to Ohio if you have guests visiting from out of state that are looking for something that they can't get elsewhere. They're known for their Raspberry Chocolate Chip, but take advantage of the tasting spoons and try out a few things before you settle! The milkshakes are never a bad choice, and if you ask for an extra shot of vanilla in yours you'll be glad you did! Crowded in the evenings and on Sunday afternoon, but worth the wait! read more

There was a long line all the way to the door but the wait was definitely worth it. The staff is always friendly and attentive and the ice cream is the best in the city. read more

Delicious ice-cream and toppings! Clean interior, very pleasant helpful staff. Highly recommend. read more

The ice cream is awesome. I am wondering if the service is an issue. I bought junior scoops and was charged 3.25$ each. I don't think the junior scoop is this price as I've gotten them before. Most recently last week. I am more frustrated by the employee insisting the price of the junior scoop had increased. This is not an issue but I felt like the person may have not been honest and just charged the wrong price and unwilling to correct their mistake. read more

This is one of my fav places for hand dipped ice cream. Since we moved outta state we almost always come here when in town. It's creamy and i love the huge chunks of chocolate v. little chocolate chips. They also have home made waffle cones, milk shakes, sundaes, sorbet, and smoothies. I do wish they had more flavors. I'm spoiled by a place in KS that rocks at least 25-30 flavor choices. Graeter's does have a few seasonal flavors, but were out of 3 of the 4 during the holiday weekend (one that was out was Pumpkin Pie; about 4 people in line ahead of me were pretty bummed). I do like that this location has plenty of indoor seating so you sit with friends instead of sitting in your car. read more

Have brought my kids here SEVERAL times as this is one of their favorite spots. The line here is almost always short. The service has always been good. My kids absolutely love the free samples almost as much as the ice cream. Their peanut butter shakes are fabulous and I've never had an ice cream from there that I didn't like. read more

It was an adventure to find a location for an ice cream I had the mint chocolate chip huge chunks of chocolate my husband had black cherry he gave me a taste Oh my it was so good the little one had chocolate hazelnut which was a featured flavor. So glad we fit one more stop in before we aren't near one again read more

See all

I agree the parking is bad if you want to park right in front. There is a large parking area to the side of the building. People that work there are very friendly very nice & will help you in anyway they can. When you walk into the place it smells like heaven, such a sweet smell. I just wish they weren't so expensive, watch out you'll become addicted before you know it... read more

Always a favorite. This location has great service & and all the flavors you love. I've grown up eating Graeter's Ice Cream and it never disappoints. My favorites are the black raspberry chip and the (seasonal) pumpkin! You can't go wrong with anything from Graeters! This location also has an outside patio that is great for dogs & offers frozen treats, 2 for $1! read more

Waffle cone with mint chocolate chip ice cream and much chocolate chip ice cream in a waffle cone were what we ordered. It was so good! We wish there was a Graeters in East Tennessee! read more

Great tasting ice cream that I think you can only get in ohio. Correct me if I'm wrong but it is good.

This was my favorite after-school stop back in the day. Though the atmosphere at this particular location is mediocre, the ice cream is as good as it gets. I loved hanging out, watching the cars drive by from their porch with a cup of black raspberry chip in hand. read more

One of the best ice cream in Ohio. I love the buckeye blitz on waffle cone. It's always good to treat yourself to some good ice cream once in awhile. Got to try it. read more

My wife loves this place. I like it too. I think it's a little pricey myself though. Location is always clean, service is a great. High quality ice cream worth coming back for! Parking sucks at this locale--that and the higher price is why I give it four stars. read more

Oh my goodness! This ice cream was to die for. I usually only get 1 scoop when we go for ice cream. However, after tasting a few flavors I couldn't make up my mind and I got the salted caramel and the toffee chocolate chip. The chocolate chips are not mere chips but chunks of soft melt in your mouth heavenly chocolate! Definitely one of my favorite ice cream stops ever. read more

This place is the bomb! I love there flavors. From traditional flavors like butter pecan, or chocolate. To the wicked newer flavors like cotton candy or buckeye blitz. I have been going to this location for years. In the past it has been a nice place to visit from time to time. However recently I have been visiting alot more often. For some reason it has a more homely feeling now. The employees to the new candy displays. Which I didn't even know Graeters had candy till recently when the young lady ringing out my order pointed me in the right direction. It is amazing! A little like Anthony Thomas in the area, but some items are way better. Like my favorite the sea salt carmels. If your in the area I suggest you check it out. If you have been there before I suggest you try again. It is a much better experience now! read more