Buckeye Whittie. Very solid, good peanut butter cookies and good custard filling! 10/10 will buy again.

Stopped by Whit's Frozen Custard in Uptown Westerville this afternoon after riding up State Street and spotting the sign for the flavor of the week: Twisted Coffee. The sign did exactly what it was supposed to do, it made us stop immediately. The frozen custard was smooth, rich, and very creamy, exactly what you want from a great dessert spot in Westerville. The coffee flavor was tasty and well balanced, with fudge, peanut butter, cookies, and crumble mixed in, making it a fun and unique treat. I would have liked just a little more coffee flavor to come through, but it was still absolutely worth the stop. If you're looking for the best frozen custard in Uptown Westerville, this is a great place for an afternoon or evening treat while walking State Street. The location is right in the heart of Uptown, which makes it perfect for a spontaneous dessert stop. Address: 46 N State St, Westerville, OH 43081 (Uptown Westerville Inc) read more

See all

Amazing frozen custard! Loads of flavors to choose from! Service was speedy and knowledgeable about the choices. Atmosphere is nice but no where to sit. read more

Love Whit's Gahanna. This one is just as good, but with a college-y atmosphere befitting the area. Whitsers are my favorite. Go there!

It was hot and humid and the line was long, but these Midwest workers really know how to move things along. Whit's did not disappoint. Smooth and creamy custard and so many toppings it will make your head ache just to make a choice! read more

See all

Very friendly staff and service. The custard is top notch. We got the buckeye sundae. Amazing. It was not too sweet, it was simply fantastic. Wish there was some more outdoor seating. Will be going back for sure. read more

This location can be found in the middle of a small town Main Street (which according to their website is what they're about). There is parallel parking just outside the doors and along the side of the road. The custard is not overly expensive. We tried a mix of chocolate and vanilla and enjoyed both. My only wish was that they didn't crush the M&M's. They have a small number of tables and chairs inside along with two benches. read more

Whit's Frozen Custard - Case of ice cream sandwiches. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

One of the few things that excites me as much as a burger is ice cream (not a real healthy approach, I realize). I remember when a visit to Whit's meant a trip to Granville or Johnstown but we got Whit's in Westerville a few years ago and it's as good as I remember from my stops at their Granville location. This is FROZEN CUSTARD - not actual ice cream - but the difference means little to me - I love both real ice cream, DQ's frozen milk product and Whit's frozen custard. read more

A Columbus staple for a reason, Whit's is certainly among the greats for Columbus frozen treats. I especially like the downtown Westerville locations for its charm. I opted for a small Whitster with Penguin Tracks custard (vanilla with fudge/brownie) with salted caramel and heath mix-ins, but you really can't go wrong at Whit's. Everything is great! read more

Whit's Frozen Custard - Whitster - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

This was a great way to end dinner. We stopped in to have Whit's Frozen Custard! Such a cute little shop with a polite and busy staff. They mix and make their custards and unique blends of custard as well like the Apple Pie ,Red Velvet, Buckeye Madness, and more. You have many selections from waffle cones to sugar cones or bowls or their whister. This place is bright, well lit and they have seating both inside and out. There's even pints of frozen custard to take home. I picked up a Red Velvet! read more

See all

Wow! We're from the Cleveland area & made a stop here on our way home. This is seriously the best custard we've ever had!!

Usually enjoy eating some fresh frozen custard from Whit's. Not this visit. Was in town all week visiting family. Waited all week for the flavor of the day that I wanted which was fluffer nutter (peanut butter and marshmallow fluff). Ordered three cups of fluffer nutter and took it home to eat after dinner. Boy were we disappointed when two of the dishes were plain vanilla and the third cup just had a little peanut butter stirred in. Their vanilla custard is very good, but that's not the flavor I had my heart set on and waited all week to purchase. Here's hoping my next visit to town I can visit Whit's and get a decent flavor. Sorry no photos as Westerville was setting up for "Third Friday " and parking was hard to find and the main road was clogged with traffic. read more

I don't know why I never ventured into Whits before because it is amazing! This location is super clean and quick with great staff to help you choose which amazing flavor to get. Love that There is a big sidewalk area outside to enjoy your treat and it's close to parking at the corner. read more

Whit's Frozen Custard - Mud pie blended - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

Chocolate Frozen Custard. Made out of antique machines!!! Like turning back time. Wonderful. read more

See all

Nice little custard shop at one end of Uptown Westerville. It was wintertime, and during the holidays, so their selections weren't that many. But what they had to offer and what you could buy to take home were plenty enough. read more

Great place to stop for a quick dessert. Whit's has the "take/weigh what you desire" model down. There are a selection of about a dozen frozen yogurts and 20-30 toppings ranging from fruits, candies; bobas and syrups. You pay for what you want in your cup. Toppings are pretty standard for these types of fast buffet yogurt places but the yogurt flavor was very good! Flavor of the month was watermelon but had an excellent taste to it, not overly "artificial watermelon" My daughter and I each grabbed a cup and made it out under $10, that's a win! :) read more

Whit's Frozen Custard - Two yogurts! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

Great price on a really big cup of delicious custard. Every week they have a new flavor. You can check the website for the current flavor of the week or upcoming flavors. They will always let you sample the flavor of the week or their regular flavors which is chocolate and vanilla. There is a reward kiosk on the counter. Be sure to register and redeem your first reward. After a few visits you get a free cup as well as other offers sent via text. The custard is really delicious here and for the price you pay you get way more than the competition gives you. read more

See all

Nice to have a location in Westerville & family fav. While I don't want to discourage you from a vine or 2 scoop, know they are generous scoops. I opted for the flavor of the week; had salted caramel, pretzels. Heaven! Kids were happy with vanilla. Already looking forward to the peppermint flavor at Christmas! read more

Whit's Frozen Custard - Flavor of the week: salty caramel waffle cone pieces - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

Whit's is always a staple. I love the daily and weekly flavors! I used to get Whitsers, which are basically cups of custard mixed with toppings of choice. Now, I almost always get the daily or weekly flavors on a cone! I really appreciate this location because they almost always have vegan options as well! read more

Library offered a free custard with their summer reading program. And since I love reading and I've cream, this was a win - win in my book. Came on a Monday evening with my husband - the woman checking us out gave him a sample to try and then we placed our order. He got a Buckeye special and I went for the flavor of the week (strawberry) cup. His was very full and very sweet. Mine was also sweet. I thought they were on the edge of too much, just falling into the right amount... And they were both mini! 4 stars because it was just a little too sweet for us. But it was still a yummy treat and I recommend checking it out. read more

This is a definite favorite since a friend recommended it about a year ago! You can always get the chocolate, vanilla, or the flavor of the week. We get the flavor of the week and have never been disappointed. You can look up the flavor online, and usually a particularly yummy sounding flavor is what entices us to go again! There are lots of toppings and mix-ins you can get, but we usually just get the flavor of the week, topped with whipped cream and a cherry for free (sprinkles are also free)! The dipped cones look good, but eating from a cup is less messy. They have cookie, custard sandwiches that are huge. I've not tried one yet, but they look amazing! You can also get quite a few flavors in the case to take home. I also want to try the cakes, because they look so good! read more

Whit's Frozen Custard - Two scoop buckeye custard with whipped cream and a cherry on top! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

We love Whit's and especially the Westerville location. They have a flavor of the week and a flavor of the day in addition to vanilla and chocolate. The prices are amazing for how much custard you get and it's always delicious. Plus the employees are super friendly every time. Lots of selection of whittie's and quarts to go in the freezer too. Best ice cream in Uptown for sure. read more

I visited Whits for the first time. There were so many options and ways to get your custard it was hard to decide what to get. I had the buckeye, (vanilla custard, chocolate sauce, Reese cups and peanut butter) and my husband had the Grasshopper (vanilla custard with mint flavor and chocolate chips). Mine was so good, mixed well and just delicious. My husband sat down away from all of us and just ate his without a word, he was so excited about it and liked it so much he ignored his family. Lol. We are close to this location a lot of the time so we will be going back often. read more

This place is very interesting. My daughters and I ordered a cone with ice cream and toppings. When I ordered the girl said she could put my toppings in a bowl but could not put them on my ice cream cone. I repeatedly asked why and she could not tell me why. When we got our ice cream it was in a bowl and they handed me a cone. This is a joke! I will never go back here again. My 2 year old hated the ice cream and we threw it in the trash. read more

Whit's Frozen Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

Went in for the first time, no greeting from staff. Advised it was our first time and asked about the flavors of the day. Got a mumble in response and then stared at until we made a decision. Felt rushed and cold as if the person behind the counter just wanted us out of the store. Store smelled odd. Custard was good, would go again but probably not back to this location. read more

After having such a bad experience at the whits in Sunbury I would like to recognized not all the whits are equal. Westerville is clean, organized, professional and accommodating with nut allergies. They take nut allergies serious and recognize it as a life threatening condition. Not only do they change gloves and wash the scoop they get the Oreo toppings from the back so there is NO risk if cross contamination. I will drive the extra 7 miles and leave a generous tip for the amazing caring customer service. Bravo read more

Delicious homemade custard. I love the mocha mud pie sundae and their whitties (frozen custard cookie sandwich). The custard is very fresh and flavorful. The servings are generous. Not a huge eat-in area. read more

Theey couldnt take my $50 bill. The mint flavoring was artifical and I did not enjoy my choice.

I love living near Uptown Westerville because we can strap the baby into the stroller and walk to Whit's. It's been a while since we've been there, but they now offer a rewards program we're your sixth treat is discounted just by signing up. Yummy custard. read more

First time trying Whit's and it was good. Had chocolate frozen custard on a waffle cone. Yummy! Will be back again!

Stopped by the Westerville location on my way out of Columbus back to Cleveland Sunday October 28th. It has become somewhat of a tradition to drop in to whits for custard on our way out of town. I tried the German chocolate which was awesome with chunks or cake and coconut. It's pretty simple but we have been here a couple times and have no complaints. I do wish they had lots of choices in flavors like some of their competitors down the road, but I understand it's their thing and I always like to drop in and see what the special is. No doubt we will drop in again next time we are in town. read more

Well, the flavor of the week is penguin tracks, my fav! So I put a reminder on the calendar so I didn't miss out. My husband and I went today at 2:15 for an afternoon treat. We both ordered a single cup of penguin tracks to go. The place was empty, clean, friendly. That was the best part. I am not sure what they gave us but what we had was a nice dip of vanilla with a small vein of caramel in one spot. Normal penguin tracks is filled with goodies, caramel, fudge, brownie bits in every bite. Today all we got was basically vanilla, albeit the vanilla was good but it was a sorry attempt at penguin tracks. Such a disappointment. If this was our first visit it would probably be our last. Going forward, looks like Graters and Dairy Queen will win out. read more

Great custard and super helpful staff. Very clean and fast. Indoor and outdoor seating - it was yummy!

This my shit but cmon - where are the flavors? I even just wanted chocolate but they ran out. How do you run out of chocolate when your only flavors are chocolate and vanilla??? Okay, and the flavor of the day. So three flavors. But seriously. But anyway this my shit!!!! read more

Staff is very friendly, custard was amazing based in recommendations from the staff. Learned the difference between custard and ice cream!

My favorite place to get ice cream in Westerville, besides DQ. So creamy and delicious!

So delicious! Love their flavors of the month. Only complaint is the staff can be very slow, rude and distracted. I was in last week and the only girl working the register was just talking to a customer (because she knew him) when he had already been helped and was on his way out the door while five people stood in line and waited. This lasted probably 3-5 minutes before someone just started ordering in hopes she would pay attention to them. The workers seem very young, I think they would benefit from a manager or someone who isn't going to get distracted when her friends come in, watching over them. read more

Custard was awesome would've given it five stars if they could move the line a little quicker line was out the door and down the sidewalk. We visited at 8:30 PM on a Sunday evening. read more

I really want to like this place, but after four less than satisfactory visits to this location, it's hard. The frozen custard is good but the service is awful. They forget orders and have no customer service knowledge of how to resolve the situation. I've never seen any management there, only a few teenagers behind the counter, I'm glad they're giving teens jobs but they need some direction and help. read more

This custard is so delicious! It's way better than ice cream! The staff here are so friendly and helpful. We definitely recommend!!! We will be back! :) read more