Goodfella's Pizza

The breadsticks were swimming in butter... yum! The pizza was pretty good too, lots of cheese and…read moretoppings!

Had a great meal here tonight at Mazerella's. I had the Buffalo Chicken (Crustless Style), my…read morecompanions had the: Grilled Chicken Alfredo - He said the chicken was so incredibly tender and delicious and the garlic bread was also tasty And the Maz Combo Pizza - She said it was "super good" And my crustless was wonderful. The flavors were are balanced, the cheese has awesome pull and it was a great portion size. You order at the window and take a seat. They will bring your food out to you. They have soft drinks in a cooler in bottles and cans and a soda fountain. Our food was delivered hot and delicious in less than 15 mins. We will be back!

Thin Crust pizza

See all

Sherrilli’s Pizzeria

3.7(13 reviews)

9.5 mi

Criminally underrated pizzeria that's a must-try for fans of the "Indiana Cracker Crust" style. I…read moreoccasionally stopped by when it was still known as "Sir Dano's," and in my opinion, it has only gotten better since the rebranding. This is especially true of the dining area; it was previously as hole-in-the-wall as it gets, but is now charming, surprisingly spacious and still manned by nice folks. The crust is a bit thicker than the usual tavern crust pizza and the flavor has a cornmeal undercurrent to it. It takes some getting used to, but once it clicks, it feels like a eureka moment and is truly addictive. It helps that it reheats extremely well and the toppings are great across the board (I highly recommend the deluxe pizza for this reason - not a weak topping in the bunch). As for the rest of the menu, Sherrilli's also boasts some of my favorite breadsticks in the area and a stromboli that compares favorably to Pizza King's, though it can't quite touch Mazerella's. The baked spaghetti is hearty comfort food, a terrific value and comes with a couple of those manna-from-Heaven breadsticks. The chicken wings are pretty negligible and you'd be better off exploring the rest of the menu, though the Sherrill's Gold sauce isn't half-bad. For maximum effect, swing by here on a cold winter day and get a booth in the back; it's toasty and a bit rustic, and Sherrilli's really shines under those conditions. You can't go wrong with a pie here any time of the year, though. They're also stalwarts on Groupon, just sayin'!

Two years ago I left this place a 5 star review. Today not so much. I ordered a 1/2!sausage and 1/2…read morecheese only. When o got home there were 4 small cheese only pieces on the edges. The rest was sausage. Too far to go back. And when I looked at my receipt I was charged a .50 delivery fee. I picked it up!!!If you order from here be sure to check your order before you leave.

Burnt pizza (2)

Pepperoni and sausage 14 inch. This reminds me of the old Steve's Pizza king and the blackened crust, delicious!!!!

See all

Extra sides & funny signs

Brittany's Brick Oven Pizza

4.9(104 reviews)

24.7 mi

Great little place with great staff, great service and the pizza is fantastic in their brick oven!…read more Highly recommend the lunch special!

Superb pizza and bread sticks! The small salad was of a generous portion and all the ingredients…read morewere fresh. The balsamic vinaigrette dressing tasted homemade. The restaurant was well staffed and all of the staff that serviced our table were extremely nice, attentive and friendly. Sweet and kind I'd say. The restaurant was busy with table seated guests and the staff was processing carry out orders efficiently. Quite possibly the best pizza this seasoned citizen has ever had! Excellent overall experience! Tidy and clean restaurant and bathroom too! A real delight!

Inside

Hungry as a bar of Pizza in the front. Gluten-free cheese pizza in the back

See all

Outside

Chicago City Pizza

4.5(26 reviews)

9.9 mi

My wife and I stopped by for a date night after hearing good things about Chicago City Pizza, and…read moreit was worth checking out. The pizza was tasty, the service was good, and the location is convenient. It's a small place inside, but that adds to the cozy small town feel. We also liked the train running around the restaurant and having a TV on while we ate. If you're looking for a laid back local pizza spot, it's definitely worth a visit.

The food is always great, portions huge, and the employees are always helpful! We love that they…read moreare trying new recipies and am excited to see what they come up with next!

20.0 mi•Downtown, Medical Center

See all

Parlour - Downtown Louisville

4.0(203 reviews)

Very good food, definitely stands out with the pizza and pints being everywhere in Louisville. My…read moreonly suggestion was it was freezing in there. Special thanks to the manager who cleared up one small error on our ticket. She was a beautiful lady with long hair and glasses.

Shall we get our pizza on!…read more The pizza journey of this restaurant continues from Jeffersonville, Indiana to Louisville Kentucky. Now do you want something unique and special. It's delicious and hot!! It makes you want to keep repeating and retuning. What makes this place so special is the sauce. Is it all in the sauce ! Yes truly it is. That red sauce in the pizza and doused in cheese. Wow! If you have experienced their pizza you can know how it's tastes. Now being sensitive to spice, something's the special sauce can trigger your stomach issues and sensitivity. But take those antacids to not have it set off. The pizza here is absolutely delicious. Again the key ingredient, "the sauce," so make sure and ask for extra. The cheese bread is delicious too. We have dined in and taken it to go. The service is stellar . The restaurant is a sit in place with a bar. Bring the family. It's a great place to gather and socialize. Eat pizza and drink. Just enjoy the ride of life.

Weclome to Parlour

See all

Good beer from Louisville

French Licks

4.4(70 reviews)

46.1 mi

Pizza-amazing, ice cream-amazing, staff-amazing! Nothing bad to say about this quaint little…read moreplace! The menu is simple, the staff is beyond friendly and helpful. Very inviting environment ! Dining room only seats 50 people but the atmosphere is so cool and unique! Prices are great! And you can even get "adult" milkshakes with your favorite liquor added in. Just a fun place! Plan to go back many times! Also family friendly as well! Definitely recommend this little gem I'd you are in French Lick , Indiana. You won't be disappointed!

0 stars. So gross. Paper thin cracker pizza. The expresso martinis were sugar water, no booze…read morewhoever. Kids ate their fake cheese pizza bc they are young enough to not have a palate. The house salads came to table with rotten lettuce with cheap cheese dumped on top. No croutons or vegetable. So gross. My husband gave the salads back and no one came to talk to us. We left after dumping the drinks. So gross. And NO GLOVES when making our pizza with long acrylic fingernails. Gross. Gross. Gross.

S'mores ice cream- delicious!

See all

Menu June 16, 2023

Chicago's Pizza

3.9(86 reviews)

45.8 mi

We went on a Wednesday evening and they were steady. You grab a menu and then come back to the…read morecounter to order. We had a "Meats" and added green peppers and onions and the kids had a personal pepperoni and a personal cheese. We also got salads and cheese bread. Everything was delicious. Everything came out very quick and hot. The staff were all very pleasant. The restaurant was small and clean. We would definitely eat there again.

Great friendly service, clean environment and great pizza !! Deep Dish all the way!! The price was…read morevery competitive to other pizza places!

Pepperoni cheese sticks

My pie

See all

Jumbo Veggie with banana peppers.

The Drake

4.4(14 reviews)

24.9 mi

Convivial atmosphere. Righteous pie. Good music. Bartender is kinda spicy. In the very best way…read more 10/10.

They finally went back to their original thin crust pizza and prepare it perfectly…read more We have got 5 pizzas this fall and they have been excellent every time.

Only bottoms up draft system in Madison In

Chicken Bacon Ranch 12" pizza

See all

Chicken tenders rolled in flour and buttermilk and cooked golden brown.

Fire Oven Pizza

4.3(85 reviews)

26.8 mi•Okolona

We are from Chicago and come this way several times a year. Fire Oven Pizza is always on our list…read moreto order from. This time we had a mushroom and spinach thick crust and it was outstanding. We also ordered the BBQ wings, highly recommend.

Not great, didn't have all the sauces listed, not all ingredients were fresh looking. Service not…read moregreat.

Chicken Tikka Masala Pizza

See all

Tequila & Mezcal

4.9(17 reviews)

0.2 mi

Nice Mexican restaurant. Portions are large. Service is good and very attentive. Price is medium…read morepriced. Parking can be limited.

This is one of my favorite Mexican restaurants. I would highly recommend to anyone. My husband and…read moreI come here often and they have great food, drinks, atmosphere, and service. This place definitely checks all of the boxes and has become a staple. It is family friendly and we will always recommend this restaurant!!

View of the inside

Enchiladas Bandera

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

8 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Bella L.

12 years ago

If you live in Henryville and you haven't tried Goodfella's then you should probably fix that. I absolutely love this restaurant. The food is great. I always get the cheese pizza (I know, not very exciting) and the green bean crispers (insert drool emoji here). There's more than just pizza on the menu though and the lunch specials are usually a big hit. The prices are great for the amount of food you get in exchange and the servers are super friendly and welcoming. I would highly recommend to anyone. read more

Melissa B.

6 years ago

This is an awesome place to eat. We get delivery and carry out a lot. The food is amazing and the employees are very kind, friendly and very polite. The chef salad cannot be beat. I take it to work a lot and everyone wants to know where I got it. I personally cannot eat all of it. Everything is fresh, well made, and rarely any issues, and when there was a an issue they fixed it immediately. No problems. I love this restaurant and highly recommend it to anyone. read more

Julie B.

3 years ago

Haven and the team serve fresh, hot and delicious food for breakfas, lunch and dinner. Buffet, outstanding specials. Fast, friendly service. up from Florida and felt at home at Goodfella's. almost forgot to mention their fountain drinks cost half as much as back home, nice price! see you next time read more

Clyde L.

10 years ago

Phenomenonal pizza. I am extremely impressed and definitely wasn't expecting pizza this good in the area. Everything was right from the sauce to the cheese to crust. Highly recommend. read more

Jeff S.

10 years ago

Love Goodfellas! The pizza is great, the Calzones are unbelievable and the sandwiches rock. Breakfast is great too largest and best pancakes around! read more

Alisson C.

3 years ago

Awesome pizza!! delicious and they also have dessert pizzas!! the service is also great and the people are so kind! my family and I love it!

Makayla S.

7 years ago

thin crust chicken bacon ranch pizza and baked potato pizza was amazing! whole family loved it

Michele S.

12 years ago

Great food and staff was friendly! Food came out fast and hot. This place was very clean to.

Goodfella's Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Henryville, Indiana Restaurants near Goodfella's Pizza

BEST of Henryville, Indiana Things to Do near Goodfella's Pizza

BEST of Henryville, Indiana Coffee near Goodfella's Pizza

BEST of Henryville, Indiana Breakfast near Goodfella's Pizza

BEST of Henryville, Indiana Lunch near Goodfella's Pizza

BEST of Henryville, Indiana Shopping near Goodfella's Pizza

BEST of Henryville, Indiana Brunch near Goodfella's Pizza

People found Goodfella's Pizza by searching for…

Spaghetti in Henryville, IN

Thin Crust in Henryville, IN

Chili in Henryville, IN

Grinders in Henryville, IN

Restaurants BBQ in Henryville, IN

Takeout in Henryville, IN

Burgers in Henryville, IN

Deep Dish Pizza in Henryville, IN

Restaurants in Henryville, IN

Kid Friendly Restaurant in Henryville, IN

Pizza Delivery in Henryville, IN

Grinder Sandwich in Henryville, IN

Buffet in Henryville, IN

Breakfast & Brunch in Henryville, IN

Hot Wings in Henryville, IN

Calzone in Henryville, IN

Lunch in Henryville, IN

Best of Henryville

Things to do in Henryville

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Goodfella's Pizza also viewed

Chicago City Pizza

4.5

(26 reviews)

The food is always great, portions huge, and the employees are always helpful! We love that they…read moreare trying new recipies and am excited to see what they come up with next!

Teena's Pizza

3.1

(17 reviews)

I'm glad I hadn't previously driven by this place, or I may have never ordered from here. I…read moreinitially missed the building and drove by, even with Google maps. It looks sketch, and I briefly reconsidered my choice. But I'm glad I went in! Yelp was zero help in finding this gem, so props to Barstool's One Bite app. I have struggled (to put it mildly) to find even decent pizza around these parts, but this was sooooo worth the drive! The sticks were fantastic and the pizza was even better. I threw my half of the pizza down my gullet so fast, my throat was struggling to keep up. I wish I would've ordered a larger size. Don't let the looks of the building deter you. There is delicious pizza out here in BFE.

In the area starving & looking for a place to eat, Teena's Pizza showed up my Yelp app and it was…read morenearby. The is parking & the building is small. Surprisingly there was plenty of seating for the 10 of us. The staff were nice and I ordered 8in buffalo chicken pizza, fried dill pickles & large drinks. They have fountain drinks & 2 liters drink options. They ordered the largest cheese pizza & it came with free breadsticks. We did have to wait for a decent time but they were fairly busy with people picking up call in orders. The fried dill pickles & breadsticks came out and they were hot and fresh. I loved the pickles they were crispy & seasoned & had a dipping sauce. Also did I mention it brick oven pizza style, so once our pizzas came out a few minutes later not & fresh out the oven. You can see the crisp on the bottom & crust. The buffalo chicken pizza was good not hot buffalo sauce but still packed some flavors. 8 inches wasn't a big pizza almost a personal size but still plenty and our other group devoured their cheese pizza. It the huge and delicious. They didn't have a trash can and we were told to leave our stuff for clean up. They have one small bathroom but it was well stocked & clean. We were pleasantly surprised by the location size, service and food. Don't sleep on local places you never know until you try it.

Mamma Rosa's Restaurant

4.1

(29 reviews)

They have the best lasagna!! I love their pizza…read more The "big Mamma pizza" is huge! The sauce they use is a sweeter sauce. They have a salad bar. I do wish they would bring back their homemade bacon vinaigrette style dressing (they use to have it on the salad bar)

Good little Italian restaurant. Quick to take your order and get your food. I had the chicken parm…read more With spaghetti. Not the best I've had. The chicken is chicken strips covered in a slightly tangy marinara sauce without any cheese topping. The spaghetti is really good tho. My wife had the baked spaghetti with their marinara sauce. She liked it. We don't think we'll be back.

Mazerella's Upper Crust Pizza & Pasta

4.5

(91 reviews)

The breadsticks were swimming in butter... yum! The pizza was pretty good too, lots of cheese and…read moretoppings!

Firehouse Pizza

4.4

(5 reviews)

Love love love Firehouse Pizza. The have the friendliest service and best steak hoagies.read more

The service was very fast, the food is always great! Great…read morelocation & prices!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The Red Pepperoni

4.3

(207 reviews)

It was fantastic! Our first time visiting and we will definitely go back when in town…read more Food! Service! Ambiance!

Solid pizza joint on the far end of town…read more.. Coworkers wanted pizza for lunch, so we stopped in... Pretty darn good. The restaurant itself is a cool lil place... Not huge, but good size seating area and very clean. The staff was friendly/attentive and the food was alright... It's not the best pizza I've had, but respectable especially for small town Indiana. Plus, the prices were very reasonable especially for the amount of food you get ($30 for lunch w/ tip). TRP is worth a stop when in Madison if you're looking for a solid pie.

Charlestown Pizza Company

4.1

(83 reviews)

I had a great experience with this pizza company! The pizza was delicious, fresh, and cooked to…read moreperfection. The crust had a great texture, the toppings were generous, and every bite was full of flavor. The quality of the food really stood out, and the service was friendly, professional, and efficient. You can tell they take pride in what they do and care about keeping their customers happy. Whether you're ordering for a family night, a get-together with friends, or just craving some good pizza, I would definitely recommend giving them a try. I'll absolutely be ordering from them again!

A new favorite pizza joint. Really like their pizza pot pie includes 10 toppings. The small side…read moresalad is as big as other restaurants' regular salads with fresh ingredients. The drink menu is extensive and reasonably priced. The servers are always friendly and attentive. Don't sleep on this small restaurant.

Old School NY Pizza

3.6

(74 reviews)

Sitting at a table next to the sidewalk, enjoying a slice of pizza -- what a lovely experience in…read moreNorton Commons! This is the kind of neighborhood experience that NC is made for. My MIL lives in NC, and we met up for dinner while family was visiting. We got a long table out front and were able to decide on a few pizzas to try, including a basic cheese (for the kids), pepperoni and sausage and the chicken pesto. Each was good, with the chicken pesto my favorite. The flavors worked really well together. We didn't have to wait too long for our pizzas and could also enjoy a glass of beer -- the adults, not the kids ;-) -- to round out the evening. NC boasts several restaurants now, but I would definitely come here again.

Old School New York Pizza was definitely old school... emphasis on OLD…read more This pizza just tasted tired. Nothing about it stood out, nothing made me want another slice, and there definitely wasn't anything here that reminded me why I love New York-style pizza. As a pizza snob, I can usually find something to appreciate. This one? No thank you. Palate don't lie. ‍

Marco's Pizza & Sub

3.1

(17 reviews)

Great stromboli s and pizza is yummy. Prices are reasonable and service is quick. Friendly staff…read more Definitely recommend.

Pizza is good but when you try to call them, they are always busy. I spent almost a half a day just…read moretrying to reach them, but the phone was always busy. They need to update that. It's like only one person works there and sometimes they just get tired of making food so they just leave the phone busy like they're talking to their relatives on the phone

Jendy's Pizzeria

4.0

(36 reviews)