We went on a Wednesday evening and they were steady. You grab a menu and then come back to the counter to order. We had a "Meats" and added green peppers and onions and the kids had a personal pepperoni and a personal cheese. We also got salads and cheese bread. Everything was delicious. Everything came out very quick and hot. The staff were all very pleasant. The restaurant was small and clean. We would definitely eat there again. read more

Great friendly service, clean environment and great pizza !! Deep Dish all the way!! The price was very competitive to other pizza places! read more

Chicago's Pizza - Deep dish !! - Pizza Near Me - French Lick, Indiana

Great service and the pizza was really really good. I was pleasantly surprised and we will return when we are in the area.

Always really yummy food. Our favorite is the chicken bacon ranch pizza on thin crust.

Great pizza and salad bar!! Good pricing too. Loved the buffet setup. We walked right in and picked up our pizza and salads. read more

Cheesey bread is delicious, thin crust pizza is best we had since leaving Ohio 45 years ago ! Meatballs are perfectly made also! read more

The staff here are the rudest people you could ever encounter, just total disrespect for their customers. The founder, Bob, would be disgusted with how they act. Total lack of class and over the top disrespect. Look elsewhere. While the pizza is actually good - the service more than offsets any positives. read more

From outside just another joint, but when you step in welcome to the locals favorite. Place was busy, but not too noisy. The service friendly and welcoming. And smelled like good ol' pizza! Made to order, specialty or just good pepperoni. Mine was the all meat, add cheese add jalapeños and add .... Yup pineapple. And it arrives. Food porn!!! And so starts my assault on hunger! Bite by bite, by slice and... pizza is gone and so is my hunger, for now. Wow this is good. Meets if not a bit better than expectation which is saying something because my expectations were high. Sauce Yum, crust, yes, topping and cheese good. Will return! read more

See all

The parking lot was full, but still had plenty of seating. We were greeted immediately. Very friendly service. Very surprised how quickly the food arrived. We ordered the garlic cheese bread and 18" traditional pepperoni pizza, so yummy. We couldn't finish it, we took it back to the hotel with us. And the pizza is still yummy when it's cold when we had some for breakfast the next day. read more

Very tasty pizzas and garlic cheesy bread. Would've liked some more sauce on the pizza but that's just our taste. Great fair prices as well

We've eaten there this year dnd last year with z very large group (20 last year). We have found them to be friendly and accommodating. Everyone enjoys the pizza. They have gluten free crust. We will happily return whenever we are in town.. read more

I am from Northwest Indiana, so the concept was a little different to me. You walk up to the counter and place your order and then go sit down and they bring it out to you. Typically I'm used to a waitress but I'm fine with whatever. The pepperoni cheese sticks were pretty tasty dipped in marinara. The sauce was sweet, but not too sweet. we got a pizza and I had it on thin cracker crust which was pretty tasty. I just wish I would've gotten a little bit bigger of a pizza but they only went up to 14 inches. Maybe I should've had a small as well? Anyway, I didn't leave too extremely full, so maybe it's good that we didn't have more to eat. Place was pretty empty when I went there the pizza is just OK, but it was filling for the night. We were here for a conference. read more

Chicago's Pizza - Pepperoni cheese sticks - Pizza Near Me - French Lick, Indiana

This was a unassuming spot from the outside, but upon entering, you can tell it is a local's favorite spot. This place was packed! It's the kind of place where you order at the front then grab a spot and wait in full anticipation of the delights to soon arrive whilst engaging in the indulgent aromatherapy of pies being made in the kitchen. It has a nice clean and well loved environment with marble tables and dark wood benches, big open windows, and beautiful scenery around. There is a large parking lot that the trolley driver can pull into, or if you are driving yourself, is easy to navigate. The pizza was really good and my husband loved his as well. We both are a 10" each. They weren't AMAZING, but they were really enjoyable and up to expectations, so I'm certain you will enjoy this spot...if you can find a table! read more

See all

The pizza was good even though they were so crowded but they did their best to make it quick for the customers including us. The place was clean but simple. read more

Everything was wonderful here from the service to the food. One of the best pizzas I've ever had. I wish we had this restaurant where I live. I would definitely be a regular. read more

Bread sticks was not done, very blah, cheese dip not much taste, pizza wasn't done the cheese wasn't even melted. Will not be back read more

Good pizza quicker than I expected. Ambiance could be better, but it is a family friendly pizza joint. It was clean, too, and employees were friendly. read more

The food was very good. We had pizza and a Stromboli with a salad. The salad was cold and fresh and very refreshing. The Stromboli was pretty good but the sausage was not evenly spread and a lot fell out of the sandwich. The spaghettis was also very good. I want to try the crispy crust next time read more

Our family loves this restaurant, especially the sweeter sauce. From the buffet, to the breadsticks, salad bar, pizzas, and pasta dishes - we love the French Lick Chicagos. The employees are wonderful and always courteous. I wish they would bring back the meat spaghetti sauce though (now only offer plain sauce with meatballs). We will be back!! read more

Went here yesterday and got a large pizza and a couple sales both of which were very good and the service was very good to match as well

The best breadsticks you can find anywhere! Everything we get from pizza to sandwiches and pasta is always delicious.

The food was delicious! I love knowing that the dough is homemade. If you are looking for some pizza in the French Lick are definitely skip Papa John's and try this place out, you won't be disappointed! read more

Chicago's Pizza - an order of breadsticks and the chef's salad - Pizza Near Me - French Lick, Indiana

OK, it's not deep dish Chicago pizza but it was filling and reasonably priced. We also got a small tossed salad with it for$3.50 which was quite large. They have a salad bar for $6 but there's not much on it to be honest. Trust me the tossed salad will be enough. Service was very good and the folks there were very friendly. The total cost was less than $25 which included a couple of diet sodas. That's a bargain. Do add a tip for good service. They certainly deserved it. read more

we chaise a busy night for sure for me and my mom and grandma and papaw. which the food was hot. the place was noisy which I wasn't surprised at all because it was a night of the polar express. which it was busy with kids and toddlers. read more

Worst pizza I ever had. There was barely any pepperoni or sausage in it. It is definitely not Chicago Thick crust style.

This pizza was awesome. There are slim pickings in the area, but this was definitely worth it. We got a deep dish style pizza. It was so good, we are going to eat pizza again today. The wings were good, but I recommend cooking them a little longer. Other than that, the staff was nice and attentive. If you visit French Lick, be sure to stop at this restaurant to eat. The Small pizza, is big enough to feed two people. read more

Chicago's Pizza - Deep dish!!! - Pizza Near Me - French Lick, Indiana

Didn't know what to expect when we saw this Pizza joint across the street from the Waterpark. Pizza is A1...wings were amazing and everything was hot and fresh.. stop by and you won't be disappointed read more

Chicago's Pizza - Jumbo Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - French Lick, Indiana

Visited here for the first time about 8:00 PM on a Friday night. It was still pretty busy. Me: Salad bar (great) and baked ziti with meat sauce (average). I wanted the lasagna but they were out of it. Party #2: Sausage and pepperoni pizza on a traditional crust (excellent). Party #3: Salad bar (rated great) and a half order of the garlic cheese bread listed under the appetizers (rated great). Party #4: Salad bar (no rating) and a steak hoagie (rated really good). Positives: variety of choices on the menu Negatives: we all got up to go to the Salad bar and while we were gone our table was completely cleared (like post meal), the server was not very pleasant for being in her role, our food was all brought out at different times (with the pizza having a more than 5 min delay and was last), our server wasn't overly attentive, and I had to go to the register to ask for a box and our checks (granted they were still fairly busy). I would probably try another restaurant in the area before I would visit here again. I liked the salad bar the best. read more

See all

I visited Chicago's in December when French Lick is full of visitors at the hotels and for the Polar Express. We opted out of overpriced hotel food and happily settled into a booth at Chicago's in a Friday night. The place was packed! Servers were genuinely friendly and moved things along so even though they were very busy, we were seated, received drinks, apps, and food, pretty quickly. Between the friendly, local vibe and the prices, this is a straight up win. Six of us shared appetizers, three pies and everyone had a couple beers and it came to $30 for each couple, including tip. We would've paid almost double at our hotel and the same food would have been half as good. If you are in French Lick, give this small Indiana chain a try. We were glad we did! read more

My sisters and I were craving a good deep dish pizza while vacationing in the area and this place did not disappoint.

We travel to French Lick each year for my sons birthday. Chicago's Pizza is our favorite pizza joint! read more

Chicago's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - French Lick, Indiana

A good pizza buffet if you want a quick, cheap lunch. Iceberg mix with tons of salad toppings. A few cold pasta salads. On the hot size, a mix of at least 4 different pizzas at a time. The breadsticks are unseasoned, but soft and chewy. They have regular cheese, nacho cheese, and marinara for dipping. They also have one cinnamon sugar pizza that is very good. When I requested a cheese pizza, they had one hot and ready within 10 minutes and even delivered a couple slices to my table. read more

When two guys who grew up on NYC pizza try a chain pizza place in Indiana, you know it can't turn out well. We needed a quick snack and this place looked inoffensive enough. Sorry to say, the pizza they serve is high school cafeteria quality. Nothing more or less. Eatable for sure but not a dining experience. Three stars is generous but fair because the prices were low, staff very polite, tables clean and they have Larry Bird memorabilia. You make the call. read more

Just your basic pizza nothing fancy but done well! The service was super fast and friendly. They were in the middle of a busy shift of family's trying to shuffle in and get some grub before heading out to the Christmas train ride. The servers were all very nice and prompt offering refills galore! The restaurant had a mom and pop feel with some local memorabilia hanging on the walls.. Though they were quite busy the place was fairly clean. We ordered the ham and pineapple on thin crust. It came out piping hot with oozing cheese. The crust was super thin and crunchy and the sauce had a mild sweetness to it. Definitely not the best pizza I've ever had but it was worth the money and didn't disappoint! They also offer a gluten free crust! The next time I visit French Lick this will be my go to pizza place! read more

Chicago's Pizza - Hawaiian pizza - Pizza Near Me - French Lick, Indiana

If you want a Pizza Hut pizza with a Showbiz Pizza atmosphere (chaos/insanity) this is your place. Completely adequate food -- but the crowd is pretty backward. It's cheap, hence you get what you pay for. There are better options. read more

The deep dish pizza was yummy and filling! Overall it was super yummy and we got to bring some home for the next day! read more

Chicago's Pizza - Chicago's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - French Lick, Indiana

This is the place to go in French Lick for a fast, cheap weekday lunch. The lunch buffet is less than $8 and includes a fountain drink. The salad bar is pretty basic, but includes a couple pasta salads. There are usually at least 4 different pizzas on the buffet (cheese, pepperoni, sausage, combination, vegetarian, ham & pineapple, cheeseburger, etc.) There are also breadsticks with dipping sauces (nacho cheese and marinara). To finish it off, there's a dessert pizza. The decor is pretty common for the area - meaning there's a lot of Larry Bird memorabilia hanging up. read more

Stopped to grab pizza on our way in from out of town. The service was SO nice and the pizza was good!

I realize it's a pandemic but there is absolute lack of any resemblance of customer service. If you aren't going to put in any effort close the doors and go carry out only. read more

The pizza here is phenomenal! My go-to, when in town, is always the veggie. I just discovered that they offer a jumbo size which was perfect for serving 6 for lunch. The reason this got 3-stars instead of 5-stars is that the customer service is always a little questionable. If they would improve on that aspect then this would be a 5-star experience for sure! read more

Chicago's Pizza - Jumbo Veggie with banana peppers. - Pizza Near Me - French Lick, Indiana

See all