Sitting at a table next to the sidewalk, enjoying a slice of pizza -- what a lovely experience in Norton Commons! This is the kind of neighborhood experience that NC is made for. My MIL lives in NC, and we met up for dinner while family was visiting. We got a long table out front and were able to decide on a few pizzas to try, including a basic cheese (for the kids), pepperoni and sausage and the chicken pesto. Each was good, with the chicken pesto my favorite. The flavors worked really well together. We didn't have to wait too long for our pizzas and could also enjoy a glass of beer -- the adults, not the kids ;-) -- to round out the evening. NC boasts several restaurants now, but I would definitely come here again. read more

Old School NY Pizza - Chicken pesto - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Kentucky

Old School New York Pizza was definitely old school... emphasis on OLD. This pizza just tasted tired. Nothing about it stood out, nothing made me want another slice, and there definitely wasn't anything here that reminded me why I love New York-style pizza. As a pizza snob, I can usually find something to appreciate. This one? No thank you. Palate don't lie. ‍ read more

Old School NY Pizza - Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Kentucky

Let me start by saying the smell of this place is a 5 out of 5, and the food that we had were delicious! The reason for the low score comes from ambience and timing. We went on a Thursday rainy night and sat in the enclosed patio which is a nice set-up that we quickly learned is where they accommodate all large parties. The noise grew very loud to the point it seemed like tables across the patio were trying to battle to be heard. We got there ahead of the six person party and the 8 person party. However the timing was very off for the restaurant this night. We chose pizza thinking it would be quick and painless. We were here for almost 3 hours, we ordered two sodas, a salad to split, one large pizza and that's it. We had to flag people down for soda refills and after placing our order for the pizza about 15 min after sitting down, we then waited about an hour and 45 min before it arrived. Everything tasted amazing and it is obviously a hot local spot! But from my experience if you want quick food with a more chill ambience I would suggest other restaurants in this area. If you have a rowdy crowd ready to have some fun drinks and an absolute need for pizza they have you covered! read more

See all

This is the best eat-in pizza place ever. The pizza is amazing but the people make it awesome!! The vibe is perfect and casual. Their menu is excellent. Highly recommended!! read more

Great place to swing in and get a quick slice. Definitely recommend visiting. A++++++

I love having not only a pizza place in my neighborhood, but a delicious pizza place with so many yummy options! Normally, we eat in and we love the vibe there, but this time we picked up pizza and garlic knots to go to bring home for our Bachelor watch party! Everything was ready on time and made as ordered! We ordered the 18 inch Porko pizza and the garlic knots. Both were so flavorful and delicious! Totally hit the spot and was a perfect amount of food for the three of us. read more

Old School NY Pizza - 18 inch Porko Pizza and Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Kentucky

Good pizza, but they close at 9pm!!!??? At least 10pm. Lazy pizza people. Guess they have a captive audience and don't need real hours. Wish they had pork sausage. read more

AMAZING food and service. I have never ordered anything that I don't like. Not to mention the service is amazing. The owners and all of the staff are always so friendly. This is a great neighborhood spot and we are happy to live so close to here! read more

Good pizza. They've got the thin crust figured out. Toppings are good. Pretty quick turnaround

We love this neighborhood gem!! We can get pizza any where but always come here because it's delicious! When we dine-in we sit at the bar and Brooke is fantastic! Her service is attentive and she's simply a kind soul! Pepperoni pizza is our go-to because well...it's a classic! Pepperonis are perfectly crispy and it's just the right amount of YUM! The crust is my favorite part - you can taste the freshness! If you crave pizza and a beer - make a stop here! read more

Old School NY Pizza - Large Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Kentucky

See all

If I could've picked 3 1/2 stars that's probably the score for New York pizza. Ordered carryout, service fast and friendly. Looked like a decent place to sit down and watch the game and have a beer. Pizza was just OK (would ask for it well done next time) I wouldn't really call it New York style pizza (crust to thick) more of a football style pizza, but a solid pizza for game day. 6.5 out of 10 read more

We tried the PBR (potato bacon ranch) and pepperoni pizza. Crust was good, not too thin and had a nice crunch but not burnt. The ratio of sauce to toppings was spot on. The flavors really didn't wow me, reminded me a bit of frozen pizza. It was good but not anything special. Nice patio area, friendly staff, and the pizza came out relatively quickly. read more

We've been coming to this location since it opened, and this was by far our worst experience. We waited 15 minutes to be acknowledged, another 15 for a table, and over 1.5 hours for our food, which arrived incorrect. During that time, many to-go orders were served before us. We understand to-go business is important, but it shouldn't negatively impact dine-in guests. Very disappointing experience and we won't be coming back. read more

There is a reason that old school is a regular spot for many of us in the neighborhood... Aside from the great food, it's the people that make the business! For example, yesterday while we were getting pelted with snowmageddon 2025 , Old School opened and stayed open and the place was packed... A huge thank you to Chris and Natalie for being open, our regular favorites, Brooke and MacKenzie, thank you both for being there for all of us!! If you haven't been you should and I recommend the Brooklyn pizza, their cheeseburger pizza is awesome, and they make a killer Philly steak and cheese. The sandwiches and salad are also top-notch, you can't go along with any choices that you make! See you there! Cheers!!! read more

Great service and food! Brooke is amazing. All the games are on so ambiance is great.

Excellent pizza with great service. The food came out fast and everything tasted fresh and delicious. Definitely a solid go-to for classic NY style pizza. read more

Brooke and Natalie are the best! The cauliflower crust is to die for! Service is fast and polite and ambiance is great. Can't beat the location. read more

Typical NY Style Pie but nothing to write home about (I prefer Goodfellas for NY style). Good experience with service both times but I came 2:30 pm on the weekend so it wasn't busy. I got the $9.25 special both times I came and the slices were reheated nice considering I bought by the slice and during the end of the special. I recommend the Ford Truck Plant Pie! Ambiance was fine but I didn't love the house flies... read more

Old School NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Kentucky

See all

Old school is a great spot to get good pizza, sandwiches, etc. always a friendly staff and great service. I'm a regular here because it's so consistent. read more

So so good! Pizza hot and fresh. My son is a picky pizza eater and he loves this place! Can't wait to return next time we're in the area!

I'm so happy they added another location. This one is a sit down restaurant while the other is mostly carry out. They have an outdoor patio area. I believe this location doesn't offer pizza by the slice (it wasn't on the menu). They have a bar area as well. There are a couple slushee alcoholic drinks for $8. I had the pina colada and it was pretty good. Not the best I've ever had, but still good. I'm obsessed with their garlic knots so we had to get an order of those. They did seem a little smaller than I remember. The taste is amazing though. I wish we would have got 2 orders. I usually get pepperoni pizza, but I wanted to be adventurous so we got the PBR pizza. It's potato, bacon, and ranch. It was seriously so good. It had the flavor of a baked potato, but on a pizza. I definitely recommend. The 12" pizza had 6 slices so it was the perfect amount for 3 people. My sister loved her bacon calzone. I think we'll be coming to this location a lot more than their other location. read more

Old School NY Pizza - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Kentucky

See all

The Post finally has a competitor in our pursuit of the best Pizza in Louisville. So, why did we like it? Our sausage pizza had generous and flavorful sausage slices. The sauce was superb. The crust was tender. Perfectly cooked. The crust had a nice brown crisp crust. These new places that burn your crust and call it " NY Style" are misguided. Great environment at the restaurant. We sat outside and it was a beautiful night. Great service. The prices were very fair for what you get. My only criticism is charging 50 cents for water. Great, great place. It is nose-to-nose with The Post. And a contender to be our winner. It will be in our championship round! read more

I hate to leave a negative review but the experience wasn't great. The wait time was long and we didn't get what we ordered. We were informed 20 mins after we ordered that they were out of what we ordered. Had to settle for something we didn't want yet charged full price. Probably won't be back. read more

Pizza was OK, I'm a Detroit style pizza lover and this proved it. The staff was great and pleasant. We ordered take out and it was rather quick. I'd say it rates a little better than Spinelli's Pizza but really greasy. read more

If this was my first time, I'd never come back! Awful service from the kitchen! Ordered a pizza and pepperoni knots to go...knew it was busy and would be a while. But... pizza came out nearly 30 minutes before the knots and they put in a warming bag... unacceptable to not have them ready closer to same time! Need to be better Old School!!! read more

Our server, Jenna, was wonderful! She was attentive, friendly, and made our experience great. We not only loved the vibes this restaurant offered but the service. Good service is hard to find but Old schools got it! Pizza was delicious too, some of the best in town! Highly recommend becoming a regular at this spot. read more

This place is crazy busy with families, and bar flies alike. My take out pizza was ready when promised. The hostess, was friendly and efficient while juggling two or three things at one time. read more

First, I'm disappointed in this business covid practices. You couldn't walk in the door without being 6 foot from a table with guests with no masks. Second every seat at the bar top had a person at it and they were shoulder to shoulder no masks. As for the food, the pizza was okay. The crust was a bit chewy and not in a good way. It didn't remind me of New York pizza which was disappointing. The little garlic knots were delicious. They were not really knots but little balls of bread covered with butter, garlic, and parmesan. I would revisit this place if it was near by or if I was in the neighborhood, but I wouldn't go out of my way for a revisit. read more

Very disappointed in the service we received last night. Order was wrong...waitress said "she didn't write it down". A lady who identified herself as the owner was extremely RUDE to my family when I asked the price difference between the 16oz beer and 12oz. She insisted they were the same size. Very argumentative and belligerent. She yelled at me that she "would just take our pizza off the check". Never asked for that. We ate what was delivered to our table. Pizza was good. As always. The owner needs help with her attitude. read more

Old School NY Pizza - 16oz vs 12oz. They don't look like the same size! - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Kentucky

Greeted and seated for a two top indoor, there is outside covered patio seating. Covid 19 table distancing with staff wearing masks. Deanna took our drink orders. The bottle price was a much better deal than per glass for the white my wife selected. Good beer and mixed drink prices. We ordered a garden salad which was large enough to share. We ordered an 8 slice pepperoni and mushroom pizza. Nice NY/NJ thin crust, cooked properly with browned oven side. Small round thinly sliced flavorful pepperoni and small mushrooms. highly recommended Slainte read more

Old School Norton Commons has amazing pizza and other menu items but most importantly the owners and staff are amazingly attentive to their customers! It's my go to for pizza. read more

I don't normally like NY Style pizza but this place is great. Love the Brooklyn pizza with sub of and ham for sausage and pepperoni. The Greek Salad is a favorite too. Good ambience and friendly service. I highly recommend ***** read more

Best pizza in town! I've been eating it for 9 years now and never get tired of the endless choices. Great subs too read more

Celebrated a Birthday with some old friends, had a wonderful experience. The pepperoni knots and wings were fantastic. The restaurant had a great ambiance, and the service was impeccable. The best experience was the Brooklyn Deluxe Pizza, wow! Highly recommend! read more

Old School NY Pizza - Old School New York Deluxe - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Kentucky

Amazing service, great customer care and the best pizza in louisville. Absolutely love this place.

Food is pretty good. Service is horrendous! On 2 recent occasions we went to the restaurant to eat and waited and waited and waited and waited for our pizza - at least an hr on both occasions. Waited 30 mins for a glass of wine. We kept asking where our food was since everyone around us was getting their food. On 2nd trip, we never got our food. we grew tired of waiting and left. They never offered to comp the food or drinks - just offered a discount. They're much more focused on call-in orders than people who take the time to eat in the restaurant. Won't return even though it's just around the corner. read more

Really good NY style pizza in Norton Commons!!!! Leaps and bounds superior than any delivery pizza!!!!! read more

The pizza reminds me of the New York style pizzas I used to have while visiting NY. The pizza tastes real good. Joes Pizza comes to mind. The cheesy bread is awesome too the kind I like. read more

I haven't been to the new location yet but been to the main one everlastingly times and love their pizza and garlic knots. By far the best NY style pizza I have had in the Louisville and Indiana area. read more

Awesome food and even better staff. The wings are killer. Went in for a quick dinner with the wife. Enjoyed some pepperoni knotts while waiting on pizza. Both came out perfect. read more