Pizza here is definitely tasty. A little doughy so it's not the typical thin crust tavern style you find at a lot of small shops. It's inside a gas station. Order in person or over the phone. Pay at the gas station cashier. Bring back your receipt to the pizza counter to grab your pizza. It was fast and friendly service. Clean and smells amazing inside. I got the beef and onion along with a specialty pizza, the taco pizza. I enjoyed the taco pizza. Very tasty except it's a hard one to warm up the next day due to the lettuce and tomato. The beef and onion was decent. It doesn't have a strong flavor. Just enough to make you wanting more. Again, lots of dough so it fills you up quickly. read more

Godfather's Pizza - Beef and onion. Small. - Pizza Near Me - Merrillville, Indiana

See all

First things first, this Godfather's pizza is located inside of a Mobile gas station. But when I tell you that they have a Large 1 topping pizza for $7.99 you should believe me. Well now that Large Pizza has turned into a Medium pizza but still Delicious. I'm guessing that Inflation hits all areas of life. They do have a small area inside where you can sit and enjoy the deliciousness of hot, gooey goodness. The service is always good and all of the guys who work there are pretty cool. The $7.99 pizzas go pretty darn Fast but you can call and place your orders in advance but on a good day you can find pizzas and a few other things under the hot light. Not sure if all the other Godfathers are located inside of gas stations but when the pizzas are that Good...Does it really matter. read more

See all

Delicious, reasonable price, good location. Lots of people always around. Plenty of parking. Nice employees. Godfather's Pizza is as good as it was way back in the day. Worth checking it out. read more

Godfather's Pizza - Meats pizza - Pizza Near Me - Merrillville, Indiana

it's ok. not bad for a quick bite. used to go after work occasionally. snag up a little premade pizza

So delicious! I love to buy again! It's a great place to get a pizza for a great price. Never would think to buy from a Gogo gas station

Honestly some of the BEST pizza I have ever had! The crust is so crispy and buttery. They have a lot of choices in terms of toppings. I've ordered from them on multiple occasions, and each and every time, the service was great! They have great employees as well! I will definitely be a returning customer!! read more

Godfather's Pizza - Meat combo - Pizza Near Me - Merrillville, Indiana

Taste was pretty flavorful, however I asked for well done and it was nearly the opposite. Soft and mushy crust.

This is a fairly good place to get a pie. I used to get one once a week carry out and it was very good. Over the past 3 years the food hasn't lost its quality and it is still rather inexpensive. A lot of times the sauce on pizza will make it or break it. In their case it makes it. It's nice to get breadsticks and their pizza sauce to dip them in. I really can't comment on the other items they have because I've never ordered it. I am always at work when I frequent this location. It has been over all good. Customer service is average, nothing to rave about. Rating below. Location: convenient 4 Price: reasonable 4 Food: excellent 5 Customer service: average 3 Score: 16 out of 20= 4stars read more

This pizza is DAMN good. I wonder if their secret ingredient is crack....I mean, its tasty "can't stop eating with a second slice in my hand" good. They always hand out coupons. A medium is like $16, but well worth it. With a coupon, $9+ tax. No delivery. Carry out only. Slightly odd for how good it tastes, considering its embedded in a gas station. read more

I was staying nearby at one of the local hotels, and needed a few pizzas for a gathering. First off, it's in a gas station. And this particular station seems to be some sort of local hang-out. So it seemed very busy inside and out. The process of paying for the pizzas was a bit odd. I went to the pizza counter and got in line. They rang up a bill that I then had to take to the cashier of the gas station. After waiting in line for the locals to finish chatting and paying for their purchases, I was pleasantly surprised that the bullet-proof glass was open and I could actually talk to and pay the attendant. Once this was accomplished, it was back to the line at the pizza counter, where I eventually was able to hand over a copy of the paid receipt to get my pies... All in all, the pizza was pretty good! No complaints at all! But I probably won't be back. The gas station experience was enough to keep me away... read more

Surprisingly okay pizza as far as "crappy" pizza (in a good way) goes. They had a Twizzler strudel that was AWESOME. The kiddos liked everything and still talk about the strudel lol. I would eat here before going to Verona's down the street! read more

Never even got to place an order. I was places on hold for 11min and finally a women picked up only to place me back on hold. After my phone hit the 17min mark I moved on. read more

Do not go here ever I got a medium pizza which was the size of most small pizzas and it was 13.99 I split it with me and my friend it was supposed to be thin crust but it was about an inch thick took them about 30 minutes to make it the lady was very rude handing it to me I said thank you and she just turned away and ignored me I left and I ate it it was pretty good. But about a half hour later me and my friend both felt horrible I threw up in my friend just did not feel good I would definitely not recommend. read more

The best pizza ever. I highly recommend anything they have. Their cheese sticks are AMAZING! ******Great pizza! Nice people. :)******** read more

Some of the best pizza I have ever had. Everything from the toppings cheese sauce to the buttery crust and the prices are reasonable....u can't go wrong with godfathers. read more

I love this place because it has hard working people who make this pizza a great pizza. Put one slice of anything from there and you will fall in love with the cheese as it melts in your mouth as it satisfies you. This is hands down the best pizza place on the surface of this world... mark my words. read more