What a fantastic meal. Not much to say. Absolutely fantastic. Especially during off-season their winter pri-fix menu is amazing. A lot of comments about prices and perhaps portions, but when the food taste this good and the presentation is this beautiful it's worth it. The desserts were next level. The Smashburger with fries was from the night after dinner for lunch. One of the best burgers I have ever consumed. Separate review of the actual resort is another story. The resort itself is definitely extremely overrated and just not taken care of. read more

See all

Base my reviews off what you pay: Price - $100+ Food - 4/5 - very tasty. Service - 4/5 - friendly and on par. Ambiance - 3/5 - gorgeous location but inside leaves some room for desire. Overall - 4/5 - stayed at the Gurney's resort so was able to try this place for drinks, appetizers, and breakfast. Drinks were good, nothing crazy. Appetizers were great, Tuna Tartare was especially good. Breakfast was great, fantastic tasting. Staff were friendly and engaging, stayed on top of things. Of course the spot has a gorgeous view, inside was fine. Place is pricey but one of the more solid spots in Montauk. Besh Dish - Tuna Tartare, Shakshuka read more

See all

Food was delicious, service was great, and ambiance was pretty - it didn't feel like a hotel restaurant. I will say, I made the reservation months in advance for the winter prix fixe, but upon our arrival, we were told the special wasn't happening because of the holiday weekend. I understand, but someone could have called in advance to confirm and update my reservation. Regardless, the food was tasty. The tuna was phenomenal. The oysters were fresh. Portions were a good size. Cocktails were great. The sour is in a small glass. For the price, would have liked a full size cocktail, but the drink was tasty. I really enjoyed the banana cheesecake. It was unique but so delicious. read more

See all

First time coming to the new restaurant at gurneys, Gigi's, and based on the reviews here we were a bit skeptical if it was going to be really good or just okay, but the meal and service (and ambiance as always here) was so good I feel inclined to leave a review in case anyone else comes to yelp before going. My boyfriend and I are avid diners, eating out at least once a day in the city and 80-90% of restaurants being of this caliber, and are in the hamptons for his birthday. We decided to come to Gigi's for dinner on his birthday, seeing as Gurneys is always beautiful and Scarpetta in the past had made for great meals. We were more than happily surprised by how amazing dinner and the drinks were at the newer opened, Gigi's. Our waiter was also incredible and made my boyfriend's birthday dinner amazing! The food was absolutely amazing including the bread (with a delicious butter) and chocolate dessert not featured in the photos here. Again, this experience was so great and exactly what we were hoping for so I just wanted to leave a review so anyone else checking yelp before coming would know as well! Thank you so much again! read more

See all

It's a beautiful restaurant! Not pictured- the cold pressed juice was flavorful and the best thing for breakfast. A side of potatoes was $14 and $30 for avocado toast was a bit excessive. read more

Gigi's - Avocado toast with salmon and pancakes - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

I had a fantastic dining experience here. I was skeptical with the limited reviews and heard mixed opinions beforehand, but the food was excellent. Cocktails were great, the bread and honey butter were incredible, loved both of the pastas. Portions also were considerably generous. Would definitely recommend to anyone in the area looking for a delicious meal with some of the best ambiance you could ask for. read more

The reviews for Gigi's are a bit negative so we almost didn't go. Is it pricey? Yes. But is the food good. Yes. We went for Christmas brunch (so one of the few places that was open). The service was excellent- efficient and welcoming. Everyone on staff was friendly and helpful. The setting was beautiful, but for the fact that there were boards covering most of the view of the ocean in the main dining room. The shakshuka was delicious, the tomato sauce and short ribs were flavorful. The avocado toast was good. The avo was nice and ripe, but there was less than one cherry tomato on the dish. I also added the smoked salmon, which was fine but nothing super memorable. read more

Gigi's - View from the casual self -serve cafe was better than the main dining room due to construction. - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

This is the restaurant on Gurney's property. The place is newly designed. The outdoor deck is beautiful over looking the ocean. We ordered old fashions. We were disappointed when it came in a plastic wine cup with lots of ice is an understatement. Order your drinks from the inside bar and bring them out. Ask for the large ice cube. We had a beautiful table overlooking the ocean which was beautiful. I had the tuna and my husband had the lobster tagliatelle. Both were just ok. The staff were excellent! Unfortunately we wanted to go to the bar for a night cap but the new design has stairs to get down. How does that happen? So we couldn't get there. My husband can't walk and uses a mobility scooter. How did the town approve that design! We spoke to the manager. He was very apologetic. Once again another business is like f those disabled people. Shame on you! read more

We went there last night The vibe was so much fun Just so loud you could not hear anyone talk at the table The service was impeccable. And the different breads and butter were fantastic. A lot of very good looking people and great people watching. The food was very, very good of course expensive but that is to be expected. We definitely will be going back. read more

The restaurant is nicely decorated and very large But there is an enclosed outdoor area where you have a view of the ocean. At night you have the sound of the waves and the inside eating area is dimmed And its just a wondrous experience.. The food and deserts are very good az well read more

Gigi's is very pretty. Like, "we spent the entire budget on lighting and chairs" pretty. It's aesthetically polished and clearly going for upscale chic. Now, let's talk about the service. Our head waiter was fantastic, warm and professional. We know this because we saw him once. To take our order. And then... he vanished into what I can only assume was another dimension. Enter: the man in the feathered fedora. Manager? Host? Performance artist? Hard to say. He swooped in approximately four minutes after we sat down, clearly concerned we might require time to read a menu. But when we dared to want a second cocktail later? Gone. Nowhere. A myth. A legend. Oh wait -- we did eventually spot him. Twirling and vibing at the service island while we were scanning the room for hydration. We ultimately flagged down the very kind sommelier for another drink -- which was not wine, but at that point we would have accepted Capri Sun in a martini glass. The food itself? Honestly, delicious. They absolutely know how to cook. No complaints there. The only catch is the price -- which feels slightly ambitious for what arrives at the table. It does appear to be the same kitchen that services the entire hotel, which explains a lot. Earlier we waited 30 minutes for a $25 breakfast sandwich at Dune because the kitchen was "busy." Busy seems to be the restaurant's unofficial mascot. And now, dessert. Or... not. On Valentine's Day, a holiday practically built for chocolate, we were informed they couldn't offer their dessert menu because the kitchen was too busy. Instead, we were presented with a hard chocolate brownie heart and the sweetest whipped cream known to mankind. We were told not to worry, we wouldn't be charged. Which is comforting, because paying for it might have required securing another cocktail. (See above.) If you go, admire the decor, enjoy the food, and maybe order two drinks at once. Just in case. read more

Gigi's - Dessert - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

The view from the patio is spectacular, and the wait staff was professional and accommodating. We really enjoyed our shrimp cocktail and oysters. A little different take on an old staple and it definitely made it memorable. My chicken sandwich was so good. Loved how nicely everything was presented and even the fries were perfect. My wife had a watermelon salad and she said it was the best she's ever had. Loved everything about this place. read more

This meal was actually better than expected. Service was slower and it took forever until someone came and actually poured us water and gave menus, but I had very low expectations for the meal itself given the reviews. Yes, there was construction still going on in the lobby, but the restaurant itself and outdoor table area weren't impacted. I got the lobster pasta and it was a generous portion and not bland at all. The onion rings with the "secret sauce" were well worth it too. For dessert, I wanted to sub out the gelato flavor but the server had to check because the kitchen doesn't like to swap things out, but they ended up being able to accommodate our request. read more

i would give this place a zero if i could, and we never even got to the food. Gigi's took over the spot where Scarpetta used to be, which was one of my favorite restaurants in the Hamptons. It was the only place you could dine, and dine fairly well, while looking at the ocean. Not going there anymore. We had an 8pm reservation, and we got there at 7:55. There are a bunch of tables outside, and then a massive indoor eating area. At Scarpettas, the indoor seating was warm and open, and it felt like you were a part of the outdoor area, especially when you were by the open windows. We were told by the hostess that there was a 30 minute wait for an outdoor table, even though there were 5 outdoor tables open. We were also told that there were 5 couples ahead of us for outdoor tables. They offered to seat us inside, and since we were hungry, we thought we would try that. The formerly warm and comfortable indoor seating of Scarpettas now had the warmth and ambiance of a middle school cafeteria. There was not a single person eating inside this massive tribute to the color cream other than us, and when we asked if they could open the glass doors so we could see outside and warm up a bit (it was freezing inside) they said they could not. So we were dining alone in naugahide hell staring at a dark glass door and freezing, while 4 tables still remained empty outdoors. I'm not sure if they were holding those tables for groups of four, but we were told that outdoor tables were first come first served (you can't reserve outdoors), and we were sitting at an indoor table for 4. So if we took the outdoor tables, since we were there first, and a party of 4 came, couldn't they take the table we were sitting at? It was so depressingly bad that we walked out without ever ordering. read more

Food was excellent and you can't beat the view. Great service as well. I would come back in a second. read more

See all

Complete joke. Manager's attitude is absolutely atrocious. He is right, everyone else is wrong. Worst customer service I have literally ever experienced. Food was inedible, severely undercooked, loaded with salt, and overpriced. read more

During a really lovely 3 day stay at Gurney's Saltwater Spa in Montauk last week, my wife and I had an unexpectedly wonderful dinner at Gigi's. It was really one of the top highlights of our stay. The very nice and helpful waiter, Felix, and the warm and knowledgeable manager, Mimmo, both made us feel welcome and special, and helped us order a delicious and perfect meal. It was so good that we look forward to returning, just to go to Gigi's without necessarily staying at the spa. I couldn't recommend it more highly. read more

We were in the Hamptons recently celebrating my best friend's bachelorette and had planned what was meant to be a special sunset dinner at Gigi's. Unfortunately, what should have been a highlight ended up derailing the rest of our getaway. Half of our group became violently ill for two full days afterward. After comparing what each person ate, we narrowed it down to the halibut, as it was the only dish those who got sick had in common. I contacted the restaurant the next day to inform them and request a partial refund. Despite leaving multiple messages over the following week, I never received a response. I eventually obtained a manager's email and reached out directly. His reply was incredibly disappointing -- he dismissed it as the halibut being "quite rich" and that for guests "unaccustomed to such a savory preparation, it can occasionally cause stomach discomfort." This was not simple "stomach discomfort" -- it was severe food poisoning that left half our group bedridden and extremely unwell. The lack of accountability or concern from the restaurant is shocking. We will not be returning. read more

The restaurant was incredible from start to finish!!! We ordered basically every appetizer on the menu and every single dish was AMAZING , we finished every plate brought to us. Shared the porterhouse & halibut for dinner with sides and that too was incredible. Ordered all 4 dessert items on the menu, each one was better than the next. Our service was great and ambiance beautiful - Loved Thjs place and will be back for sure! read more

See all

We ordered two steaks: one medium, and one medium plus 2. What we received were drastically undercooked dishes, one rare, and the other at best medium rare. My husband's steak was sent back three times, yet each time it was returned with no noticeable improvement. When we requested to speak with the manager, we were met not with understanding or accountability, but with condescension. He attributed the undercooked steak to the LED lighting on the table and insisted that perceptions of doneness vary. Even if that were true, shouldn't a steak ordered as medium plus at least arrive medium? What was most disappointing, however, was not the mistake in cooking, but the dismissive attitude and lack of care shown by the manager. Remarking multiple times that he worked at steak houses in NYC and he knows what he was talking about. At $72 per steak, we expected not just a properly cooked meal, but basic respect and hospitality, neither of which were offered. read more

Was worried the new restaurant would live up to Scarpetta, but I have to say the food was delicious. Ate there for 2 different meals and both times had great service. Can't beat the view so that always helps. Only thing is is extremely expensive which is common in Montauk. read more

I am sure it's tasty, but the only way you get in the general vicinity is to valet park and they were "too busy" to take any more cars. Oh well, plenty of lobster rolls to find. read more

Ignore the haters!! The food, service, and ambience was top notch!! Our table of 8 left completely satisfied, we all all tried dinners from the seared tuna, rigatoni vodka, multiple fillets, to the tomahawk special!! Our server knew the menu, the special, and never left our drinks empty! Do not leave this restaurant off your list of places to see on your trip to Montauk! read more

We went to GiGi's and had a beautiful birthday celebration. the food was amazing! The entire staff is incredible. They were all so attentive and made sure we had everything we needed immediately. I've frequented some of the top restaurants in NYC but I have to say GiGi's blows them all away! Special shoutout to Vladimir and Amos! Vladimir is a professional server with such class and a great disposition. A true gem! Amos the Manager has a grand personality and such a great sense of humor. Amos is a professional and very entertaining. He can make anyone smile and laugh. I love frequenting restaurants where the food and service is fantastic and the cocktails are exceptional! GiGi's is the BEST! The ambiance overlooking the ocean, the delectable food and the entire staff are exceptional. I strongly recommend GiGi's to everyone! THANK YOU to for a very special evening last night! read more

Delicious food, well made drinks, lively atmosphere and superior service in a comfortable modern setting. Our price fixe menu for our party of 15, served family-style, was plentiful and delicious . Don't miss the Hamachi, Tuna Tartare, Wedge Salad, Pepper-crusted Tuna, Phyllo-Crusted Halibut, Whipped Potatoes and the array of desserts. The service was on point, professional and non-intrusive. Daniel our waiter and Mimmo the manager helped to make a special celebration that more memorable. We "night-capped" the evening out at the firepit area over looking the beautiful Atlantic vista complete with great music and fun vibe. read more