I found this hidden gem thanks to a recommendation from the staff at the Montauk Sound View. They told me Bennett Shellfish is a local, family-run seafood spot and, although it isn't a traditional sit-down restaurant, it's the place to go for a fresh lobster roll. It was less than a 10-minute drive from where we were staying, and going there was the best decision! They were offering two lobster rolls for $41, and they were worth every penny. Each roll was generously filled with large chunks of fresh lobster, a little diced celery, and just the right amount of mayo. They weren't overly dressed or packed with unnecessary fillers--the lobster was definitely the star. One roll filled me up, so I packed the second one in a cooler and brought it home to my dad in Nassau County. He loved it and gave it a 5/5 too! They also sell baked goods, and the chocolate chip cookies were delicious. Just keep in mind that there is no seating and you cannot eat on the premises because it's an active driveway. Everything is to go, but the beach is only a short drive away and makes the perfect place to enjoy your food. If you're looking for fresh local seafood, generous lobster rolls, and a no-frills hidden gem, Bennett Shellfish is absolutely worth the visit! read more

See all

I had heard amazing things about it so went off the beaten path and found this small fish store on a private residence with lovely and friendly owners. Follow the fish sign to the location and it's easy to spot Some things to know: it's cash only. The offerings are mostly to take away and heat up at home. The only thing that I saw that you can get and eat right away is the lobster roll. But this is what you should get anyway! So fresh and simple.. not overtaken by other ingredients. The best part? The price.. it cannot be beat. Two for $40 is incredible and the quality is certainly there! read more

Bennett Shellfish - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

Believe what all the other reviews say and I will include mine. We made a point to stop here to pick up lobster rolls to enjoy at Montauk Brewing. Delicious with plenty of lobster meat. Was great to chat with Kimberly as well, personable and knowledgeable. read more

Bennett Shellfish - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

It is literally a shack behind her house. Best part is not how delish or affordable it is but that she is open year round!! We came early spring and most restaurants are still closed but she's open. Lobster rolls 2 for $38!! Cash only. And she is just absolutely lovely!! We will definitely be back read more

Bennett Shellfish - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Finally had the chance to give Bennett Shellfish a try after seeing it all over social media. As others have said here and on the Gram, this is run out of a couple's actual home and as such, there are (understandably) rules to follow. You'll pull into their driveway and ring the bell as indicated. Once we did, there were signs all over about not eating here which, again, understandable, we're in your home. Ambiance is very much to-go counter. We entered to a stressed out lady behind the counter who yelled out "it's cash only!" which I'm guessing has been an issue despite all the very clear signage. Her husband was having some breakfast at the counter and immediately told us that he knew he was breaking "the rules" (dude it's your literal home do what you want). We ordered two lobster rolls as well as clams on the half shell - the total came to $49 which is a steal here compared to other spots. The clams were extremely fresh (just shucked, to the point where there was juice everywhere in this paper container with no top which is great if you can eat it sitting down at a table somewhere...not great if you know you need to GTFO and drive somewhere in your car with it). I saw another couple take their lobster rolls to go and even though the buns were packaged separately, the lobster salad was piled into the same flimsy paper container with no lid. If you don't want people to eat in your house (or driveway), serve these things in actual to-go containers. If you're coming here I would honestly bring your own Tupperware because now my car smells like clam juice. But I guess that's the price you pay for quality seafood and an affordable price out in Montauk. read more

See all

Wow!!! On a daytrip to Montauk this week, we took advantage of Bennett Shellfish's amazing deal of 2 for $40 lobster rolls. The lobster was perfectly fresh, sweet and ample, and the price cannot be beat. I love supporting a business like this, too from local fisherfolk. Its cool how they run it right out of their house, at a side entrance. The little shop was super clean, the owners friendly. Also scored some amazing homemade cookies and good drinks. All in all, miles better than any lobster roll you'd get that'd cost twice that much. No dine-in, but you don't need that. Do what we did, grab the rolls and eat them on the beach. read more

See all

I don't even want to tell people this place is good because it really is THAT GOOD. And forget the lobster rolls! Get in that freezer and try any one of those desserts! The chocolate mousse is something you'll never stop thinking about... Don't go here if you don't want the memories plaguing your mind all day and cause you to think how an hour drive really isn't THAT BAD.. read more

Bennett Shellfish - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

There is not better lobster roll on the island than Bennett Shellfish! Plus you cannot beat the price 2 lobster rolls for $40. Also need to try their fish dip and Lobster Pie. The owners are 14th generation local fisherman and the nicest people read more

Bennett Shellfish - 2 for 1 lobster rolls $40 - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

The lobster rolls were very good but the service was so odd and unpleasant. We asked them if there was a beach they recommended to bring our food to eat and they rudely said we could figure it out. They have a whole menu but were only selling 3 things the day we went, which was fine. They also offered us a $10 size of the smoked trout (also very tasty) but it was the size of a condiment. Not worth the price and I think they overcharged me. Cash only. Nothing notable for the ambiance - it's grab & go. read more

Visited the Hamptons for the 1st time & my friends decided that we wanted lobster rolls. We were unsure about the entrance because we didn't know that it was a literal building that look like a house. Upon entering, we noticed that barrage of pictures on the wall and the countertop with the menu and other food items. We placed our order for the lobster rolls. I really appreciated the fact that they had a 2 for $30 deal, which is very cheap (especially in the Hamptons area) compared to most places that sell lobster rolls for that price or more for just one lobster roll. I decided that I couldn't wait anymore and I want to take a bite of the lobster roll just to see how it tasted. I must say it might have been the BEST lobster roll I've ever had in my life. The owner of the shop told us that the recipe has been her family for generations, and it definitely tasted that way! I love how incredibly juicy and plentiful the lobsters were on the lobster rolls. I know there's a battle between putting butter on the lobster rolls versus using a mayo base spread. Though I prefer both, there was something especially unique about the based used to flavor the lobster rolls. I think I'm more upset that I didn't buy more. I highly recommend this place & would love to come back whenever I am in the Hamptons again. read more

See all

Exactly what you are looking for. No need to shop anywhere else for your standard, classic lobster roll. Great services and ambiance.

sooo delicious! clint was very accommodating with our friendly. will definitely be back read more

Bennett Shellfish - lobster roll and chips - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

Honestly amazing fish dip, except the condiment size container was literally $10. The food was fresh and good. The service was kinda rude though. I felt very uncomfortable there. They were not friendly. read more

Great mom and pop seafood spot with tons of fresh, local, catch options. Found this place on yelp when we were looking for some fresh oysters and they did not disappoint. The fishery is located in the back of the owner/bay man's house and they feature only the freshest long island seafood, ranging from mussels, scallops, oysters, and there famous lobster pie. They also have some delicious chocolate mouse cake, and seafood fixings. The women running the spot was very friendly and helpful. She was also proud to talk about how her husband was a 14th generation bayman and catches what they sell. Definitely recommend if your looking for some fresh seafood to go. They are cash only and have parking in their driveway. read more

Bennett Shellfish - Fresh caught and shucked wild oysters - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

Absolutely the best lobster roll in Montauk...crammed with lobster meat, very little mayo and very little celery. Just the freshest lobster. And, the two-for-one can't be beat! read more

Rumor had it that a lobster roll special could be had in Montauk. The promise was 2 lobster rolls for $30. Well that caught our attention and we headed over to Bennett's. As advertised all of the ingredients are provided for this make it at home delicacy. The result? The lobster rolls were really good, nicely flavored and sized appropriately. Nice to know there is still decent value to be had in Montauk. read more

Best lobster roll we ate in montauk! We tried a few and this was the best in terms of freshness, flavor, and price. Store is locally owned and the owner Kimberly was super sweet they do a 2 for 38 lobster roll all week long and make it right in front of you. Place is cash & takeout only, and a 20 minute walk or 5 minute drive from a chase ATM in downtown Montauk. Would highly recommend to anyone visiting from out of town looking for some fresh seafood read more

Place rocks. The food was excellent! The owner was friendly and so welcoming. The restaurant felt like home (because it is a home). Would recommend to anyone looking for an authentic montauk experience! Stop by for great food and an even better deal that does not break the bank read more

Took a mother's day drive to Montauk from the North fork with my sister and nephews. Had the two for one lobster rolls and inhaled them. Soft unfussy roll, absolutely packed with fresh lobster in a barely there dressing. All you could taste was lobster lobster lobster. Delish read more

The owners wife with warm hospitality served up our 2 delicious lobster rolls to go (take out only) from a batch she just made. Light on the mayo/sauce so that the wonderful chunks of lobster meat were full flavor and abundent. The tasting offered of tuna/blue fish dip was a nice bonus and yummy treat. Highly recommend! read more

Bennett Shellfish - Yummy lobster rolls - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

Bennet shellfish is a small store out of a family home with fresh seafood to go. We visited on a Saturday afternoon, and were able to enter to place our order immediately. We were greeted by the owners and they were super friendly! They answered all the questions we had, and gave us samples to try. We got the lobster pie and some oysters. The Lobster Pie took about 20-25 minutes to prepare -- you just brush some melted butter on top of the pie and place it in the oven, and you are good to go! The pie was creamy and yummy, and the oysters were super fresh too! Their menu apparently changes everyday, so would return to try other menu items when back in Montauk! read more

Bennett Shellfish - Lobster pie - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Place is adorable, in their family For generation and lobster rolls were amazing! Don't forget to bring cash Just go! read more

Best Lobster RoLLs... will be back! Parking very limited! But a great grab & go or take home & truly enjoy the freshest

Great fresh seafood selection to take home. The lobster white pizza is decadent and original. Large amounts of lobster meat spread generously throughout the pie. read more

See all

The OYSTERS!!! were amazing!!!! I love oysters and good quality oysters. Fresh, big, full of flavor! Its not often that you come across wild caught oysters at a reasonable price. The husband catches them and the wife was the one selling them. She was so so kind!!! I can't wait to come back and man if i had more time, i would love to try everything on the menu! read more

Bennett Shellfish - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Mostly takeout. Enough meat for two lobster rolls with two hotdog buns. They also give you a bag of potato chips. Decent portion for $38. There are also some other items for sale (pickles). Service is friendly and the ambiance is neighborhoodly. read more

The Lobster rolls are the Best in town! The staff is so friendly & knowledgeable! My go to seafood store when in Montauk! You wont be disappointed! read more

The woman that runs this is so nice! Note- CASH ONLY and TO-GO ONLY!! She runs this out of her residential home! Lobster rolls and oysters are the only foods ready to eat, you'll get the pies frozen and have to bake them at home. Our lobster rolls were packed and the oysters are shucked right in front of us and both were delicious. read more

A true Montauk experience. Very good lobster roll, and excellent value compared to the other places in town.

Excellent food always fresh and very good prices! Everyone always pleasant and friendly! Ambiance nice and clean!

Second to none the best lobster rolls in Montauk. Should try the smoked fish dip as well, absolutely delicious

Great lobster rolls. Great price. The owners were very friendly. We had our order for takeout ate lunch on the beach.

Besides the obvious quality of the seafood and other products, the overall friendly atmosphere is phenomenal. Finding this oasis of fresh seafood choices is well worth the effort and you will be rewarded. I love Bennett Shellfish because in the end it is truly about Lola Snow's dream. A dream that has her daughter flourishIng helping others by helping run such a first class business! read more

Friendly staff, great oysters and lobster roll! Love this shore side spot for summer days

Great little seafood treasure in Montauk. Was craving a lobster roll and they have a two for one deal for $30. This is NOT a sit down restaurant, but you can get the freshest seafood here for you bring back home. Clint is the owner and he could not be more welcoming and friendly. Since I'm staying at a hotel, I will be going back after I check out, to pick up some fresh oysters and lobster pizza to bring home with me. read more

Take out only, super fresh and tasty! Clean and friendly with a good sense of humor! Lobster rolls are fantastic.

I've never been so disgusted by another human being in my life and I've worked in customer service for years. Do not go here the lady literally stalks you on her security camera before you walk in the door. read more

LOBSTER ROLL! What a great find, and one of few open in early May on a Wednesday. Plump, fresh lobster in a soft roll. We also bought delicious smoked bluefish dip. So pleased to find this shop, family-run for 14 generations. Yum!!! read more

See all

Second day in a row this weekend for clams in the afternoon. So delicious. Only positives for this business. Bring cash.

Hours are irregular. Stopped by twice and no one was there. They're not inexpensive but certainly less than Duryea.