Saw the reviews that werent so great but thought id try it anyway. Should have trusted the reviews. Im not from the area but when meeting a friend decided to try this play upon leaving watertown. Upon walking in guy was on the phone for around 10 minutes as I waited. Bought 1 sub and cheese sticks. came out to 27+ dollars. The board says all subs are XL subs, yet they are regular size youd find anywhere. Price was 12.99 for a sub, I added Cheese and a few other veggies with oil and vinegar. It costs around a dollar fifty more for cheese. Well upon opening my sub there was zero cheese inside. so money already wasted. The bread was regular white subroll bread fine, but the sub is completely lacking in flavor. The meat tasted strange, says its bore head on the board with their official seal up there but didnt taste like it. tasted like shaws meat. lower quality. oil n vinegar tasteless. worst sub ive had in a long time. Its too expensive, few dollars more and I could have got Jersey mikes Cheese sticks were alright. nothing exciting. I wouldnt call this an Italian restaurant by any stretch of the imagination. Maybe be better attentive to your customers when they walk in. I know the owner likes to respond to ppl on here, You should be ashamed of how bad your sandwiches are. If ppl pay for extra ingredients put them in the sub! After this experience its hard to believe the people making complaints are wrong in any way on here. Never again. Do Better. read more

Average neighborhood pizza/sub shop. Plenty of food options. Chicken broccoli Alfredo was a hit with the kids. We loved the onion rings...good crisp/quantity/batter to onion ratio. Subs are alright...ditto on the pizza. Staff is friendly. Plenty of tables to dine-in on. They also sell pizza by the slice. No parking at all, unless you find some on the side streets. The Main Street is too busy and risky to park on. If they get ahold of your phone number, you WILL get random texts with coupon codes from time to time. Ordering online gets a slight discount. read more

See all

Food is good. We ordered 2 chicken parms but my girlfriend wanted extra pickles and y'all slacked on those. & She asked nicely too. Maybe you could hook her up next time. That would be greatly appreciated. read more

Gerry's Italian Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Watertown, Massachusetts

I've been a loyal customer for many years, always been happy with the food and delivery, but last night the food was much later than usual and it was not hot. So I emailed the next day and told them about my experience and suggested they offer a coupon to make up for it. Instead, I got the third degree, so I sent photos of the ticket, auto response to the online order and the time of arrival. I was not only told my computer must have been at fault, the owner (it turned out) was dismissive. All I can say is, they must be under new management as the prices have gone way up, they loyalty coupons have disappeared and the delivery fees are $5.00, making it $20 for a sub. You'd think the owner would at least have been polite. What a shame. read more

The Venetian Chicken is awesome every time!! I am not sure if I have been going there for 10-15 years or more. The staff is always friendly and courteous! read more

I'm not sure if there are new cooks or owners but I've ordered cheese pizza very simple I get crust with a good amount of cheese which is awesome but you lift up the cheese and all that's underneath it is crust you couldn't scrape off a tablespoon or a teaspoon of sauce from this one large slice. Size of portions great delivery time quick also local. read more

Gerry's Italian Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Watertown, Massachusetts

Placed an order for delivery at 5:30pm Friday night. Estimated delivery time was 30 minutes. Cancelled the order at 7:20pm. They say: it's out for delivery. No phone call, no apology, no "how can we make it right" disorganized? Unprofessional? Incompetent? Who cares. Never again. read more

We got two large pizzas (my kids enjoyed them) and wings (which were really good). The show stopper for us was the gluten free pizza. I have tried LOTS of gluten free pizzas, and the crust was delicious and by far the best I've had in the area. While the crust was on the thin side (as gluten free crusts tend to be), it had fantastic flavor and was crispy and soft. Gerry's will be my new go to for GF pizza! read more

My meatballs were cool. Not bad. I had pizza from here too not much of a fan. I wish I had more to say but not much else to say. read more

Gerry's Italian Kitchen - Yum - Pizza Near Me - Watertown, Massachusetts

This place blows now... we spent $90 on takeout and threw out 80% of it... not worth the money or aggravation

Quality food at affordable prices. The dinner for 2 is a great deal as can easily feed 4. Always get a gret meal.

Called Marsalas Italian kitchen tonight in Waltham for my fave pasta dish offered by them, the "chicken abruzzo style pasta dish".. always stellar service , quality, taste from their food.. portions etc over in Waltham . The Guy who answered phone told me to call Gerry's Italian kitchen cuz Marsalas is no more.. so called & ordered the dish & below is what I received... chicken is minimal , cold & hard.. biggest fail is there's almost no sauce here (supposed to be a pink tomato/cream sauce) .. so dry.. even veggies were scarce.. upset/disappointed is an understatement .. Bring back Marsalas or at very least have the chef/cook from over there go show Gerry's place how to make it properly cuz this is no where near the great dish Marsalas consistently put out..! Terrible :/ read more

Gerry's Italian Kitchen - Chicken abruzzo pasta dish - Pizza Near Me - Watertown, Massachusetts

See all

If you want to waste your money...order from here If you want food like the one in photo...order from here If you want to order from a restaurant that doesn't care about their customers...order from here If you want to be taken advantage of as a consumer...order from here If you want your kids to think you're a shitty parent for serving this food to them...order from here Hey Gerry's...get your act together read more

Gerry's Italian Kitchen - The most pathetic pizza ever delivered - Pizza Near Me - Watertown, Massachusetts

We ordered takeout from here while at work and I must save the food was incredible. The Portion sizes are BEYOND generous for the price. The garlic bread, chicken broccoli Alfredo and the rolls are all to die for. Will definitely be ordering from here again read more

Gerry's Italian Kitchen - Chicken Chicken Ziti and Broccoli Alfredo - Pizza Near Me - Watertown, Massachusetts

I have been a customer of Gerry's for over 30 years! The OG Gerry's was amazing and dependable delicious Italian food. I have tried to hang in with the new owners but I just cannot anymore! They constantly get orders wrong and the food is just awful and awfully expensive for sub-par food. You hear staff frequently talking about complaining customers--they should be listening and correcting! Last straw tonight--ordered a pizza and salad--$30!! Sausage and mushroom pizza--literally 6 pieces of sausage and a handful of mushrooms on a quarter of the pizza! Pizza crust overcooked--and tasteless. I threw half pizza away. Folks--DON'T WASTE YOUR MONEY HERE! Go to Belmont Pizza where you will never be disappointed. F*&K this place! Never again. and they will not care! read more

Got a large steak bomb almost 14.00 dollars. Was so disappointed with the sub I think he forgot the steak, they used to fill the sub not now. The Sub had so little meat in it it only would fill half the sub roll I will never go they again. Total waste of time and money read more

Visited Gerry's for the first time in a few years and regretted it right away. We were looking for something close by and decided to order a couple basic things, pizza and a sandwich. Just not good. The pizza was very greasy. It's not good food, nothing Italian about the place, and doesn't seem fresh. I would not recommend at all read more

I have been a customer for many years. This is one of the few places I get takeout from. I've never had a bad meal. Pizza is always great. Salads are amazing. Generous portions of pasta. Employees are always very friendly and smiling. I would recommend stopping in and trying any item. read more

Gerry's used to be one of my go to places for pizza. The recently changed owners or managers and the change has not been for the better. They skimp on the cheese even when ordered as extra cheese. The ingredients don't seem to be the same quality. Can't comment on the other items in the menu but right now I'm not ready to risk it. read more

I have only ever had delivery from Gerry's, so this review is only to discuss the food. Pizza: Full disclosure, I'm a New Yorker, so I'm never going to be fully satisfied with pizza from anywhere but home. Comparing it to pizza places in the Boston Area, I think its about average. It doesn't have any wow factor, but its decent. Pasta dishes: I've had a few pasta dishes from them (chicken Alfredo, baked ziti, penne Al Vodka). Like the pizza, its okay. I think they do pizza much better than their pasta dishes. The last dish I got from them (Alfredo) was drenched in sauce and quite grease. It tasted alright, but probably because I was very hungry. Cannoli: I wonder if its homemade or store bought. I say this because while they tasted fine, they didn't taste fresh. For the price, I won't a fresh cannoli. But they tasted alright. Overall impression of the food: If its the closest pizza place to me (or other pizza places are surging on Uber Eats) I'll order a pie. For pasta dishes I'm going to elsewhere. Its not a bad restaurant, but certainly not worth any hype. read more

I don't usually go out of my way to write reviews. Walked in to pick up my food and workers in the back were making subs with no gloves on. Ordered a steak and cheese, felt sick to my stomach the next day. Last time I order from here. read more

Disappointed. have ordered her many times over the years and was always ok and just ok but for me convenient. I have never had pizza here . My last order was inedible . so called antipasto was a salad mix topped with some rolled up cold cuts . This is the worst "antipasto " I have ever had . Ordered pasta with veal . Sauce was decent but pasta was over cooked and veal was tough and inedible. Will never return , sorry read more

Been ordering from here for years. Occasional lateness and need for follow up, but we're usually pretty forgiving about small stuff. Unfortunately tonight we can't forgive, and we'll never order from Gerry's again. More than a half hour after our Grubhub order was supposed to have arrived, my husband called Gerry's to inquire about its status, at which time the man on the other end of the line told him our order had already left the building. We live less than five mins from this place, so we figure great, 5-10 mins and we'll have dinner. Another 25 mins go by, husband calls again, and as he begins to speak, the guy HANGS UP ON HIM. Husband tries calling one more time, and it rings and rings and rings. Utter failure. Terrible customer service. Never, ever again. read more

Pasta did not taste as good as the last time we ordered door dash never sent the slip to the restaurant definitely not worth the 25 dollars we spent read more

I come here pretty often. This place is absolutely great the food is great whenever I go, and the staff is absolutely awesome very nice people. I definitely would recommend it. read more

One of my favorite spots for good Italian takeout and subs. However, the website is useless for ordering. I always have to call which makes it inconvenient to order. Once that's fixed, I would surely order more often. read more

This is based on their steak tip dinner...all other food has been great. Steak tips, WHAT A HUGE DISAPPOINTMENT!! When you order tips, one would expect chunks of meat but not here....instead, it looks like the end result of cutting a childs steak so they can eat. The tiniest pieces of steak, which total maybe 2-3 tips, over a mound of fries. Not worth $17, so beyond disappointed. Stick to their pasta, wraps or calzones. read more

I'm not sure how is this restaurant operating still. I ordered a slice earlier and once I saw where it was I was disgusted and I ended up throwing it away. The shelves where they had it were so full of dust and the place was dirty. I wonder if there is a committee that checks sanitation in these types of restaurants because man they are dirty. read more

I came in and looked at the menu the counter guy asked me what I wanted,I said I was looking for a meatball sub but it wasn't on the menu. He said "oh we have meatball subs, that's a new menu" I said I'll have one then, he says that'll be $13.75, then I say that all the other hot subs on the menu are $10 he then says "those are the old prices" to which I responded " on the NEW menu?" This place is sketchy read more

Wanted to try something new-order a few things - it took Over 2 hours to get delivered and everything was ice cold - and whne we called to complain they offered nothing -will never go there again read more

Not so great customer service !! Their steak and cheese taste amazing. It was small actually read more

See all

I would give zero if I could. We called ahead and picked up a sub It was terrible but that's not the point. When we got our credit card statement we noticed that they charged us twice , exact same amount but different date ( I had never ordered from them before. We don't live nearby. Happened to be in the area ) we called them and the immediate response was "oh okay just come back and we will give you another sub or we will give you cash ". It sounded so suspicious, as if this wasn't the first time this happened. Come to find out same thing happened to friend of mine when she ordered form Gerry's. I'm sure they must get away with this often. Not many people check credit card that carefully when it's small amounts of money. read more

GERRYS tortellini Alfredo is absolutely amazing!!!!!! I would recommend anyone to get take out here!! ALSO the Caribbean sweet and spicy wrap is delish! read more

They have amazing Italian suns-but don't like anything else from there..the service is alright.Also,they can improve on keeping the place more Clean read more

Gerry's Italian Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Watertown, Massachusetts

BOMB ASS CHICKEN ALFREDO ZITI! Sauce wasn't too thick or thin. HUGGGGGEE PORTIONS for about 10 bucks, which could've fed ~2 people. But girl can eat, so, I did. And I'm happy. Visit this place! read more

Let me start off by saying the pay by the slice setup is awesome. Great slices! So, I read a glowing review posted on the front of the shop for cheesesteaks, ordered mine and it was basically the same flavor as strip-mall beef with broccoli, but without the broccoli. Stay away from it. Would be 4 stars, but took one off for the cheesesteak lie. read more

Just average. Nothing special. Tried the meatball sub and and pizza. Not bad not great just eh. Delivery was fast though. That said, it showed up while Grubhub was showing an in process status. Weird. So I guess they are not using Grubhub delivery. read more

Nice enough guys, they just aren't making the food properly. Ordered here a few ones and am always disappointed. BLT sub? Filled with chopped bacon (basically bacon bits). Chicken fingers? Homemade but done with the egg/bread crumb breading and they didn't give me any dipping sauce so I just had to use ketchup. I'm sorry chicken fingers are fried chicken if you insist on making them in house make them right with buttermilk and flour. Fries were awful, like the lowest grade of frozen fries you can get. If you're doing frozen fries rather than fresh cut you need to get the breaded ones not these limp tasteless bits. Everything was also very oily, I think their fried is set to loo low a temperature. Pizza is doughy. Salads are very meh. In fairness though my girlfriend, who hates everything, got their chicken soup and said it was very good. read more

my staff and I wanted some soup and found Gerry's Kitchen and decided to order. we had the clam chowder and and OH MY GOODNESS we immediately called back to tell them how wonderful it was! honestly the best clam chowder I've had EVER. It was very flavorful and had a sweetness to it that I enjoyed alot so if you havent tried Gerrys Kitchen please try it! HATS OFF TO THE CHEF read more

Will never order from here again. Absolutely zero customer service. I don't know how a business can be run with same ongoing patterns (orders don't arrive, calls are dropped, no one knows what's going on). Food was estimated to be delivered between 30-55 minutes. When it was well pass the window for delivery, I called and they said 10 min (we live less than 5 min). Called again 20 minutes later, same story. I don't even know if the person who answered the phone knew they were running a pizza shop. Done ordering from here. read more