Young girl at the counter was rude and unfriendly. The pizza I ordered, (cheese and pepperoni)…read morewasn't anything like any of the other pizzas I've ordered in the past. The sauce tasted like it was burnt and I believe the dough was old. The cheese and pepperonis hardened up fast as if I had refrigerated it and slid off the crust every time I bit in. I was surprised because I've never had a bad experience here. Then again I haven't ordered in years. It may be years before I visit again.

Hands down my fave pizza locally! I usually get the everything- no anchovies- eewwww- and white…read moresauce. Everyone who's had it loves it! My guy and I can also keep it basic with pepperoni and sausage- just perfect. The workers are all adorable teen/20's who have big smiles and greet you/check you out quickly. This is the Capos that accepts credit cards. The other location, said to be the original in Geneva, does not. They only do cash. I'm a credit card user, so it'll be a while but I plan on checking them out too.

The pizzas are beyond delicious with true cupping pepperoni that takes every single pie to the next…read morelevel. The calzones the Hawaiian the all the meats or the true pepperoni and cheese can't be beat on any of the three. This is hands down the best pizza in the area no question no other contender hard stop. Sauces delicious not sweet not too earthy not like they're putting patchouli in their you know sauce it's delicious The cheese freshly grated none of that cakey yucky came from Sam's club type thing true mozzarella. The calzones we've had there have been amazing meatball and pepper ring, pepperoni and cheese, All the meats, Hawaiian, literally just order all of them You will not be disappointed. We've ordered from the one in King Kone in Perry as well as the original in Madison and the true OG in Duffy's in Madison and they are all absolutely amazing. Thank you Kay Jack for giving us good pizza in the 44081 ZIP code.

It's a good pie place. I was a fan of the dough. The sauce with breadsticks is a bit heavy on the…read morespices. I would order again. My picky eater kids loved it and that's good enough for me!

When this was on Top of the hill back in the day it was the best pizza around. It's not really the…read moresame anymore maybe the sauce has some of those old qualities but I'd say that's about it.

Love their pizza. Wings aren't deep fried so not a fan but absolutely nostalgia and love for their…read morepies and salads. And their dough doesn't make me sick

Always a delicious pizza. I love a good thin crust and lots of veggies. They let you choose 5…read moreveggies if that's all you put on there. If you're a meat lover you can choose up to 3 meats and 2 veggies. The real star is the garlic butter Parmesan sauce they will drizzle on the crust or entire pizza if you like! Worth a try, it's like chipotle for pizza.

Food was good, service was quick, most employees were friendly! Would reccomend this place!read more

The service at this location is stellar. The pizza was ok with a good amount of toppings, but not…read morethe style we prefer. It's a bit bready which was kinda tasteless; not a good dough texture or taste.

I can't believe that this place doesn't pop up when you search wings. Have a cottage close by so…read morewhen we are here we always manage an order of the hot barbecue wings. Some of the best I've had. These guys are always friendly and on time with the orders. Just wish we could get these at home, but happy we could get them here.

Medium pizza supposed to be 10"..... pizza was 8.5" Called…read moreto tell them about size of pizza they were not very customer friendly and I told them I would not order from them again this is about the third time we've ordered from them... and remember why we don't order from them anymore. We used to order from them almost weekly years back.

I walked into a building clearly in the middle of a renovation. I was very curious what such a…read moreplace might produce. I am happy to report. It produced an amazing pizza with fresh mushrooms, and spinach. The crust was superior and the cook was perfect. The beer was great and we will be back Many times. I'm also confident when the renovations are done it's going to be a spectacular location to hang out in as well as eat from.

This is the most excellent pizza and wings we'ever had!! We have been ordering every friday night…read more Delivered hot fresh and perfect. Exceptional pizza. The wings are delicious the hot sauce is so awesome i savor the sauce.

This place has a lot of ups and downs. The food is incredible, but there is ZERO ambiance because…read moreit's designed as a takeout and there's zero parking because of it. Service is incredibly slow but I have never had an issue with attitude, only that it seems like they don't know what they're doing at times. Then again, their wings are so good even if I was mistreated I'd probably come back. Definitely pricey though!

We've passed this place year after year without going in, and boy were we missing out! It's not big…read moreby any means, but very cozy. The kitchen is out in the open and it"s neat to see all the hard work they put into their dishes. I ordered the cheese ravioli and the sauce was the best sauce I've ever had in my life. I was sopping it up with the last piece of bread we got. The ravioli was also cooked to perfection- not too hard or soft. The house salad was really fresh and the vinagarette dressing was tasty as well. Took a piece of the lemon cake to go, and it was also extremely delicious. My husband got chicken parm, and shrimp cocktail, nd he loved both. The portion was huge! All of the portions were huge and you definitely get a great sized meal for the price (the pasta meals come with salads, by the way!) It was super busy and more and more people were lined up for tables, so hopefully we can come by one More time on our trip if it's not too busy! I can see why people wait to eat, because it's 100% worth it! This is now a staple on our Geneva trips for sure.

The people working in the restaurant were just flat out rude. My boyfriend and I went in to place a…read moretogo order tonight and were met with attitude from both the lady cooking and the lady working the register. We were told that they were behind and would not be able to fulfill the order until 7:45 pm. When we tried to place the togo order for 7:45 the people working told us that they weren't taking togo orders anymore. The restaurant seems to be unorganized and extremely terrible with customer service. Between the rude employees and the inconsistency i could care less to go back to this place, the food isn't worth the miserable people working there.