The pizzas are beyond delicious with true cupping pepperoni that takes every single pie to the next level. The calzones the Hawaiian the all the meats or the true pepperoni and cheese can't be beat on any of the three. This is hands down the best pizza in the area no question no other contender hard stop. Sauces delicious not sweet not too earthy not like they're putting patchouli in their you know sauce it's delicious The cheese freshly grated none of that cakey yucky came from Sam's club type thing true mozzarella. The calzones we've had there have been amazing meatball and pepper ring, pepperoni and cheese, All the meats, Hawaiian, literally just order all of them You will not be disappointed. We've ordered from the one in King Kone in Perry as well as the original in Madison and the true OG in Duffy's in Madison and they are all absolutely amazing. Thank you Kay Jack for giving us good pizza in the 44081 ZIP code. read more

It's a good pie place. I was a fan of the dough. The sauce with breadsticks is a bit heavy on the spices. I would order again. My picky eater kids loved it and that's good enough for me! read more

New Place in town for pizza. Got the Hand stretched thin with the sweet sauce with pepperoni, original crust with pepperoni and sausage with the garlic pecorino Romano crust and the pizza logs which were phenomenal. Price is higher than the chains but it's worth it so don't be a cheapo and make this your new place in town read more

See all

Discovered this hometown gem today! This is going to be my new go-to for pizza. Very generous toppings, amazing hand stretched crust, wonderful savory options. Best I've had in a long time! read more

First timer here and I'll definitely be coming back! A little pricey, but definitely worth it!

This is HANDS DOWN the BEST pizza spot in all of Lake County!!! I almost don't want to write this because I don't want anyone else to know The staff is super friendly and the pizza is amazing! Support this local family business it is well worth your dollars!!! read more

We were so impressed with this restaurant, their food and thoughtful service was amazing. They even offered us some to-go plates so we could eat our pizza on the beach with our girls. I also wanted to stress that it's not just good pizza for the region, it's great pizza by ANY standard. read more

I was looking for some good pizza in Madison and found this in my online search. The staff was friendly and welcoming. They explained they had lunch time specials to I chose a couple slices. The crust was delicious, the sauce and toppings just right. I was very pleased to have found this shop read more

Outstanding food, service, and atmosphere! This will definitely be my go to pizza on a weekly basis. Love the pretzels, love the friendliness of the employees and the owners engagement in the community. He even brought in high school students to create artwork in the pizza shop. He's a great, overall human being! You must try the pizza, the pretzels, anything. read more

The Godfather salad is amazing. The pretzels are served cold so is the cheese. The pizza was better than other pizza places in the neighborhood. Clean and bright. No delivery. Staff is courteous. read more

Love this place! Everything we've ever gotten has been good! Pepperoni longs are awesome.....Highly recommend!

We got two pizzas from KayJack yesterday and they were fantastic. We're definitely going back for more! I love their cupping pepperoni. read more

Kay Jack Pizza - Cupping pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Ohio

See all

Have eagerly awaited the opening of Kay Jacks...so happy they have their own space. The pizza is awesome. Best pizza here or anywhere. They make their own dough and their specialty pies are to die for. Can't wait to try some of the expanded menu items. Yes, being new they are working out some timing and supply things - but well worth any wait. Put Kay Jack on your must-try list soon read more

This place, formerly in Duffys, just opened down the street from me. Hands down the BEST pizza in Madison and honestly the county at very least. Great service, very friendly folks. Glad to finally have good pizza in the area. read more

Best pizza my husband and I have ever had. Fresh in ingredients every time and consistent. We love the hand stretched larges. Depending on my mood I love the pulled pork one or the margarita! Owner and workers are so kind and their FB is informative on news and updates. read more

I love the pizza I've been there three times the service is great and the people are wonderful very honest about what you're going to receive and they make sure that you're happy and they make sure you know what you're going to receive has a very nice atmosphere when you go in. Thank you for your service. read more

Awesome pizza! We tried the deluxe and weren't disappointed, it tasted as good as the online pictures looked. We can't wait to try the Margarita pizza next ( or maybe the chicken bacon ranch) we'll definitely be back! read more

The crust was over cooked and the red sauce gave everyone heart burn. The employees were very nice.

My husband and I have ordered the lunch special a couple times here, and they were pretty good. We like the value for the three pieces of pizza you get. Very convenient. But we had ordered their calzone for dinner once and I absolutely loved it, it was pretty much a Stromboli, and at the time we came here no one was making Stromboli at the time we ordered, so I was happy! It was delicious. We ordered a calzone to share this time and it came with pizza sauce inside and I personally was not happy with it, I don't really like pizza sauce and I had just assumed it didn't come with it as it didn't the first time we ordered. So I called to make sure we weren't missing something, the calzones do come with sauce and we just had a mess up the first time. I wasn't calling for anything other than information to make sure next time we order correctly, and Bill offered to remake the calzone without sauce for us. So very nice and appreciated! To be fair my husband loved both versions so it was delicious but the one without sauce was so much better in my opinion, and definitely made me happy! Thanks again to Bill and his crew, they were all so pleasant and happy to make a fresh delicious calzone for us! We will be back! read more

Bottom line, BEST pizza around!! The crust is awesome, we had the red sauce which complimented the crust very well. The toppings were cooked just right too. We are looking forward to trying the white sauce. Bill, the chef, really cares about his pizza and it shows! He's always eager to make sure everyone enjoys their pizza. We are so glad Kay Jack is finally here. read more

I tried 3 pizzas tonight. A margherita pizza, a pepperoni pizza and a sausage / pepperoni pizza. All 3 pizzas were amazing. The dough is not your typical boring pizza dough.The owner takes pride in kind of an artisan dough,very light and extremely tasty. The sauce is very flavorful unlike all the other pizza shops in town...do yourself a favor and order a pizza from this place..you won't be disappointed read more