OM Gooooooodness! First time trying a large pepperoni and sausage with extra cheese When I saw the ovens and pizza pans I had a feeling this was going to be great! And it was DELICIOUS The dough was soft with a crunchy bottom. Not hard or dry. The sauce was freshly homemade with a touch of sweetness. Topping were abundant and fresh too. The three ladies working the ovens and counter were all pleasant as hot as it was I will be back and would recommend Colucci's Pizza read more

Some of the best pizza this side of the Mississippi. The dough and crust has a perfect chew and taste which is a fantastic foundation. The tomato sauce is very fresh and flavorful and tastes homemade and then the toppings and cheese makes this pizza one of the best that I've had. They are not skimpy on their toppings and their sausage is very tasty. read more

Not a lot of custom pizza options but the ones that are...delicious! Very good prices too and gluten free crust options.

Colucci's is a hidden gem! We got the cheese and buffalo chicken pizzas, and I can say that I really recommend their specialty pizzas over a classic cheese (even though it was pretty good, too). I also loved their wings, the chili one was excellent, and the garlic parm was pretty good as well. Inside, there are a bunch of ovens that probably make it very hot in the small space that they have. Their service was excellent and professional, and the food was great. read more

See all

We love Colucci's pizza, been getting it for years. Lately it seems the sauce has changed. Still good though.

Pizza was good, but terrible service. Extremely difficult to get someone to answer for a call in or delivery order. Expect to wait a while

This brings back memories to salvatos pizza at the top of the hill back in the day. The sweet sauce the hand pressed sausage and the high quality ingredients read more

Colucci's Pizza - Pepperoni sausage extra cheese - Pizza Near Me - Jefferson, Ohio

Best pizza around, I live in Ashtabula and go to Jefferson to get their pizza, wouldn't have it anywhere else

I have eaten pizza from places all around this country, including nice Italian pizzerias and restaurants. I have to say without a doubt that I think Colucci's consistently has the best testing pizza I have ever eaten! Way to go Colucci's!! read more

I know if I'm around that area again that's where I'm going for wings. Friendly staff and fast service, I would definitely recommend giving there wings a shot. read more

Found a winner. Homemade dough. Good fresh toppings except for the canned mushrooms and the super finely diced onions(too small). I've been trying pizza joints around the area and have been disappointed. This was the best I've had so far. It's sad how bad the local pizza shops are around here. I ordered from a place in mentor and it was straight up gas station pizza. The dough and the sauce are boss. Do these right and you are a winner. This place is a breath of fresh air. read more

Colucci's Pizza - Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Jefferson, Ohio

Best pizza in ashtabula county. It's hot as hell in the place and the workers still give great service. My recommendation is to grab it as soon as it comes out of the oven. read more

This is one of our favorite pizza places. If you're ever in the Jefferson area then give them a try. We usually order thin crust, extra crispy, extra sauce and pile on the veggies. The people there are always friendly as well despite how hot it can get there in the summer. read more

This pizza is really great! I had the pepperoni supreme, or whatever it's called, with some sausage on it too, and was quite surprised, and pleased, how good this pizza is. While I personally would've preferred more sauce, everything else was quite tasty and well put together. Plus, they use the old fashioned ovens unlike a conveyor belt ovens some places use. Unfortunately only take out but still happy I went! read more

Coluccis, What happened?! I grew up in jefferson and I have loved this pizza for so long. I make it a point to get a pie every time I travel home. I have sang praises to my friends about your pie. I've gone as far as to proclaim that nobody can truly rate a pizza until they've tried Coluccis. I even dream about when I can get my hands on a slice of heaven..... Well Coluccis, you have shattered my dreams and broken my heart. My past two experiences here have been filled with utter disappointment. The pizza is missing it's famous sauce and is nearly flavorless. I actually had to doctor it up myself. Also I noticed the toppings seem to be of lesser quality. My world has been turned upside down. To whom ever is in charge, please rectify this at once! This is a crime against pizza, and will tarnish the great reputation Culoccis once had. read more

Visited the shop during my visit to NE Ohio. I ordered my pizza well done and they did a great job cooking it just right. Tasted great as well. I've heard people say it doesn't taste as good as it did when my grandparents owned the business, but I will say the pizza tasted as good as I imagined it would. read more

I have been getting Colucci's pizza ever since i can remember. It is the only pizza place in Jefferson that doesn't make me sick and you get enough to eat thanks for staying the best around read more

Yumm! These place was so delicious. Just ohio from Cali and didn't know what to expect but the crust was crispy, buttery, garlicky and delicious on my calzone. I scarfed it down. The calzone was not too big, and yummy with the sauce. My other friend who got the calzone loved it too. However my friend who got the pizza said that it was undercooked. read more

I grew up in Ashtabula county and have been going to Colucci's for years. I just bought a couple of pies last week. As always, it was excellent. I recommend giving them a try especially as a break from Dominos and Papa Johns. read more

Very inconsistent on quality. Some orders have cardboard texture. Yesterday's had little sauce and a pinch of topping plopped on one side. Not good. Sometimes the pizza is very good. I guess it depends on who is cooking. read more

I was so impressed with the sauce they use I've stopped going to Papa Johns. You have to give it a try.

Horrible pizza! Ordered two large, because they are only 12", one with pepperoni and the other with green peppers and both were equally disgusting. We have been traveling over 5,000 miles and have eaten at nearly three dozen pizzerias and this is definitely the worst of them all. read more

I have alway liked Colucci's pizza, now the pizza doesn't have much flavor they're making substitutes. I asked for onions they put dried onions on my pizza, I asked for extra sauce I got less than the regular amount of sauce. I guess I'll have to just venture out to other pizza places. read more

Colucci's Pizza - two slices of pizza with toppings - Pizza Near Me - Jefferson, Ohio

Provolone cheese instead of Mozzarella, canned mushrooms instead of "fresh", tasteless sauce? No thanks, I'll spend my money someplace else.