If the year were 2020-mid 2022, this review would have 5 stars! Unfortunately, after the last dozen…read moreor so orders I have placed, today is the day I feel inclined to review. Over several months my s/o and I have been delivered burned pizzas; this also partakes with the sides we order, have been either uncooked or incorrect. We chose to look past this, since normally the food from HOP is great! This evening I decided on takeout, and after a 6 minute drive home I opened my pizza box only to find a "small sized" piece of somewhat cooked dough, sort-of-warm cheese: not at all finished cooking, but at least the toppings were correct... the few pieces that were given that is. All of this aside, this facility has their recipes DOWN! The uncomfortable in-person service and uncooked food is completely indecorous! No coupon or such is wanted... just the great HOP food we love!

Best pizza you'll ever eat!!! Come all the way from Chardon!!! Well worth the drive! Staff very…read morefriendly!!

I've had Maria's Pizza before and it's very good. But when you walk-in during a weekday for lunch…read moreand it's not that busy, what's the excuse for having to wait for the by-the-slice specials? More supply chain disruptions?

Shockingly delicious. I didn't expect this place to be this good. Really really really good food…read morehere . Can't wait to order again

Great pizza, reasonable prices, been going there for many years, only thing that could be better is…read moreopen a little early and earlier on football days. Would be nice if they delivered, but it's worth the drive

Killer dive joint if you like pizza. They sell pizza. Nothing else. They do it right…read more Killer crust, sweet but zesty sauce, incredible amount of toppings. Its a shady looking place but they rock! $16 for a X-Large 3 topping that beats the shit out of any chain. DO IT

Amazing service great people ordered the hot garlic pam wings they were amazing I would highly…read morerecommend to anyone who lIke spicy

We were in the area early April visiting from Southern California. Took our chances walking in, and…read morewere welcomed. The beer is very cold food is amazing. We liked it so much we were back the next day for stake at noon. Great owner and bar tenders. Highly recommend Taylor's Pub. I wish I was there right now. Enjoy.

Best and original Pizza! Been consuming for 45 years and ready for my next slice. Everything…read moreelse rocks

Yay!! I finally got to try it!!! I'd heard that the Geneva Capo's was a religious experience. It…read morehad been closed for renovation, and there was also a passing of the torch from Dad to Son. Love that. Also, they now accept credit cards- woohoo! That was a challenge for me previously as I don't carry cash. Friends of mine turned me onto the Grinder which normally I'd be meh about- it was epic! The pizza- we ordered a white sausage/pepperoni with capicola and it was perfection!!! Wow! The location, just off Broadway, has indoor seating as well if you choose to dine in. I believe I met the owner while I was picking up, told him it was my first time at this location and he had such a happy demeanor and assured me I chose well and he hoped I'll be back! Extra bonus love for the super friendly- especially as he was multi tasking and they were busy! I feel both locations of Capo's are awesome, but this one is sincerely a gem.

The pizza was prepared well, but after I slipped on the stairs they refused to honor the 'Carryout…read moreInsurance' that is on their website. Had to throw out both pizzas. Would not recommend for future orders.

Wish I could leave 0 stars or I would. First off took over two hours to be delivered when they told…read moreme only 45 mins. I only live 12 mins from the store but I had a sleeping baby when I placed the order or I would have just went and picked it up myself. Second it arrived luke warm but again my kids at this point were starving so it is what it is. Lastly the delivery woman lied about why it took so long. I know it's not her fault it took so long but don't lie. I'm not going to tip once it's been over 2 hours, you lie to me and I just paid $63 for some hardly warm pizza. Avoid ordering delivery from this location, it's not the first time for me it took forever.

The pizzas are beyond delicious with true cupping pepperoni that takes every single pie to the next…read morelevel. The calzones the Hawaiian the all the meats or the true pepperoni and cheese can't be beat on any of the three. This is hands down the best pizza in the area no question no other contender hard stop. Sauces delicious not sweet not too earthy not like they're putting patchouli in their you know sauce it's delicious The cheese freshly grated none of that cakey yucky came from Sam's club type thing true mozzarella. The calzones we've had there have been amazing meatball and pepper ring, pepperoni and cheese, All the meats, Hawaiian, literally just order all of them You will not be disappointed. We've ordered from the one in King Kone in Perry as well as the original in Madison and the true OG in Duffy's in Madison and they are all absolutely amazing. Thank you Kay Jack for giving us good pizza in the 44081 ZIP code.

It's a good pie place. I was a fan of the dough. The sauce with breadsticks is a bit heavy on the…read morespices. I would order again. My picky eater kids loved it and that's good enough for me!

Went there when I was a teenager. Moved away for nearly 20 yrs. Then came back and it's just as…read moregood as I remember

Haven't been here for six months but wanted some good burgers & chili fries so we stopped here…read moretoday despite the rain. Ordered 3 Papa burgers no cheese extra sauce, 2 chili fries no cheese & 2 root beers to go. When we got home our burgers were thrown together & barely had any lettuce but had pickles & a dab of papa sauce. The fries were loaded with cheese, guess the girl taking our order didn't understand we wanted No Cheese. We were very disappointed with our meal especially the fries because we could only eat the bottom without cheese. Our root beers were delicious & the restaurant was very clean. Do not waste your money on their food even though they have wonderful root beer. We won't be back!

Always delicious! The order is always ready on time. Everyone is very friendly when you go. The…read morebest pizza around!

I love this place. I…read moregrew up in New York City and this is easily the closest to NYC pizza anywhere around here. And even if you don't care about NY style pizza, it is just flat out terrific pizza, with the perfect chew to the crust and top notch toppings. Good beer selection (with a chilled glass). And staff is always very friendly. My only negative is that it isn't closer to my house.

For genuine Italian pizza this is your place to go. These folks know how to cook. They've been…read morearound along time and once you try the food you'll see why. The service is excellent and the place is well kept.

Pizza and salad was delish! We loved the salad we ordered. They were not skimpy on the cheese and…read morethe cheese was a perfect addition!