Great place to visit on your hunt for seeing some rare and unique toys, however that's all you'll…read morebe doing is "seeing" them because pretty much all the vintage and rare items are not for sale. Owner is very friendly and nice, but it's really not a shop you need to visit if you're actually trying to purchase something for your collection.

Great shop packed with something for everyone…read more Visited from Ohio last weekend and was blown away by the selection. Everything from wrestling to horror toys to NES games. Prices were fair and ranged depending on the item. The shop owner was nice & helpful. Don't pass this place up of you're in the area.

Asked several times about One Piece Box Prices. 500 years in the future @ Game Universe: $175,…read moreonline: $115-125. Same thing with OP-06, Wings of the Captain. Purchased a box on TikTok for $130. TCGPlayer had it for $145-160. Asked front desk... $264. Looking for one piece cards, avoid this shop

Cool little game shop, great rpg and board game selection. Friendly staff and clean space.read more

Despite the size of the store has quite a large selection of both vintage Newark games and games to…read moreplay

Cool store! Lots of old video games and accessories. Fair prices too. They also have some old…read moreschool arcade games, trading cards, dvds and vintage merchandise in general.

I loved the service that I got from here, every time I asked a question over the phone they were…read morereally nice and actually gave a crap what I was looking for!

Wow this place is very nice and organized. What I like about the workers here is the fact that…read morethey know their store anything you ask them they have an answer. All The games they have are in good quality. Too bad is too far from My place I recommend it to all the gamers out there have fun

The Service these guys provide is great!!! Got to handed to their enthusiasm and care for the…read morecustomers and the store itself, they have a lot of good selections of music, games, toys etc. Although the layout is average for a store it's kinda cramped when walking through the store when you're in a group of three ( don't try bringing and carry a book beg here it'll will get in the way of people walking around) and there is no public restroom here. Other then those two things this place is great, and would come back again.

Shopping here feels like buy deodorant for 15$. You may like the smell but receipt never makes…read moresense, I hate everything about the store with their prices and I want to just toss this brand buy my own. Again, everything about this store, simply not worth it, if this were a candle store I'd probably never walk back in and this has games. - lack of games - overpriced games - forgetful staff - not useful policies - (Broken games) - jaded staff - theft of discounts and useless membership(literally just giving them extra credit for their stocks and prices, which they will take from you regardless of whether you're a member or not) - (Overpricing for taxes) - The games The scammy, scummy and their games suck, the only reason I'd go back is if their consoles are cheaper than the ones online. They have 200$ games and half a thousand dollar consoles, I rest my case.

Disney Lorcana booster packs are $5.99 MSRP.. this store sells them at $14.. a $8 mark up. Worse…read morethan scalpers. You can get them cheaper on eBay. Dont support stores like this.

Eric at xtreme games is always welcoming, kind and helpful. Is very knowledgeable about disc golf…read moreequipment and is a great resource to new players or veteran players alike. He is kind and patient with children and always friendly. He goes above and beyond when it comes to customer service. I would highly recommend xtreme games for anyone looking for disc golf, Pokemon cards, magic the gathering, board games, and much more. I've used their online catalog many times when searching for hard to find Pokemon cards.

Game Together MKE has the best selection of retro video games in Milwaukee, especially games in…read moretheir original boxes, but their prices are higher than similar stores in the Oshkosh/Appleton/Green Bay area and the offers they make for your items are not as good. During my most recent visit I felt insulted by what they offered in trade for six of my GBA games that Price Charting had valued at $154 (they offered $65 which is only 42% of the value). Just the day before, a store in Appleton offered me $50 in trade for the highest value game by itself (I didn't have the other five with me and only decided to trade all six while I was there). Needless to say, I left with my games and without the console I wanted to trade for, which was also priced higher than at the store in Appleton. The lack of other quality options in Milwaukee dictates that I can't completely rule out going to Game Together MKE again and that's probably why they price things the way they do. I wish there were other options in Milwaukee or that they treated their customers with more respect.

I had heard good things about Game Together MKE, and was excited to find a place that specialized…read morein video games, because I couldn't find anyplace else like that here in Milwaukee. Me and my brother both were excited about this, and so we went together one day to check it out. I would say they had a pretty cool selection, however that is about where the positives stop. My brother noticed one of the limited edition N64 controllers (jungle green if you must know) paired with a regular N64 console behind the front desk. My brother was ecstatic about this, as he has a jungle green N64 but does not have a matching controller for it. He asked if they would be able to separate the jungle green controller from the regular N64 and he could purchase the controller itself. They said they wouldn't be able to do that. We thought that was kind of ridiculous since they had other normal n64 controllers they could've paired with the n64, but whatever. I ended up purchasing a Batman game for the Sega Genesis as well as a Sega Genesis Controller, and my brother purchased a copy of Frogger for the Gameboy color. When I got home, I immediately tried to play the batman game, and it wouldn't boot. I pulled it out and cleaned it, noticing that the connector pins were filthy and obviously hadn't been cleaned by the business before they put it on the shelf. After cleaning, it booted fine. I then tried to use the controller. The controller, also, did not work properly, and half the buttons felt sticky. I opened the controller and it very clearly had had some sticky liquid spilled into it at some point. Even after cleaning the controller still did not function correctly. This isnt really my experience nor my purchase, but I thought I should note that my brother's frogger game was also filthy and even after cleaning still did not boot. There is clearly terrible quality control at this business, and they don't actually test or clean their equipment/games before selling them. I will not be returning to this business.

Looks like I had the opposite experience of other reviews today. Great staff! Larry was incredibly…read morehelpful, as well as the other two associates. They not only worked together to help me get what I wanted, but also greeted every customer and helped them simultaneously.

The staff was never pleasent but they weren't insulting rude. Not that I went often but I really…read morewon't be going back.

I love this place, prices are great customer service is great, and not a single complaint about…read moretheir selection! They may have what you're looking for, but if they don't they ask if you want to be put on a list to be notified when they get one in. This place is a true believer in physical media and I love it. If you're a video game, movie, or music fan you need your check this place out!

Several employees working not doing anything but talking to their coworkers. Store was dirty and…read moreunorganized and the bathroom was filthy. I do not recommend.

Living nowhere near this place, I'll most likely not be back, but I had a very positive experience…read morehere. The owner was very nice, and the wide selection of old and new video games dating back to Atari 2600 could have kept me occupied for hours. I was able to find two games I had been looking for for a while, both at prices at or better than I had seen anywhere else.

Good selection of retro video games and very fair pricing. The owner was easy to negotiate with…read morewhen selling items to him too. Definitely a place to come back to.