The store paid out well when they first opened and needed stock. Now that they are stocked up with…read morewhat my buddy and I brought opening week, they pay like 10 cents a dvd. Rare stuff you might get $1. They preach a business model of "paying top dollar" but let me tell you, that is a lie. If you confront them on social media, don't worry, they will just delete the comments and block you instead of explaining their practices. I literally saw a blank VHS tape in the infamous glass case for $8. Ridiculous. Save your money and go to Preplayed in green bay. They will be straight up and honest with you. If you're looking to buy, go to Half Price Books in Appleton as well. Won't be going back to this store. What a let down.

Several employees working not doing anything but talking to their coworkers. Store was dirty and…read moreunorganized and the bathroom was filthy. I do not recommend.

Living nowhere near this place, I'll most likely not be back, but I had a very positive experience…read morehere. The owner was very nice, and the wide selection of old and new video games dating back to Atari 2600 could have kept me occupied for hours. I was able to find two games I had been looking for for a while, both at prices at or better than I had seen anywhere else.

Good selection of retro video games and very fair pricing. The owner was easy to negotiate with…read morewhen selling items to him too. Definitely a place to come back to.

Great selection of comics, magazines and statues. They also have a very helpful and friendly staff…read more Will be back.

They've done a great job cleaning up the place and improving the lighting. Fantastic for back…read moreissues. They also have an array of used DVD's and video games, plus a wall full of great action figures and collectibles. Also, they participate in Free Comic Book Day.

I had this nice black gentleman named Dwayne assist me when I was searching for a preowned 3DS. I…read morelooked all over the place and when I got to the mall he showed me all their available models and really helped me out. He showed a lot of personality and professionalism and I was in and out in a jiffy. He even got me to sign up for their membership and got a great deal! Hope you're doing well Dwayne

This store is Top Notch!! The manager and staff are very helpful and fixed an issue I was having…read morewith equipment I got from the Portage WI store. I ordered a PS4 pro from them and what they sent wasnt tested and was total mess. The PS4 Pro wasnt cleaned so the fans were as loud as a plane landing. Before equipment goes out it needs to be tested and CLEANED with a compressor and opened up to check the parts - none of that was done. Plus I got an old sticky worn controller and a cream colored short computer cable for the controller?? Everything was suppose to black and the cord should be 10ft. I had this machine for 2 days and realized it was junk and no quality checks were done on it before shipping it out. I went into the Mayfair and the manager was so helpful, he exchanged everything with an explanation of how it should run and sound. He personally tested my new unit. The controller seems new, the cable is black sturdy and 10ft but the best part is the machine is AWESOME !! Ive been playing it now for 4 hours and its quiet as mouse! I trust this store, they know what they are talking about. So happy now!!

Used extremely manipulative wording to have me pay for something 300$ over price charting. I…read moreshould've known better but I'm young in life experience and in the hobby of collecting. Genuine POS with profit in mind over people.

Not a welcoming environment for retro game collectors if you plan on shopping around. Would rather…read morepay double at another place if it means we can look around. Owner needs to work on his professionalism as a one man job. I understand rules as a business, but maybe let the costumer know at the door/before entering rather than letting them stand there waiting to be attended.

Was in Milwaukee and had Record Head on my list. The store is huge and offers both new and used…read morerecords including other items. I searched the used section and found records that were on my wish list that were of great value. Street parking is limited. My tip is to park in the lot behind the store. If you are in to vinyl you will want to plan to visit Record Head, I am very happy I did !!

I bought 2 controllers from their games section and one was faulty, one didn't even work at all,…read morewas told they were refurbished but the screws on the back say otherwise. I also took my signed soldout shows modern rapper vinyl and they said they didn't do modern artists despite having frank ocean on the wall after being offered a whopping $10. AVOID!! These people have gentrified the hobbies.

What's better than FREE arcade games? NOTHING…read more I saw this place on social media and was definitely intrigued by the notion of completely free to play arcade games, so I HAD to check this out I was not disappointed. Dozens of free arcade games galore! Also, if you want to buy some games to take home as well as sell old games and systems this place has you covered too! Friendly service, the value was about what you'd expect for the going rates of new and used games, so all in all, pretty dang good!

Game Together MKE has the best selection of retro video games in Milwaukee, especially games in…read moretheir original boxes, but their prices are higher than similar stores in the Oshkosh/Appleton/Green Bay area and the offers they make for your items are not as good. During my most recent visit I felt insulted by what they offered in trade for six of my GBA games that Price Charting had valued at $154 (they offered $65 which is only 42% of the value). Just the day before, a store in Appleton offered me $50 in trade for the highest value game by itself (I didn't have the other five with me and only decided to trade all six while I was there). Needless to say, I left with my games and without the console I wanted to trade for, which was also priced higher than at the store in Appleton. The lack of other quality options in Milwaukee dictates that I can't completely rule out going to Game Together MKE again and that's probably why they price things the way they do. I wish there were other options in Milwaukee or that they treated their customers with more respect.

There was a good selection of toys and the staff was fun. I purchased a cool puzzle at a reasonable…read moreprice.

I love this place so much, even as a teen i admit, i go there quite a bit to pick up some candy and…read moremaybe a trinket after i get payed, the owners are amazing, and the rest of the staff is also very nice! If you're looking for a good local toy shop I would highly recommend this place.