Oh my gosh... that's truly the only thing I can think to say!! You HAVE to try this place! The…read moreshakes are HUGE and so fun and fancy. You get to keep the cup as well when you're done. The service is great, food is great. The inside is quite small, so we had to wait for a table outside, but that's just a testament to how amazing this place is!

If I could, I'd rate this place a 0 but since I can't, it's getting a 1. My family ordered two…read moremilkshakes, the Bonnie and Clyde and the Cheer Up Buttercup. Keep in mind, they were $30 each! The toppings looked nice, but both milkshakes tasted like burnt plastic. We told one of the workers, who went to speak with the manager. The manager said there was nothing they could do and even admitted they'd gotten similar complaints before but still refused to fix it or offer any refund. They said they'd "call the higher-up managers," but nothing happened. We were shocked at how expensive it was and even more disappointed by the lack of customer service. Save your money don't come here.

They didn't have pistachio flavored ice cream so I deducted a star... but I decided to get a New…read moreYork cheesecake milkshake. Which was delicious. Service was a little slow but I think that's cause the girl was holding down the fort on her own. The ambiance has the feel of an old school creamery.

So I stopped to get my daughter an ice cream for her birthday. One scoop in a cake cone $5, ok a…read morebit pricey but not a big deal, but they could not take tap or break a $50. Luckily, I had my cash app card. The ice cream was melting so bad I asked for a cup and spoon, and the lady asked for 10 cent, she knew I only had my cash app card that Im not running for 10cent. I assume she would have just given us a cup since we bought an ice cream. Kinda disappointed in the price for quality and service, probably won't be coming back, it's just not worth it, I can get her a $2 ice cream that you charge $5 for, somewhere else and I'm sure they won't mind giving us a 10 cent cup either.

Asked for an ice cream cup to put the broken waffle cone in and this is what we got. The cone was…read morebroken when you handed it over. Same with the customers in front.

Disappointed in this place. They ran out of kids cups for ice cream and I was told by the owner…read morethat I can use the kids cup that they have for display if I still wanted to do a kids cup for my 2 year old. Sooooooo, you want me to use a cup that's used for display, that others have touched, for my kid? Yea. No thanks. If you can recommend something unsanitary like that, it makes me wonder what other unsanitary stuff this establishment does.

Customer service is good They always seem to be out of…read moresomething Most all yogurt has a great taste to it Great toppings as well Some seating inside and some outside

I came here on a warm afternoon perfect day for a frozen treat. I got a mix of flavors including…read morestrawberry. It was a little too sweet for me. It wasn't busy at all and they had plenty of seating. The parking was difficult; we had to park 4 streets down.

What a shitshow of a location to access. But it's all about…read moreto be OK because they have butterscotch sundaes!

Party of 10 all wanting a frozen treat on a warm evening. No one was there when we got there and we…read moregot our ice cream quickly. All of a sudden the place was packed but we had our treats and off we went.

Great variety of cobblers! They also have cookies and milkshakes. They taste homemade. Great…read moreservice and very friendly. Will definitely order again.

Stopped in to try out the peach cobble, when you walk in the smell is fantastic! Greeted with the…read morebest service as there are many choices. We decided on the peach cobbler with vanilla ice cream and the banana pudding with red velvet cake. Both were delicious! The peach cobbler had just the right amount of crust and peaches, the banana pudding was so flavorful. We are here for another day, might have to come back to try the cinnamon roll and the shakes. You place your order at the counter, there are tables to eat inside or take it to go, parking is a shared parking lot, also a cute small kids playground next to it, We will definitely come back the next time we are in Columbus

Literally parked in front of the place when we were trying to explore downtown. Saw the extreme…read moremilkshakes people were eating curbside and decided we had to try it. Small little ice cream shop with a few tables outside serving extreme shakes and a few food items, including hot dogs. Had the chili dogs with tots. Great flavor! Finished up with a Say Cheese strawberry cheesecake shake. A bit pricey but it was plenty for two of us to share. It's nothing fancy but everything was good and the Staff was helpful and friendly.

Excellent milkshakes, rude and impatient service. Daughter…read moredidn't even order because of this.

What a cute paleteria! So many flavors to choose from! And they have other snacks also. I got…read morethe mango paleta, it was perfect, the right amount of sweetness and texture. We definitely want to come back and try other items.

Putting aside the identity issue of the place unless I'm missing something (ice cream slash…read more7-11nacho bar.... The ice cream really didn't taste that good. It almost didn't taste fresh which does not make sense because it's frozen and ice cream. Also, the guy serving was not very welcoming or friendly, like he was almost annoyed that we were there. The corn in the ice cream must be a Mexican thing, I didn't get it There's also Ben & Jerry's in the same block, I don't see this place making it, which is unfortunate because I like to support small business.

Extremely friendly and professional staff. Clean & inviting atmosphere. I love that there are…read moretables and chairs in an open area to get some of the sun and enjoy the weather. Hands down one of the best Italian ices we've ever tried! Mouth watering deliciousness!! Will be coming back here when we come back South.

I've visited here several times over the years and it remains consistent. I have some dairy dietary…read morerestrictions, so their italian ice options make it easy to have something sweet with out restricting any flavors. My favorite is the pina colada because it has small pineapples in it. The customer service is always amazing and they're always smiling and willing to give you recommendations. It's clean and welcoming. You have to try sitting on the patio on the warmer days!

This place was ok. Service was very slow and took a while to make our three items. It appeared the…read morecashier was learning, so it didn't bother me, but if you're trying to get something quickly this might not be the spot. The two slush bowls took the longest. I would suggest switching to cups instead of bowls so it's easier to eat. I didn't have any beans in my bowl as described on the menu. Plenty of seating inside.

!!!DO NOT GO HERE!!! Something sketchy is going on at this "business". I was charged $475. on…read more7/21/23. I live 1700 miles away. And $475. at an ice cream shop? I called twice, both times got the runaround. GIVE THE MONEY BACK. This is the last time I am asking. ***edit*** I just spoke to the owner. His story is, supposedly a gentleman came in their store last Friday, WITHOUT AN ACTUAL CREDIT CARD, said he "forgot the card but knows the number" ???!!!***###!???? So the employee went ahead and charged 475. for a "GIFT CARD" without the "guy" using an actual card??????? WTF