New Paltz, NY - great sandwiches that hit the spot! We picked up a few on our way to the Mohonk Preserve, and ordered a Cubano (I'm told a customer favorite), Italian combo, trifecta combo, and muffuletta, which could've been more olive-y but you don't commonly find this New Orleans staple around these parts so I was glad to see it on the menu. This is mostly a takeout joint though there are a few counter seats. You can also purchase jars of Frank's own house-made pickled goods, preserves, and bottles of hot sauces in the store. I haven't tried those but hear they're good so will pick up some next time. read more

See all

Ordered a couple of sandwiches for lunch. Nice and friendly service. Menu full of cool sandwiches. Had the roast beef on a hard roll and a panini with turkey and pesto. Fresh deli meat and bread. Pesto excellent. Flavors combos were very good. Wish there was a little more meat in the turkey panini. Tried some pickles to go along with the sandwich and not impressed. Too large, sweet and vinegary. Would prefer a naturally fermented Kirby pickle. Very fair prices for very good quality sandwiches. 4.5 stars. Will return read more

See all

I love this place! The staff are always so nice and friendly, the sandwiches come out quick and are very filling. The place is so cute with 7 seats at a bar facing the window (meaning a table that's higher than a table) and a bench with table in the back. Definitely recommend!!! By the way: They prefer cash read more

I love this place! The sandwiches, the banter, watching the magic of making the sandwiches come together at the counter. The specials are always top notch. The AEPhi is always a great choice. I'm going later today! read more

Frank’s Fresh Pickling - Roast Pork Special Sandwich - So juicy and flavorful! - New American Near Me - New Paltz, New York

Yummy wraps - perfect for hiking and hitting the road. Got tuna wraps - would love to try the other ones next time! read more

Frank’s Fresh Pickling - New American Near Me - New Paltz, New York

Amazing simple fresh sandwiches here, appreciate a simple written menu with exactly what in every sandwich. I got Tom's pesto and there plenty of meat, not a huge amount of the greens as filler and two slices of fresh mozzarella, with homemade pesto. Peasant bread was amazing too, soft but with a great crust. read more

See all

So glad this place is here. No need to drive to POK. The panini are fresh, delicious and tasty!! I got some chicken salads. This could be hit or miss, a lot of times with too much mayo or not enough seasoning. This was spot on. Pickles are lovely and crispy. We walked in with no one there and all before 1130 the place was packed w regulars. By 11:50 all of our food was wolfed down. Insert happy babies and happy mom. Thanks for the advice, patience in choosing breads, and a FAST, convenient, lovely and easy lunchtime fix. Would Definitely recommend and return. The space is a market selling spice blends, pickles , and sauces. To the right is the kitchen where the magic happens. An efficient space and friendly service w a smile. read more

Frank’s Fresh Pickling - Chicken salad on sourdough - New American Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

This is such a great sandwich shop! I typically go with the Cubano, but every other sandwich I've tried on the menu is great. The sides in the display counter are also wonderful. I usually bring them to family cookouts and they're always a hit. Of course, make sure to get some pickles... they're the best around IMO. read more

Our experience at Franks Fresh Pickling was HORRENDOUS. Upon arrival we were bullied and talked down to as customers. My friend mispronounced the sandwich name and the employee mocked her to her face and left to go to the bathroom...when our sandwiches were "ready", he made fun of the way she said it again and then we were only given once sandwich. When we told the larger older man working that we had another sandwich he responded with "You need to speak up." We left the establishment already irritated with the lack of respect from the employees. For the finale, our sandwiches were made wrong??? I don't know how that is possible after the countless altercations we had previously but Frank the owner should fire the rude larger man because his sandwich making skills are MID. read more

The food was amazing. We had three different sandwiches and wraps. All were so so good!! The owner Frank is the best! read more

Hands down the best sandwiches in New Paltz! I am addicted to the pickles! Came in yesterday with a few friends who have never been to Franks before, now they cant wait to go back! Fast service, not expensive, fun names for the sandwiches, highly addictive pickles. read more

Frank’s Fresh Pickling - Logo on shirts and front sign - New American Near Me - New Paltz, New York

Frank's fresh is always well worth the stop! You can't go wrong here. This place has great sandwiches for pretty affordable prices. Everything is usually worth it, but my personal favorites are the 1) Mushroom Salad, 2) Olive Salad, For Sandwiches: 1) Chicky Bird, 2) Trifecta Combo, 3) Joe Fatz read more

Frank’s Fresh Pickling - Left: Trifecta Combo, Front: Chicky Bird, Middle Bottom: Mushroom Salad, Middle Top: Olive Salad, Right: Log of Mozzarella! - New American Near Me - New Paltz, New York

Excellent sandwiches and pickled items. The Cubano is my favorite (they really nail the combo of meat and cheese and pickles and condiments and then perfectly grill it on the panini press), but every sandwich has been great. If you really want to taste what Frank's is all about, make sure your sandwich choice has pickles or pickled onions! While your sandwich is being prepared, have a look at the jars of pickles and sauces and jams. My favorite are the Marinated Sweet Bells (watch out for the cloves!). The bread and butter pickles are wonderful too. If you like to try new things, the pickled radishes smell funky but are delicious on a sandwich. My only unsuccessful purchase was a hot pineapple habanero sauce and it was unsuccessful not because of the quality of the sauce but because of my own lack of fortitude! I still may give the pickled jalapeños a chance some day, though, if I'm feeling brave. read more

Awful experience! I walked in ordered a cheese sandwich. The guy was so rude and unfortunately unprofessional. He made my sandwich never put gloves on and answered the phone. He seemed like he was coming down from a high or was high "coke high" couldn't stop sniffing snot. I asked if he put cheese on my sandwich he was like nope. Then he went to take off the gloves and said oh I'm not wearing gloves. I paid 9.00 for cherry peppers lettuce and tomato. Sad because it's a super cute place. I will never revisit and yes I tossed the sandwich! read more

First encountered Frank's Fresh Pickles the day after I moved to New Paltz a week ago. A friend introduced me to it as a "go to." I was skeptical. I'm from Astoria, NY, I grew up a bit of a deli snob. I mean, we know "good deli" in Queens! But I stopped in another day and asked one of the guys making these awesome sandwiches) l aaked one he liked best. He said, "The Julio!" (named after himself I later learned!) And I was blown away! So much that yesterday I ordered a Julio, a Daddy Slaw, a Cubano, an AE Phi, and an Italian Combo on my way back down to see my family! Their Queens skepticism disappeared immediately as my 3 year old grandson exclaimed "These are GOOD ... I like what you brought us so much!" through mouthfuls of hoagie, turkey and pesto! read more

Frank’s Fresh Pickling - A Smorgasbord of Frank's Pickles Sandwiches! - New American Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

Great Sandwiches, the service was friendly and quick, love the vibe. Check them out I recommend the Tuna sandwich!

One of the best sandwiches in the Valley. I was hoping for a good meal and all expectations were surpassed.

No pics because I wasn't anticipating doing a review but the AE Phi panini deserves some recognition. It's a turkey panini with pesto, mozzarella, spinach, and tomato. That really hit the spot. My friend and I both agreed that it was delicious because we ordered the same thing. We were pretty relieved to find this place after walking down main street in search of some lunch. If you're looking for an easily accessible pit stop from I-87, New Paltz is your town and Frank's is your sandwich destination! read more

I am very upset that this place is so delicious because I live two minutes away. I am going to want to get these sandwiches all the time! Absolutely delicious! read more

Frank’s Fresh Pickling - Tom's Pesto - New American Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

I'd give them a 100000/10 if I could. Juliano, Frank, and Versailles (I think that was his name) are the best. amazing service and even better food, or vise versa, idk... both too good to choose read more

My roommate and I visited for lunch, We were welcomed by the kind workers, we took a while looking at menu and has questions and he was very patient. I did "build your own" sandwich and I was very pleased! We sat by the window and their little daughter came and sat with us- she was so sweet! We will definitely be back :) read more

Best sandwich! Fresh deli meats sliced as they prepare your sandwich. I think the secret ingredient is the roasted red peppers in a seasoned balsamic! Mmmm!!!!!! And did I mention the bread? What? No! Ok well it was also delicious. Stop here after shopping around town. Sorry no photo, we devoured the Italian sandwich we ordered and added bonus, the employee who waited on us was polite and friendly. read more

Ate here while exploring New Paltz on a rainy day. Delicious sandwiches and fun atmosphere. One of our sandwiches was delayed but they ended up giving it to us for free. Highly recommend the Oregano Gangster. read more

Amazing food. Great staff. An overall cool place to stop in for a bite to eat. We never drive through New Paltz without a stop at Frank's Fresh. read more

Really good sandwiches- slightly disappointed that sandwiches that were listed without lettuce were covered in piles of shredded lettuce.

Frank makes an excellent sandwich and his service is impeccable! Came all the way from Chi-town and it was definitely worth the trip! Check out Frank's Fresh you won't be disappointed. read more

The meat they used in my sandwich hardly had any taste, but the bread and sauce was good. The pickle on the side was good as well. The guy working there was very nice, and the place had a bit of charm but didn't have much atmosphere. The natural wooden tables were nice to sit at though. read more

Went on a walk and stumbled upon this sandwich shop, pleasant and very friendly owner, glad to see a new restaurant and on top of that, a sandwich shop, will definitely be coming back. He offers daily specials, merch, spices, sauces, and plenty more. read more

Frank’s Fresh Pickling - New American Near Me - New Paltz, New York

Beyond delicious sandwiches!! Yum had the FIREBIRD and my bf had the APD. Both beyond perfect and filling! Wish I tried their homemade hot sauces with the sandwiches but next time read more

This place is awesome. Great sandwiches, great pickles/hot sauce, super friendly staff. Only place in town where you can get a quality (read: fantastic) sandwich for $8. Really special spot, can't recommend it enough. read more

OMG this place is great. Got a sandwich & a wrap - both were excellent! The sandwich bread was outstanding & the wrap delicious! Friendly courteous staff in a great location. Highly recommend. Definitely will come back on my next trip to New Paltz. read more

So we have ordered from Frank's a couple times now and IT NEVER DISAPPOINTS!!!! This place is awesome!! Sandwiches are freakin' great and we tried the shrimp salad and without a doubt it was phenomenal! read more

Arguably the best thing to happen to the village of New Paltz since running water and electricity. The owner and workers are always friendly and the food and pickled goods are amazing. A must try if you are in town. read more

Best sandwich I have ever had in my entire life! I literally dream about it daily! Wish I lived closer and could eat here every day.

Not only were the pickles DELICIOUS but the owner was so nice and took the time to speak to us and tell us about the town. We can't wait to go back!!! read more

Great sandwiches prepared with grace, care and gusto. They are a really special treat. And try their great other odds and ends, such as kimchi or pickles. read more