Food was alright but we found a long hair in our pasta. Space was cozy (in a good way - was cute and comfortable) but service was not great. Just very slow and inattentive. We didn't even mention the hair we found because there was no server around for most of our meal. Was disappointed because I had been dying to try this spot for a while. The tortellini is probably the star but it's a very small serving. Wagyu carpaccio was also good. read more

See all

My friend picked this restaurant, which is usually the safest bet because he treats choosing restaurants like a competitive sport. He lives out of state, so whenever he visits New York City, he does a whole research mission and sends me a shortlist. When he sent me the name of this place, I looked it up and thought, this is going to be an adventure. Even if it ended up being bad, I was ready to roll with it. I got there first and waited for him outside. You can actually walk right past the restaurant if you are not paying attention. It is not hidden, but it has that blink-and-you-miss-it kind of entrance. The space inside is long and narrow, stylish without trying too hard. We had reservations, and once we walked in, we were greeted right away. Before going, I checked the menu online and realized I would need Google Translate or at least a small culinary dictionary. I understood maybe thirty percent of the menu. But that is part of the fun, so I made a little plan for what I might order. We usually get a bottle of wine, and since my friend leans toward fish, we try to balance things out. I mentioned the Wagyu Beef Carpaccio or the Double Cut Lamb. Those names alone made my tongue tired, but when the staff brought out the raw cuts to show us before cooking, they looked incredible. You could tell the quality right away. Before the main dishes came, we tried a bunch of smaller plates. The bread and butter alone were dangerous. It is not just bread and butter here. It is bread and butter with a personality. The butter was soft and rich, and the sesame focaccia was so good it almost made us forget we had real entrees on the way. There was also this dish that felt hot and cold at the same time. I still do not know how they did that, but it worked. All those little bites actually fill you up more than you expect, and then the entree arrives like it is here to challenge you. Everything tasted amazing. Our server, a woman with a warm personality, made the experience even better. She was friendly in a genuine way. She checked in on us, joked with us, and brought the kind of energy you hope for when you go out. Not the attitude-filled trendy energy, but the welcoming kind. The whole staff seemed on point. Would I go back? Absolutely. In fact, I already have my target for the next visit. I want the 60-day dry-aged Double R Ranch rib steak. It is meant for two people, but I do not care. I am ordering it for myself. My metabolism said it is fine. I will pair it with a bottle of wine and worry about the consequences later. Who is coming with me next time? I promise I'll take photos next time. It felt too 'trendy/rookie-ish' to pull out my phone for each dish like i was a little kid visiting Disneyland for the first time: all excited. Cheers. read more

A cozy, dim-lit spot serving up natural wines and small plates -- would recommend coming with a smaller group and making a res ahead of time, though there are larger tables. The servers are attentive and nice! I'd recommend getting everything family-style -- their menu changes frequently based on what's in season. My favorite bites were the Scallops and Sesame Focaccia with Butter, Banana Split was a close runner up. I wasn't particularly a fan of the Pea Agnolotti, but otherwise everything else was good. read more

See all

I went to Fowl Witch family after my sister recommended it. The restaurant is cute with cozy vibes. Our server was amazing--easy to talk with, personable, attentive, and very friendly. Unfortunately, the food was a miss for me. We did enjoy the Beef Carpaccio and the Focaccia. The pasta dishes left much to be desired. We ordered the Veal Tortellini, Pomodoro, and pasta with clams. The Veal Tortellini was a pretty small portion. The pomodoro had a strange tangy flavor. Our dishes must have been left sitting for a while, perhaps to bring everything out at once. But everything was lukewarm and that added to the disappointment. read more

My friends and I got a reservation for 6:15p on a summer Friday a few weeks in advance. The cave-like restaurant was full the whole time we were there. Our waiter mostly impressed me with drink recommendations. His knowledge of wine and how it would pair with our food was impressive. The pastas are small but definitely worth it. They melt in your mouth. I'd recommend any of the vegetable-forward and cheese-based dishes, as well. None of the desserts really tickled our fancy. Check out the bathroom for a dance party. read more

See all

Despite being a sleepy Sunday evening, Foul Witch was hopping. I grabbed the last bar seat for an excellent and interesting dinner. The Celery Alla Romano featured slivers of celery (a little difficult to eat) mixed with a generous pile of anchovies and a beautifully pungent Pecorino. It was a great salad and a good beginning. The kitchen features a wood oven, so the Roast Shoulder of Goat sounded like a great match. The roasting brought out a nice flavor that complimented the unique taste of goat meat. My favorite dessert in a long time is their Black Pepper Gelato. The very definitive peppery flavor was complimented with saltiness, sweet, creamy and sugary elements. It hit every not right. I'd have another right now, if I could. While eating, my neighbors shared their impressions of their meals and we all agreed, this was quite the place. With so many interesting options, I can't wait to return. read more

Foul Witch - Foul Witch - Pepper Gelato with Mint - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

A group of us ate here after reading great reviews. The menu is amazing!! Staff is very knowledgeable about the menu and its ingredients. The decor a super cool. I love the spooky candelabra. This place would be a favorite of someone who enjoys the dark sides of life who has an eclectic pallet. I would for sure come back here again. read more

See all

Really good appetizers. More of unorthodox Italian cuisine but refreshing taste. Intimate vibes with low lighting. Bread was so good read more

See all

Cute little restaurant in East Village on Avenue A. Good Mimosa drink. Cheeseburger was excellent. Limited menu but all good. No hot drinks. You can hang and won't chase you . Great service. read more

See all

The space has a spooky quirkiness to it thats done in a tasteful way & could be romantic if not for the loud music. It's worth a try but lacks the charm for a second visit imo. The highlight is the "off menu" fire & ice, a mix of spicy nduja sausage and creamy stracciatella cheese. Two very different textures and flavors that combine together very well Unique but also familiar! This with the complimentary bread (esp the focaccia!!!) is the best bite of the night. Also their butter If you can get past the VERY small portions of the tortellini, you will taste a strong amaretto flavor that feels a bit off against the rich veal filling. And rly the 15 tiny pieces of pasta is shocking even in nyc standards Potatoes are served cold, covered in a lovely butter blanc sauce & paddlefish roe. I rly liked but feels like a financially irresponsible reco. Oven baked hen is good, very juicy with a light ginger sauce but at the end of the day, just chicken. Veal Tortellini $32 Fire & Ice $26 Dressed Chicories $24 Purple Peruvian Potatoes $36 Guinea Hen $56 이름이랑 잘 어울리는 마녀의 집같은 분위기의 모던 이탈리안 와인바다. 그렇다고 유치한건 아니구 펑키한 바이브 히든 메뉴인 fire & ice 주문 필수!! 매콤한 소시지랑 크리미한 치즈의 조합이 맛남. 이거랑 식전빵이 베스트. 다른 디쉬들은 쏘쏘. 뭔가 딱히 인상깊은게 없다. 토르텔리니는 맛보다 쪼끔한 사이즈가 기억에 남고, 감자는 차갑게 나와서 약간 당황쓰. 오븐 암탉 구이는 낫배드! read more

See all

I dropped 1.5 stars subjectively because the portions to price ration are absurd! The food was good, though nothing super mind blowing. I will admit, I didn't look up reviews for this place. Only came by as a suggestion from a friend and glanced at the menu prior. Prices looked amenable for regular portions. But alas, little did I know it was more of a tapas small to medium plate type place. Racked up $100+ per person. Service was great! The staff were kind! I just wish these plates were larger or lower in price. Mucho dinero! Don't think I'll be back. read more

See all

Foul Witch is delicious! The free bread is nuts. We started with a salad, the puntarelle, got some wine and a couple of pastas, and finished with the sorbet. The chitarra with Dungeness crab and veal tortellini are insane. The broth for the tortellini is addicting. For dessert, we had the peach and tomato sorbets. So refreshing for the end of the summer. I wish I could try all of their pastas and desserts! Excited to come back. We walked in at 6pm on a Sunday night for 2 and sat at a high counter by the bar without any wait. Service was perfect and the ambiance was nice! It wasn't too crowded around this time. read more

Bread, great. Anchovy & stracciatella, can't go wrong. Tersa (head cheese), delish. Pancetta kind of a rip off for the price. Tortellini, one of a kind and worth it. Lobster linguini, meh. Wagyu, amazing and worth. Overall this would have been a 4 star meal--pricy but with some stand out dishes making it worth it, except the hen dish which was weirdly stringy and when we shone a light on it (dark venues hide sins?) revealed that parts were basically raw with bloody red meat around the bones. Even this was forgivable (ish) but what was unforgivable was that when we, very gently and kindly, showed our sever the dish and shone a light on what was very obviously bloodied raw chicken and asked "we think this might be undercooked?" She scoffed and said "well it's not, but I guess I can ask the kitchen." Turns out kitchen agreed with us, but how hard would it have been to simply say "let me check on that for you" instead of giving us that attitude? read more

My partner and I have been wanting to try Foul Witch for quite some time, and have heard nothing but rave reviews from some friends who have been a couple of times, so when we walked by and were lucky enough to snag 2 walk-in seats at the bar (~6pm on a Sunday), we were ecstatic. Oh, and if you couldn't tell by the 5 star review, we enjoyed our meal quite a bit. While it was pricey for a casual dinner, it is an excellent date spot (ambiance and all). Also - sitting at the comfortable bar leaves you right next to the open kitchen, so you get to see all of the magic in action. While we came for the wine (such an extensive and unique list), we stayed for the food. What an incredible gastronomic menu, all items which pair well with wine (I mean most food does anyway). The bartender, Alexis, was incredibly friendly and either verified or suggested items when we were choosing what to do for dinner. She was also ON IT with water refills and playing / setup, and was easy to approach when we needed something ( which could be a rarity at many spots of this calibre in Manhattan). Food-wise we ended up ordering a few dishes, the anchovies, the veal tortellini, the Oxtail Fazzoletti, the goat shoulder, and the sake lees cake for dessert (a lot of food, but we ended up finishing everything, it was that good). It was difficult to pick a favorite, but the goat was an incredible protein choice (honestly wouldn't have guessed it was goat) - flavorful and super easy to cut (not too gamey or fatty) and paired well with the charred scallions and turnips. Also - do not pass up on their bread and butter (they gave us a slice of each focaccia and baguette) - paired well with every dish and also great "in between course" palate cleaner. We will definitely be back and hope we get to experience sitting at the bar again! read more

See all

First time here at Foul Witch and it was honestly very surprising. I don't know much when it comes to Italian cuisine so my review doesn't have any frame of reference on how these dishes taste anywhere else but every single one was fantastic! The meal was paced well and we took many recommendations from our server. She was fantastic and really made the experience very easy going. She even helped with wine pairing. The standout dish to me was the Veal Tortellini. The flavour really stood out and I would probably go back and order two next time. The space is nicely lit and was never too loud or too quiet. Not very large so would definitely recommend a reservation. read more

See all

Their free bread (especially the focaccia) is delicious, but nothing else here really stood out. The service was quite slow, we waited quite a while to get our food and then the check. We started off with the Fire & Ice, which was stracciatella and a spicy sausage dip. It paired nicely with the bread they gave, and we ended up asking for an extra serving of bread. For pastas, we ordered the spaccatelli with aged game bird and the chitarra with dungeness crab. I personally preferred the crab, it had a lot more depth and flavor in comparison to the game bird which felt a bit lacking. However, we were way too full after the appetizers and bread to really be able to enjoy the entrees here. It was a bit on the expensive side as well and in my opinion, the portion sizes didn't really justify the cost. read more

Foul Witch - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I thought it was just ok - certainly nothing too memorable or "magical," but it was a solid meal. I wouldn't come back, but it was worth a try. The bread (mostly the butter) was fantastic, the high point of the meal. The beans were great. I quite enjoyed the orange wine as well. As for everything else, it was just fine. The veal tortellini was good but not super memorable. The bucatini with crab was the same, though I slightly preferred it to the veal. The cake for dessert was strange, the honeycomb was really the only thing giving it any sweetness. I didn't love it but appreciated that it was unique. As for service, our waitress was nice. We had our waters refilled throughout our meal which was great. The dishes are super cute, the bowls look like little dinosaur eggs. The restaurant itself is nothing special, though if I were to give a recommendation I'd definitely say sit in the back at the bar area if you can. read more

See all

They had me at butter made in Bushwick. Finally made it to Foul Witch. Having any bread service much less one this stellar is a rare treat in NYC. Ate: Ficelle & focaccia plus butter. Mushrooms in brood $23 Doran's beans with salsa verde $17 Bay leaf ice cream $8 This is a pricey small plates kinda joint & they made an incredible use of space and a very wide business move to the EV for their first full service resty. Dessert was tasty & inventive not jaw dropping .The bread and savories alone are worth the price of admission. I will be back for more. read more

See all

I was super excited for this location since I'm a fan of Roberta's in Bushwick. Was lucky enough to dine with friends this past Sunday. I'm not sure what was in this space before Foul Witch, but it looks like they might kept the prior restaurants aesthetic. Overall, not the look I had expected but it was cozy and comfortable. We tried a ton of things from the menu, but memorable dishes were the fire and ice (a must order), abundance potatoes, veal tortellini in brodo, sunchoke caramelle, and the dry aged duck crown. The duck was SO GOOD, I really recommend ordering it. Glad to have the Foul Witch in Manhattan and I look forward to seeing how this restaurant develops. read more

See all

I've read great things about this place and my friends and I decided to try it out. Overall it was a good time. I was able to secure an early reservation at 5p on a sat. The place fills up fast so would recommend getting a reso when you can. We ordered the scallops, the capellini with crab, veal tortellini, a nduja pasta, an English pea pasta dish, the guinea hen, and the lamb, and the sake lee cake for dessert. My favorite was definitely the capellini pasta.The pasta is cooked perfectly al dente and the sauce was deliciously creamy. Would recommend getting some additional bread to soak up the flavor. The decor was interesting that gives it a unique vibe and the wait staff was super helpful in picking out the wine. The only caveat is that the portions are small so the price can add up! read more

See all

I was very excited after managing to score a reservation here but wasn't sure what to expect because of the mixed reviews. Maybe some dishes are more memorable than others but overall, we had a great experience. First, the space is pretty nicely done - modern mixed with an 'antique' vibe (if this makes any sense). Service was friendly and attentive at all times. Now onto the food, the Fire & Ice starter paired with the house bread was SO good, probably my favorite part of the meal. The Boston Mackerel and Spaccatelli with Aged Game Bird were good, but I was more impressed by the Roasted Shoulder of Goat. It was my first time having goat in that form and it was great paired with the roasted veggies that came with it. This was the perfect amount of food for the two of us! read more

See all

A genuinely delicious meal at a truly unique and interesting restaurant! My friends and I went for dinner after hearing very promising things. We ordered the scallops, the capellini with crab, veal tortellini, a nduja pasta, an English pea pasta dish, the guinea hen, and the lamb, and the sake lee cake for dessert. Everything is so delicious. Our favorites were definitely the capellini and the dessert. The pasta is cooked well (perfectly al dente) and the sauce was beautifully creamy. The cake was also so moist and has a wonderfully light flavor. The winning element across all of these dishes were the sauces - just so amazing! We definitely thought about asking for more bread just to sop up the remaining sauces. The restaurant itself was so uniquely decorated, which really leans into the theme set by the namesake. A particularly surprising design choice is how the bathrooms are decorated - definitely worth a visit in its own haha. The only downside is that it's relatively expensive, especially considering how small the portions are. But overall, the food was delicious and the vibes were just so fun. It's definitely a great venue for a cool (albeit pricey) night out with friends. read more

See all

Very cute romantic vibes at this new place owned by Roberta's management. TLDR is that while the pasta is quite good, it's small portions for the price. The bread they start you with is DELICIOUS. Went great with the fire and ice. Our favorite pasta was actually probably the goat meat - unique flavor. The veal and sunchoke pastas were also good but very very tiny portions for what you get. After the pastas we were still hungry so we added on the grilled lamb. The lemon was a good touch. Overall it's nice to try this place once but I wouldn't necessarily go through the hassle to get another reservation. read more

Foul Witch - Fire and ice - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I'm sure because this place kind-of beats to it's own drum, that's the main reason for such mixed reviews. I personally was a fan and enjoyed my experience. As always I jotted down some notes during my time, please enjoy- Fire & Ice: an interesting tasting experience on the plate, the nduja sausage mixed with the creamy stracciatella cheese is both unique but also comforting. It's a combo I've never had before but one I enjoy. Two different textures and flavors that seemingly wouldn't blend well that kind of do. While this was a cool way to start off the meal, it wasn't my favorite bite and it you need to edit something off the list to try; start here. Oh! This is also an off-menu item and might not always be available. Table bread & butter: Call be crazy but this is some of the richest, creamiest butter I've had. Even the bread itself has an unqcious creamy quality to it. Specifically the (focaccia?) bread. Purple potato's and Roe: - boy is this expensive but good. The butter berblanc sauce is heavy enough to be paired with the potatoes but still light enough to not overwhelm the rest of the meal. The pops of raffle fish roe and bursts of saltiness with every bite. Incredible and delicious. Veal Tortellini: - not sure what I was expecting but it wasn't this. The pasta pockets sit in a beautiful savory with a hot of sweet broth. The crevices in the noddles catch some of this while the tortellini itself is filled with a delicate light cream. Bay leaf ice cream: - tart and tangy, velvety smooth. The savory notes from the fresh zing of the huckleberry paired with the crisp savory garnish, this is the perfect type of desert This entire meal would have been better to split for 2. These are small, tapas style dishes. Service was lovely I sat at the bar and the bartender offered great suggestions to help me create a nice meal! Vibe: - from the food to the atmosphere- funky and quirky - Club like music that makes you question if you're at a warehouse party in Berlin. I get the 'spooky' theme/ vibes but this is a scene that's hard to describe, cave like, this place feels underground I had a fun time, but I don't know if I'm running back in the next week. This is definitely the type of place you come when you want something a little different from the norm. 4/5 read more

Foul Witch - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

"Hipster's Paradise" Hoodies and flannel, the staff in contrived style, With a decor that makes you smile. Exposed bricks whisper secrets of days long gone, With a tasting menu where dishes are a yawn Where pasta's al dente in the night, Small dishes with too much salt make it a fright A fusion of tradition with a hipster's flair, Pretentious nostalgia's in the air The Oxtail is the dish to embrace but pandering to Brooklyn is a disgrace With service so precise, It won't distract from the high price read more

One of my favorite new restaurants of the year. We absolutely loved almost every dish. The anchovies were some of the best I've had in NYC. The bread and butter were salty and perfect. We really loved the celery, beans, and mackerel, and all four pastas (chitarra with crab, veal tortellini, game bird spaccatelli, linguine with uni) were amazing, especially the tortellini, which came in an incredible broth -- if you had told me this was at a Massimo Bottura restaurant, I would've believed you. The grilled pork and roasted goat shoulder were also both outstanding. We got the sake lees cake and bay leaf ice cream for dessert, both of which were good and interesting, but I don't know that feel a need to get either next time. read more

See all

The veal ravioli was to die for. It's been months (we went in the summer) and I'm still thinking about it. It's our Roman Empire. The bread & butter was amazingly fresh and my friend literally said she wanted to rub the butter on her body she loved it so much (if it's not special butter this would be hilarious). The carpaccio was so flavorful and complex. I cannot stress enough how great this meal was. Service was amazing. I am a water whore so even if I felt bad (and asked for a carafe) the waitress was ON TOP of things and I never had to ask for a refill she just refilled it like a magical little water fairy. Because of the food and the service I'm giving this five stars even if I did have a few nitpicky comments: Decor could be WITCHIER. Hang some herbs! Just kidding, but it would be cute. My only REAL complaint is that I hate the chairs on the high tops but I am a long life hater of bar stool type chairs- especially hard wood- for a dining experience. I'm short I won't subtract any points because the food was THAT good but I wish I could sit happily. Secondly, I am not a fan of their ice cream (my whole table wasn't but it was a savory ice cream which is just obviously not my cup of tea). I had more pictures and usually they're clear but I was so enthralled by the food I couldn't even be bothered haha read more

See all

I don't like writing bad reviews, but this was a pretty rough experience (Feb 10th 2025). There were three major issues that went from disappointing to infuriating. First, the food was barely okay; the grilled wing of skate was a bizarrely flavorless pile of cartilage with maybe two bites of edible food (the potato side dish was good, though). The mackerel seemed turned, and the veal tortellini, while good, was more of an appetizer than an entree. Second, we were overcharged by almost $80 - a full bottle of wine was added to our bill, when in fact there was only a glass ordered. We were charged that, and it wasn't reversed, despite assurances that it was. Third, and most serious, was that the server ignored the fact that one of our party is sober. She explicitly ordered the "Fire Walk With Me" mocktail, clearly on the non-alcoholic menu, after asking for assurances that it was in fact non-alcoholic - but was then brought the "Laura Palmer" vodka cocktail. We only learned that it was the alcoholic drink after she started exhibiting signs of intoxication. The server verified that it was, in fact, the alcoholic "Laura Palmer," which was further reflected in our bill. Both drinks are made the same way, and the intensity of the fennel and chili masked the taste of the alcohol. She's been sober for over a year, and this accidental break in her sobriety was extremely distressing. It might be a good idea to not name your stupid overpriced twee drinks something that could be so easily mistaken, especially when the consequences are so incredibly dire for the person ordering. I don't know how to get the charges to my card reversed yet, but I will never go back to Foul Witch. read more

Unbelievable. The space was spooky and intimate, incredible music, and great service. Some of my favorite Italian in NYC!

I think there was a time that Foul Witch was trending a bit on social media? I think the food here was pretty mid and the portions were small. I think the best thing I had was anchovies with stracciatella, appetizer. Pastas were not much to write home about. There was not much dungeness crab one of the pasta dishes. The lumache with sungold pomodoro wasn't super flavorful. There are a ton of Italian restaurants in NYC. Some are better, some are worse. read more

See all

Really a wine bar with food (much like a bar with upscale grub)... Service was good. Wine selection very good. Food good ("dressed lettuces" and "Wagyu Zabuton") but nothing that causes me to return. Dinner for 3 (no cocktails or desserts; one wine ($105)) including tip was $400. read more

An incredible restaurant experience at Foul Witch. There was not a single dish that didn't exceed my expectations. We sat at the bar and the bartender was super friendly and knowledgeable. The space itself had that open kitchen airy vibe. We ordered the beef carpaccio, sorana beans, chittara with crab, goat, bay leaf ice cream and the sake cake. The goat, beans and ice cream were the most memorable. Their house made bread was to die for as well. read more

See all

Happened to land a last min resy for a prime time seating Read a ton of mixed reviews and was preparing for mediocre - and can say I am converted. A lot of reviews kept panning the place for small size dishes - but I seriously left beyond full with the 4 things we ordered. Each dish was executed incredibly well and the portions were perfect for two people in fact I would say it was better for four. Food: Sorana beans $19 Aged game bird Spacatelli $29 John Dory for two $98 Sake lees cake $12 1 glass of wine Total bill $174 The beans were cooked well the sauce it came with used a Parmesan rind which complimented the house bread The pasta game tonight was duck ragu -- bit strong on the the salty side but it could be the cheese that was heavy on the savory The star of the night was the John Dory - for two? More like for 4! The presentation was well executed and the service was exceptional. Our waitress was knowledgeable about every detail and her enthusiasm made a difference The cake - was a bit on the heavy side I would probably come back for the ice cream or the gelato next time Yep I plan to come back read more

See all

Was able to snag a day of reservation with the Resy alerts. The space was cool, food was creative and tasty and all of the staff we interacted with were lovely. I would go back to see how the menu changes as the season changes. read more

See all

I was happy with the food at Foul Witch! Although, I wasn't blown away, everything was solid. We ordered the fire and ice, sorana beans, pork, veal tortellini, spaccatelli with game bird, and whole john dory. My favorites were the fire and ice and beans. The fire and ice was great with the bread. The bread and butter was also delicious!!!! I didn't want to stop eating it :') The pork melted in my mouth and had great flavor but was a little too fatty for me. The lemon broccolini did help balance it out slightly, but I still couldn't eat more than a piece or two. I also don't think the john dory was anything too special -- probably wouldn't order again. read more

See all

The experience was pretty foul. I'm a big fan of Roberta's in Bushwick, so I went into this having the highest of hopes. Needless to say, I was severely disappointed. I'd like to go on record stating if I could give half stars, we'd have a 2.5 situation. But, rounding down on this one. Service: 2/5 Maybe they aren't in the groove of things. It is fairly new, so I'm going to give them the benefit of the doubt. There were a few times when we needed someone to come to our table, and they completely disregarded us. When we asked for explanations of the dishes, we pretty much got a regurgitation of what's written on the menu. They also put off the vibe that they would much rather be anywhere else, and in the moment I could relate. Food: 3/5 Fire & Ice: 3/5 I was hoping for a creamy rich stracciatella and a FIREY base (hence the name). The base wasn't punchy and there was no fire in sight. The cheese looked creamy and beautiful but didn't have much salt to it, and the creaminess didn't live up to the appearance. The beans: 5/5 Best part of the meal. Which is kind of sad. They were buttery, rich, and the salsa verde was bright with citrus and herbs, it added life to the whole meal. Bread & Butter: 4/5 How could you mess this up? I mean you could. But that butter, damn. I would eat that with a spoon. The amount they give you really made up for the small portions in other departments (not really tho). They brought us more bread but took away the butter and took us about 20 minutes to get someone's attention to bring more, knocking a star for that reason. Caramelle: 3/5 This was my favorite of the two pastas we tried, but not one I would eat again. The filling tasted like pure sunchoke, nothing else. Which maybe that was the point. But I feel like there should be some additional flavor to compliment it. Sunchoke doesn't give main character energy to me, she needs a companion. I thought the lemon would be it, but it wasn't quite strong enough. Spaccatelli: 1/5 My own personal ick, the pasta was completely over cooked. Maybe some would disagree. But the soggy noodle, mixed with game meat, and a bland white sauce had me feeling like I was eating a tuna delight casserole at a forced social function. Kept eating it to not hurt anyone's feelings, but at one point I had to put the fork down. We didn't even finish this one, which says a lot since the portions are sized for a mouse. Lastly, the sad herb garnish didn't do much and felt like a complete afterthought. TLDR; Will not be returning, especially for how difficult it was to get a resy. Even if it was easy to get a resy, I probably wouldn't return. Looking at price compared to value, and the math ain't mathing. Who am I, but an average consumer with a phone writing my average opinion. Maybe this was harsh. But that's showbiz. read more

See all

so sad to be giving this cute place 3 stars. first and foremost the staff and service was on point. our waiter was so attentive and honestly was such a huge help in choosing the wines. the reason I gave this 3 stars is because of 2 of the dishes. it was the polenta with uni and the grilled tripe. both dishes were EXTREMELY salted. it was SO hard to eat. but coming in at almost $30 per dish, we stomached it down. besides that the other dishes were good. we got a red wine and a white wine and both wines were pretty yummy. read more

See all

Cool vibe in here. Very helpful and polite servers. Food was tasty but definitely overpriced. $28 for 2 scallops. There were 3 of us, so we had to add a single scallop onto the dish - for an additional $14. The portions were also really small. Good food but I probably won't be back just due to the price and portion sizes. But all the food was really good! read more

See all

A cozy date night spot in LES! Great wine and creative food flavors. Our server was knowledgeable and patient, which helped a ton. Everything tasted fresh, including the bread. Definitely coming back--with an actual date next time. read more

Foul Witch - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We came to Foul Witch last night for dinner. The food and service were excellent. I would agree with some of the other diners that the prices are high for the portions. The wagyu carpaccio was fantastic. Perfect flavoring and I liked swapping the lemon for lime. We ordered the scallops, which were delicious and cooked perfectly but note there are only 2. They are sizable enough that you can cut in half and turn into 4 pieces. For the pasta we had the lobster bucatini and the cappelletti. Both were delicious and the bucatini had decent size portions of lobster in it. For dessert we had the black pepper gelato which I think was the best gelato I've ever had in my life. Also DO NOT SLEEP ON THE BREAD & BUTTER!! Lastly they have an awesome bathroom that will make you dance, which is always fun. To conclude, I would definitely come back. It was a good vibe, with great food and great service. read more

See all