I was starving, and this was the first pizza place I saw with something truly rare, abundant parking. Destiny. Pizza was good. I had it cold because that's how I like it. No complaints there. Service was... philosophical. The place was empty, yet it took a while to be noticed. The staff seemed deeply committed to important discussions with friends. Once I finally received my pizza, I stood by the door, hanging like a lonely pepperoni, waiting for someone to remember I existed. Apparently there's another register somewhere in the back. So I took a small pilgrimage through the restaurant, paid, and escaped with my dignity and my slice. They do have a seating area to the left. I didn't explore it. At that point, my relationship with the establishment had run its course. Would I go back? If I'm starving and the parking lot calls to me again... nah... read more

Fortissimo - Pizza Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

I've been ordering from here for a few years now, and they're usually pretty good. Unfortunately, my last experience left a bad taste in my mouth -- literally and figuratively. I ordered a large plain pie around 8:45 p.m. and picked it up at 9. When I got home, it was obviously an old pizza that had been reheated! It was cold, hard, stale, and not fresh at all. I called the store to let them know, but instead of apologizing or offering to make it right, the person on the phone argued with me and insisted it was freshly made. It clearly wasn't. The lack of accountability and customer service was disappointing. They close at 9:30, and if they didn't want to make a fresh pizza that late, they should've just said so because I would have gladly taken my business elsewhere. After this experience, I won't be coming back. read more

See all

This is truly a local pizza place, we often (weekly) pick up pizza, wings, salads, wraps and soups. But we dined in this weekend which we have in the past but this time I was promoted to write a review. The dining room is cute and cozy, very old school feel but clean. The server was super friendly and prompt and attentive without being overbearing. They have a liquor license which is a plus. I had Cabernet which was lovely my husband had a peroni. Bread is served with a delicious olive tapenade. I ordered their vodka chicken parm which was not the best I've had but certainly delicious. The chicken was juicy and crispy and not too thin. The sauce was very good. Our daughter had the gnocchi bolognese and my husband had the chicken arrabbiata and although he liked it, felt it could have been spicier. Overall a great experience and we will dine in more often. I find the food here to be much better than the local Italian restaurant near by. read more

Fortissimo - Pollo Arrabbiata - Pizza Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

See all

I was in the area and needed a quick bite to eat so I stopped by. I was happy to be able to get a quick plastic free meal. I paid about 13$ for 2 slices and a bottle of soda. The slices were a good size and i was happy they had some drinks that weren't in a plastic container, but damn! The plain slices they had didn't look too appetizing so i went with the margarita. They were very good but 4$ a slice is too much. They were advertising a lunch special, 2 slices and a soda for 6$. Go for lunch! Or maybe order a pie but don't go here for a few slices if you're on a budget. read more

Fortissimo - Pizza Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

I ordered the mixed veggies with chicken and it was outstanding! The order came on time and no complaints here! read more

Fortissimo - Mixed Veggies & Chicken - Pizza Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

Cute place I stopped in for a quick and fast lunch in a hurry on a busy day. The staff was very pleasant and I ordered a slice and drink. The slice was enjoyable and they had tables ( w nearby TV's) I was able to sit down and enjoy my food. It appears that they also had some waitress service available too. Parking was easy with a lot in front. I would come by again when I was in the area. read more

I recently visited this fast paced pizza plus restaurant. The staff was very attentive, The volume of food was more than worth the price. The quality and service was great. I got the ribeye meal. The meat was very tasty and enjoyable. I highly recommend this destination and food. Bob K Hazlet NJ read more

This will be my last time at this restaurant. Reservation for a large party was made 10 days prior and we arrived to a staff already overwhelmed by 2 other large parties and no table set for us. When I stated we had a reservation, there was no book for the staff to even check. Why take a reservation if you are not going to write it down and have enough staff to serve your guests??? 2 tables were hastily thrown together, overwhelmed staff struggled to serve with no time to clear appetizer dishes before mains were served. Tables of dirty dishes remained throughout the restaurant all night. One of our entrees was totally forgotten. The parking situation already is an issue but we have always returned, after this experience, we will never come back. read more

Last weekend, I took my partner out to dinner at Fortissimo. We were in West Orange that afternoon and instead of trekking home and cooking, it just made sense. Also, both of us had been to the pizzeria when we were kids (we're talking 90s here), but haven't been in recent years. So why not do something different and try it out? Suffice to say, we were not disappointed. It exceeded my partner's expectations - he raised an eyebrow when I first suggested it (the last time he was there, it was after his Mountain Top league soccer game) - but we had a fantastic dinner and would definitely come back again. So I dine with a vegetarian (who occasionally goes gluten-free); and we were able to order a fulfilling meal here. Below is what we ordered: - 1 large tossed salad with dressing on the side that we shared - 6 piece buffalo wings that I housed on my own - 1 personal cauliflower cheese pizza with roasted pepper, garlic, and spinach (~$20) - 1 personal regular drunken nona pizza pie (~$13) - 1 grilled veggie wrap that he sampled and then took home because we ordered with hungry eyes Salad was fresh. Wings were really good, the pieces were a generous size with a flavorful sauce and the right amount of heat. My partner said this was the best tasting cauliflower crust pizza he's had and would order it again. My drunken nona pizza was awesome and will be my go-to order. And the veggie wrap was a hit when sampled and also when eaten the day after. Our waiter was cool and took care of us. Also, when we entered, the guy at the counter greeted us and said we could take any table. There were about three other parties seated in the dining room area, and a few people ordering or picking up take out at the counter. The dining room area has nice dark wooden tables/booths, brick on the walls, wine racks and there was a piano in the middle of the space (surprised to see the piano). The vibe felt that it's a family friendly, chill, italian eatery where you can enjoy a good meal. Recommended! read more

See all

Stopped by for lunch for my first time here. I went for a slice of the chicken parmigiana pizza. While I didn't love this slice, I probably should have started with a plain on the first visit. There are lots of positive reviews here so maybe I just hit it on a bad day. On the positive side, there's plenty of seating, parking in front, and prices are very reasonable. read more

Fortissimo - Chicken Parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

See all

Unfortunately I was surprised at the amount of things I disliked at this establishment. To start the caesar salad came with one sprinkle of parmesan meanwhile the grilled chicken in both pastas ordered at the table came with a balsamic glaze that impacted the taste and flavor of the pastas. It was horrendous and completely unnecessary. Meanwhile the curly fries that came with another dish were horrible as well, lacking in flavor and freshness. Additionally, the service was not great, we had to ask multiple times for things to come and be prepared. read more

Grew up eating this pizza and even working there post high school. Left for 20 years...came back and the pizza is even better. Love their chicken parm pizza. I know it's basic but their house salad is perfection. read more

My family and I eat here often and have consistently enjoyed the food, ambience and service. We order the pizza often for take out. The portions are generous and fresh. read more

Yum num num. pizza was fresh and crisp. I would give 4-4.5 for flavor and taste. A little bread-y but flavors on top great! read more

Fortissimo - Verdone Sicilian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

The food is always hot and delicious. The people that work there are great. They are always polite and respectful. The only issue I have with them is getting my order right. I often have to have them redo the order because something isn't right. But that's not enough to make me stop going there. read more

There are lots of pizza places win West Orange, you can have your pick. For years, we've picked Fortissimo. The food is well made, delivery is prompt, and service, when you could eat in, was friendly. Portions are so generous, you often have a meal for the next day. Prices are reasonable. The food is first rate and I've never had a bad pizza, sandwich, salad or appetizer here. Freshness and flavor are key. Our go-to place. read more

I've been eating here about once a month for the last 11 years. I have a pretty good selection of food and different daily pizzas. Today they have a very creative menu based upon the Super Bowl. I always prefer the Insalata de Mare- it's a delicious combination of chilled shrimp, scallops and calamari on a bed of shredded lettuce with light olive oil and lemon. I have no clue why it is on the appetizer list and not under the salads but who cares. You usually have to ask for Italian bread with your meal because they usually don't bring it out otherwise. They always put a birthday candle in a cannoli for free if you're celebrating someone's birthday in your party, which is a nice touch. Update 9/4/2018: This is the third time I have been here when a lunch special is missing one of the main components, yet it's the same price. No compensation. In this case, I was really digging the lemon pepper chicken salad because of the avocado that was supposed to be in it, but when it arrived, we were told there was no avocado because they didn't get the delivery. read more

See all

I understand that I asked for extra vodka sauce on the vodka pizza but this is out of control. The only reason why I asked for extra was because last time my boyfriend ordered it, there was literally 3 tablespoons of vodka sauce on the pizza. When you pick up a slice it just completely falls apart. I am very disappointed. read more

Fortissimo - a pizza in a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

This is our local go to place! Wether we eat in or take out it's always amazing. They offer home delivery, which is always fast and efficient. Never had a bad meal there all their entrées are like home cooking! read more

Not sure what happened but the pizza I ordered today wasn't good. Aside from the burnt borders, the sauce was flavorless and very off. read more

Fortissimo - Pepperoni thin crust - Deliciouso - Pizza Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

See all

Was looking for a new pizza place. Glad I came here! Staff was nice and friendly. Good selection of food on the menu. I got a medium cheese pie, which I must admit was damn good. Crispy, cheesy and had the right amount of sauce also. I also got an order of garlic knots, which was okay, I would recommend adding more garlic so that you can the full effect. I even went back on another date just for the knots and the same. Otherwise good pizza at a good price. read more

04-28-1957A few days ago I had picked up a plain medium "thin" pizza and found it flat and too chewy. Evidently it was just not to my liking, because when I tried their "standard" crust (plain pie) it was still plenty thin and very good. read more

After buying a slice and a drink for $8 we sat down in the EMPTY dining room and quietly enjoyed our food. We were then rudely interrupted by the manager, who rudely told us we can't have a pizza box in the dining room. We looked around confused at the other patrons, who didn't have any food or drink, that were ignored. Very disappointing, confusing, and rude experience. Fortissimo has become much more aggressive towards PAYING customers. read more

The server was attentive. The sauce just had enough spice. I just had the most delicious pizza! The flavors were so rich and the crust had the perfect amount of crispiness. I could eat this pizza every day and never get tired of it.I just had the most delicious pizza! The flavors were so rich and the crust had the perfect amount of crispiness. I could eat this pizza every day and never get tired of it. read more

Best pizza in jersey hands down. Warm, friendly, down to earth staff with great homie ambiance. Would recommend to anyone!

Great food! Pizza, wings, pasta, salads and wraps are definitely a must. There catering menu is great as well.

I placed three large orders on Ubers eats over the last few months. Each time, none of the pizza boxes were secured with security tape. Also, ordering heroes, the carton is not secured and the bag that the hero was in is was not taped. Also, the hero was thrown is the a styrofoam carton with no tin foil. The bread was soggy. Please announce when you change your packaging for pickup and third party delivery. It sucks. read more

I had a late lunch here earlier today. A friend of mine told me to meet her here. First time ever eating, or hearing about this spot. I WILL BE BACK! Excellent small restaurant, looks like a family owned business. Our server, unfortunately I didn't ask her name was super attentive and friendly. I made it simple. I ordered the personal flat crust pizza with spinach, and a salad. The pizza was delicious on the 1st bite! Really good. My friend had shrimp parmigiana. Looked so good! In any event an overall excellent experience. I will be back. My grandchildren will love a spot like this, since they love love pizza! read more

Food is great. But delivery is beyond disappointing. I gave up ordering here because of how disorganized their delivery is. Tried again and disappointed again. Unbelievable! read more

This place is hit or miss at best. I've been going here for years primarily b/c my kids know the name and it's close by. A few weeks ago we ordered wings and asked for "mild". They sent me some sweet bbq - not what I expected. Not good at all so we tossed it. Yesterday, the kids wanted pizza so we chanced it - although hubby said "remember, they're hit or miss" but I called anyway. This time when I called I spoke to a young lady and specifically asked for not sweet, not bbq mild hot sauce. I was assured that would be the case. When we got the food it was the same sweet bbq (grrr). I called and the young man that answered apologized and asked me if I wanted a new batch. I said yes, please. I drove back to the restaurant to return the food we didn't want and that same guy said... oh, do you want a new batch? I said, yes, please. I gave him the bbq batch (my mistake I guess). About 10 mins later that same young man brought me the new batch. I decided to check before leaving (bbq is dark brown, hot sauce is more orange), and although the order seemed very much globbed on since it was the right color I didn't complain. However, on my way out I realized that the order wasn't even hot. It was barely warm! So I went back to the counter and told the young man and he said (with a look on his face like - I know it's cold), do you want a new batch. By now, I said no. I complained that what had just happened was deceitful. I was asked to move away from the front. The next young lady that attended me said she was the manager. I told her I wanted a refund. She did it and gave me a revised receipt. When I asked for other confirmation she couldn't provide it. Someone close by suggested I ask for the owner. That young lady called the owner who interrupted me more than listened and in my opinion defended the staff. What a shame. We definitely won't return there. I can't imagine what else is going on behind the scenes. They have a bunch of people behind the counter but no one is accountable. read more

Fortissimo - Pizza Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

Ordered a salad from here that was supposed to come with chicken, tomato and mozzerella. It had about 4 chicken strips and some crumbly parmesan cheese. We called, and they did not refund it. read more

I've thoroughly enjoyed the regular pie with cheddar cheese. Soooo good. If you want real authentic pizza. This is exactly where you need buy. Services is fairly quick. The welcome could be a bit warmer but I guess with covid and masks you can't really smile. Otherwise, my favorite pizza place. read more

Their food is very good. They deliver in a timely manner and charge appropriate prices. My one deterrent is that they don't have too many specialty slices available if you're just walking in for a quick bite. *For the record, that may have just been the two times I tried doing that* read more

Got the chicken parm sandwich. Not very flavorful and the chicken seemed like it was reheated/not fresh. I should've stuck with pizza.

The food is ok but they always get the order wrong when you order for delivery or pick up. Then they're unapologetic about it when it happens. They need better customer service for sure! read more

Been coming here at least once a month for 20 years. Never had a bad meal. Went in recently on a busy Friday night for pickup and the takeout counter was packed with orders. The staff were organized, on top of everything and made the potential hectic experience of Friday night pickup a breeze. Staff were smiling and ready to assist. I was beyond impressed with the service and staff. Food is always a solid 4 out of 5 for a local pizzeria. Thank you Fortissimo! read more

Love love love. They put their foot in it.. and I love that they have a personal size.. well worth the money..

I ordered takeout from Fortissimo. It was hard to chew the crust. I ordered onions on the pizza. I found parts of the onion that should have been discarded. The cheese was not stringy. It was a lump. read more

I couldn't give this restaurant Two Stars if I wanted too. It took over an hour for delivery when I was told 10 -20 mins for an 8 minute walk away to a hotel. There was no utensils to eat with (told must make a request- to a hotel? C'mon man) The food was not seasoned or had any flavor at all, everything tasted the same. BLAND! No dressing for the salad or any condiments to add like S&P. The only compliment is the Francese was delicious but wasn't on the pasta. Not a great experience at all. read more

Fortissimo - Pizza Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

Great restaurant! One of the best pizzas around. Definitely recommend! Just perfect, pizzas are so tasty, fresh, quality ingredients. read more