Great burger for sure. Old-school bar, plenty of locals and sports on TV. Cold beer, friendly…read moresmiles, and good service during my first and only visit.

Unfortunately I don't like writing bad reviews for small town businesses, especially one that's a…read morestaple for Hawley. But this is pretty bad to warrant a negative review. Tried to meet friends for drinks there, but The system they use does not scan out of state licenses or federal Identification. So although my husband both had his Real ID FL license and his military spouse ID, he was totally denied service, and was told he can't even be in the bar. Unfortunately they lost customers tonight because of it. While I understand PA licenses have to be scanned, it is a huge flaw that they don't scan any other ID's, especially those that you can even fly through airports and enter federal property with. For a town that relies heavily on tourism in the summertime, I feel that it's a massive flaw to not accept out of state licenses.

As someone who has been coming here for at least 3 years, this was the first time where the food…read morereally didn't hit right. They must have changed the chef bc solids like poutine were prepared differently - almost like a mozzarella cheese spread across the top so that's all you tasted, vs It used to be very light melted cheese and more curds / gravy. We tried the special Swedish meatballs which were so Smokey, It overwhelmed the dish. They also switched up their pretzels and cheese, which was extra runny instead of thicker beer cheese. Beer was still solid as ever and loved.

The reuben egg rolls were overcooked. The fries were not…read moregood. They were pale in color and just didn't taste that good. My burger was very good.

Reuben, corned beef hash and turkey BLT were really good. Tavern fries were good also. It was…read morereally cold inside. Waiter- Veteran- was very nice Definitely will return

Have been here a few times when traveling. Very disappointed this time. If not for friendly…read morewaitress would be a bust..had to wait for table and the two men working there were rude..no urgency to clean table off for us after waiting 10 minutes. Food was ok. Asked for gravy on my home fries...was forgotten and didn't get tol done w meal and I could see one of the guys was disturbed I asked for it. Will not stop again

Had an absolutely fantastic dinner Tuesday night at Settlers Inn in Hawley, PA during their Burger…read more& Brew special! My burger was cooked exactly to my liking -- juicy, flavorful, and spot-on medium-rare. Paired it with a perfectly poured Black & Tan that was the ideal companion all the way through the meal. From the food to the friendly, attentive service, cozy ambiance, and incredible value... everything was outstanding. If you're anywhere near the Poconos, do yourself a favor and go. Already counting down the days until I'm back! #SettlersRestaurant #HawleyPA #BurgerAndBrew #PoconosEats #SupportLocal

Great place to stay....older and quaint long standing favorite place when we come up to PA!…read moreGreat hospitality! Terry and Kevin are awesome! Restaurant is very good too and the lobby fireplace is very welcoming. Outdoor firepit is a favorite!

went last night after a suggestion from a local, as nothing is open on mondays. the servers were…read morekind and made good conversation. the vegetarian wings are some of the best ive had, with a great medium sauce. onion petals were yummy too. vegetarian puttanesca was a huge portion and a little watery, but still had good flavor. thank you coras!

We were staying at the nearby Woodloch Resort and this cafe looked cute from the outside the few…read moretimes we had driven by so we stopped in for dinner. The inside was nowhere near as nice looking as the outside. Very shabby, worn walls and furniture and devoid of a welcoming typical restaurant atmosphere. Young female host was rude and cold in all interactions with us. We waited a long time after being seated to be greeted. Older female server who only had a few tables from what we could see was also rude, brusque in her conversations with us and never checked on us after the food arrived. Food was subpar and overpriced with no one enjoying it (3 children and 2 adults). The host girl was assisting the server and literally dropped plates on our table two different times. The worst dining experience I might have ever had.

Very good burger best I've had , although the service was what brought me to write the review , I…read moremade a long drive to get a burger and I called to confirm they would still serve me nearing close , they said yes . After arrival they turned me down. Disappointing drive home .

Had a little time to kill in the Lake Wallenpaupack area and was looking up some suggestions from…read moremy videos and searching items on google for a spot to grab something to eat. Came across a spot on google that was using seeded semolina rolls and cooper sharp for a cheesesteak so I figured why not give it a shot. I would come to find out that they no longer use cooper sharp (which is why this is a 4 and not a 5 rating), but I wanted to try this out either way. So in the middle of nowhere...this is a good steak. Plenty of meat and it was tender and seasoned nicely. The cheese sauce they make here went nicely on the sandwich and the seeded semolina was a good roll. It was not a Philly or NYC quality roll, but it was good. Price was about what I'd expect. Not much else to say really, if I was back in the area I'd absolutely try this spot again. Meatheads - Didn't Suck! Check out the video and content on hundreds of other places by checking my social media pages here - https://linktr.ee/Didnt_Suck

Stopped in for the restaurant. Brunch sounded really good…read more Not busy at all this Sunday morning. Got a really nice table by the front windows. Grabbed the mushrooms and polenta to start. Lightly breaded and fried. Yummy. Did need salt but otherwise well made. Main was their burger. So good! Juicy and flavorful. The onion jam was delicious. Their wine selection is very good. Get the flight. It's a really good deal and you can try 3 different wines. Service was quick and food came out fast and hot. Others noted the prices a a little high but the food was really good.

The Settlers Inn is a historic Arts & Craft Lodge that was built in Hawley, Pennsylvania in 1927…read more It was founded by local citizens in Hawley. Shortly after the completion of Lake Wallenpaupack (a man-made lake), local businessmen believed that tourists would come to see it and they raised funds to build a grand hotel known as the 'Hawley Community Hotel'. When the building was nearly finished, the stock market crashed and it sat empty for 20 years. It officially opened to the public in 1947 and went through several owners. It served as a nursing home, an inn, and even a private school. Since 1980, the inn has been owned and operated by hospitality experts Jeanne and Grant Genzlinger who dubbed it 'The Settlers Inn'. The on-site restaurant and Chestnut Tavern offer farm-to-table menus highlighting quality products of local farms and purveyors. Kate Woehrle is the current executive chef. The inn has been a member of Historic Hotels of America since 2010. My family and I recently visited The Settlers Inn while we were spending Memorial Day weekend in the Poconos. The timing of our visit coincided with their Memorial Day Brunch. The beautiful hotel had a spacious dining room that even featured live music from a piano player. To drink, I ordered the "Settlers Inn Bloody Mary" (blue cheese olives, alpine beef stick, aged cheddar, dilly beans, pepperoncini, celery). This was a great brunch cocktail! Our server brought us some delicious complimentary Brewer's Bread for the table. For the appetizer course, I had the "Smoked Trout Dip" and my wife had the "Black Pepper Ricotta Toast" (asparagus, cured egg yolk). We were both happy with our choices. For the entree course, I had the "Smoked Salmon Eggs Benedict" (potato pancakes), my wife had the "Crispy Chicken Sammy" (coleslaw, brioche, roasted jalapeño aioli), and our son had the "Birthday Cake French Toast". Everything was excellent and tasted so fresh! For dessert, our server told us to help ourselves to the dessert table which featured fresh baked goods like cookies and cannoli. We had a fantastic brunch at the Settlers Inn and would definitely return on a future visit to the Poconos!

Had a great time. Great food, drinks, and service. We had no problem docking at the dock n dine…read more Will come back again soon.

Didn't live up to the hype; the food is better at the diner down the road. Won't be going backread more

I regularly get their roast beef hoagie with extra meat and mayo, and it's always been excellent.read more

I've passed by this deli for years and finally decided to give it a try. Being in the mood for…read moresomething hot I ordered The Bandito which is grilled chicken, pepper Jack cheese, jalapeños, lettuce, tomato, and chipotle mayonnaise. It was decent but nothing really special. So why four stars. Because their Deli Sandwiches made with Boars Head Cold Cuts are fantastic. My wife brought home two Roast Beef Hoagies that were packed with delicious Boars Head Roast Beef. The bread was crisp on the outside and soft inside. The lettuce and tomatoes were fresh and tasty. The only thing I would recommend is that you ask for salt and pepper in any Boars Head Cold Cuts because Boars Head doesn't add salt to their meats, which is actually a good thing. This is a great place to get a sandwich.

It's not the same as it was. This used to be a popular place on the lake now it's a shadow of its…read moreformer self. The potential is there and it just needs to be utilized.Absolutely love the location. Love the summer days near the lake at the pool bar 10/10. Dining and indoor bar is mid at best. Hopefully they will revitalize and make it awesome. Cause right now its deadsville..

So sad it has the makings of an amazing place but the prices do not match the staff and quality of…read moreservice of $15 drink made with the wrong ingredients. Staff yelling across the bar at one another long waits, poor customer service