Stopped by for lunch and it was so good…read more They have daily specials, and the portions are no joke. Even a half sandwich is a huge, very filling serving. Everything is made fresh to order. They slice the meat and cheese right there and you can fully customize your sandwich, which I love. The service was phenomenal. Super friendly and welcoming, which made the whole experience even better. Cute shop and they also have a great selection of Italian products in the shop, plus their own ready-made items like homemade frozen pizzas and take-and-bake entrees, which is such a nice bonus. It's takeout only, but they make it easy with online ordering. Prices are very reasonable for the quality and portion size. This place is truly a hidden gem.

Great Italian deli in the area! The food here was excellent & came very quickly. Service was…read moreoverall very good as well. We didn't stick around for long as we took for takeout. Many options, will definitely be returning to try more things!!

First time customer at Pizza Supreme. I "really" wanted to like this place, due to proximity to my…read morehome, and the fact they offer "take-and-bake" pizzas. Love picking up pizza this way and simply cooking it on my schedule hours later. Ordered hand tossed 14 inch with traditional pizza sauce. Toppings were cheese and Italian sausage. Presentation was excellent. Couldn't wait to enjoy it later. First criticism would be the sausage, however. What cold be better than fresh Italian sausage on a pizza? This sausage (on the other hand) was pre-cooked, obviously provided by a food service company... very similar to what any consumer can purchase from grocery stores. Disappointing. Now the crust. I opted for "hand tossed" style crust. The crust "looked" freshly made, but after cooking it, suspect it too was not homemade dough at the restaurant, but rather, received, likely frozen from a vendor. Baked at 425ºF (per instructions) for around 15 mins. Crust edges were lightly browned, as was bottom crust. Top cheese had acquired some color as well, so it was done. The crust lofted when baked like "hand-tossed" crusts are supposed to, however, I did not smell the characteristic scent of "yeast" when baking. When sampling the pizza, could not detect any flavors of yeast in the crust, even when it had cooled a bit, further increasing suspicions this is not homemade dough on site. Crust tasted quite like some of the frozen varieties of "rising crust" pizzas do that you can find in your grocery freezer section. If it is homemade dough on site... I must apologize for being incorrect, but it certainly did not taste as such to this reviewer. Now the sauce. The traditional red sauce provided was only "okay" as well. Would describe it as very thick. Like it's 80% tomato paste, 20% sauce with very little spice. "Lacking" in flavor is what I would say. So: a crust not unlike frozen rising-crust, lackluster manufactured Italian sausage, and lackluster sauce. Nothing tasted "bad" but nothing stood-out as exceptional either. Goal here is not to upset the apple cart of this restaurant. There are plenty of 5 star reviews so they seem to have a solid fan base. Coming from a pizza lover who makes their own often from scratch, however... Pizza Supreme did not inspire. UPDATE: June 2, 2026. Just noticed the last two review after mine that glorify the place are interesting as they are the only review either reviewer has done on Yelp. Makes one wonder if they are even real. Just sayin'

Best Pizza, honestly. Just moved to the area, and looking for our new go-to's. Pizza Supreme hits…read morethe mark. We ordered 3 different personal pizzas and a personal pizza fries to try multiple. Not a single bad slice to be had.

This had been on our bucket list for a while and we were extremely excited to try it! We got the…read morepepperoni pizza, which was perfect for the two of us (we had some leftovers). Flavor and texture wise it's a really solid pizza, I would definitely recommend it. It was so filling and cheesy. We also tried the red and white wine. They have outdoor and indoor seating, which is a big plus in the summer. Some of the reasons: why I am not giving it a 5/5. It's because we waited a close to 50 minutes for the pizza. And the pizza is definitely more on the pricey side, which I am okay with, but I think waiting that long for one is too much.

We have driven by here several times and always said that one of these days we will try it. Friday…read morewas finally that day. It smells amazing when you first walk in. They make a wonderful butter crust deep dish pizza that is smothered in toppings. We decided to go simple - with pepperoni. The amount of pepperoni they put on this pizza was amazing! Let me back up though, we started with an order of cheesy garlic bread donuts. What could be wrong with that combination? They arrived and were the size of golf balls. So garlicky, so cheesy, so yummy! I will admit, it was a rather long wait for the pizza and I was starting to feel a little hangry but when it arrived, it was worth every minute of the wait. So delicious and filling . One piece was all any of us could eat. Was just as wonderful the second day. The inside of this place is charming. An old Mario video game kept our 7 year old entertained. The music was a little loud and hard to hear over but this is clearly a place that neighbors know and love. We will certainly be back to try other items....or maybe stick with what we already know and love. The best part? You are right around the corner from Nellie's and everyone knows that ice cream fills in all the cracks after a good meal! If you are looking for a great neighborhood experience, I highly recommend Mario's!

Pizza is SO good!!! Love this hidden place! We have never had a bad dish from there!!!!read more

This is a hidden gem that one has to experience, The original owners closed this and then it was…read morereopened by a new group with a changed menu. My wife has fallen in love with this restaurant so much so that we eat there at least once every week. We have tried their pizza, sandwiches, Mexican original items and much more. Stop in, try their sandwiches which are always oversized and more than what you would get at most other places in the area.

I've been coming to punch since I was a kid, it's that good! The pizza here is the best I have ever…read morehad (including abroad). The salads are very good as well. Service is generally pretty quick, and order ahead options are available. The staff is friendly. Highly highly recommend if in the area!

It was a wonderful weekend to enjoy their outdoor patio space for a date night. The parking space…read moreis ample even with shared area with other businesses. As soon as we walked in, we were warmly greeted and menus were easy to browse without feeling pressured to pick right away. The service was quick and the staff was helpful. The food is consistent and freshly made. It's a great location for Neapolitan pizza rain or shine with plenty of seating both inside and out!

My son and I were out shopping and there is a Facebook marketplace online coupon for buy 1 get one…read morefree Butter Chicken or Tiki bowl. It was 12:15 on black Friday and Noone else was here. Should have been a sign. I showed cashier coupon on my phone. No expiration date anywhere. She calls her manager to see if she can take it. The answer was no! Huh? She said we could order $9.99 lunch. We would have probably ordered more, but I said to her. "You would turn down business?" We then walked out. Never to return! I predict they will close soon. They do not honor their Facebook marketplace ad. I said they need to take it down then.https://www.facebook.com/share/1Bi8J6gFpG/

I tried the tandoori chicken bowl, flavors were all great. My problem with this bowl is that the…read moreratio's were SO off. I was basically eating a 1/4 cup of rice with 1 piece of chicken, 1 cucumber and 1 strip of a carrot, not even any garbanzo beans in every bite. Not worth the money in my opinion. Just stick with a pizza, I have never had a bad pizza here!

@punchpizza is one of my go to comfort foods. For the good times and the tough times, grabbing a…read morepizza from Punch always does the trick. Obviously folks know about this place but I still want to highlight them because longtime fan. Fun fact, each location has hidden cat figurines in their restaurants. Generally in the ceilings. My stop tonight was at my local St. Paul location. They have a whopping 12 locations in MN all listed in one of the last photos. My go to order that won my heart: Toto (no crushed red pepper, add roasted red pepper) side of olive oil Honorable mentions Punch Salad Bruni (meat and onion featured in post) Gorgonzola Salad When in doubt of what to get, go to Punch. For more awesome food spots check out the account mallorymademetryitmn on Instagram!

First time trying punch pizza and it did not disappoint! I ordered the Bruno for takeout - it took…read morea lil bit of time but I was given I free drink while I waited which was much appreciated! The inside was nice with a great view of the stone fire oven. The servers were friendly too! Now for the pizza, the crust is everything you'd want from a pizza. The right amount of char with a good bite, toppings were delicious and the sauce was good and not overpowering. For the price I thought it was a good deal! Will definitely be back when I'm in the area.

By far my favorite pizza spot in Minnesota--and one of my favorite pizza places in general. They…read moreserve authentic Neapolitan pizza at an extremely affordable price, and it truly stands out. The owner grew up in Milan and was inspired to bring true Neapolitan-style pizza to Minnesota. Having lived in Italy myself, I genuinely believe Punch Pizza can hold its own against many Italian pizza spots. The pizza is incredibly light, flavorful, and made with exceptionally high-quality ingredients. The mozzarella di bufala is even flown in from Italy weekly, which really shows in the taste. On top of that, the portions are very generous. If you're ordering, don't skip the Punch Salad--it's a must. The service strikes a perfect balance between casual and sit-down dining. You order and pay at the front, then you're seated and served, which keeps things efficient while still feeling relaxed. Honestly, I love everything about this place.

I stopped in for a to-go pizza and was able to place an order and have it ready in 10 minutes. The…read moreMargherita Extra was so good, with Mozzarella di bufala, Mt. Vesuvio tomato, and basil. Sometimes the simplest pizza is the best pizza and this is case in point. I will definitely be back to get it again!