Highly recommend, your tastebuds will be razzle dazzled! Everything was delicious, so full of flavor. Wonderful, friendly service and staff. You can't beat the view. If it's summer, book your reservation online a few days ahead of time, fills up fast. Looking forward to next time! read more

See all

If this review were solely based on the food and the view, it would be a five star review hands down. Unfortunately, the service brought down the experience to a three star. Each time we have visited, we have required a reservation. If a restaurant is using a reservation system, they should be able to accurately staff based on projections or control reservations based on staffing. In a full ten table restaurant, much of which sat parties greater than four, there was only one server tonight. The rest of the team, including the host and the bus boy did help out, 17 minutes into us being sat. Our assigned server never came to our table to greet us and eventually our table was taken over by the hostess. She was very sweet and helped where she could, unfortunately she was being pulled in so many directions, as was the remaining staff. She told us they weren't anticipating such a busy evening and only scheduled one server, which really doesn't make much sense when we have only been able to get in with a reservation. The food, on the other hand, was really great. They offer a large selection of beers and liquors (several local offerings) as well as a classic cocktail menu (no modern drinks on it). We've hoped to try the ribs on both occasions but last time they were out and this time the smoker was down. We instead had pulled pork and brisket. Both were great and we equally enjoyed the sides-- macaroni and cheese (featuring an old bay seasoning) and garlic mashed potatoes. We will be skipping the coleslaw next time as it was vinegar based and we prefer mayonnaise based. Their barbecue sauce offers a nice kick. We especially loved the corn muffin starter and the pickled red onions. We will be back for the food and hope for an improvement in staffing/service. read more

Fitzgerald's Restaurant - Pulled Pork with Coleslaw and Macaroni and Cheese - American Near Me - Eagle River, Michigan

See all

Never a bad meal, fantastic location, wait staff for the most part pleasant, and not a huge place. I did speak to a local and it appears that whoever answers the phone gives off this arrogant vibe. "We don't need to do that...etc..."(we get enough business, we don't have to be humble.) So yes, there is something missing about this place. Feels like a city restaurant transplanted in the U.P. If you must go here, drive out to the Jam Pot to feel better about life. read more

Fitzgerald's Restaurant - Ribs, slaw, and beans. - American Near Me - Eagle River, Michigan

For us this was a hidden gem. I can't believe it took us all this time to get there. Food and drinks were amazing and the staff was wonderful! Can't wait to make it back! read more

See all

Freaking amazing. This is one of my favorite places to eat in Michigan. Everything on the menu is good. This time around I got a flight of beer and a prime rib sandwich. The wife got a chicken sandwich and kids had mac and cheese and chicken tenders. Everyone was hangry beforehand after a half day in Copper Harbor and we all left The Fitz happy after eating. All of their meats are great, as are the sides. They open a bit late, so plan ahead if you go for lunch. The beach is right next door, so just be sure to wait 20 minutes before swimming. read more

Fitzgerald's Restaurant - American Near Me - Eagle River, Michigan

See all

Beautiful view, delicious food, great service. Great adult beverage menu. Friendly staff.

It looks like a typical up-north restaurant, but both the food and the service is indicative of a big city dining experience. The bar drinks were excellent. I had the whitefish and the peanut butter pie. read more

This place is out of the way but DEFINITELY worth a stop if you're anywhere in the Keweenaw!! It's right on the water, with plenty of windows to take in the view while you eat. I bet the attached hotel is fabulous, but unfortunately we were staying elsewhere. Their menu is very small, although I'm not sure if that's a residual covid thing or if that's normal. Their mac and cheese was only offered as a side but it was INCREDIBLE and I would probably ask if I could order it as an entree next time I'm there. It was different than other mac and cheese's I've had, in the best way. The ribs were also great and also came with a side of green beans that wasn't on the menu but was a pleasant surprise, but that mac and cheese really stole the show! They have a nice cocktail menu as well- highly recommend The Last Word. read more

This place is the best. Stay here. Ate here. Had a great time. Need to expand more!! Mike the owner was great to talk to.

My husband and I ate here over the Fourth of July and food was good but we hadn't made a reservation so ate at the bar. This trip up we made reservations for 4-on-line--because they don't answer there phone--and they didn't have our reservation, so I showed them on my phone that they still had a table available per their website and the hostess replied nothing available you could sit at the bar.She was rude and not accommodating at all. I said I tried to confirm my reservation by calling and she reiterated that they don't answer their phone. Don't know how you can run a business without answering your phone--we won't be back. read more

The service was wonderful. The ambience was very good. It's a nice little place to eat with a view of Lake Superior. The food gets a mixed review. Baked beans, Cole slaw and brisket were very dry. The ribs and pulled pork were excellent. read more

Great food and location is beautiful! Service was great as well. Definitely need a reservation so call ahead!

We ate here twice during our stay and if I could rate more than 5 stars, I surely would. Starting with the selection from the bar, we were so excited to explore all the different offerings! What a huge, varied selection of beers and spirits! We both tried as much as we were able to. My personal favorite was the Gold Rush (rye, honey and lemon) and my husband loved the 16 year old Scottish ale Ola Dubh. Absolutely glorious stuff We also had Irish Coffee several times, which was perfect for a chilly October afternoon. The food was superb. We had creamy red pepper bisque that was so delicate and full of flavor. The brisket was perfect. I had Pitmasters Pie, which had brisket and vegetables in a red wine sauce with garlic mashed potatoes on top. Absolutely superior. My husband had the special, Filet Mignon with cherry wine butter and claimed it as the best steak he has ever had (he has had a lot of steaks) The staff was attentive and helpful. This experience was one in a million. What a fantastic establishment. We will be back, planning on making this our annual anniversary trip read more

Fitzgerald's Restaurant - American Near Me - Eagle River, Michigan

See all

Absolutely fantastic experience. We were initially disappointed because they did not have indoor dining open but it worked out perfectly. The food was outstanding and the setting cannot be beat. If you are anywhere in the area please go out of your want to come here. read more

Fitzgerald's Restaurant - American Near Me - Eagle River, Michigan

Loved the falafel Good gem in the Northwoods . Will b back. Loved the carrot cake washed down with coffee. Was here to leaf peep for the fall colors read more

See all

I want to begin by acknowledging the beautiful location of this restaurant. While the ambiance is charming and the food is decent, I regret to say that my recent dining experience fell short of what I'd hoped for. Despite hearing glowing recommendations from a close friend, my visit left much to be desired. This is the same friend that also helped ruin this experience, read on:) Upon making reservations, I encountered some awkwardness, but I managed to navigate through it. However, I found it unusual and uncomfortable to be required to pay upfront for your meal, a practice I've never encountered elsewhere. As someone who dines out frequently and has traveled extensively for both work and leisure. During my visit, I was taken aback by the attitude I received when making a simple request to substitute water for simple syrup in my cocktail. Furthermore, when inquiring about a salad option, I was told there was none. Despite observing other patrons enjoying salads nearby and seeing salads on the menu, online. He took our menu before we ordered and I was struggling with my glasses. I couldn't help but notice the similar treatment of other guests nearby. This leads me to believe that there may be an issue with the service or management. As a patron, I believe it's essential to feel valued and respected during a dining experience. AdditionalIy, my dear friend told me to name drop, but the owner took offensive, yes. I at no point threw out a name and then asked for a favor. We were friends and I was expressing his compliments and that my friend even shared his favorite items on the menu. But the comments I received back from Fitzgerald's owner, this was not appropriate. He has gone on to tell me that my service experience was horrible because I named dropped, (which I was told to) and was done as a compliment. After reflecting on the interaction and observing the owners responses to other customers, along with reviewing past reviews and speaking to members of the community, it has become apparent to me that there may be underlying issues within the establishment has been building over the past few years. It's disheartening to learn about the departure of key staff members. While I understand the challenges that come with running a restaurant, it's crucial to prioritize professionalism and customer satisfaction. A great view, decent food will only work so long when you treat your customers horribly. Especially when its over a compliment from a referral. Even if he did not like the person, who would do that and I don't need to know this. Ultimately, my hope is that they take this feedback constructively and strive to improve both personally and professionally. I believe that every business has the potential for growth and success, but it requires dedication and a commitment to excellence. I understand that if the owner comments to this review, its going to be nasty and my fault. (Look at his past responses) It's a true shame because we were very excited to eat here and have a great experience. The owner literally destroyed our experience, over sharing a friends referral and telling the owner that a mutual friend is doing well, Seriously? https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g42154-d1574611-r938806283-Fitzgerald_s_Restaurant-Eagle_River_Upper_Peninsula_Michigan.html# read more

My girlfriend and I just spent two nights and had a fine time. The rooms are clean and the beds are good, the view is INCREDIBLE. The sound of Lake Superior at night is amazing. They have an adequate patio out back with picnic tables. The staff could not be nicer. The food was excellent. The beer selection was very good. The seating in the rooms is rather spartan. Otherwise, WHAT A GREAT PLACE. We will be back. read more

Fitzgerald's Restaurant - The view from the deck - American Near Me - Eagle River, Michigan

We were lucky to snag seating at the cozy bar on a busy Saturday night in Sept. We were greeted by a friendly young bar staff and treated to expertly crafted gin and tonics garnished with fresh juniper and rosemary which was so refreshing after a long day of hiking and paddling. We knew immediately what we were ordering as we spied it on another diner's plate--the delectable looking white fish with the pickled veggies to begin. Everything tasted as wonderfully as it was plated--deliciously! This was the best meal by far we had on our trip through the UP. Super friendly staff, cozy bar, nicely prepared food! read more

We had shrimp po boy and it was one of the best ones I had. Crispy shrimps with nice bread and sauce..yum.. Their poutine is good too. Its heavy because of all the cheese but good. They only allow carryout during covid but you can sit on their deck in the back or any bench on the beach. Taking out one star because they didn't give me my water :( read more

Great pork bar-b-que! Large portions and the Mac n' cheese deliciously seasoned. Green beans and super good bark on the rib tips appetizer. Great dinner with a view! read more

Always an excellent dining experience and atmosphere. Justifies the trip to the Keeweenaw. Reservations system was great to use.

Beautiful restaurant on Lake Superior! The food and drinks were amazing. I had a hard time deciding what to get, there was so many great choices. Very unique and innovative dishes ! Will be back! read more

Very good food and beautiful view. I'd go back. Good service. Found the environment a little loud.

Interesting place. They design says German food and they have a number of German entrees but they also had an eclectic mix of other items in the menu. We got a ciabatta style roll with spices and oil like you would at an Italian restaurant which I thought was odd. View is great. Pretzel and cheese app was so delicious. I enjoyed the sauerkraut. Smoked chop was cured and a bit too salty for my taste. Wide variety of desserts. I'd recommend it. read more

This is THE PLACE for BBQ in the Copper Country! The service is super friendly and top notch. They currently have a limited menu but it doesn't matter because everything on their is great. Brisket is juicy with just the right amount of fat. It pairs perfectly with their creamy Mac n cheese. Also, make sure to pair it with an Old Fashioned. Then walk it off by taking a stroll along beautiful Lake Superior. read more

We LOVE this restaurant. The incredible food, the beautiful view, the delicious cocktails, everything about The Fitz is amazing! Whenever we are in town, we make sure to go here as many times as we can. read more

Great comfort food! It was a beautiful day to sit literally right over Lake Superior on the deck!! The brisket was my personal favorite. read more

Fitzgerald's Restaurant - Yummy food! - American Near Me - Eagle River, Michigan

Be sure to make a reservation! The food is the best in the area! Service is top notch. And, the cherry on top is the view!

Went to dinner here. The place is right on lake superior. The food was quite good but I think the drinks were even better. Frances had the Norwegian paralysis. The bartender shook it for like a full minute. Desert was key lime pie read more

Fitzgerald's Restaurant - Inside the restaurant - American Near Me - Eagle River, Michigan

See all

Where to start... Definitely our favorite place to eat in the world. The brisket is to die for, the shepherd's pie is exquisite, and I have no words for the smoked prime rib. The food here is phenomenal and so are the hand-crafted cocktails. The staff is wonderful and ALWAYS so polite and professional. If that isn't all enough, this is also our favorite place to stay. The accommodations are perfect as is the view of Lake Superior. While the brisket alone is worth the 12 hour trip from Nebraska, this place is our go-to long weekend trip and we make it as many times as we can during the year! read more

Fitzgerald's Restaurant - Beautiful View!! - American Near Me - Eagle River, Michigan

See all

Several people told us to make sure we stop at Fitzgerald's while visiting the area. When we looked online we were suprised to see they recommend reservations. "Reservations recommended" is not really our preferred eating environment. We ended up there about 3 p.m. on a Saturday afternoon, and once we saw what a small place it is - reservations for a Friday or Saturday night certainly made sense. The restaurant sits directly on the beach providing a beautiful view of Lake Superior, with a patio for outdoor seating. It's filled with nautical decor and substantial wood tables and chairs. They have some unique items on their menu that may be impressive to "foodies". Prices were moderate - high, server was cordial. I'd give them a 3.5 if that were an option. Aside from the fact that they were the only option in that vicinity, we really didn't see what all the fuss was about. Jim & Colette http://www.roamingtogether.com http://www.facebook.com/followrt read more

Fitzgerald's Restaurant - American Near Me - Eagle River, Michigan

Oh man ... "French Toast" pork belly, curried rice/lentil with avocado, kale, and sweet potatoes, and a Brussels sprout & blue cheese salad ... this was not expected ... this is a gem of a place ... not overpriced and the food was truly top notch ... kids loved their burger and brisket too (and said the fries were amazing) :) read more

See all

It is sometimes hard to find very high quality restaurants in the UP, especially the Keweenaw Peninsula. This place takes the cake. The Fitz is my all-time favorite restaurant ever. It is a very small restaurant, so I recommend getting a reservation NO MATTER WHAT. Sometimes you have the whole place to yourself, sometimes every table is reserved. You can also sit at the bar. The alcohol menu is honestly like 15 pages long, and it is incredible. The barbeque is just delicious. The macaroni and cheese is spiced so well. Their barbeque sauce is fantastic. I love trying new foods here, and the Douglass Anchor is a perfect way to try everything and feed two or three people. The desserts here are also delicious. I like the chocolate cake, but a lot of my friends and family prefer the Key Lime Pie or the Peanut Butter Pie! I have celebrated special occasions here with groups as large as ten, and if you call in advance, they really are so accommodating. You can drink outside on the patio, but cannot be served food outside, as it is not staffed. You have to walk to the bar, order the drinks, and bring them outside yourself. I would certainly recommend celebrating the Fourth of July here, because they shut the restaurant down, set up tables, tents, and a bar outside, and serve food and drinks using a chip system! It is SO FUN! The atmosphere is great and the people here are just so friendly and fun! My favorite part about this place is the positive energy of the wait staff. They all LOVE their jobs, and it shows in their work. I also love watching the freighters in Lake Superior, the waves on the beach, and skipping stones before or after dinner. I am excited for a winter of the Fitz staying open! read more

Fitzgerald's Restaurant - Cute atmosphere - American Near Me - Eagle River, Michigan

See all

Dinner at The Fitz is a real treat. The view is spectacular--the dining room is about 30 feet from the water, with a lovely deck in between. Amazing barbecue--probably the best ribs I've ever had. They're dry-rubbed and don't even need the sauce that comes with them. You'll leave full and happy, especially if you get the mac and cheese as a side. The beer and whisky selections are thoughtfully curated and impressive. And let me tell you, if this place was in New York City, the owners could charge three or four times what you'll pay in Eagle River. Pro tip: make a reservation for about 90 minutes before sunset. Enjoy your dinner, then get a drink and a slice of pie and head out to then deck for the show. read more

Fitzgerald's Restaurant - Scotch on the deck at sunset - American Near Me - Eagle River, Michigan

Loved everything. Drinks were fantastic. Food was delicious and the windows looking over Lake Superior is a great addition to the atmosphere. So glad to have found the fitz open for winter. read more

See all

Wow. The Fitz is an absolutely amazing restaurant and the best way to cap off a day of Copper Country Cruising. If you want to eat on Lake Superior, you can't get any closer, as the waves are lapping on the shore closer to your table than the host stand. Check the sunset time and make a reservations BEFORE you leave Houghton/Hancock/Calumet, that wall you'll be guaranteed the best sunset you've ever seen over the greatest Lakes of them all. There was a MASSIVE beer and bourbon list that is brought to you on a clipboard. It would have taken me longer to figure out what I wanted to drink than it did for me to drive there from Houghton. Luckily, the waitstaff is very well versed in the menu and they can even help you with pairings. The menu was a little smaller than I would have liked, but that slight inconvenience was offset by the amazing food that they had on it. I didn't get the chance to try the ribs, but they looked absolutely amazing. I instead had NY Strip Steak which exceeded my already high expectations. You will not be disappointed by the food and it will be a highlight of your trip through the Keweenaw. I can't recommend going to The Fitz strongly enough. It is 100% worth the trip and the the expense. (Bonus Points for picking a name so heavily steeped in UP lore) read more

Fitzgerald's Restaurant - Looking out over the lake, awaiting sunset. - American Near Me - Eagle River, Michigan

See all

Unique dining experience during this Covid time. The restaurant setup on ordering station outside with the dining room closed. You could order and eat on the beach or take home your meal. Great food timely service read more

It's hard to find good BBQ in the Midwest. I know...I've been trying for years! Who would think I would find it on the shore of Lake Superior? Our party of four (and a toddler) tried all the BBQ items on the menu. The Pulled Pork was tender, juicy and flavorful. The Ribs were perfectly cooked, rich and meaty. The Brisket was perfectly cooked with a fantastic bark. my favorite side was the Mac and Cheese. It is also worth mentioning that Fitzgerald's has a huge selection of Beer and Cider. If you use a wheelchair, access is a little tricky. You have to enter through the kitchen (which was spotless, by the way) and then go up one step in the dining room, so make sure you let them know when you make your reservation. Even though it's a hassle getting in, it's worth it and we will definitely be back! read more

A truly outstanding beer and cocktail list! The beverages amongst our table were all very well received! We had both the pulled pork and brisket; they were fantastic. read more

My first time at Fitzgeralds. It was recommended by our daughter. Did not disappoint. Food was excellent and the view from the dining room was amazing. The only disappointment was that they were out of my favorite whiskey. read more