First the person at the register was great. The food was a win one and lose one proposition. The lobster roll was very good lots of lobster the right amount of mayo. The fried clam roll with sweet potato fries was not fried enough. Clams were soggy and the sweet potato fries were really bad. There were about 7 or 8 clams and a huge pile of fries. If you like lobster rolls read more

The lobster rolls were stuffed with lobster. The fries were great too! Seating is outdoor at picnic tables out of the sun. I recommend this place! read more

quantity of food given is limited. They give more fries than needed yet limit the quantity of clams or scallops. The potato salad is phenomenal, wish the quantity was increased. Wished they offered coke and Pepsi as a drink read more

Service was very quick and efficient. The place is very casual and pet friendly and the food was very good. There was great outdoor seating, great for larger parties. Looks like a little hole in the wall but food was very good. read more

See all

We were on vacation at Point Sebago and drove out to try this place. It was the worst experience I've ever had in my long life of eating seafood in New England. The fried clams were tiny, the batter was nasty. The scallops were very mushy with poor batter. I upcharged to Onion Rings, they were close to inedible. My wife's lobster was mediocre. I didn't think it was possible to mess up a lobster. We should've driven to Portland. read more

This place is right across the street from where I live. Guess it's time I review them I've patronized Fishermen's Catch a couple of times, mostly because it's convenient. They offer their lobster rolls on special at least once a year for a few days so that is what I wait for. Lobster rolls are pretty good but could use a tad more flavor. They used to be $35 but now it's $38. Would I pay that for a lobster roll with chips? I think not. I brought my mom here on a separate occasion and she did enjoy her steamed lobster. That time I got their haddock sandwich which came with a side of fries. The fries were crispy and tasty. Service is usually pretty quick even when there is a little bit of a line. They only have outside dining which could get hectic because it is off of 302. Overall, they do a solid job but they are on the expensive side. read more

See all

Amazing fresh seafood. Easy casual dining outside. Loved the fried scallop dinner with onion rings and choices of lobster rolls

We ate here last weekend and were extremely disappointed. We ordered clams and weren't given anything to wash them with, no hot broth. When my husband went back to ask for broth, she gave him lukewarm tapwater. The already cold clams, rinsed in tap water, and then dipped in cold butter was beyond terrible. So I went up to ask as well, not believing they couldn't give us some broth which is what every restaurant gives you. The server was extremely rude and said "fun fact, broth is hot water". Which we all know isn't true. read more

My favorite lobster roll. Took me years of driving by to finally try them and I'm disappointed with my last self for not stopping sooner. The service is fast, the location is convenient & the lobster rolls are perfection. Most recently, I ate here twice in the same week. No notes. read more

Great little side of the road stop for a tourist like me who wanted to get a lobster roll while visiting Maine. I picked it mainly because it was on our driving route but was pleasantly surprised by the super nice staff and the good food. They have the main patio, where we were able to sit because we had stopped for a late lunch around 2:30 PM. They also had a tent across the parking lot with several picnic tables to accommodate during busy times. I can't speak to the authenticity of the lobster roll since I'm an out-of-towner, but I was very pleased with my buttered lobster roll and clam strips. My mom absolutely loved the fried pickles she got with her own classic lobster roll. read more

Fishermen's Catch - Buttered lobster roll - Seafood Markets Near Me - Raymond, Maine

Best lobster rolls in southern maine by far! I wish they were open year round, because it is such a fun treat going to Fishermens Catch to get a lobster roll read more

Fishermen's Catch - Lobster roll - Seafood Markets Near Me - Raymond, Maine

Great location. Bland Lobster and Crab Rolls. 3/4 of the meal is French Fries....no wonder we have an obesity epidemic and lead the world in cases of type 2 Diabetes. read more

The whole belly clams and onion rings were superb. It was a to go order and everything was ready to go when promised.

After I saw the lobster rolls on Yelp, I had to come here. They have both a seafood shop and full restaurant menu with all the classic Maine seafood. We tried the classic lobster roll, the lemon, the fried scallops, fried whole belly clams, and clam strips. Everything was amazing - but what really stood out to me were the fried scallops! They were the best I've ever had. A super light, crisp, crum fry that was really firmly stuck to the scallop (which is hard because scallops are very wet). So impressive. And obviously we have to mention the lobster rolls. I really like how they have classic variations of the roll on the menu. It was the biggest lobster roll I've ever gotten, and for $22 it was a steal. Also, weirdly I'm mentioning the fries but they were an awesome thin battered wedge. If you're visiting Maine or live in Windham, it's definitely an excellent representation of Maine seafood and I recommend checking it out! read more

See all

Their food is to die for! Locally owned by an amazing family, fair prices and quality that cannot be compared. I have lived in Maine most of my life and have a very high expectation for quality when it comes to seafood. Fisherman's Catch is one of of the only Places I get seafood and lobster rolls. Try the garlic dusted roll, you can thank me later! read more

Had the lobster roll They ask how you want it prepared. I chose with a little Mayo my friend asked for lemon Neither of them had much flavor. The lobster itself was good, the sandwich was hearty but lacked flavor You get a bag of chips with it We ordered pickle chips and onion rings. The pickles were good the rings seemed out of a bag of frozen veggies but they were okay Sorry no pics read more

My wife and I ate there yesterday the food was awesome. Had the fried pickles , fried clams , and a butter lobster roll. This place service was awesome also. About 10 minutes for some of the best seafood on RT 302 and the tent set up was great nice ambiance and set up. Lobster rolls w butter was over filled and the whole belly clams were cooked with utmost quality and the fried pickles were obviously good Thanks and keep up the great job read more

The best lobster roll I had during my visit to Maine! Food - Lemon lobster roll - this was so good! The perfect amount of seasoning to go with the generous portion of tender lobster on a warm, buttery bun. Fries - I was expecting basic frozen fries but was pleasantly surprised to receive fresh, hand cut fries that were crispy and perfectly salted. Fried pickles - these were good but a bit heavy. I think I would skip these next time. Service: The girl who took our order at the window was great! We had a big group and she made sure to read our order back to us. The food came out fairly quickly and was so fresh. Ambiance: No frills ambiance but allows the food to speak for itself. You can eat at the picnic tables outside or take your food to-go. They also have an indoor area to purchase fresh seafood. read more

Ok yes it was expensive, about $140 for 2 of us and only outside seating wight near the road, HOWEVER, we ordered a ton of food,certainly did not eat it all at once, and LOVED all of it. The lobster rolls were well stuffed and delicious but the highlight of the mean was the clam strips. They do have full belly fried clams available but that is not to my preference. The ones we had were fresh, tender and simply yummy! Would I pay that much again? I'm not sure, but it was really good. read more

Fishermen's Catch - Lobster roll, onion rings, shrimp and clam strips. And this was after we'd eaten quite a bit. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Raymond, Maine

Take out only, with picnic tables- View is of Rt. 302 traffic. This is compensated for by a perfect fish chowder. The "classic lobster roll" is packed with lobster- devoid of any seasoning, and no Mayo to taste of- okay only- it's $30 which is the going rate for portland area.. I'll stop again for the fish chowder but will avoid the lobster roll. read more

It's been a while since I was able to return, and the lobster roll is still great, but it didn't seem to have enough seasoning or something this time. I'm not sure if anything has actually changed, but I didn't find myself enjoying it quite as much as I did the last few times I was here. In addition, the seafood chowder was not available (it was a little before 12) which was disappointing because we did not have time to stop by again this trip. We got our food almost instantly, but when our friends joined us, they had to wait quite a while and we ended up being late for our jet ski rental. I don't really fault the staff for this, because some people did place their orders between ours, but it was also quite hot inside--the AC was running but minimally. read more

Fishermen's Catch - Lobster roll with mozzarella sticks and fried shrimp - Seafood Markets Near Me - Raymond, Maine

Brought the family here while on vacation. Got two lobster rolls, the scallop dinner, two kids chicken finger plates and some onion rings. Everything fried was pretty much burnt, over fried, and tasted horrible. How do screw up french fries? The lobster rolls were average at best, probably frozen. No need to come here again for us. Pay top dollar for below average food. Nice outdoor dining though. read more

This place was AMAZING!!! We were visits family and had to come back the next day to try something else!! First time had the haddock dinner ... so fresh so good so good!!! Next day came back and tried the lobster roll and seafood chowdah!!! A must try!!!! Can't wait to come back in mid July to visit this place AGAIN Hands down worth a trip!!!! read more

This was a good find as I was wondering the street lost in Maine. I had the lobster roll. It was good, but not great. I honestly expected more. You got a good amount of meat and a good ratio of cut, but it lacked flavor. read more

Fishermen's Catch - Seafood Markets Near Me - Raymond, Maine

Great food in a roadside setting. We enjoyed fried scallops, shrimp, and onion rings. I recommend the seafood chowder. read more

Bill and the short staff atFishermen's Catch always serve great lobster, great clams, great everything each and every time we visit. Excellent service from a great local restaurant . Will always pick Fishermen's Catch above the rest. It's the first place I stop after months of deployment, and it always makes me feel that I've come home. read more

We visited this restaurant on our weekend at a friends and it did not disappoint! The clam strips were fresh and the fish and chips was flaky and so very tasty. It's a walk up window so the service was fine. Seating is outside and on this particular day the covered area was perfect! The only reason I have 4 stars is because their clam cakes were flat and not round as I am used to. Would definitely recommend! read more

I thought it was going to be a restaurant but it turned out to be a drive up fish stand kind of place, sit on the picnic tables. The food is amazing! It's not a clam chowder, it's a seafood chowder. And it was so full of goodness that Neptune himself would approve. There was even a hunk of lobster in there that was about half a claw. The flavor was amazing!!! Lobster roll was just average. It was a lobster roll, nothing special about it. The roll could have been buttered and toasted but I didn't notice if it was. The fried shrimp and haddock were cooked perfectly. Light crunchy batter on the outside, soft tended deliciousness on the inside. Definitely worth a stop. read more

Thoroughly enjoyed my dinner at Fishermen's Catch. Free parking was definitely an added bonus. I was able to sit outside on their beautiful patio, thanks to all unexpectedly clear and glorious evening. My dinner was simple -the lobster Cobb salad with a side of their griddled cornbread - but both were delicious. Very nice evening. read more

I came here on a food tour and got a small bowl of the seafood chowder - WOW! I've never had chowder with so much seafood in it, it was both beautiful and delicious. I can see the hype around this place, and say the chowder lives up to all the 5 star reviews. read more

Surprised they are voted best lobster roll in windham because they are my least favorite thus far. Got a classic roll, lobster had minimal flavor and 2 separate bites (beginning of roll and mid roll) had large sharp pieces of shell on it. After the second time I couldn't eat anymore so I ended up tossing 1/3 of the roll out. Disappointing. The friend shrimp were pretty good. Good tartar sauce. The lobster roll was a very big portion at least. read more

When I took a trip to Maine the first thing I think of is a lobster roll. I went to Fisherman's Catch and this definitely is the best lobster roll going. Not only do they have amazing Lobster rolls but there sides are amazing as well, the chowder! To die for! It's a local business in Raymond and you get that small town feel when you walk up to the window and always see a emailing face! There service is very good, the people taking your order only want to help you and ready to answer any question. Would totally recommend! read more

This is my current favorite local lobster roll spot. If you're visiting Maine and need your seafood fix, this is a really good option. They have several ways of personalizing how you get your 'roll and I broke tradition for the lemon pepper last time. It felt like sacrilege but was transformative. I now also dress my chicken salad in the same way. The other seafood here is also excellent. The clam rolls etc are fresh and light. You can eat outside under the pines on picnic tables (no fuss.) just keep the squirrels from stealing your food. read more

My husband had been raving about this place every time we were up here so I finally got to see what the fuss was over. This was one of the BEST lobster roll anywhere ever....big fluffy beautiful roll perfectly buttered and grilled...unbelievably fresh lobster...and just the right amount of Mayo. We also tried clam cakes which were also delicious and perfectly seasoned and sweet potato fries. The server was super attentive and helpful. Now mind you...lobster IS expensive right now so get over yourself if your going to squawk about the price of the lobster roll...give. The prices here for the quality of food does not get any better anywhere! read more

You get your moneys worth! Really good seafood for a small town. This is a spot that competes with all the other big city restaurants. Can't go wrong with any part of the menu. Came to fisherman's 3 or 4 times in a week vacation read more

See all

Grabbed lunch at Fishermen's Catch on Friday afternoon. Tried two styles of Lobster Roll and was disappointed with each. I also felt the prices were far too high. Quality: Ordered two different types of Single Lobster Rolls at Fishermen's Catch. We did The Classic with lobster meat tossed in light mayo and The Buttered served with warm butter and no mayo. I tend to prefer the warm option for Lobster Rolls, but while the butter was warm, the roll was still served cold. I think The Classic option, which at least embraced the cold style was the better of the two, but I was not impressed with either. They were both stuffed in bread that felt a little stale and the texture of lobster was just not that good. I think it may have been too much claw meat, which I honestly thought would be better, but it was a goopy mess. Quantity: While there was a fair amount of lobster on the Single Lobster Roll, it messed up the proportions and was on a smaller sized roll. Value: $27 for a Single Lobster Roll. Ambiance: Fishermen's Catch is located in the small town of Raymond, Maine. They have a small market at the back of the building and then an ordering window area in the front. Two picnic tables sat near the ordering area, which was helpful for the long wait. On the other side of the parking lot they have a massive tent, with additional picnic tables and heating lamps. On a shockingly cold July afternoon, the fire was very necessary. Crowd: A few other customers strolled in as we were waiting, however that was more a result of the slow service than a testament to the popularity. Service: There were not many other guests and we had a relatively simple order, but it took nearly half-an-hour. Not a place you should visit if you are in a rush. Parking: Gravel parking lot located between the main building and the outdoor seating tent. read more

See all

Very nice lobster roll, lots of meat nice flavor. It's pricey $51 for roll and a beer. The meat is cold but didn't taste frozen. Overall I would rate 3 1/2 stars. I prefer PJs on the Cape and Reds in wiscasset read more

Fishermen's Catch - Lobster rolls - Seafood Markets Near Me - Raymond, Maine

See all

We were house hunting in Maine, didn't find anything that fit, but ate some seafood, while we were near the coast. We had 2 hot buttered lobster rolls. There is parklike outdoor picnic tables. The lobster rolls were huge, like double what you get from some places. They give you so much butter on the side too. I did have some pieces of shell, but it happens sometimes. Lobster was broken up more than some places. The area to the north of here is super beautiful. I was though shocked to see so many NY and NJ people in Maine. Maine was super busy with tourism. Yes it was summer, but more so, it is the super rich from the Maritime states, having a summer of recreation, as thy bought there 2nd, 3rd, or 4th home in Northern New England. I hope they don't try to make our states like the ones they left! I always find it funny how many people complain about seafood being pricey! This is good bang for your buck in the world of lobster rolls. read more

Had one of their classic lobster rolls today, it had plenty of lobster meat but was bland tasting at best, so many seafood places now don't boil their own lobsters anymore and just buy it frozen. No flavor at all, tasted like I got it at a gas station. Don't waste your money. read more

My favorite lobster rolls! The staff and owners are so nice! Can't wait to go back! If you visit Sebago you should stop in and have lunch