I had the opportunity to dine at Fire, located in Wind Creek-Atmore in celebration of my birthday (2025) and I really enjoyed the overall experience. The restaurant is a nice size, appearing to accommodate any size party with availability at the bar as well. I looked over the menu prior and decided to go with the fried green tomatoes, wedge salad, 6oz filet mignon (medium well) with a loaded baked potato. My meal was good from start to finish. I also decided on the Seven layer chocolate cake (delicious) and to my surprise it was gifted for my birthday. JP and Shakira (spelling, my apologies) took care of us throughout the evening. read more

See all

From the moment we were seated the JP was very attentive and provided us incredible service. The appetizers we had were the filet bruschetta and the lobster bisque. The lobster bisque was by far the best I've ever had , large clumps of claw meat, perfectly balanced with butter and cream. The steaks we cooked to perfection. The only disappointment was they ran out of bananas foster. We will definitely be returning. The ambiance and menus are perfect for any date night or celebration. One last thing please don't bring children to the restaurant. This is a beautiful nice restaurant it is no place for kids under 13. read more

Went here for my wife's birthday. This is supposed to be a high-end restaurant... they charge high-end prices but then fail to deliver the high-end dining experience... when you are paying $47 for a pork chop, $55 for a lobster tail, and $63 for a steak you deserve to be treated like it. Food was okay but at the end of dinner the staff handed us plastic containers to pack our own leftovers. We are certainly not above packing our own food but when you are paying those prices you expect to get a certain level of service. This totally killed the "high-end vibe!" Made the place feel like an Applebee's of similar chain restaurant, rather than fine dining. I asked the waitress about this and she said it's "been that way since COVID." Seriously, COVID was six years ago! Plus, they deliver your food without gloves, handle your water glass, etc... why stop short and hand someone that just paid over $200 for dinner plastic containers and have them pack their own to-go? Destroyed the illusion of a nice, and special occasion! When there are other restaurants, and Casinos for that matter, a relatively short distance away, we will NEVER spend another dime at FIRE, and will most likely not spend any more real time at Windcreek Casino because of this. We work too hard for our money to spend it on a dinner that does not make you feel like they appreciate you and want to deliver a special experience for the money you are paying. Totally disappointing! If you are in Atmore already check out Gather Restaurant where they actually appreciate you! read more

Fire Steakhouse exceeded my expectations the ambiance was quiet yet swanky we received the 5 star service from JP and Ann (may have the wrong name) the extra pallet cleansers between each course were a nice touch that elevated our meal and experience. I would definitely bring my family here again We had the : Fire stack Lobster tail Lamb Chops Filet Mignon Broccolini Garlic Mash and Loaded baked potato read more

See all

Food: Delicious. Big, tender steaks. Service: Attentive and friendly without being intrusive. Ambiance: upscale steakhouse chic. What's not to like? read more

Fire Steakhouse - Steak house chic. - Steakhouses Near Me - Atmore, Alabama

The Food was Amazing ! The Service was Incredible. We sat at the Bar. That's what we prefer. The Bartender was Wonderful. We can't wait to return. read more

Food was pretty good. Will definitely return. Service was great and we really liked the bread service. Not too pricy and the blackened ribeye was delicious. read more

See all

A group of us went Friday night for our monthly dinner outing. Very disappointed Some of the steaks came out cold and were sent back. When they came back out they did not have everything on them. For Alabamas number 1 steakhouse I would hate to see the worst read more

My wife and I had a wonderful experience at this steak house. The food was great but to top it all off was amazing attention that all of the service staff gives to its customers. The ambiance and decor brings it all together. I will definitely visit Fire again. read more

Ambiance was really good. Service was really good. The $60 steak was fatty, gristly, and over cooked. It was the worst high-end steak I've had in 51 years. The asparagus was thick and tough. The quiche was cold. The smoky bourbon was awful: wrong cherry for an old fashioned and was overly sugary; I've had better cocktails in bowling alley than at Fire Steakhouse. Don't waste your money at Fire. read more

It was pretty good for the price point. The Mac&Cheese was alittle oily but still good! Steaks were cooked correctly & SUPER tender. It was pretty quiet & vibes were right. Everyone was so kind. read more

Fire Steakhouse - Bonbons - Steakhouses Near Me - Atmore, Alabama

See all

This was a GREAT dining experience. We had steak and sword fish. A PLUS !! The service also gets a A plus. The young ladies that served us were fantastic. I highly recommend the Fire when visiting Windcreek Casino. read more

Nice decor food mediocre. Good service. Excellent. Atmosphere. The meat was not good. Spinach excellent. The salad had too much vinegar

First and foremost, our server, Sierra was phenomenal. She has served us twice now out of the four times we've been here (2 birthdays, our anniversary and New Year's Eve). The food is always good and unexpected for a small town like Atmore. Ambience is nice but a but loud even though it wasn't very busy. Will keep coming back and I hope Sierra is well taken care of so she will stay. Making reservations now for our anniversary in September read more

Visited for the first time today, mainly because of its 5 Diamond rating and recommendations from friends & family. We went into this expecting to be wowed and having the chance to enjoy a new upscale restaurant experience. The bread service, which was served with 3 different kinds of butter was great. When the entrees came out, I was excited about the loaded baked potato I saw on the serving cart. The waitress put both dishes down in front of us and revealed my 14 oz New York Strip and my wife's Delmonico Ribeye. To start with, I didnt see any steam or smoke rise from underneath the lids when they were lifted. The butter on top of the steaks wouldn't even melt because the steaks were cold. To sum it up, the steaks were very bland and overcooked and seemed to have been sitting out for a while before they were served. Very disappointing meal and very overpriced for what you get. I have had a better steak at Texas Roadhouse. The service, on the other hand, was great but we will not go back. read more

Great food. Definitely get the oyster appetizer--it is divine. Service is very good and they brought out a tasting from the chef and bread prior to the appetizer. Everything we had was very good and they sent us home with a long stemmed red rose. This was a wonderful experience. read more

See all

The ambiance is amazing. We had lamb chops, bison burger, loaded baked potato, sweet potato soufflé. All delicious. I did I say the lamb chops were delicious? I asked my date if I would embarrass him if I picked up the bone to get all of the meat off! Our server Helena was very attentive. Ask for her! read more

We were in Atmore for an occasion so we decided to have dinner at Fire. What a very nice experience. From the Hostess to the server and her assistant. The Wedge Salad was delicious with the mild Blue Chesse, Grape Tomatoes and Buttermilk Dressing. We ordered the Onion Soup and Lobster Bisque, both were tasty but the Onion Soup was not to my taste. The Aged Ribeye was fantastic!!! $65 maybe a bit steep but it tasted great. They ended the meal with a few Ice Cream Truffle like bites.....super good. All around good experience....Forgot...Amuse- Bouche was a treat.....and they also served a pallet cleanser....Strawberry Sherbret with Champaign....Nice Touch!!! read more

See all

This was the BEST steakhouse EVER! The service, the prices, the staff, the quality - all AMAZING! I need the recipe for their homemade steak sauce! OMG! I could have had this on everything! Do not pass up a chance to enjoy this place! Truly an incredible experience! The ambiance was above and beyond a first class! Thanks so much to all from the time we walked in until we left! read more

I forgot to take photos of our appetizer and main courses because we were too busy enjoying them. Everything was perfect from the drinks to the food to the dessert to the service. An excellent choice for our Valentine's dinner. Our steaks were delicious and cooked to perfection and their house steak sauce is perfection. read more

Fire Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Atmore, Alabama

See all

Ambiance was top notch. Wine selection was excellent. Service was impeccable. Food was 5 star. I had a wonderful time enjoying the company of others at this establishment. My first time eating here and it was a treat. I forgot to take pictures of my shrimp stuff crab over fried green tomato. I dig in before I realize I miss my chance of a great picture. Oh well, hope you all enjoy. read more

See all

First of all we decided to eat there last minute and the manager made room for us. Definitely make a reservation. The server Ladana, was beyond attentive. These servers have an assistant and they refill, pre bus, open wine, run food and whatever the server needs and they were very accommodating. Absolutely the best!!! My steak was so tender and delicious! I didn't care for the asparagus because it was Al dente . The cheesecake was phenomenal but the crème brûlée was very strong with the grand mariner so I really didn't taste anything else. We also had there house red wine and it was very smooth for a Cabernet. I highly recommend this place it's worth every penny! read more

See all

The food, service and ambiance was excellent. In my 59 years I have never received the attention from my servers and chef like I did at Fire Steakhouse. From the complimentary bruschetta from the chef and bon bon when we told our server we were too full to order dessert to the long stem rose given to my date at the end of our meal. We sat and talked forever and had already paid our server. She came back checking on us and filled our water glasses and made sure we didn't require anything else and thanked us genuinely again and again. We will definitely return. read more

Fire Steakhouse - Fire Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Atmore, Alabama

First time here and it was great. The service was top notch not just from our waitress but from everyone that checked in with us as well. Started with the fire stack and each part was done well. I had the dry aged cowboy steak and it was just amazing - from the seasoning and the sear to the tenderness - it cut like butter and i am not a sauce on my steak type of guy but the sauce along with the roasted garlic just took the steak up another level. The dessert, the grand marnier creme brûlée, was just the perfect way to end this meal too. I would recommend this place to anyone who enjoys a beyond great meal and experience. We will be coming back to Fire for sure. read more

See all

Oh my from start to finish this place was excellent! I ordered the lamb chops and my husband had the filet mignon and it came out perfectly cooked. The meal started with a meat and onion tart, followed by warm sourdough bread and 3 different butters, a small amount of sorbet to clean the pallet and then the meal! Yum! Then to top the meal off they brought us chocolate bon bons. This is an experience that you cannot miss! read more

Fire Steakhouse - Chocolate bon bons came at the end and was included in the whole course of the meal. - Steakhouses Near Me - Atmore, Alabama

My "Go-To" for fine dining in the Atmore area! The service is UNREAL. Professional, friendly, fast - a true dining experience. Located within Wind Creek Casino right off of the casino floor, FIRE steakhouse is a comfortable, quiet and delicious mix! Even though you are right next to the casino, the glass doors and dark tint keep the restaurant calm and comfortable. Try not to fill up on their bread. Bread is served hot with three different spreads/butters. YUM. Get the FIRE oysters if you are a seafood fan. They come lightly fried with cheese. The fried green tomatoes are also a treat. I always get the filet salad here when I am in town. It's the perfect mix of tender meat, tomatoes and fresh greens. They have a large selection of wines and cocktails. The bar is small but super Comfortable to eat at. However, if you are with guests get a table for the full dining experience :-) Check the hours on their website before making plans. I think they may be closed on mondays! Cheers! read more

Food is great and staff is friendly! The only reason I didn't give a 5 star is that the restaurant could be updated a little! Definitely one of my go to restaurants in the area! read more

Food, service and ambiance were all great. All of my food was incredibly delicious and the service was superb. The night I went, all the women were given a single long stemmed red rose. What a great touch! read more

They pride themselves on letting you know there are the top steakhouse in Alabama. We ordered. 9 ounce fillets, and we noticed that we get our food about the same time as another table that sat down 15 minutes after us. So we get our steaks and they are tough, dry and tasteless. Good thing they gave me a sharp knife because I wouldn't have been able to cut into it. That $50 steak was dry, tasteless and terrible. It was so bad that I actually said something to the waiter who said she talked to the chef. No one ever came to our table or tried to make it right. The server offered a free dessert. I booked this reservation a month out for our anniversary and they made sure that it was miserable. I wouldn't drive five minutes to go to this restaurant . These people need to know that you can't live on your reputation, you have to deliver every day to every person. Food 1-star read more

Food was really good, service was even better! Table was decorated with rose petals and candles for our special occasion. They even gave us 2 complementary roses and desert on the house. read more

Even before Covid-19 this place has gone down on the food quality. Little to no flavor is the best I can sum it up. Way overpriced for what you get. This visit I ordered the special, blackened grouper, bland and not good and small portion. Won't be back unless I absolutely have to. read more

From start to finish, not only is the service impeccable, but the food is cooked to perfection. We eat at 4$ every week, and few compare. Multi layered flavors that perfectly compliment each other. Each of the staff are amazing! We started with the scallions, then moved on to the lobster cakes, filet medallions & ended with bourbon pecan pie. We live in Panama City Beach, but I would make the drive back Just to eat here. If I could add a diamond to the 4 stars, this place earned it. read more

See all

This is a beautiful restaurant that provides excellent service. However I feel they could certainly make some improvements to the menu. I didn't review Fire the first nor second time I came here because one time there was a concert going on and I like to give a place two fair tries before reviewing. But this will likely be my last time visiting. They recently changed the menu and apparently they will be changing it every 3 months so that's good for the regulars. But tonight I had a hard time finding something I wanted to order because the selection was so small. For app we got the oysters Rockefeller. Those were wonderful. Great crust & sauce. Love the spinach underneath. Really full of flavor. Mains we got the bourbon glazed salmon which was a big piece of fish, but lacked a little in flavor. I do NOT suggest the asparagus that comes with it. It is totally flavorless. We subbed mashed potatoes for grits (just preference) and we're please with the portion of the sides & the flavor. We also ordered the twin medallion filet. The steak was cooked perfect and had good flavor but the bacon wrapped around it paired with the crab topping made the dish a little too salty. I liked the creamed spinach we ordered on the side but it's heavy on the cheese and not on the spinach, reminds me of a spinach dip rather than creamed spinach. The waitress seemed to be less than knowledgeable about the menu, that's always a let down for me as I often like to order what they suggest. But she clearly hadn't sampled much from their selections. Overall the place is a good meal for the area but nothing to drive over from Pensacola for. read more

See all

This restaurant looked like it would be the one healthy, serious food opportunity in an area that was dominated by fast food chains, but there was no indication that it was situated in the middle of a gambling casino. Walking my 7 year old grandson through a myriad of flashing lights and machines we finally found the restaurant boarded shut. It would make sense to indicate on the website that it was shuttered and that it is housed in a casino. read more

First visit to Fire steakhouse and everything was excellent from service to cocktails and meal. We had a great lemon drop martini to start and it was served frosty cold as it should be. We all had the onion soup and this was top notch. Served piping hot with a beefy broth loaded with tender onions. All topped with cheese and broiled to perfection. Steaks, 2 had the ribeye and 2 had the filet. They were all cooked perfectly. The ribeye was well marbled, juicy and tender while the filet cut like butter. All were served with either loaded mashed potatoes or baked potato along with roasted asparagus. Mashed were topped with cheese and bacon and might I add there was no shortage on the bacon. The potatoes were smooth and creamy with loads of melty cheese. We ended the meal with grand manieur creme Brule. Crunchy sugar topping with creamy orange flavored custard. If I'm ever in the area again we will definety return. Ps. They ended the meal by giving each lady a long stemmed red rose. Such a nice classy touch read more

See all

This was our 4th visit to Fire and each time has been a wonderful experience. The service is second to none and the food is absolutely fantastic. I highly recommend the Pan Seared Diver Scallops. It is by far one of the best dishes I have ever eaten. The Bourbon Brined Chicken and Waffles is amazing as well! My only complaint was an apparent miscommunication on the dress code. We were in town for a race and called to inquire if there was a strict dress code. We were told absolutely no jeans, no t-shirts, no shorts, and no flip flops. We scrambled to go shopping for dressier clothes in Atmore (which is a challenge!) only to arrive and see that everyone else in the restaurant was wearing jeans! read more

The food is very good. I love their Brisket Sandwich. The staff was very Friendly. Quick service.

This place is phenomenal! My love and I went to Fire before a concert and we were NOT disappointed. Our server/bartender Mitchell was just wonderful from beginning to end. I ordered the scallops and wedge salad. Because my honey knew I would eat it all he only ordered the olive bread and New York cheese cake. The complimentary bon-bons and long stem red rose were simply the icing on the cake. I've fallen in love with Fire! We plan to go back and truly enjoy the steak in the near future. read more

See all

I just one of the best meals!! Awesome. Service was great, French onion soup (awesome), Oysters Rockefeller's (amazing), and topped off with the 60 day aged Cowboy Ribeye (perfect)!!!!! My compliments to the chef.....absolutely superb meal. read more

Fire Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Atmore, Alabama

See all

I am so sad to give Fire a 3 star! We love this restaurant and look forward to every visit. I do not know that we will make another trip simply because it turned into a 3 hour affair. The food was good. Not 5 star good, but good. No complaints there really. The major complaint was with the service. Our waitress was very personable, but just had too many tables to man. It turned the experience into a common, 3 star experience at a 5 star price. My husband and I took our mothers and aunt for what we anticipated to be an incredible dining experience. Our bill was $260 + and $40 tip. This was not a $300 food experience. We didn't even get the rose at the end of the meal. Even the girl cleaning the table commented on our slowwwwww service. Also, I suggest a dress code for dinner. It has just totally slipped. It seemed to be filled with gambling comps, with a more casual feel. Just not at casual prices. ***I was called by management and will definitely give them another try. I also raised them to 4 stars simply bc of their fabulous customer service! read more