Even a five-star restaurant makes mistakes. ALL ethical businesses from a food truck to a five-star restaurant take responsibility for their failures. Fiesta Mexico, however, does not. While entertaining out-of-town guests, we ordered from here. The "crab quesadilla" looked at like a stale pita left on a sidewalk that someone vomited on. It was burned around the corners and definitely not a quesadilla. Being a business owner myself, I am quite empathic to the occasional error. However the ethical business refunds the customer, apologizes, and offers incentive to for the disappointed customer to patronize one's business again. The rest of the food smelled stale and we were afraid to eat it. We threw it away and ordered elsewhere. Well we should have filed a complaint with the health department and the Better Business Bureau. YELP and karma, however, will take care of this dreadful place. STAY AWAY! read more

LOVE this place! Ive been here a few times with ZERO complaints. Try the "grande dinner" with a Corona Margarita! read more

Fiesta Mexico - Corona Margarita... you NEED this! - Mexican Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

The lunch buffet is small and has a cold side and a hot side. The food seems pretty authentic. Steak, chicken, and ground beef fajita. Peppers, and enchiladas, and taquerias. The food is always fresh and hot on the Buffett. The servers are very friendly. read more

Great service and ambiance. Food was sub-par. Had to pay extra for lettuce, sour cream etc. Taquitos we're over cooked, dry and overpriced.

I have been to this location twice now - the first time was after I got married at the District Magistrate and with a group of family. This past weekend My wife and I decided to avoid fast food and stopped in. They had signs up with specials for cinco de mayo. The two listed that we decided to were Crab Enchiladas and Fish Tacos - both were reasonably priced - 8.95 and 6.75 respectively. I ordered a Tecate and it came with a lime in the bottle neck, so I asked for a glass and they returned promptly with a mug. Before I go on I will mention that I was told the owner also owns El Rodeo on RT 30, which is the place I was using as point of reference for comparison. I like the layout - it seems mor spacious with a few separate seating areas -booths, tables for two and long group tables with a nice window with view of half the parking lot. They have a small bar in the back toward the kitchen area too. There was a server that appeared to be receiving training, but it did not delay anything our food came out hot within minutes. I asked for hot sauce and was handed two bottles -one pepper sauce and one habanero sauce which was nice for the choice. I tasted my wife's crab enchilada which tasted like a crab cake sliced up, put into a tortilla and covered with cheese sauce. It tastes better than it sounds, but the filler (breading, red pepper) was an unnecessary addition. I enjoyed the cold beer and fish tacos with some habanero sauce mixed in to the rice which was cooked very well - nice and fluffy with great texure. We picked up a gift card for my father in law's birthday too, so it was very convenient. I prefer Fiesta Mexico slightly to El Rodeo, but have considered both to be better than average service wise and the food is good too. read more

Fiesta Mexico - menu - Mexican Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

See all

Best Mexican restaurant in the area with a friendly staff and very fast service. The lunch buffet during the week is a great deal with enough options. It gets even better when they offer their drink and food specials. read more

Fiesta Mexico - Mexican Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

I ordered a classic Burrito and got REALLY disappointed when the server brought out my plate. Their burrito is different than any other burrito I've ever seen. It's exactly like an enchilada. There is no rice, beans, guacamole, salsa, etc inside it. It's ONLY meat, or whatever other flavor you pick. Mine had literally ground beef only. It comes on a plate covered in a lot of tomato sauce and cheese. You def can't eat with your hands because it's very soft. Really, not a burrito at all!!! read more

See all

Wife and I had a very good time. Romantic atmosphere, classy music, wonderful food, and friendly staff. Will be visiting again. read more

Fiesta Mexico - a woman eating a plate of food - Mexican Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

Had dinner with friends last night at this location. Staff very friendly and welcoming. Service was great and attentive. Ordered margaritas and a mojito from the bar. Drinks were delicious and arrived quickly. Chips and salsa were good. Entrees came quickly and were sizzling hot. Very nice presentation and delicious. We will definitely be back. read more

Great food, great atmosphere! I took my wife here for her birthday and she loved it. They had a live Marrachi band and the food was top notch. I was hesitant to go at first, but we are now regulars at this location. read more

I ate food from this restaurant twice. Mixed findings each time. Take out. Food is okay. Edible and not bad. Not great. First time the chips were not good but that is okay, not what I came for. Second time better enjoyed. First time rice was good, second time cold and not tasty. Tacos were good. Corn Tortillas were soggy the second time. Just Not right. Slaw not that tasty. First time tacos and enchiladas were good. Nothing was great. Enjoyed other Mexican restaurants in York better. Summary, most things not bad. Will get something not enjoyable in your order. Probably won't return here. read more

Love the 'Jośe's Combo!' Great portion sizes. Genuine steaming fresh food. I have yet to be disappointed, even with carry out! If you're choosing Mexican, might as well make it fiesta! read more

I ordered from here for the first time on January 28th And got the Quesabirria tacos and a Mexican coke and this food was fire Literally one of the best places that I have had tacos at Thanks for the great food highly recommend And I will be ordering again. read more

The restaurant is nice at new place. Food was great, but service was horrible. Waitress never checked in on us to see if we needed more to drink or if the food was good. The kitchen too forever and they were not busy. Not going back. read more

Had the tacos, the flavor was good but when I came to think about it I paid a little over 5 dollars per taco. I used to get these things in Yuma Arizona for around a dollar a piece. I know everything is pricy now a days, but 5 dollars for a corn tortilla, a little meat and some chopped veggies... read more

Great new location! The details in the remodeled location across from Giant are fantastic! Today the Queso Fundito is perfect. And the chimichangas lunch was equally tasty! Personally I think their coffee is among the best too. All served up by a wonderful staff. read more

So on food alone, Fiesta Mexico rates a 3-- however, their service is so fantastic that I have to bump them up to a 4. They have the friendliest servers who are super patient, attentive, and helpful. The food is good, not the best Mexican I've ever had but surely not the worst. I'm pretty boring when it comes to ordering at these kinds of places (tacos + beans, por favor), but I've dined with others who have enjoyed slightly more sophisticated options. I would definitely say Fiesta Mexico is the best Mexican joint in York. Does it compare to something you'd eat in South Texas? Heck no. But I certainly don't expect it to. Fiesta Mexico also offers a lot of promotions/discounts-- most recently a $4.99 lunch deal. Their beers are also incredibly inexpensive, at least compared to the price tag I'm used to seeing for Dos Equis. I've been there more than once where a group of 3 has dined, with beers, for less than $45. That, in my book, is a deal. read more

We are not from the area and stopped here based on yelp reviews. We had spectacular meals. Service was 9/10. Highly recommend.

This has got to be one of the best Mexican restaurants I have been to in the States. The chorizo is amazingly authentic and the portions are hefty, yeah I said hefty. "The Good" -The prices are very reasonable for both the quality and amount of food. -All the food was very high quality and very different then the cookie cutter Mexican restaurant that exists throughout the States... Although some of the menu items have the same names you can always taste when there is love and pride in the food. -This is the first time I ever saw advertising on a Pint Glass... kinda similar to the old advertising on the place mat but on the pint. -Queso Fundido. Please, just order it... do not think about it or what it will do. This would be one of the last meal dishes everyone thinks about. It is simply amazing -Jarritos (What soda is supposed to be) "The Meh" The limit of two baskets of chips. Yeah you need to save room for the fantastic food, but with the people I hang with those chips will not stand a chance. "The Bad" The fact that there will be no room for desert unless your portion control and will power are at their best. read more

We've passed Fiesta Mexico plenty of times and finally got to try it out this week. The decor looks pretty similar to El Rodero's, which makes perfect sense if they're owned by the same person as the other review indicates. We were greeted warmly and seated right away. I'm personally on again, off again about Mexico food and usually need to be in the mood to dig in. Sadly this mood only comes around once in a long, long time. At Fiesta Mexico I finally found something that I can always eat - the fish tacos. I've been to Fiesta Mexico twice so far and had it both times, I just couldn't resist it. The fish, according to a friend, is a battered and fried haddock. The taco is very simply done - a bit of lettuce and loaded with fish and pico de gallo. My boyfriend had the Chile Colorado and Chile Verde and said both were good, although the Colorado won out. The rest of the menu looks pretty interesting as well and I hope to have many trips back to sample them all! read more

So disappointed! This used to be one of our favorite family places, but we won't be back. When we arrived, I noticed an application for a liquor license transfer to a new owner. I was a little worried that things might have changed and I was right to be concerned. The salsa was so spicy, we couldn't eat it. We asked for a more mild one and received a version of a marinara sauce that was warm. The queso fundido was a shell of its former self. The rice, which is my daughter's favorite, was bland. None of the meats we had seemed to be seasoned. It was just a terrible experience. I guess the fiesta is over. read more

This place was excellent!! I lived in Phoenix, Arizona for 4 yrs so I Picky when it comes to Mexican. I ordered the carne asada tacos and my boyfriend the Hawaiian fajitas both were fresh made to order delicious food! My steak (carne asada) was tender just like the menu said and the refried beans very good!! My boyfriend who is very picky actually liked it and said he would come back! As would I, I will be taking advantage of their lunch specials! So happy I found good Mexican food in central PA! read more

We originally went to el rodeo and didn't like their customer service for nothing there so we got up and left and hopped on over to Fiesta mexico and Im so glad we did! The food was great the price was awesome and the service was the best! So El Rodeo lost some customers and Fiesta mexico gained some! Great staff and Great Job To everyone there! read more

Fiesta Mexico - My son eating his San Jose Burrito and It was delicious! - Mexican Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

We got Jose's combo and fish tacos food was very hot and delicious. The prices are very reasonable. The server was very attentive and service was great. I would definitely recommend this restaurant. read more

Good food & decent service. Nice ambiance. Prices are just as good. I'm no Mexican food oficionado but this place is just fine. Full bar and lunch buffet too. $1.99 Monday Margaritas. read more

See all

Went here on a random Friday night because we were in the area and it was recommended. My first impression from the outside was this was a former fast food restaurant. Inside however was another story. It was nicely redone with separate dining areas with arches, authentic Mexican décor, and tables like I've seen no where else. I liked the variety of the menu although some things were listed several times, which I found is pretty typical with ethnic restaurants. Our order came out super fast, was fresh, and very tasty. We were pleased with the meal overall. If I had to list a negative it would be that the waiter was hard to understand and we had to get someone else to look for him so we could get our check. The horchata was also a little too milk flavored then what I am used to. Overall a very good meal for the price, we'd go back if we are back that way again at mealtime. read more

Restaurant was almost empty at 9:30 on a Saturday night. That was a bit surprising, but we decided to go in based on the Yelp reviews. I thought there was a funny smell inside, but neither of my dining companions smelled it, so maybe it was just me. Service was prompt. Drinks were out quickly. Food was also out quickly. What can I say? It was tasty, hot, and fresh. It wasn't anything mind-blowing, but it's a solid choice for dinner with friends or family. read more

Ordered food to be delivered and was missing half my order. Called and was asked to hold and spent 5 minutes listening to nothing but noise from what I am assuming was the kitchen. Hung up and tried to call back and got a message saying the phone number was not in service. My husband and I used to enjoy going here but now I would never recommend ordering from here and will not be going back. read more

Good food always come back here on a regular basis.. ... So esta muy bueno .yes I do read more

The food was good. Too many choices. Menu difficult to read. Staff wearing masks appropriately and following social distancing.

On sunday i took my son and his girlfriend to fiesta mexico. The food was terrible! I was so disapointed. With drinks we spent over 90.00. I would recommend skipping the food and having a variery of margaritas. I can not believe how horrible the food was. read more

Our favorite spot for family dinner. Maribel is a wonderful waitress and the rest is the staff is polite and fantastico. I go for the Tacos Al Pastor, my wife often has either the Fiesta Taco Dinner (shredded all-white meat tacos on soft shells) or the taco salad. There's even chicken tenders for my picky eating son. 5 stars for Fiesta Mexico! read more

I must say this was some of the best Mexican food I have had. They just started indoor dining and the staff was pleasant, all wearing their masks PROPERLY, tables were socially distanced. The food however was the star. There were five of us including one child and we all loved the food. Definitely check this place out. read more

I am a fan of Fiesta Mexico. I like their lunch buffet and the selection on it. I like their dinner combos too. The service is always decent as well. I like the vegetarian options that they have and the prices are very reasonable as well. This may not be the most authentic Mexican restaurant around but there is a lot of bang for the buck and I am never disappointed. Good fried ice cream as well. read more

While the food and drinks are good and we have been here a couple times, tonight was not an enjoyable experience. Our waitress, Maribel who constantly yelled while asking for our order, how our food was and then let us just sit there for the longest before getting us the check. Then when she did it took the longest for her to process and bring us a receipt. Not impressed with her as a server at all. read more

Food had been great but the latest experience AWFUL. The Jose's combo came out cold. the wraps were like rubber. I couldn't eat much. When I told the waiter, he didn't have an answer. I sent an email telling them my experience. I will send an update once I get a response. Well its been a month after several inquiries and no response so the update is that I won't be going back. read more

Finally got to try out their lunch buffet yesterday. It runs Monday - Friday from 11:00 to 3:00 I believe and it only costs $8.99!!! I can't wait to go back again!!! read more

After eating the same two meals for years (taco trio...I get all chicken or the chicken fajita) I've decided to try some different entrees. I had the chicken mole (shredded chicken with a dark, mild sauce) recently and I loved it. I normally go for hot/spicy but this was a refreshing change. Next visit I tried the chicken enchiladas with poblano sauce (another mild dark sauce.) YUM! Many people will not try Mexican food because they can't handle spicy. Fear not! There's plenty of delicious, mild choices. I've never been disappointed with service or food here. Please don't ever change! read more

I love Mexican food was very pleased with all the choices only critics was unlike most other places there was no sauce on the inside of the enchiladas leaving them to seem very dry and a little salt and pepper while cooking the meats couldn't hurt but the flavors in sauces on the outside and the chip and salsa where very good with just a little tweeking here and there could be 5 stars all the way. The waitress was nice enough but she could have asked if we needed anything because we did I had to get up and find her but overall I will give it another on the food alone asking them to put sauce into the dishes not just on them. Pretty tasty overall though. read more

Decent place, food was good, service was great. A great atmosphere and plenty of parking. Some unusual dishes on the menu, I recommend leaving your comfort zone and trying something new. read more