Rating: 5/5 Stars Fellini's is easily a 10/10. The pizza is exactly what you want: perfectly crisp and easy to fold in half for that classic experience. One of the best parts is the sauce--it's savory and fantastic without being overly sweet, which is a huge plus for me. The location itself has a great energy with those downtown vibes, and the throwback music they were playing was incredible! Whether you want to sit inside or enjoy the outdoor seating, the atmosphere is spot on. Definitely a must-visit. read more

See all

Felini's Pizzeria doesn't serve pizza. They serve confidence. The kind that makes you question every sad, floppy slice you've ever eaten in your life. First bite? Immediate disrespect to every chain pizza joint in America. The crust actually has structure. The sauce tastes like it went to culinary school. The slices are so big you need both hands and a game plan. If your pizza doesn't fold like a proper New York slice and still hold its dignity, what are we even doing? The vibe is loud, chaotic, and perfect. The staff moves fast, the ovens are blazing, and the whole place feels like Atlanta's unofficial pizza headquarters. You walk in hungry and leave rethinking your loyalty to every other pizzeria. If Felini's isn't in your top tier, your taste buds need counseling. read more

Food There's bunch of great options but this time around I opted for the Italian sausage pizza slice. The cool thing about their Italian sausage is that they are large slices unlike other pizza places. It was a satisfying slice but beware of the hard crust. Service Great staff, friendly, quick Ambiance Casual with plenty of seating read more

Fellini's Pizza - Italian Sausage Slice - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

I was coming from an event and I hadn't ate at all. I just wanted something quick and simple. Checked Yelp of course and found Fellini's! I've been here plenty of times but I was so excited to see it was nearby. I ordered the cheese pizza with pepperoni and it was perfection. It was everything I needed and wanted. Usually the crust is so hard but this time around everything was how it should be. The people here were friendly and quick. The cashier had a great personality. The place was clean and had plenty of seating. Super casual great pizza spot. read more

See all

Was craving some pizza, but just wanted a slice or 2. I was driving by and saw Fellini's and decided to stop. It was a busy Saturday night. I've been to other locations before so I already had high expectations. They did not disappoint. The service was excellent - fast, friendly and accurate. I ordered 2 slices. The white pizza wasn't my favorite, but overall it was good. Still get an A+ from me! read more

Fellini's Pizza - White slice on the left - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

I've heard mixed reviews about Fellini's, but when I came, they were on point! I ordered a slice of pepperoni, and my pizza came out super fresh. It was hot, had a generous amount of pepperoni, and the crust had that nice crunch to it when I bit in. I enjoyed every single bite of my pizza and regretfully did not order another slice. I came when it was not busy, so perhaps they gave some extra care to my slice. Regardless, I would totally come back. They have indoor seating as well as a patio area. This location does not accept cash! Parking in the lot is a bit limited and tight - lots of cars parked over lines. read more

Fellini's Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

What else can I say. An Atlanta staple. Cheesy, Saucy, Fresh N Hot! Great Patio for Al Fresco dining and multiple locations. I ordered a slice of white and Meat Lovers and it's just what I was craving. Slices are huge so 1 slice is really like 2. Give them a try... read more

Fellini's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

A Slice of Perfection at Fellini's Pizza! Fellini's isn't just a pizza restaurant -- it's an Atlanta institution and a true love letter to New York-style pizza done right. The moment you walk in, you're greeted by the irresistible aroma of fresh dough baking and melted cheese bubbling in the oven. The vibe is laid-back, local, and full of character -- the kind of place where friends gather after work, families share a pie on the weekend, and everyone leaves with a smile (and maybe a little extra parmesan on their shirt). The pizza? Absolutely outstanding. The crust strikes that rare balance -- crispy on the outside, chewy and flavorful inside -- and the sauce has just the right tang with a hint of sweetness. The toppings are always fresh and generous, whether you're going classic with pepperoni or loading up on veggies. Don't miss their white pizza; it's rich, garlicky, and downright addictive. Service is fast, friendly, and unfussy -- the team at Fellini's knows their regulars, and they make everyone feel like part of the family. Pair your slice with a cold drink, grab a seat on the patio, and you've got one of the best casual dining experiences in the city. In a world full of trendy pizza spots trying too hard, Fellini's keeps it real -- simple, delicious, and consistently excellent. If you haven't been yet, you're missing out on one of the best slices around. Fellini's Pizza: A timeless classic that never disappoints. read more

See all

Pizza = 5 stars. As good as other fellinis. Location = easy accessible for the area but because of the location the parking lot is kind of a pain. It's small and the spaces are very hilly. Also the outdoor patio is very loud because it's along a bush street = 3 stars overall. Overall 4 stars because food is good but I like the amenities at the other locations better read more

Very good hot pie! We ordered the meat special along with a slice of the Sicilian white pizza and vegetable pizza. All three were very good. Only thing that's bad is the parking at this place! It sucks! read more

Fellini's Pizza - Meat lovers and Sicilian vegetable pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

I've been a fan of Fellini's for quite a while. They've always been pretty consistent and tasty for a good quick slice. They have counter service and will bring the food to your table with an open drink dispenser. This place can get pretty busy depending on when you go. Most locations have a good outside sitting area in breezy locations across Atlanta which is great when you want to sit and just chill on a patio for a bit while drinking a cold beer. I personally like the salads here with their house Italian dressing and their White Pizza. It's not the best pizza, but as I started with, it's consistent and decent pizza by the slice. read more

I haven't been here in over a year and it wasn't this location. I called in a pick up order and was happy it was ready when I arrived. Staff was nice and quick to greet me. Pizza was sooo fresh and not overly salty. Fellini's remains one of my favorite pizza places, but I do wish they used cherry tomatoes or cut the slices. Also, the cheese wasn't how I had it before (as a standard pizza?), so not sure if I ordered the wrong thing. Nevertheless, yum!!! read more

Fellini's Pizza - Medium meat lovers - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

This was my first time eating at Fellini's versus getting it to go. The location is great (I took the bus there) and there is ample indoor seating. I ordered the spinach and mushroom pizza but with regular cheese (it comes with extra cheese by default) and it was great. It didn't taste greasy at all and the little bits of minced garlic on top gave it a nice flavor. I ended up getting 2 slices of regular cheese to-go and they were still good! Overall, service was great. I went during lunch time and was seated quickly. It only took about 10 minutes or so for my original slice to come out. My to-go one took a bit longer but that's just because quite a few people came in to pick up orders at the same time. The ambiance was nice, they had the garage doors up since the weather is warming up which is nice. I also noticed that there weren't any flies or anything which was nice. I'd definitely come back to this location! read more

See all

Went to a movie, then got a slice of pizza (Fellini's special). Very large slice for $5+...nice employees, quirky decor, fast service and tasty. Chill atmosphere inside and out (nice big patio). Clean and smells yummy inside, pizzas are always cooking/fresh. read more

Fellini's Pizza - Slice of pizza, Fellini special I think...? - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Fellini's pizza is a place you have to stop by if you're in the area. The ambiance is a really good spot for groups with plenty of seating and a nice area to eat outside as well. The service is pretty straightforward and good. You just order at the counter and then they will bring the pizza to your table when it's ready and everyone we interacted with was very kind. The food was the real highlight of the experience though. The taste and portion size was outstanding. We ordered 2 medium ($33 total) pizzas for 3 people and we were absolutely stuffed after 3 slices each. Another person in our group got the calzone which was also delicious and a great pick as well. Overall Fellini's is a great choice for some fairly quick, reasonably priced, delicious pizza. read more

Fellini's Pizza - Medium pizza with sausage - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Consistently great people who all seem to enjoy being there. Good pizza and no hassles for customizing. Great family spot too.

I love this location, because of the open seating. The pizza is always hot and fresh. My favorite is the pepperoni slice and the prices are great. The service is great! read more

was a 5 star review on here and have been a customer for years but had to change my review to a 1 star review because of a mistake and then a specific employee Samantha who in my opinion is rude, condescending, argumentive and has no business dealing in customer service. I drove all the way from Mableton waited for my pizza, drove all the way back home and had to come back because a pizza I order well done was not only not well done it literally had raw dough.so I asked for a refund and if this pizza with raw dough looks well done, she did not process the refund and would not answer the question if the pizza was well done (so how was I going to get a well done one if they thing raw dough is well done) so instead of a refund and an apology she just kept arguing that well done is and opinion, so I then asked in her opinion was this well done she refused to answer again then another guy came over and started to do my refund because she wasn't and just kept escalating and arguing to where another employee asked her to stop and she kept going then when it to the back and came out running her mouth again. read more

Fellini's Pizza - The employee Samantha that I don't think should be dealing with customers and likes to escalate situations. - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

I had a disappointing experience at the Howell Mill location on Friday, June 26. I called from the parking lot to place a to-go order, and the young lady who answered told me they don't accept to-go orders between 5 and 9 PM on Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays. I said okay and decided to go inside to place my order in person. After ordering, I was told it would take 30 minutes for my calzone. No problem--I sat down inside the store to wait, despite how hot it was inside (the thermostat read 81 degrees). While sitting there, I watched the same young lady who answered my call take two to-go orders over the phone--pleasantly and without hesitation. When I picked up my food, I asked who the manager was and was told it was the person handing me my order. I explained what I witnessed, and instead of acknowledging the issue, he tried to tell me it wasn't the same person--insisting I was mistaken, even though I had a clear view from my car earlier. Then he admitted, "Well, she wasn't supposed to do that." So which is it? I work in a customer service-based field myself and understand policies and mistakes happen--but to lie to my face and treat me like I imagined the whole thing was unacceptable. The difference in how I was treated versus others was noticeable, and I sincerely hope race wasn't a factor--but I'd be lying if I said the thought didn't cross my mind. I typically go to the Decatur location and have had great experiences there. Unfortunately, the Howell Mill location left a very bad impression. Customer service and consistency matter--this location needs work on both. read more

I don't usually write reviews, but since I won't complain to who wasted their money on this pizza; I feel inspired to... pizza was undercooked... I don't know how everyone else in my group ate their pizza, I rushed thru one slice & will throw away the rest when nobody is looking. never eating this trash again. read more

Fellini's has the look, feel, and even the smell of an old-school pizzeria. I loved seeing the hot pizza oven, front and center, as soon as we walked in. We ordered a large pie with mushrooms, tomatoes, and ham (they do half-pie toppings here) and issued a framed postcard so that our order could find us in the dining room. Seating space is plentiful here, including an expansive indoor dining space and patio spacing outdoors. We sat indoors, where an otherwise industrial space was made to feel cozy with soft lighting and splashes of artwork all around the perimeter. Our pizza arrived at our table within ten minutes and found it to be better than average for Atlantan pizza. The sauce is excellent - neither too sweet nor salty - and the crust had a unique chew beneath the crisp. Interestingly, we noticed our slices with ham had become a little soggier than the ones without, which made us wonder if certain toppings might release moisture to the detriment of our pie. Either way, we devoured most of our pie and appreciated that Fellini's keeps their takeout boxes on a helpful table by the dining space so that you can easily retrieve whatever you need on your own. Service here is brusque yet efficient. Since most things are set up for self-service, we enjoyed the ability to dine without having servers repeatedly check in on us. The parking lot outside is small but seemed more than enough spaces on a weekday night (weekends might be another story). We were also happy to discover they're open until midnight, so we'll certainly be keeping Fellini's as an option for late night eats. read more

See all

Really good pizza served here. The ingredients are fresh, the sauce was homemade and the crust was nice and crisp. I ordered a sausage, pepperoni and meatball pie. Friendly staff and great service. read more

See all

Mom and I wanted pizza and Fellinis was close by so we came to check it out. The first thing that I noticed was parking was a nightmare . Their lot is super tight and very difficult to enter and exit from. That being said, the restaurant itself is rather large with plenty of indoor and outdoor patio seating. Instead of table service, you order at counter and they bring the food to you. We ordered a vegetarian pie (with sausage on one half for mom). When the pizza came out it looked and it smelled delicious. I think the pizza was decent but I felt that the sauce was too thin and watery. All of the topping, including the cheese, basically slides right off the crust. So although the taste is there, the pizza itself was messy and can use a little improvement. I'd say that although I'm interested in seeing what other pizza places are out here, I'd give Fillini's one more try to see if there's improvement on the next pie. read more

Fellini's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

My favorite place to get pizza! I always get 1 veggie slice and 1 Fellini's Special. One day I'll try something different but their pizza is so good! I once ordered a veggie pie but it wasn't as good as the individual slice so I don't get the pies. The service is quick, my order is always ready by the time I pick it up. This is my number 1 pizzeria! read more

Fellini's Pizza - Fellini's Special - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

This place never disappoints!! Consistency is key to any successful business and Fellini's has stood the test of time!! Whenever I need a great slice of Heaven, Fellini's is my go-to!! The service is always excellent and if you like the ambiance of chilling out on the patio, then the one on Ponce is just a short drive away!! All locations offer the same quality I've grown accustomed to!!! read more

The whole model of adding toppings to a premade pizza slice and then it taking 20+ minutes to be served needs a rethink. A freshly made personal pizza could be accomplished in that amount of time and would be worth it. read more

I came on a Friday night and the location was pretty busy and lively with numerous groups and families dining in. I placed a to-go order at the counter and the employee patiently explained some of their unique menu offerings. I only had to wait about 15 minutes for a fresh medium pizza that was delicious. read more

Ordered - we received a poorly filled calzone with unbaked marinara, 1 slice that were ice cold that came 20 mins after the baked calzone. Charged $2 for a box apple juice and ultimately was approached by a cashier who attempted to check me for failing to properly charge me for food. Makayla was the cashier who then had to be coached into a apology and then felt she was offering me a courtesy charging me for less. Definitely underwhelmed and will not be returning to the location. read more

Great pizza that is a little on the high side of price but not ridiculous. The square pizza (works)was awesome, very thick and crisp but covered in toppings. The regular pepperoni pizza was amazing too. Customer service was meh read more

See all

The pizza tasted great, the workers were courteous, and I really liked the feel of the place! The prices are reasonable and our pizza came out pretty quick. Definitely down to come back. read more

Fellini's Pizza - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Fellini's is my go to pizza spot that has consistently served fresh, quality food since my college days at Emory. I can't say any particular location is my favorite, but I will say that I have received the best overall service at both the Howell Mill store and Ponce store. The staff are always super friendly and eager to help. That for me goes a long way when there are hundreds of other pizza spots in the city. For my recent visit, I ordered a calzone with sausage and pepperoni , plus a house salad with balsamic vinaigrette. Both were delicious!! Plus, the serving sizes are very large, making it easy to share (in this case, I shared with my husband). While there are definitely more authentic pizza spots in the midtown area, I will continue to support this local staple. read more

Fellini's Pizza - Italian Sausage and Pepperoni Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Fellinis is another staple in our family. I feel like I used to come here when I skipped school in my youth... if I weren't an angel. Anyway, for fond memories Alone I would give this place 5 stars but they just deserve it overall. The pizza is always tasty, artwork is interesting, service is generally friendly sometimes a little indifferent but never rude. It's quick. The patio is lovely in warm weather. It's open late.... Go! Oh and The leftovers reheat beautifully! read more

This was my first time at this fellini's location. I've been to the one on Roswell road and had a less than stellar experience. But this time was very different! There was no line when we arrived on Wednesday evening around 6. The person at the counter was so nice and quickly placed our order. They have lots of indoor and outdoor seating available. We sat outside because it was a nice night. Our food came out very quickly! I got a white slice with meatballs and spinach. Soooo so good! The crust this time was so fluffy. They were very generous with the cheese and toppings! It was a large slice and was plenty for me to be full! read more

Fellini's Pizza - White slice with meatballs and spinach - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

I've always been a Fellini's fan. Places where I can order custom individual slices of pizza are always a win. Recently, on a Friday night, a friend and I went and I ordered 2 slices with various spinach, broccoli, and green olives, yum! Plus I got a local brew. Probably less than 10 minutes after placing the order, my slices arrived. I doused them with red pepper flakes and dug in. Since the slices were already cooked and reheated with the toppings, the crust was nice and toasty, very crunchy. I happily inhaled the pizza while sipping on my beer. I can't count how many times I've been to Fellini's, but I know for certain I'll be back. Until next time. read more

Fellini's Pizza - Pizza slices - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Picked up a pizza while I was out. It was extremely fresh and very yummy. I will not hesitate to get another pizza from Fellini's the next time I'm in the area. read more

I would give 0 stars if I could. I asked for a make your own slice with sausage, ham, onions and green peppers. This is what I got, lol. They did put 3 out of the 4 of those things on top of an old cheese slice. A banana pepper and mushroom made it on there, too! Like...what??? I was so disappointed when my wife brought this back home. read more

Fellini's Pizza - Make your own slice: sausage, peppers, onions and ham. I did not ask for that random banana pepper nor mushroom. - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

This place has a good menu and a big space to chill and grab some tasty pizza. We had the special, white, and hawaiian. The crust is thick and made the pizza filling. The lady who helped us was nice and gave us some really good vegan recommendations. We also got the salad and it was packed with ingredients and went very well with the pizza. I noticed there are a few of these spots around town and I would roll in for a slice or 2 again. read more

You can never go wrong with fellini's in Atlanta. They have some of the best pizza in the city. The service could be a little better but overall it's never a disappointing experience. read more

My first time eating here. Was craving some pizza and was recommended by my manager. The lady taking my order was so wonderful! She explained the entire menu front to back. We did process of elimination to determine what I should order. 2 single slices that tasted fabulous! The layout of the restaurant felt very strange and not so warming but the food definitely made it for it! read more

I never thought it was possible to make a bad pizza. I went on Saturday and ordered 2 slices. The crust was rock hard, pizza was super salty, and was so unenjoyable that my partner and I had to both throw out the pizza and go eat elsewhere. Maybe it's because we ordered slices and not personal pies, that the quality was so poor.. Even the service was awkward . You have to order at the counter first, and then go find an open table and wait for an unhappy looking waitress to bring you your food. And then they automatically prompt for a tip on their cashier screen for this service (since they don't take cash)., before you even know what the service will be like. Now waking up the next day and stomach is messed up. I don't know how they have a 4.5 rating on Google unless it's fake reviews. I gave 2 stars because at least the seating space seems like a nice place to chill with friends, if you can all tolerate crappy pizza. Also the cash register girl was sweet. read more