We were greeted warmly and politely and treated well until the end--I'll get back to that. The decor is over the top in a fun and festive way--lots to look at and a magical air. It's nice to be offered a free glass of wine, regardless of the quality. Food was a mixed bag: soup and homemade pasta were excellent, but both eggplant and marinara sauce were oddly flavorless and the shrimp in a pasta dish had a fishy, not-quite-right taste. They also upsell by offering side dishes without explaining that they are not included with the entree (and, for the prices of the meals, they should be). When I asked for clarification of the bill at the end, the warmth and politeness evaporated. I would have chalked the costly side dishes up to experience and returned if the entire meal had been tasty, but the hostility at being questioned + an only half-good meal = we will not come back. read more

I am very surprised about some negative reviews from this Italian restaurant. We have been going here for years... Or their location before in Ardmore. every time we go there the food is solid, and it is a great value as well. It's a BYOB and it is a down to earth Italian restaurant. The customer service is fantastic as well! read more

I was recommended this spot for my friends 21st birthday and it was amazing! Food was great. The owner provided efficient service, very friendly. Low light vibe, loved it! read more

Fellini Cafe - Table seating - Italian Near Me - Lower Merion, Pennsylvania

See all

Finally got to try this place, I have been to numerous Fellini Cafe's over the years and this one did not disappoint. Ordered To Go, Pollo Parmigiana. I was really having a hankering for some chicken parm and this did not disappoint. I went with the pasta side, paparadella? A flat thin noodle in nice red sauce. As with most italian restaurants they don't serve the pasta and chicken together, even tho this is where it all ends up anyway...The pasta was perfect au dente, and the chicken was delicious! He even thru in some bread which was half a roll and went perfect with my meal. It is very cute inside, I love the decor. I'll probably order more to go before I sit inside during the pandemic tho. I'm also anxious to try their desserts. read more

First time eating at Fellini Cafe. Had the Veal Osso Buco special with homemade pasta. Very good food. They seemed short staffed for a Saturday night, but the owner gave us a tiramasu which was fantastic. I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for good italian food in Bryn Mawr. read more

How pasta, crab, and shrimp can be completely devoid of flavor is beyond me. Absolutely tasteless. Bizarre. Server was nice though. read more

This is our second girls night out at this restaurant and it just is amazing. The atmosphere is friendly the wait staff is beyond helpful where they just keep taking care of you all the time the food is amazing and it's a BYO we brought two bottles of wine with us And they were opened and poured my meal consisted of a Caesar salad pasta with seafood and dessert lemon chello. Everything was delicious. We can't wait to go back. read more

The owner & chef were so gracious. The food was amazing. Real authentic Italian food. Absolutely no disappointments here. We were a party of 7 and everyone got a different Italian dish. All of us were so happy with our entrees. Complimentary bruschetta & after dinner drink. Really nice inside. read more

Fellini Cafe - Italian Near Me - Lower Merion, Pennsylvania

See all

We've been going to Fellini's since it opened in Bryn Mawr and always enjoy our meals and the service we get from Pino. I'm not adventuresome so I usually order the homemade Pappardelle with red sauce and meatballs. it's always good and there's so much of it, I have lunch for the next day. The hub typically orders the special pasta of the day and cleans his plate. It's BYO so the dinner tab is always reasonable. read more

Amazing experience doing take out. So friendly and welcoming. Just had a newborn and they were so kind to us

As an Italian food lover. I was yearning for some great Italian food last night. I ordered a Caesar Salad, Veal Parmigiana with a side of pasta, and asked for some extra marinara on the side, from Fellini's Cafe in Bryn Mawr, around 4 PM on Thursday, July 14th, using Grub Hub. I tracked my GrubHub driver on the app, starting from the time that he arrived at Fellini's Cafe for pickup. His wait time was short. And, even though he left my food at the wrong door, it was delivered quickly. The lettuce in the Caesar salad was warm and soggy, the veal parmigiana was covered in some unusual cheese that did not act like melted cheese when I cut into it; It had the texture of cheese whiz. The cheese was even worst than the veal itself, toughest veal ever...I may never eat veal parmigiana again, anywhere. By the way, I never got the side of extra marinara, maybe they just poured it all of over the meal. When I called to speak with the manager the next day, Pino, I let him know that I was not looking for any refund or payback, but, since I have enjoyed the food there in the past, I thought someone in charge should know about such an unappetizing meal that I got from his kitchen the night before. I told him all the issues. However, as soon as I mentioned to him how tough the veal was he kept interrupting me as I was speaking. He said, they have the best veal and that customers lick there plates clean. My dog would not have licked the plate that this meal was on. He implicitly called me a liar. I will never dine there or order another meal from this Fellini's or any others again. The meal was disgusting and the manager was rude! It was like flushing money down the toilet which is where the meal should have been disposed of too....very very disappointed! Stay away from this place! And, after my conversation with the manager, the establishment seemingly must have an implicit policy..."no complaining allowed!" This dining establishment's review history has decreased slowly over the years - which is expected, but now, they are down to a Yelp 3.5 stars. Just check-out the amount of one-star reviews recently. (One has to wonder if this is why some dining establishments whose menu is listed on GrubHub, for delivery, like Feliini's Cafe, do not display their star reviews on GrubHub - like the other other quality confident dining establishments do? ) Bye-Bye Fellini's read more

We received delivery tonight form Fellini Cafe. We have eaten at the Berwyn location and the Newtown Square location. Doordash only offers the Bryn Mawr location, so we ordered from it. The Gnocchi was mushy and tasted raw like dough. The bread was stale. Possibly a day old? The chicken parmesan was below average. It tasted like a frozen chicken patty with sauce and parmesan cheese on it. NO MOZZARELLA, all parmesan cheese which tasted like Kraft. The salad arrived with the dressing on it. I have never had delivery where the dressing was applied. It was not salvageable. It was drenched in dressing. read more

We ate inside and liked the atmosphere. The mussels were on but I worried that some tasted a little 'off. Our mains were a specials - so special they were not edible. We took polite bites and left the rest. I think this meal qualifies for the worst of my life. On the plus side, redeeming this to a one star, we were offered a glass of wine when we arrived and a glass of anisette with the bill. read more

Where to start? We went to Fellini about 3x before the shutdown, and it was uniformly excellent. Particularly amazing were the lobster ravioli (that sauce!) and the chicken Marsala. Also the beautiful salads. I didn't have any of the issues noted with service then or ordering in (see below) -- t owner is super nice. During the shutdown we ordered their dinner for 4 I think 4x now. It's routinely dinner for 4 and lunch for 4 more :) let's just say the chicken Marsala got ordered repeatedly. The Chicken Fellini is also great. I think at this point we have had all the pasta varieties on their menu, I think. You really won't go wrong, but the mushroom pasta is the one we keep coming back to. Also once I forgot several of the dishes and the owner found the number I ordered using and called to make sure I got the rest of my order. Awesome service and greatly appreciated. read more

OMG ‼‼ Lets get started.. first , the water glass qas FILTHY . had greasy moop on it & he poured water in it .. horrible .. then .didn't bother to ask if i wanted anything to drink... Second , ordered the mozzarella caprese . the mozzarella was the worst, the tomatoes werent ripe & there was only 2 pieces of basil on it .. horrible . the bread was old & stale .. horrible !! the lasagne had NOTHING in it .. it was literally sheets of pasta with a couple of melted cheese slices in it .. horrible!! All I can say about this place , is its HORRIBLE ‼ WORST food I have ever had.. EVER ‼ RUN AWAY, FAST ‼ BLECCHHHH SMH read more

My Family, Guest and Myself are always satisfied when we dine @ Fellini Cafe. Delicious!!

Ordered delivery on a Sunday evening - it arrived hot & fast! The homemade gnocchi was excellent, and the bread is really good. We really enjoyed the Cesar salad and cheesecake, too. No complaints - thanks! read more

I had an amazing takeout meal last night and tonight from The Original Fellini's Cafe in Bryn Mawr. The appetizer was stuffed calamari was filled with shrimp and crabmeat in a delicious crab sauce. The entree was amazing braciola with homemade pappardelle pasta in a marina sauce. The portions are very generous. I thought I was 10 yo again sitting at the dinner table with my grandmother who would make this exact meal from scratch. Pino and Franco (owners) are phenomenal....last week I had takeout dinner for 3 on Monday and dinner for 4 on Wednesday. My guests were amazed and wanted the contact information. Their number is 610-527-5200. They are open 7 days a week for takeout. They also offer delivery through DoorDash and GrubHub. read more

Fellini Cafe - Italian Near Me - Lower Merion, Pennsylvania

We went to Fellini's to celebrate my Granddaughter's birthday. There were six of us and we had the BEST Italian dinner...very authentic Italian cuisine. Warm welcoming, excellent service made for an awesome special Birthday celebration. All of us gave Fellini's 5 Stars!!!! Try the Melanzana alla Parmiggiana....FANTASTIC!!!! read more

Last evening we had a wonderful birthday celebration and Pino could not be more accommodating! The food was absolutely delicious from beginning to end. We started with an antipasto which he added a few things since we were a group and made the birthday girl feel even more special singing happy birthday at desert time! Great atmosphere go in and relax you know when you get takeout it always loses something so ignore the negative reviews and have a great time and a great meal! read more

Lunchtime on a Thursday. 1 pm. Only one other table though it was 13. 2 people working the dining room. A nice middle aged man and a surly woman. I ask what the soup du jour is and the surly woman says he will be with me. She brings one piece of bread out with one pat of butter. I ask her for more butter and she rolls her eyes at me. I order raviolies under the homemade pasta heading. If it's homemade it's overcooked. I decide to switch to coffee having tried enough. With only 2 raviolies eaten server doesn't ask if there is a problem. $16 no salad or soup. 1 pc of bread. 1 butter. After waiting 15 mins for cappuccino and now waiting 20 more mins for someone to take my payment I decide to make use of my time by writing this post. Let's recap. Slow surly service. Dirty tablecloth. Unremarkable food. Expensive. Nothing warranting a return visit for me. read more

Fellini Cafe - Cheese ravioli - Italian Near Me - Lower Merion, Pennsylvania

See all

Fellini's Café food is very authentic Italian food and the ambiance is very colorful. BYOB is great they give you glass cups and ice. The service is very friendly and I recommend you checking them out. read more

I hesitate to leave a bad review during covid but considering this is strictly about the quality of food, I don't think it is covid related. I think this was possibly the worst Alfredo I've ever had- extremely water and flavorless. I thought this would be like the location in Media but definitely not! Don't waste your money. read more

Fantastic and you can tell The chef has passion in the kitchen. Got fruti di mare and chicken parm delivery and very impressed. Will be ordering from them again. Thank you! read more

DONT WASTE YOUR $$$ Im So pissed they are charging 18$ for a lousy no effort put in meal. My meatballs were raw and dry!!!! No seasoning no nothing! Just bland basic noodles with bland red sauce. This is the worst I MEAN WORST meal I had in my entire life and that should tell y'all something. Its not hard to make daum spaghetti. Its really not. Yall need to closed down shop, or hire a expertise in cooking. I don't know how someone is raised making food like what i just had. Unbelievable i can't even make this up yall, Just pure disgusting. Someone can get sick forealllll! Close yall business DOWN!! I see why yall only had 1 customer in there!!!!! So glad it was only takeout i could never sit in there!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

Fellini Cafe - Spaghetti and Meatballs - Italian Near Me - Lower Merion, Pennsylvania

Chicken parm is not edible. It was the worst meal I have ever tried to eat at a restaurant.

We had a great dinner at The Fellini Cafe in Bryn Mawr on Tuesday. Large menu, friendly, attentive service. Did not feel rushed at all. We'll definitely return soon! read more

Disappointed with takeout! We have dined in and everything was great but the takeout didn't measure up. Pasta and sauce were excellent but the chicken Parma tasted like it was left over from yesterday and reheated. Tough and just tasted old! read more

I live locally so I thought I'd give this place a try. First of all, it is so dated and tacky inside,walls coverd in plasic flowers and blinking xmas lights!!! Walking in I was overpowered by the smell of old mops...not the arouma I expected. Finally my meal arrived but it wasn't what I ordered...when I told my waiter that he had brought me the wrong entre...he told me to F myself and started ranting who knows what! Really??? I find nothing good in this place that a 2$ box of dry pasta can't match. read more

If I could give negative stars I would. DON'T GO!!! WAS DOUBLE CHARGED. when I called and simply said hello can I talk to a manager about a double charge I was told the police would be called! What?!? I've never experienced this at a restaurant in my life and I've served before. Usually I would understand being double charged and was simply calling to say hey just a heads up this is happening but to receive this response was appalling and believe this is probably happening to others. Meal was lame and service was slow. Avoid at all costs. read more

The food was bad, drowned in sauce, and the sauce was funky. The seafood tasted not fresh and rubbery. The guy who picked up the call was rude. I've never order take out and threw most of it in the trash before this place. Adding injury to insult the place was expensive. If you want Italian, I recommend going to Enoteca Tredici down the block. read more

Went here twice, before and after lockdown. Both times, the place has disappointed me. Got the spaghetti carbonara and it was extremely oily and greasy and was really bland. Gnocchi was also bad. On my previous visit, I tried the meatballs and they were very dry and devoid of flavor. Will not go back for sure. read more

This was so disappointing. Neither of the pastas we ordered had any taste. I ordered an appetizer which I was unable to eat - calamari - which had absolutely no flavor or any good sauce. There were roughly 8 calamari in some tasteless sauce. We called at 5:30 on a Saturday night to talk to the manager and the person who answered (twice we called) said there would be no manager tonight. Good to know. Really bad. Freschetta has zero competition! Only reason we went was good memories in Newtown Square of the other Fellini. Do not waste your money! read more