Fantastic Pizza! My son and I went there after his baseball game. We had to wait 10 mins or so for it to be done. The gentleman making the pizzas, maybe the owner, was awesome, super nice person and had great conversations with him. My family loved the pizza. I highly recommend ordering pizza from here. read more

Today Tony Vanoy and I stopped at "Fat Daddo's Pizza in DeSota area of Sarasota off University Blvd. It's a small place in a shopping strip area. It was clean and staff friendly! We ordered 1 slice each of Pepperoni Pizza and shared a 12oz can of Coca Cola... Oh it was so good going down! The Pizza was good and very large. I ate about 1/2 of mine my pouch was full. I would recommend and they offer free parking! I hope you try them out. read more

See all

Passed by numerous times, finally ordered take out since it's 5 minutes from my house! It was amazing got the lasagna and was extremely impressed!! Very large portion, homemade sauce came with focaccia bread and Caesar salad! Everything about the meal was extraordinary will eat there again without question!! Great meal reasonably priced! read more

Great food, great service. Nice sit down however there was no background music, something to improve on. All around a great meal! Ordered the fried ravioli as an appetizer and was thoroughly impressed! Thank you for a wonderful dinning experience and great job! read more

Fat Daddio's Pizza - Fried Ravioli, - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Lived in Jersey for 50 years. This is not the best pizza south of Jersey. Crust was 'meh'. Mediocre. It's all about the crust! Toppings were minimal. Eggplant Parm was fair. Guess I expected too much. 'Small' salad was generous and very good. No dressing though (pick up). Bread included with the order was actually very good. Focaccia style with a shredded cheese topping. read more

Plesantly surprized.. This pie is a contender for one of the best in Sarasota. Try it you'll like it.!!!!

Still the best pizza in Sarasota!! Staff is friendly. Service is worth the time and money. I'm happy to support this restaurant. ***Big bonus... liquor store right next to them!!! read more

Fat Daddio's Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

10/10 every time. Good service, pricing, and the best pizza! I highly recommend this place.

Excellent delicious pizza. It's the best we have had in Sarasota. Coming from the New Haven area, we're spoiled. Daddio's does not disappoint. read more

Best pizza in town and best boneless wings in town for sure. The breading on their wings is almost like they hand toss it and they're not frozen cause a lot of these places will just deep fry frozen chicken wings and there's are definitely not like that 10 out of 10 would definitely recommend anyone who wants some killer pizza. read more

Good pizza, good price. They're fast and made freash when you order , that's most dishes there. Delivery is fast Amd same guy, kind, curious and goes beyond. read more

Pizza is fire as always. I am giving two star review for two reasons: 1. The pizza is VERY expensive. I'm talking $50 for 2-3 pizzas 2. The entire staff is anti-mask. Two are wearing them as chin straps, three of them just don't have a mask on at all. I highly recommended this restaurant, just not during a pandemic. Been coming here for years - and after today, it may be my last. I wish the staff cared about their custoemes read more

Fat Daddio's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Ordered pizza and wings delivered to our hotel while we were on vacation in Sarasota. The pizza was very impressive and the wings were not bad. Either would definitely order again great value for the price. read more

We ordered during the pandemic during a rain and this place was incredibly impressive. The young man on the phone was so nice with a great attitude!!! Very positive and customer friendly! The food was delicious and the delivery person showed up during pouring rain and was apologetic that " it took so long." This place deserves our business because their level of service, tasty food and prices make them 5 stars in my book!!! Kudos to them!!! read more

Best pizza ever. We are from Kentucky and wanted to try a local spot and the manager or owner not sure gave some of the best advice on things to do!!! read more

Great Philly Cheesesteak I wanted pizza for lunch and was using Yelp to look through the pizza places in the area when I ran across Fat Daddio's. I remember when Fat Daddio's was on Stickney Point Rd and how great I thought their Philly Cheesesteaks were, and forgot all about pizza. Before today I had no idea they were back. I was not disappointed. I stopped in for lunch and had their cheesesteak with their homemade 'Wiz', served on bread shipped in from Philly. The bread was soft, the sandwich delivered hot, and it brought back good memories of when I was in Center City. The owner even remembered me from visiting the other store several times, and there are not a lot of places I visit several times. I learned he is a pizza maker who learned how to make great cheesesteaks. I may have to try his pizza someday but right now I can't imagine going to his restaurant and getting something other than a cheesesteak. The one negative is it was too quiet inside, they should get a TV or pipe in some music. I'm certainly glad I re-found Fat Daddio's. read more

Fat Daddio's Pizza - Philly Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

I'm a South Jersey gal, minutes from Philly. Since moving to Florida, it's been super hard to find a place that knows how to actually make a cheesesteak (or cheese steak Philly, as known in Florida). Although I live on the other side of the state, this is the the only place I've been to so far that totally reminds me of home. From the way the steak is cooked, to the cheese and the bread itself. When I get homesick and miss the food from up north, this place fills the spot every time! read more

Pizza was very good. Driver was super nice. Price is excellent. Would get it again.

Fantastic pizza, fast delivery. Pizza was still very hot. Yum. This was my first time and we will definitely be calling again. And the large is huuuge! The only thing I would suggest to the owners is that their website is so bad it was making me nauseous. Go get Wix for a cheap, easy restaurant website builder. I almost didn't order the site was that bad. Love your pizza though! read more

Stopped coming here due to bad service awhile ago. Was talked into trying it again. Ordered a pie was told 15-20 min. Came in 20 minutes later, they then started it. read more

Food was delicious. The servers were great and very accommodating! The decor could be improved to make the environment seem warmer and more welcoming. Absolutely recommend! read more

Wanted to try a different Pizza and it's close to home. Oooooh so good! Wee bit spicy but doable. Looked good, smelled good and tasted good!!! read more

Had a great time at Fat Daddio's. Walk in and I feel like I'm in NY City. Friendly prompt service and yummy pizza. Thank you FD

I've only had delivery which was lightening speed. Good super hot. Best white pie in Sarasota. So if you like piping hot garlicky white pizza and super fast delivery....you won't be disappointed. read more

Let me tell you about the guy supposedly running this business for the lady who owns it. I mentioned that when you search Fat Daddios online through google that it clearly comes up as fatdadios.com listed as the website.. well that's not their website. It's baking ware. I'll post a picture with this review. So I advise him of this to which he says it must be my phone. I have an iPhone 12.. he says it's android based.. I told him that's not how google or Yelp work at all.. he now gets angry and tells me he doesn't f&$king care about the internet. To which I say "as a business owner you don't care about reaching your customers and properly representing yourself?" To which he yells, "I'm not the F$&king owner!" Shocked that a manager working for this business would have such a distain for business he continues to say, " I shut of the phone sometimes so I don't get orders when I don't want." So I said , "what about the owner she doesn't care?" To which he continues yelling, "Thats her!, That's on her! I don't care about the internet!" .... "I'm 60 years old I don't care about the internet!" .. was literally the rudest, most out of place food service manager I have ever seen or heard. In case you are wondering I have been working in the restaurant industry for decades. I am a culinary arts student. I am 46 years old. This guy has no business as a manager or cook with as little care as he has for his customers or the business he works for. I even offered to show him how to change the web address.. that made him even angrier.. needless to say I won't be back and I wouldn't recommend.. at least when it was Honeycrust they acted professional and attentive.. I'd be willing to bet this guy doesn't even have a food handlers card. read more

Fat Daddio's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Best pizza I have had in year. Highly recommend, awesome service great atmosphere. A shout out to a the locals its as good as Frankie's and Honey Crust. Old school pizza ! read more

This place has really excellent Pizza! Really delicious food! The service was really great! The ambiance was relaxed very pleasant! Check this place out its damn good! read more

Love this place! Highly recommend! Roger does great! Love the Italian dressing, honey bbq wings, chk bacon ranch pizza, and lasagna, just to name a few!!!!!! read more

My family and I order from here fairly often. We like to be supportive of local businesses and we really enjoy the calzones. Last time, however, we had a bad experience from start to finish. I took the time to send a constructive email to the owner and not only did he not offer to make things right, he didn't reply to me at all! Not impressed and won't be going back. read more

Even though this place had no ice for the drinks, the pizza and garlic knots were top notch!!! Definitely a hidden gem!

Very friendly and the food is very well done. I've tried the pizza (white style) and steak and cheese. I went to this place 3 days in a row. Which I would never do unless it is good. read more

1st timer last night. Ordered for pickup and it was ready super fast for a Saturday night. Both pepperoni and meat pizzas were amazing. Crust was thinner, which we love. Huge serving a french fries and onion rings. Will be back to try that cheesesteak everyone is talking about. read more

Best white pizza in town . Add tomato's & onions Frank

Very good pizza. I love the marinara and the options fir toppings! Keep it up Fat Daddio's!

Tonight was our second time ordering from here. The first time we got a loaded pizza, garlic knots, calzone and meatballs. Tonight we ordered more meatballs, the same calzone for my boyfriend and chicken Parmesan for me and cheese cake. Last time the pizza was for me and I loved it. Tonight I wanted chicken parm. Let me tell you it is all amazing!!!! (I'm too full to try the cheesecake yet but I'm sure it's good.) This place is amazing with very reasonable priced. Food is absolutely amazing!!! read more

Whoa Momma! Make that Mommios! Friendly down to earth pizza people serving pizza with perfect crust and cheese . After two very long days we felt like staying in with cold beer and feet up. Pizza is excellent. Ordered same pizza BOTH nights. Delivered to our hotel door. Dad delivered pizza, son prepared. Don't know if that dad is the Daddio's but proud nonetheless. read more

I don't even feel like they should get one star today the pizza was the worst we have ever had the new owners can't cut it this was the worst 20 dollar pizza we hAve Had no more fat.daddies in our house had bad bad bad 20 for a medium that was not even good. ..bye bye. There are.a lot of good.pizza p!aces out there read more

WOW what Great Pizza !! I was totally pleasantly surprised !! I would highly recommend them if you're looking fo a great Pizza !! read more

I was with a friend, my sister and my mom. We wanted pizza, but didn't want one of the chains. We had decided on Rico's because we knew that we all liked it. I Googled their 17th st location and learned that is was not Fat Daddio's Pizza. We decided to give them a try. We were all glad we did! They delivered it and said it should be about 30 minutes, I think it was even faster than that! The guy that delivered the pizza was really nice and friendly. The pizza was amazing! We ordered a large veggie and large pepperoni. They were huge! I can't wait to try something different next time. read more

See all

Excellent pizza with just the perfect crust! Can't wait to visit this place again next time we are back on Sarasota! read more

Fat Daddio's Pizza - a pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida