Local Pizza

1

85

60

1 year ago

Ugh. So we ordered our pizza. One white called little Italy. First time I ever had thick cooked slices of prosciutto on a pizza. Usually thin shaved slices added after pizza cooked. Prosciutto was very chewy and tough. Ricotta cream was really good. Fresh mozzarella seemed like a slice of normal mozzarella. Crust had a decent flavor. Good chewy factor and good cook. Ordered a pepperoni pizza. Pizza was soggy. Crust flimsy and wet. Pepperoni was good. Cheese was salty. The pizza was ok. The bad part was the lack of attention from stafff. Walked in 20 minutes like they said when they took our order. Couldn't find pizzas. Waited 30 minutes for pizzas on top of 20 minutes. They couldn't give an answer of what happened. Didn't seem to really care. It seemed like the pepperoni sat the 30 minutes because they forgot to make the other pizza. Would have left if we had not paid. I am sure we can do better. Take out seemed somewhat active but restaurant was dead. read more

Local Pizza - Little Italy white pizza. Prosciutto was thick, chewy and cooked. Pepperoni was salty and soggy - Pizza Near Me - Osprey, Florida

Local Pizza - Do you bake prosciutto on a pizza or put thin shavings on pizza after. - Pizza Near Me - Osprey, Florida

Local Pizza - Icky - Pizza Near Me - Osprey, Florida

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Quinton W.

0

3

1

2 months ago

Service and food were awesome! I have to write more to be able to post a review. If you are in Osprey and want pizza check it out.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

jeremy l.

0

128

68

1 year ago

Holy cow. Not just good, great, but seriously OUTSTANDING pizza! Our waitress Rebecca was fantastic. Allowed us to sample a few tasters of beer before we decided what we wanted to order. Started with the garden salad. Was perfect. Just the right amount of dressing. Hearts of palm. Onions. Fresh tomatoes. Then we got our first pizza, with onions, green peppers and mushrooms. It was so good that we ordered a plain pizza for dessert!!!! The ambiance is cool. Nice stylish interior. Bar seating if you want. TV's. Open kitchen. Definitely recommend!!!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ben J.

1

37

20

2 years ago

The best pizza I've had in the area! Honestly, it's better and more affordable than Napule. If you're craving delicious pizza at a fair price, this is the place to go! Also, the service here is very kind. Don't miss out! PS... it looks better on the inside than the outside. Don't judge a book by its cover read more

Local Pizza - Chicken Alfredo Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Osprey, Florida

Business owner information

Restaurant R.

Hi Ben, Thank you for this fantastic review!…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

George S.

0

4

0

1 year ago

Today is Feb 12 2025. Pick up food at 8:13 pm. Food was very mediocre. The worst wings I have ever tried...no flavor at all and tasted like from microwave. We debated at the register that it wasn't the right flavor, but was convinced that it is... Owner must be aware... The pasta that was ordered was their carbonera but we were given rigatoni noodles instead...with no mention about it what so ever. I normally never say anything but felt that after today's experience something had to be said so that improvements can be made and others can enjoy a good meal. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kaylee B.

0

1

8 months ago

This place is bomb and so welcoming! The wait is long, but beyond worth it. Local pizza has the freshest ingredients and best menu options! I've never once been disappointed. Always clean with the cutest store front. Highly recommend as a returning customer. read more

Local Pizza - So good I could barely get a full pic - Pizza Near Me - Osprey, Florida

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Catt A.

2

202

89

2 years ago

I can't speak to the service for dine in as I took out, but I ordered a gluten free pizza and salad from here. Everything was delicious, especially for Florida (I live in New Jersey). The sauce wasn't overly sweet, the toppings fresh, and the side salad was excellent. I will certainly return when my celiac self has a pizza craving in the future! read more

Business owner information

Restaurant R.

Hi Catt!…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

V N.

0

52

3

1 year ago

So glad we found Local Pizza. Delicious food, roasted artichokes - fabulous, loved the chicken parm lunch special and lemon Caesar salad. Chris our server was fantastic! Looking forward to coming back here from NY! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bill M.

4

113

190

2 years ago

So I ordered take-out from them for my Son and his family when they came to town. I have to agree with my 11 year Granddaughter - Dominos - not that I'd ever order from them - has better pizza . Sauce was tasteless. Crust underbaked. Not crispy. It was pretty hmm... not good. That's disappointing as I would like to give 'Local' businesses a shot. But these folks need to do better. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

James H.

0

1

2 years ago

The Pizza is pretty average, Could be better 5.5 - 10 Prolly won't go back. Light sauce, pepperoni isn't the best quality. Cooked okay read more

Local Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Osprey, Florida

Business owner information

Restaurant R.

Hi James,…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jo B.

119

174

416

3 years ago

Great staff, good pizza. Honestly enjoyed the leftover pizza the next day, microwaved for a minute, for beach lunches! Outdoor covered patio. Small spot, parking easy. Only one size of pizza. Made fresh to order. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

S. H.

1

22

16

1 year ago

Heard good things about this place so my husband and I tried them out the other day for a carry out. The pizza sauce tasted wonderful, and has just the right amount of spice. The pepperoni was thick and plentiful. We will definitely be returning. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Beth S.

0

76

2

1 year ago

We got a simple take out pizza/ half pepperoni. It was not good to us, but pizza is very subjective, so maybe others will like it.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Chad W.

0

54

68

2 years ago

Good pizza spot a little away from siesta key. We had several pizzas and all were good. read more

Local Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Osprey, Florida

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Howard M.

Elite 26 All-Star

2635

493

6134

4 years ago

Florida and pizza are now like two peas in a pod thanks to the tremendous migration pattern of people from the north east cities. That being said, there is a lot of pizza competition in this area, and if you're struggling to decide where to eat your next Italian meal, this is certainly a viable option. The ambience is contemporary and hip with a stunning bar and the table service is phenomenal. It's easy to find, on the east side of the 41 in Osprey and there's convenient off street parking. Now keep in mind, the pizza is mediocre. While real pizza (in my opinion) is not overwhelmed by toppings, this restaurant seem to be thrilled to offer you all kinds of interesting pizza varieties, but when it comes down to a basic classic cheese pie, this one will not be at the top of your list. All the pies are 14 inches, which would be considered a small pizza. When you fold such a small slice it feels like a child's portion. Additionally, the pie we had was light on mozzarella cheese. There was no gooey string of cheese hanging down after you take your first bite. Would I recommend giving this restaurant a try? Sure, they might have exactly what you want. It's just not my New York City style pizza. Salute! read more

Local Pizza - Seating at the bar - Pizza Near Me - Osprey, Florida

Local Pizza - Meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Osprey, Florida

Local Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Osprey, Florida

See all

Helpful 51

Thanks 0

Love this 32

Oh no 0

Adriana S.

0

110

54

10 months ago

I was happy with the service and the pizza tasted good enough, but I was very disappointed when I got to my family gathering and opened up one of my pizza boxes. Most of the toppings I paid for weren't on there. I was already too far away to go back and resolve the issue, so it was upsetting. I was really looking forward to that combo, but ended up with just a cheese pizza. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Marty B.

0

553

241

2 years ago

Nice place but pizza is marginal at best. I had cheese pizza and there was hardly any cheese on it? Bland and limp. Much better choices for pizza nearby read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 2

Gail L.

37

333

366

2 years ago

Great pizza and salad. Molly took good care of us. Pinot Grigio was crisp and delicious Very cute modern decor and sound was good you could hear your companions . read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jeff D.

2

138

53

2 years ago

We had the make-your-own pizza, red sauce, pepperoni, onion, mushrooms. The pizza was okay, but nothing special. The service was good; the restaurant had several tv's over the bar, so we could watch the football game. The restaurant was clean and everyone was keeping busy. I'm still searching for a spectacular pizza in Sarasota... read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Nick S.

1234

1961

10108

5 years ago

Been here a couple time. Very accomodating. Yummy food. Bistro real fire ovens. Some deluxe options. Had the lasagne calzone. Lasagna pizza. Cheese pizza. Nice indoor atmostphere. Comfy but elegant. Some outdoor high tops. Local ice cream place across 41. . read more

Local Pizza - Kid friendly and accomodating. Indoor and outdoor seating. - Pizza Near Me - Osprey, Florida

Local Pizza - The Bubba liles plain pizza. She's an Old School classic type of Party Animal. - Pizza Near Me - Osprey, Florida

Local Pizza - Uncle David and his side salad. - Pizza Near Me - Osprey, Florida

See all

Helpful 11

Thanks 0

Love this 8

Oh no 0

Scott W.

0

14

2

2 years ago

Giving this pizza a 8.1. Great quality and highly recommend. Sauce has a nice tang and cheese and toppings are great quality. My new favorite pizza in the Osprey/Sarasota area. read more

Local Pizza - Pizza oven - Pizza Near Me - Osprey, Florida

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lisa M.

0

3

0

1 year ago

Shrimp scampi pizza is fantastic. Fresh, homemade pasta did not disappoint. Service was excellent as well.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Carmen D.

149

180

403

4 years ago

Stopped by today and ordered a Bolognese Pizza for take out. Despite the long wait I would still rate it as a fabulous experience. The pizza was total perfection. The crust reminded me of New York slices, although a bit smaller because the pizzas are 14". But the texture and taste is very New York. Frankly the closest I've found. The ingredients we fresh and flavorful. If they can work on the production time they would have a 5 star experience. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Marquette S.

43

50

49

3 years ago

Hot fresh, and outside seating. Wine and Dr Pepper. Tv, your love it. Come hurry you may need to get pizzas, one to go!!!! read more

Local Pizza - Outside - Pizza Near Me - Osprey, Florida

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Orlando R.

2

64

13

2 years ago

Pizza and meatballs are great. Pasta selections are pretty good as well. Service is always friendly . Not much of any ambiance but that's ok as long as the food is good. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jason B.

0

4

1

4 years ago

Best pizza EVER No BS TOP 5 in my life We are from Tampa and anytime we're back in the area definitely coming here. Try the "pretty fly for a White Guy Micah gave incredible service read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Janine J.

0

13

6

2 years ago

I visited for dinner with my family for the first time. We were delighted by the cuisine!!! The spices and flavors were extremely impressive. The menu offers a wide variety of delicious and mouthwatering starters and main courses that will appeal to youngsters and adults alike. The two pizzas we ordered were Meet me at the corner and Margherita. For Entrees we had the Roasted Chicken, Chicken wings ( hot chilli and Garlic Parm), and Roasted Cauliflower! Listen, that was the best Roasted Cauliflower ever! Everything we ate was fresh and delicious. I recommend this restaurant. The food is delicious and the atmosphere is very relaxed. Great for a family night out. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

MayMay P.

0

5

0

1 year ago

wonderful food with kind staff! inside is very clean and fancy. 10/10 recommend. :) Very welcoming and kind kitchen workers too.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Steph S.

3

28

6

3 years ago

Pizza was alright. Way too much sauce. As soon as you picked the pizza up, everything would slide off of it. Floppy under carriage. We got the meatballs for an app, they were not good at all. Weird taste to them. Im glad I tried this place because I would always drive by and it looked intriguing. Probably won't be back but it's cute read more

Local Pizza - Margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Osprey, Florida

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

John M.

664

8750

29781

4 years ago

Local Pizza probably does not possess the best name ever, but the pizza is definitely pretty solid at this establishment. The ambiance here definitely adds to a positive experience if you prefer a more upscale atmosphere than the stereotypical corner takeout pizzeria joint. The service here is definitely spot-on. They are friendly, professional and attentive. The pizza is definitely a great pizza with quality ingredients and attention to the details. The pizzas also have clever (at least in their opinion) names attached to them. I grew up in New Jersey and truly miss great pizza. In New Jersey, it seems that we have great pizza on almost every corner. When I moved to Florida in 2001, I was both shocked and more than a little dismayed to discover that great pizza (or even good pizza) was something that had to be hunted down and when found, it was a moment worthy of celebration (and what better way to celebrate than with a slice of pizza in hand?). All in all, I will give Local Pizza five stars (though I am still not a fan of their name). Local Pizza is a great place to head towards if you are in the mood for great pizza. read more

Helpful 17

Thanks 0

Love this 13

Oh no 0

Linda H.

26

19

0

2 years ago

Pizza was very good. Atmosphere was good. Service good. We highly recommend. We definitely will go back.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Patricia C.

112

69

6

3 years ago

Something changed again :(. Tried to give it another visit tonight - it was our local jam until we moved. $87 for bland takeout. Kids noodles dry and salty. Cauliflower crust pizza WAY heavy on the garlic and soggy. Plus they forgot two of my toppings! And the large cheese- where's the cheese? And also TOOOO garlicky:(. Something changed. Recipes? Chefs? Or was it the Full moon? Buh-Bye Local, we knew you when. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michael M.

12

176

59

3 years ago

Good pizza. Was it $20 good? Eh, that's a lot for one pizza. I will probably try again. Convenient pickup window.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Judy B.

0

74

0

1 year ago

This is our third time visiting this month! You will not be disappointed! On our last visit, we had two different pizzas and they were outstanding! Tonight, we had three different pasta dishes, all with homemade pasta the gnocchi was the best we have ever had in all our years of travel. Truly, best meals ever! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Vince P.

0

39

1

3 years ago

When Local Pizza is on their game, I would say this the best pizza in the area. However, Local Pizza has a real problem with being consistent. If you order a pizza here twice in the same week, you'll most likely have 2 separate opinions. Either perfectly cooked with all the specified ingredients (5 star) and friendliness from the staff, or you'll get an undercooked pie with missing basil from some rude cashier. 2 times I've also had their buffalo wings, and they dont put sauce on them, I send them back, and they make fresh ones that are correct and taste amazing. Again, consistency. They dont deliver anymore, with good reason, because they really sucked at it. They would straight up not deliver your food for some unknown reason. But they still push tipping on their carry out orders. Stop doing this. Put a tip jar and leave it at that. Wait times are anyone's guess, I'm told 5 minutes to pick up a slice, and it's never ready, kind of a nitpicky thing but annoying nonetheless. Expect your order to take 30 minutes. Some staff are the nicest I've ever met, while some make you feel like you're burdening them with your presence. Sometimes, you just never feel welcome. You'd think I'd rate this lower based on what I've said, but this place really is amazing when it's done right. I'd recommend it to anyone, but you may want to give it a few tries. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Renee K.

0

6

0

1 year ago

Food was fantastic... 2nd time here. Served ce was better than first. Service first time was to be desired but first I'd was so good we came back and service. Much better read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Amy D.

0

1

0

1 year ago

Service is soooooo sloooooooowwww. We called at 7pm on a Thursday for a pick up at 8pm. We arrived at 8 and they had not even started the order yet. Why? read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 4

See more reviews

More info about Local Pizza

66 N Tamiami Trl
Osprey, FL 34229
Directions
(941) 909-0743
Call Now
Visit Website
https://thelocal.pizza

Full menu

Hours

What time does Local Pizza open?

Local Pizza opens at 11:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Sunday, Friday and Saturday.

What time does Local Pizza close?

Local Pizza closes at 9:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Sunday.Local Pizza closes at 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.

Mon-Thu, Sun 11:00 AM - 9:00 PMFri-Sat 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Local Pizza take credit cards?

Yes, Local Pizza takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Local Pizza have catering options?

Yes, Local Pizza does have catering options.

Does Local Pizza have a drive thru?

No, Local Pizza does not have a drive thru.

Does Local Pizza have a happy hour?

Yes, Local Pizza has a happy hour.

Does Local Pizza serve alcohol?

Yes, Local Pizza serves alcohol. Beer & Wine Only

Indoor Amenities

Does Local Pizza have TVs?

Yes, Local Pizza has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Local Pizza have bike parking?

Yes, Local Pizza has bike parking.

Does Local Pizza have outdoor seating?

Yes, Local Pizza has outdoor seating options.

Does Local Pizza have parking?

Yes, Local Pizza has parking options. Private Lot Parking

Other Amenities

Is Local Pizza wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Local Pizza is wheelchair accessible.

Does Local Pizza have free WiFi?

Yes, Local Pizza has free WiFi.

More Info

Health Score

You might also consider

Bella Vino & Cucina

4.1(34 reviews)

0.2 mi

We had an excellent meal! It is a little odd that it's above a Mexican restaurant, but once we…read morefound it, ohmygosh, was it worth it. We had the meatballs appetizer - delicious! Warm, crusty bread. They bake it to order. Don't rush it. Be patient. The eggplant parm was the best I ever had. The entire table agreed. I also had the bean soup - smoky and hearty. Another at our table had the carbonara. He loved it. Everyone at our table loved their meal and we heard similar comments from others at nearby tables. Dana, the owner was our server and we enjoyed chatting with her about the recipes. I would eat there again tomorrow. And the day after.

Very Good Italian Cuisine and great service too. All of the Italian food on their menu was very…read moretempting. Not interested in Mex food though, but the Italian food is very tasty.

Pasta options

Menu options

See all

Bar

Bella Rimini

4.3(60 reviews)

5.1 mi

I had their Pasta Carbonara. It was very good. I would return for this menu option alone. I am sure…read morethere are other great items also, but I tend to stick with what I know is great. The service was great also. We had a group of 6 and the place was packed, but the service did not suffer. This was a really enjoyable experience.

So I'm updating this review because I know these people saw it but I haven't heard a thing back…read morefrom them. No sorry bro, no refund, no nothing. So in fact this is a zero star review.

New Signage

Bread

See all

Fresh baked bread

Frankie's Italian Ristorante

3.7(85 reviews)

0.3 mi

LOVE THIS PLACE!!!! Ok I have been going to Frankie's for…read moreyears since the new owner took over about 20+ years ago. Food has been consistent every time. The staff are all very nice and its a cozy little place with a handful of booths and tables. There is even a few spots at the bar. Will always go back for more. Thank you guys for all the good memories.

The best pizza in Sarasota. Period. It's small inside, but…read morethey also do amazing takeaway. And service is fast. Technically, it is Osprey, but easily accessible to Sarasota, Nokomis Venice, and beyond- and totally worth the drive (we drive from Siesta Key). I don't know what they put in the dough or the sauce, but it is addictive. And they're generous with the toppings. My calzone was dripping in Ricotta, and I wouldn't have it any other way. It's can be a little on the pricey side but again it is worth it. You're paying for quality ingredients. Once you experience Frankie's you can't accept anything less.

Spaghetti dinner special

See all

Awesome Baked Ziti

La Dolce Vita - Authentic Italian Cuisine

4.8(263 reviews)

5.1 mi

We had a great dinner last night at La Dolce Vita. It is a small place, I didn't think to count…read morethe tables inside but there is maybe a dozen, and a few more outside. Small and busy, I would recommend getting a reservation. I checked out their menu earlier in the day and was very much looking forward to trying their Pappardelle, Funghi e Salsiccia, a sausage and mushroom pasta dish with a creamy panna sauce. I was not disappointed. In fact, I found my food absolutely delicious. I loved the mushrooms, the sausage, and the sauce really tied it all together. Service was fine, maybe just a little slow at the end getting the bill, but we were in no hurry. Very helpful, one person in our group had some dietary restrictions which were accommodated.

Food was terrible, owner was more interested in being a singer than actually cooking…read more I don't know what part of Italy she is from, but it's not like any Italian food I've ever experienced in my lifetime The chicken was mushy and they use way too much salt

Inside

Divine Nutella Cake

See all

Patio

Tuscany Nokomis

3.2(243 reviews)

3.1 mi

We came up from Port Charlotte to see The Beatles Tribute band Sat night . They were absolutely…read more awesome! The ball room was beautiful and excellent svc from the bartender. We would go again.

Tuesday night pizza deal can't be beat - a great value, for sure. We ordered two pizzas for the…read moretable, and even though they were busy, they arrived reasonably quickly. The staff in the ballroom were working hard, but there weren't enough of them. Drink refills were slow, and follow up after food arrived was almost non-existent. The ballroom is ok if you into relatively loud music - karaoke was that night, but it was cold there. The seating around the outside of the ballroom is also not ideal - the tables are situated too far from the wall benches, and it is not comfortable to eat that way. I'd sit in the restaurant next time. Hopefully with time, they'll get these things straightened out.

Death by chocolate cake

See all

Bar

Giuseppe’s Ristorante & Pizzeria

4.3(90 reviews)

6.5 mi

A very friendly place with nice service , good food and great music! Make sure you check before you…read morego in order to make that there is scheduled entertainment. A fun venue! A second visit was most enjoyable! Collin, our server , was outstanding . The food was excellent ; my wife had the salmon, I had the eggplant parm. We really enjoyed the app with procutto wrapped cheese. We will return!

We ordered two pizzas and pasta one regular cheese pizza was OK but the other one with prosciutto…read morewas just cheese pizza and prosciutto on top. What kind of pizza is that taste awful Our kids was eating pasta and they said it's OK

Cocktail corner

Manicotti was amazing!

See all

Manicotto & Baked Ziti

Maestrale Restaurant and Pizzeria

4.3(72 reviews)

3.6 mi

Excellent restaurant! Our second visit even better than our first…read more Bruschetta was delicious and artistically displayed. Slight tendency for tomatoes to fall off but really good, Lasagna very tasty. The winner was the shellfish and pasta. We will all likely order that next time. Good house wines. Split tiramisu for dessert. Super light and flavorful. Alfredo took very good care of us. We will return!

Wonderful food and service. When you see other Italians eating at an Italian restaurant - you know…read moreyou are in the right place!

Burrata

See all

Wine

The Italian Grill

3.7(199 reviews)

1.9 mi

We enjoyed our meals here. The server did an excellent job and they have decorated the inside to…read moremake you think that you are in Italy. Over all it was an excellent experience.

This place is a JOKE. The so called fire has prevented them from re-opening??…read moreWebsite has not been updated in-forever.

Great veal saltimbocca!

Pizza

See all

Get.Out.

Asaro's Pizzeria Ristorante

3.6(242 reviews)

6.1 mi

Had their veal gorginzola on a take out. I won't say it was good but my wife though I was nuts when…read moreI licked the dish clean. Lol Absolutely one of the best dishes I have had in a long time. Will order again for sure but next time I will ask for more bread to sop up the extra sauce.

We have been loyal customers of Asaro's for seven years. My parents are regulars who visit…read morefrequently, and whenever family comes to town from up north, this is where we bring them. It has always been our go-to. This past Sunday, our experience was deeply disappointing and frankly unlike anything we have encountered here before. We ordered two pizzas and salads. The margherita pizza -- which my parents had ordered just one week prior without any issues -- arrived completely different. It had an additional cheese layered beneath the fresh mozzarella that was overcooked and almost burnt. The crust on both pizzas was so hard it could not be folded (anyone from the East Coast knows you fold your pizza), and my son was unable to cut through it with a knife and fork. It was inedible. We sent both pizzas back. The server returned and offered to remake only one, insisting the second was fine. It was not. When we pointed out that the margherita is traditionally just fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, and basil -- and that this was not what was served -- we were told "this is how we do it." We have been ordering this pizza for seven years. It was not how they do it. The one pizza that was remade came back only marginally better. We did not ask again. From that point, our table was completely abandoned. Every glass at our table was empty. Not the server, not a busser, not a single person passing by stopped to offer water or check on us. My father eventually had to go inside to find someone. My son had to walk to our car in the parking lot to retrieve his water bottle, and I went to my car to get a sparkling water I happened to have in the cup holder. That is how thirsty we were and how little attention our table received. The indifference started even before the food arrived. When we declined cocktails and handed back the drink list, letting the server know we would all just be having water, the reaction was visibly dismissive and unwelcoming -- not the kind of response anyone expects when simply choosing not to order alcohol. The hostess, as has been the case on prior visits, was visibly disgruntled and unwelcoming. We understand that Sunday service is busy. We were patient and did not make a scene. We simply wanted food that was edible and basic attentiveness as paying customers. Neither was provided. My mother, who has been one of their most consistent regulars, left saying she did not want to return. That says everything. For a restaurant that benefits enormously from a captive local audience and steady tourist traffic, this level of disregard for loyal, long-term customers is disappointing. We hope management takes this feedback seriously.

Eggplant and ricotta with fresh basil.

See all

Eggplant, Ricotta, fresh garlic.

Napule

4.1(428 reviews)

4.1 mi

•$$$

Napule is an independent Italian restaurant featuring top quality ingredients and delicious…read moreentrees. I have been dining Napule for a while, and the service has always been top notch. The dining areas are on the main floor with also an outdoor patio and a small upstairs area. What I love about this restaurant is you can see the cooks making your entrees. This is really appealing when you view your pizza in their wood fire oven. We tried their meatball appetizer which was a chef special, and you see from my picture there were three meatballs in a tasty red sauce topped with mozzarella and a fresh basil leaf. It was a great addition to our meal. I also recommend the Semplice salad and grilled salmon which is a good size portion with arugula and lettuce topped with carrots, radicchio and layered with shaved Parmesan cheese. Don't expect dressing as they serve olive oil and balsamic vinegar at your table. Another favorite dish is the cod filet sautéed with capers, onions, and olives which is served with potatoes and broccoli. If you're in the Sarasota area and want a clean and delicious Italian dinner Napule is a great choice.

First time dining in. I've done pizza take out a few years ago. I think it's headed a bit downhill…read more We ordered calamari and it was not great. Pretty overcooked and chewy. The charcuterie was better but tough to mess this up. I had the Quattro pizza. It was super soft and really not that great, super floppy and just ok. The soup was meh. Friends had pasta and said it was pretty good. We had a group that hasn't seen each other in over a year. Being a server is hard but you have to understand when to break in and when not too. Ours was nice but always seemed to be interrupting a story. I get it, but this is an art. I just don't see us going back, there are so many better places.