Amazing food, customer service and cleanliness was A1. This was my first time going here and I called to do a pickup over the phone and Allen was friendly, helpful and knowledgeable. Then when I came to pick up my pizza it was a BUSY Friday night but although it was busy Oliver didn't rush me in any way and made me feel as if I was the only customer. He was also able to multi task. The pizza was great it is just under Round Table. I will say it is pricier though. I paid $52 for there signature large northwest pnw or something and 6 wings. Will definitely go back and love the clean dine in experience. read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Picture frames inside with signature items - Pizza Near Me - Maple Valley, Washington

See all

Great food, our hostess Lily was very inviting and friendly which started off our wonderful experience, thanks Lily. The food was great, the price was better than I expected, and had a fun feel. I'm really looking forward to coming back to try the deserts, they looked and sounded delicious. read more

Was in the area and looking at a few different pizza options and decided to go here because it seemed more of a local business. So glad we did! The staff are very welcoming, the bar area was busy and our server was really friendly. Already a good combo! I love that there is a proper pizza oven so you can smell the fresh dough! We ordered a small portion of buffalo wings, I'm hit or miss with wings but these were terrific. The pizza we ordered was soooo good. The pizzas are a bit pricey, but they give plenty of ingredients so it's worth it. We had leftovers for lunch the next day too! We enjoyed the laid back experience overall, not too loud. There is plenty parking outside. This was so good we ended up at the Ruston location the following week (separate review and pictures!) read more

Farrelli's Pizza - 16" The Power Play - Pizza Near Me - Maple Valley, Washington

We ordered the Margherita & Northwest tradition pizza, sheet nachos and I had Strawberry margarita. I love everything except for the NW pizza. I thought it was a little salty for my taste. I really enjoyed the strawberry Margarita it wasn't too strong just right and I ask for it to be blended. It was so good. Happy hour menu was nice, they have quite a few to choose from. Server was nice and attentive. Ambience is inviting. I highly recommend it. Good for a get together with family or friends to catch up. read more

See all

Love the service! Kayla was quick to take our order. The ovens were having issue so she tried ever it in quickly. Clean restrooms and restaurant. Fresh ingredients. Enjoy! read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Great place to watch Seahawks! - Pizza Near Me - Maple Valley, Washington

We had the best time at Farrelli's Pizza this past Tuesday! Our server was Kayla and she went above and beyond to make sure we felt right at home. The food was delicious and our two boys loved playing with the pizza dough! We plan to be back on a Monday when kiddos eat free!! read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Big fat chocolate cake! - Pizza Near Me - Maple Valley, Washington

See all

My family and I tried out this spot a few weeks ago for lunch. Unfortunately, we were a little disappointed. Let me just begin by saying that while this place certainly is not bad, it's definitely not a highly recommended place from me. We started off our meal with the spinach and artichoke dip, I enjoyed that it came with both corn chips and pita bread! Unfortunately, I felt that the flavors of the dip were very heavily overpowered by the Gorgonzola cheese. That was quite a disappointment. For pizza we ordered the Greek and the hot honey pizzas. I really enjoyed the crispness of the pepperoni but didn't enjoy the sausage on the hot honey one. I found the Greek pizza to be quite unique and decently tasty! Although I personally preferred the leftover of it better as I ate them cold. I really enjoyed the freshly shaved Parmesan, ranch, and red sauce they provided for dipping!! Our service was very attentive! Never had an empty drink or need for napkins. One of the servers was very kind and bright! He certainly elevated the experience! I think it's fun how they have a pizza of the month!! They also offer daily deals for family, those who serve our country, and kids. I don't think this is a place I would frequent but I do think it's a good spot for a large group! read more

See all

The atmosphere was really comfortable perfect for relaxing without feeling rushed. The pizza was solid, with great flavor and a nicely cooked crust. What really stood out, Our server was attentive, friendly, and made the whole experience even better. Definitely a spot I'd come back to! read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Maple Valley, Washington

I have always loved Farelli's pizza so I wanted to treat my Mom from out of state. I ordered 2 10" pizzas online picked them up got home and not only did they look like the box had been shaken but both pizzas were burnt to a crisp. I called and the guy was very nice and told me to come right back that he would have them re made. I wish I knew his name. But the cook needs to go back to school apparently, because for $70 flippin dollars I definitely expected perfection. read more

Ordered delivery via gh...ordered a BOWL of soup for $9.99 and received a very small copy which contained 5 oz of soup.

Not a busy night. Sat at the bar....bartender was super nice and attentive. My problem was the bathroom. There were no less than 4 employees standing around the front desk. The bathroom was horrendous! Toilet paper rolls on the floor, empty toilet paper holders, paper towels everywhere. Disgusting!! Get a cleaning crew in there if the employees aren't going to do anything!!! read more

Missed Connection... You: Small, white, creamy, and herby buttermilk base deliciousness with perfect viscosity, served on the side. You stay around the 4 Corners area at that pizza joint, bringing up the equity and flavor of your host family's pizza. Me: Your biggest fan. But for some reason, every time I request your companionship over my pizza dinner... the service team never seems to send you along with my pie! Signed, Sad Ranch Lover read more

Had a great experience here today when I was greeted by the amazing Oliver who helped me order a Hawaiian pizza and a Northwest traditional. Always have a great experience here and look forward to being back soon. This place is always very clean and friendly as well as good for the kids. read more

STOP EVERYTHING YOU'RE DOING AND GET TO FARELLI'S PIZZA, the only establishment brave enough to turn their dining room into a temple of home shopping enlightenment. Every single TV--and I mean EVERY. SINGLE. TV.--is locked on HSN like it's broadcasting the secrets of the universe. And you know what? Maybe it is. Picture this: You're demolishing the perfect pepperoni slice while Joan in Studio B is selling moisture-wicking bamboo socks with such conviction you'd think they were woven from dragon scales. The entire restaurant goes silent when the "Today's Special Value" drops. I once saw a table of businessmen in suits abandon their quarterly reports to impulse-buy matching sets of cubic zirconia tennis bracelets. The staff has evolved to time their service around HSN segments. "I'll bring your garlic knots right after this set of collapsible garden hoses," they'll say, and somehow that makes perfect sense. There's an unofficial pizza challenge where if you can finish a large supreme during a complete presentation of the Wolfgang Puck cookware set, it's free. Nobody has ever won because they get too invested in the non-stick demonstrations. The real magic happens during the jewelry hours. Something about watching gemstones sparkle on screen while eating a slice covered in oils and oregano just hits different. Last Tuesday, the entire dining room spontaneously bought matching mood rings, and now there's a support group that meets weekly to discuss their QVC recovery. They've even synchronized their pizza tossing to the HSN countdown clock. When that timer hits zero, you'll see dough spinning through the air like some sort of carb-loaded performance art. The pressure-selling tactics have somehow infected the menu--"Only 3 slices of the quattro formaggi remain! Don't wait, these will sell out!" Five stars. Would absolutely finance another payment plan for a set of "exclusive" pizza plates while watching a demonstration of cordless vacuum cleaners again. Just remember: if you hear "Last chance!" or "Final quantities!" you better order that extra side of marinara RIGHT NOW. P.S. The hostess might try to sell you a birthstone pizza cutter. Just go with it. read more

The food was great and the service was perfect! Kaitlyn was our server and she was so sweet and attentive. Our favorite part was the chicken wings with the parm garlic dry rub, I am so picky with chicken but these were some of the best wings I've had! read more

See all

Enjoyed the pizza here, coming back again, they do have offers on almost all days of the week. Ordered their house favorites and didn't get disappointed. read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Maple Valley, Washington

See all

I found a decent pizza that is so authentic tasting! The sauce was definitely homemade, crust was on point. Loved the atmosphere, service was great! Jazz she really made us feel welcomed, her recommendation was useful. Definitely worth trying and will be back again soon! read more

See all

Our neighborhood go to place. We were ready to switch it up and go somewhere else as the toppings were light and inconsistent and the crust soft. Tonight- the chef we had around4:30 ish was fantastic!! Crust was cooked thru and the toppings consistant and actually covered the full pizza. I wish I would have got the chefs name as I really only want to go now when he is the pizza master! read more

Maple Valley Farrellis Pizza is consistently good pizza. Great crust is key, if it isn't good it doesn't matter what is on top. Fresh salads and a friendly atmosphere. read more

Pizza is inconsistent here . Not acceptable for $35 medium . The crust was not cooked, I asked for extra sauce but it made the whole pizza soggy since crust was not cooked. Also had no green peppers that I ordered and barely any chicken on it which I paid for . Will not be coming back anytime soon read more

My wife had lunch at this establishment with her friends. She ordered a Italian grinder pizzini to bring home for me. When I opened the to go box the pizzini looked different than I had in the past at the Puyallup Farellis. I open up the pizzini and it looked like the ingredients were minimal at best. The was a very small amount of meat in the sandwich. Even the tomatoes and romaine was scrimpy at best. I couldn't find any salami. Oh well for 14.99 I won't be ordering this or visiting the Maple Valley Farellis. read more

See all

Overall the food is mediocre and the service is hit or miss. We ordered a cheese pizza and they forgot the cheese. We waited so long for our order, we didn't brother to send it back. The meatballs are on the dry side. On an upside, the cheesy bread sticks are great and they have a fun trivia night. read more

A recent first timer here, I found the place to be a welcoming & laidback atmosphere. The service was wonderful & prompt. We lucked out by making their happy hour special. Plenty of great items to choose from on the menu; I liked the freedom to customize & was able to get the gluten free option of the Pesto Chicken Caprese. I will make it a point to stop by when I'm in the Maple Valley area ! read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Maple Valley, Washington

See all

Great pizza and atmosphere! Great place to watch a game and get a drink. Service is always quick and friendly.

Stopped by on a Sunday afternoon on our way home. And so happy we did! We sat in the bar during the game (happy we did!) so it was happy hour! Enjoyed our waiter who was also the bartender and he was great! Loved everything we ordered!!! Loved the Strawberry Bourbon Smash so much! Grab one for sure! Thank you Logan! Great wings, amazing baked cheese and the pepperoni pizza was perfect! Will come back next time we are in the area and will tell my niece who lives near to try it! read more

My husband and I have been to Farrelli's many times, although after a bad experience at this location, we had stopped eating there, but have continued to stop by for drinks from time to time. Recently, we were out and about and decided to give it another shot, as it was convenient. Logan was an amazing server/bartender-- I've had many here, he is top notch. Demario was the cook (I asked, to be able to leave this review) and I promise that I will only ever eat there if I see him when I walk in. The food was SO MUCH better than our previous 2 experiences at this location! It was really like night and day. We were pleasantly surprised. Good job, Demario! read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Pork nachos, they don't look great but they were-- and we've had them twice here where they were very bad. - Pizza Near Me - Maple Valley, Washington

See all

Worse service ever. Our bartender never came back for refills etc. She was very busy talking to other people, looking at her phone. Her and the other girl there today walked by our table 5 times( we counted) and was doing nothing but chatting with other staff. One actually walked around our table twice to get to someone else. We had to go to the bar several times to order then she acted all mad and huffed at us and asked several times after that if we needed anything else wanting us to go. When I finally walked up to the bar the 3rd and final time to get a Pepsi refill....it wasn't pepsi!!!! This is unacceptable. They were not busy during the game!!!! We had 2 bartenders and a server walk by and not even give us a glance. UNACCEPTABLE read more

First time customer today. I ordered a 12" three topping pizza. Pepperoni, sausage and black olives. It tasted pretty good however when did pizza places start charging $28 and some change for a "12 pizza? The service was great. But I just can't get over the price. I most likely won't be back. read more

Farrelli's Pizza - 12" pizza $28 - Pizza Near Me - Maple Valley, Washington

See all

Second visit very disappointed. I was going to order some takeouts but decided to go to the bar instead. We sat there looking at multiple groups already got their tables clean and have a menu except us. We were there before those people and I even mentioned to one of the lady for clean up and she walked away. We waited for a little longer and I tried to wave down a black glasses lady. She waved back but she was actually waving at her friends behind my desk and she even squeezed behind me and completely ignored me. We went back and order to go. The young ladies in at the front desk saved the evening and knowing their mistakes and issue us a discount. Otherwise, I would have changed this to a 3 stars. read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Pineapple mule - Pizza Near Me - Maple Valley, Washington

See all

Awesome service, drinks, and food. Good stuff here. Very accommodating, nice attitudes all around

Spaghetti dishes are no longer available with traditional spaghetti noodles. The fettuccine was salty with little to no sauce. The pizza was greasy and mushy. Had a bad experience the last time I was there however, I thought I would give it another try things have gotten a lot worse along with poor service and the bartender does not know how to make a cocktail. Will not be frequenting this restaurant again. read more

Food was poor quality at best. For 14.99 the Pizzini lacked any meat or other ingredients. The taste was awful. The sauce was minimal. Just a bad item. Will not visit or order there again. read more

See all

Trying to order food and half way thru taking pur order they walked away...we were like hey...were not done. They came back and said oh..well...food I ordered, 1 was caprese said, was missing basil. That's a key Ingredient! Brought me back a bowl of it...ok...then when done with dinner they took my only drink I had, to which I wasn't even close to finished. Still had half A drink..for 12 dollars I want my drink...I wouldn't have ordered it if I didn't want to actually drink the whole thing. Like they want you in and out as fast as possible. I said hey you took my drink..they said ya thought you were finished..and handed me the check. I wasn't drunk( my only drink that whole week) and I wasn't rude. Thanks for letting people spend their hard earned money just to get their food and drinks taken away. read more

Held a surprise graduation party for my husband. Did one of the packages which were well priced for the value. Service was okay, space was great, food was middle of the road. Its nice that theres a free place to host events which is really the strong rating. Most places charge you to use space. read more

See all

Great place! The manager helped with our reservation and was very kind. Our server was Jas and she handled our large group wonderfully! Thank you for great food and service! The other 2 families had never been there before and loved it!!! read more

We stopped in after a family day at Wild Waves. We were very hungry and excited to try the pizza that my husband says is one of his favorites. We arrived at 5:40 on a Saturday and was greeted with a smile and sat in a booth quickly. Our server arrived shortly and promptly took our drink orders and answered a few questions about the menu. My husband was slightly bummed as the spicy peppers he was craving were a seasonal or special option not available. We ordered the meat pizza and it was very good. It had great flavor and I liked the fact that they offered fresh Parmesan cheese. They offered both indoor and outdoor dining and the ambiance was family friendly and casual. I wish we had a closer location to us in the Lynnwood area, but I'll definitely be back when in the area! read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Farrell's Meat Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Maple Valley, Washington

We stopped by to get a pizza and a few drinks my wife was raving about the Northwest Traditional pizza. We sat in the bar and ordered our food and drinks. There are 11 tvs in the bar so definitely a good place to watch some sports. While we sat I noticed several tables were done eating and waiting on bills. There were only a few staff members working today so service was noticeably slow. Our drinks were ok, I didn't taste any rum in my drink but my wife said her drink was good. The pizza was delicious with loads of flavor and it had some kick which lit up my taste buds. I would definitely get this pizza again. If you go pay when the pizza comes to help mitigate waiting for the check. read more

See all

I have enjoyed Farrelli's many times, but have never shared a review. Although their pizzas are very good, I visit Farrelli's mostly for their cauliflower crust option. You may order most (if not all) of their pizzas on the menu in a personal size cauliflower pizza. The cauliflower pizza crust has never been a failed option, the crust is texture the same as a thin crest regular pizza. To start, we sometimes like to order a gin or vodka tonics, but this time we ordered a speciality drink, Monkey Jam. Very good. My husband I had a salad and stuffed mushrooms, off of the appetizer menu, while waiting for the pizza. The mushrooms were very good and flavorful. Admittedly, I did have one of the garlic bread slices, very good, worth cheat. Now for the main entrée, I enjoyed an Italian Meat Pizza and my husband had the Meat Lover's Pizza. As expected, our cauliflower pizza was perfectly delicious. A wonderful treat was devoured. read more

See all

I really love the pizza, it's hard to find good gluten free pizza and this is probably one of my favorites. They have a little arcade with about three things to do, but the duck machine seems to be a hit. The service is nice and understanding, and the ambience is comforting and energetic. Overall I definitely recommend Farrelli's pizza. read more

We went to Farrelli's twice on a recent trip to Maple Valley and both times it was delicious. The meatballs were a family favorite, and all of the pizzas we tried were very good. read more