Food is hot and fresh. Wings are crispy and flavorful. Soup specials are worth getting every…read moretime. Eaten here dozens of times without an issue.

Service is terrible. Hour and a half wait to be served after ordering. No apology until I was…read morepaying the bill, only rude "we're busy." Food was so-so, nothing fancy. Definitely not worth the wait or the lack of hospitality. Ordered shots at the bar and they were in a plastic container the size you would put Arby's sauce in. These were very difficult to drink out of. When I questioned, the bartender said she wasn't "going to be washing shot glasses all night."

Food was fast and delicious and the service was very attentive. You could tell that some…read moreimprovements had recently been made.

Loved staying here. The staff was really friendly, especially Linda. Breakfast and coffee/tea are…read morealways included, so that's a nice plus. The place just re-opened under new ownership, so everything looks super cute and nice! My only cons were Wi-Fi/TV being slow & causing some issues, slanted floors threw me off a bit, and not being able to close my window caused me to catch a cold. Will definitely be coming back, especially with the restaurant opening up to dinner and not just breakfast. I'm excited to see the American Hotel take off with the people that made it special. I also like the shops located across the street, they're definitely worth checking out.

What a little gem! The Mohawk Valley just stepped up a notch, or 2, with this spot. Staff if…read morefriendly, atmosphere is perfect and you just feel like home! Now let me tell you about the food!! I have lived in NYC and currently live in LA and typically when I come back to Herkimer we just cook at home. But instead we eat at Stone Soup or do take out! Food is delicious!!! Love, love, love this solid spot when I'm visiting Herkimer!

Went to Stone Soup finally for the first time with a couple of friends. We loved the decor and I…read moreespecially loved the music; lots of Beatles! Our server was very nice and attentive. I got the pulled pork platter and especially liked the mac and cheese on the side! The coleslaw was also a good choice. My friends got a burger and the rigatoni al forno, with a margherita flatbread which was a special. I thought the prices were very reasonable as well! Looking forward to going back during the warmer months to eat in their outdoor area!

The more you go the more you'll love coming here. Same waitresses who will remember what you like &…read morehow you like it. For the price the food is good. Where else can you get a burger & fries for under $5? Nice place and even nicer people.

My husband picked up dinner tonight which was awful. The place has newer owners who have put a…read moresignificant amount of money in upgrades to the exterior but sadly seem to have no sense of how to select quality food or handle customer service. The food is terrible - the turkey dinner was cold cuts and the saltiest turkey I'd ever tasted. I had one bite. The mashed potatoes/gravy were decent but they took no time to cut out the bad spots in the potato. I found two black chunks in the small part I ate. The mac salad was oddly greasy (like they added oil to the mayo) and has a weird taste, and the coleslaw was boughten and tasted like preservatives. My husband said nobody was in the place and staff was not friendly. The previous staff was so friendly and the place was always full. They offered no specials and the food was overpriced. The staff person volunteered that it had been "quiet" for a couple of weeks and my husband shared that people can't afford their prices." The staff person then offered that "they provide big portions!" That logic doesn't get people in the door! Sad to see a business fail but this one is on its way out fast.

You will quickly find that St. Johnsville is very small and that there are not many restaurants on…read morethe Main Street in downtown. This place is more like a small town bar where all the locals come to have a beer or play pool. Being a tourist and having no other option to eat you come in here and are very pleasantly surprised about the food. The menu is a bar type of food menu. But everything we had was delicious. Some of the best wings ever: crunchy yet juicy and not greasy! The most popular flavor is their own creation: the cowboy flavor. Really good: tangy and not sweet. The bartender, a lady that looks like Kirsten Dunst, is super sweet!

They are so nice!! Chris was so welcoming and made the best burger in town. When we drove by and…read moremade hard eye contact with Chris through the door, we knew we found the perfect place to sit down for a good meal and cold drink. Beer, wings, and fries. What more do you need. Bartender was so sweet - could pass as Kirsten Dunst's long lost twin. Pool table was great. Unique music. Made us feel right at home - even invited us back for drinks!

This is an awesome local bar, I love coming here after work to relax and have some drinks with…read morefriends!

Very good service.. clean and friendly atmosphere...food was fantastic and well done... absolutely…read morewonderful....been going here my entire life... keep up the good work

Folks, KC's closed the restaurant a few years ago. The hotel is still open and my brother and I…read morestay here every year for the opening weekend of deer season. Great people that we love supporting when we can. Miss the breakfasts.

The burger was charred and there was absolutely no seasoning or passion in there food…read more i see why this is a hot spot among the seniors also the cheese fries are not cheese fries

I ordered a hot turkey sandwich. Two thick slices of bread with canned gravy and dried chunks of…read moreturkey. Very, very salty. Ate about a third and tossed the rest. Such an easy, inexpensive dish to make properly with homemade gravy and thinly sliced turkey. Ice cream is good though.

Everything about this was excellent...til it wasn't. Overall, our experience was positive. Food was…read more(for the most part) good and it was a nice atmosphere. First disappointment was that entrees come with a choice of soup or salad. It was Caesar salad or tomato soup- both of which contained dairy so I couldn't have either and was not offered another option. The salmon was excellent but 2 bites in I realized the rice was partly crunchy. Told the server and was not offered a new portion or another option. Then coffee comes and upon pouring the cream in, it immediately separated. Was at least brought another cup. Then the bill comes and NOTHING was comped. Now, any one of these experiences would have perhaps been a minor inconvenience but you add up all three and I would have minimally appreciated an $8 dessert comped on an almost $200 bill. Would probably not be back.

First time there....no idea why we never went there before. It was awesome!!!…read moreWent on a Monday night...who would have thought they would be open. The food was awesome, bartender and waitress were incredible. Atmosphere was top notch beautiful place. Go there.